10 Actors Who Had To Beg For Famous Film Roles

"When you want something, go get it. Period." - Will Smith

We often think of Hollywood celebrities lazily auditioning for parts and nabbing them anyway - more of a formality than anything, right? Just to please the fat cats upstairs; to make sure they look okay on camera, and get on with the director. Imagined less, then, is the idea that the same Hollywood stars are having to fight for great parts and - more often than not - have to pit themselves against other established actors in the battle for a great role. It's strange to think about that occurring, mostly because we tend to envision the Hollywood elite as "having it made." When all else fails, though, and it looks like a role might be going to somebody else, an actor might resort to one final tactic: to beg. Despite the fact that the majority of us associate these folk with doing anything but begging, on a few notable occassions an actor has literally been given no other choice but to beg for a specific part. This might happen for a number of reasons, of course, but the main one tends to be that the director is unconvinced, whereas the actor feels as though they were born to play the role and can't bear the thought of it going to somebody else entirely. Join us as we take a look at 10 instances of actors begging for the parts that eventually became what are arguably their best and most memorable roles (in most cases, anyway). With a lot of the examples here, the associated directors had good reason to be nervous about casting said actors, but were presumably swayed by the sheer conviction and dedication these guys showed...

10. William H. Macy - Fargo

William H. Macy's wonderfully neurotic performance in Fargo is so good that the movie probably wouldn't have worked without him at the centre; it took Macy's brilliantly jumpy and paranoid Jerry Lundergaard to give the movie its anxious energy - the plot hinges on our belief that his down-beaten car salesman would go to the lengths that he goes to in order to get a bit of extra cash. Many believe that Macy should've won an Oscar for his role, so it's rather strange to learn that in the beginning the Coen Brothers didn't think the actor was right for the part. Originally considered for a much smaller role in the movie, Macy auditioned twice for Jerry. When the Coens didn't get back to him after his second reading, he took matters into his own hands and flew to New York to meet with them uninvited. So convinced was Macy that he was the definitive Jerry, he reportedly told them: "I'm very, very worried that you are going to screw up this movie by giving this role to somebody else. It's my role, and I'll shoot your dogs if you don't give it to me." Joking aside, he was right; Jerry Lundergaard remains his best ever performance. Perfect.

9. Meryl Streep - Sophie's Choice

In the early 80s, Meryl Streep found herself pegged as one of Hollywood's most sought after actresses - having impressed in acclaimed roles in the likes of The Deer Hunter, Manhattan and Kramer Vs. Kramer (the latter of which bagged her an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress), everybody wanted a piece of the Streep. And yet, despite her successes, she still found herself having to beg for the role that would eventually become what is still her most lauded today: that of Sophie in the 1982 adaptation of William Styron's classic novel, Sophie's Choice. Casting Streep in the role should have been an obvious move, and yet director Alan J. Pakula originally shied away from the possibility of Streep as Sophie because he had envisioned actress Liv Ullman. Hell hath no fury like Meryl Streep wanting a role, though: after finding a bootleg copy of the script, she tracked down Pakula, threw herself at his feet, and literally begged him to give her the part. He was swayed by her dedication, however, and came around to the idea... and Streep won her second Oscar for her frankly astounding work in the movie.

8. Orlando Bloom - Sympathy For Delicious

Orlando Bloom hasn't had much luck with this whole acting thing ever since he was tossed from the Pirates of the Caribbean series - a notion confirmed by the fact that he had to beg actor Mark Ruffalo for a part in his 2011 film Sympathy for Delicious. Playing the front man in a rock band, Bloom is "The Stain" in a movie about music and faith healing. We don't recommend it. Still, despite poor critical reviews, Bloom is pretty good in the movie (well, for Orland Bloom, anyway), despite the fact that Ruffalo - who directed the movie - didn't envision him for the role at all. According to Ruffalo, he had other actors in mind. "Orlando wasn€™t my first choice for this movie,€ he revealed. "I sat down with him and we talked about it and he said, €˜I€™m really broken right now and I need an acting experience. I need something where I can really dig in and change myself. I think that, for people to be great, they need a lot of trust and encouragement and love and that€™s what Orlando needed." Presumably Orlando was struggling with the lack of good roles after Lord of the Rings and Pirates; shame he didn't beg for a part in a different movie.

7. Michelle Pfeiffer - Dark Shadows

Michelle Pfeiffer seems far less inclined to appear in a movie than she did a decade ago, but you might recall seeing her recently in Tim Burton's Dark Shadows, a relatively naff film that didn't seem to know what it was doing; Pfeiffer, however, was on noticeable form as one member of a large ensemble cast, which included the likes of Johnny Depp and Eva Green. Citing the fact that she very nearly lost out on her famed role as Catwoman in Batman Returns two decades ago, however, the actress has since admitted that she begged Burton for her Dark Shadows gig. "I called him up and begged him to be in it, okay?" Pfeiffer said on the subject. "It was shameless - oh, yes I did - I did. It was terrible of me. I was obsessed with Catwoman," she added, referring to what is perhaps her best remembered role. "I almost lost that opportunity. I mean things happen so kind of fast in that way. I thought, I'm not going to let that happen this time - I'm calling him!" Well, at least she's honest. We guess the old saying really does ring true: it's not what you know, but who you know. And in this case Michelle Pfeiffer knew Tim Burton.

6. Jason Bateman - The Change-Up

Despite the fact that it's not very good and nobody has watched it since, Arrested Development's brilliantly talented Jason Bateman - who seems unable to land himself a role in a good film - reportedly begged for his role in comedy The Change-Up, a body-swap comedy which co-starred Ryan Reynolds and Olivia Wilde. According to... well, himself, actually... Bateman was so taken with the premise behind this comedy flick that he begged the studio to cast him. It's safe to say that Jason Bateman might've jumped the gun a little, given the end result. "I was very excited to read the script based on the fact I was going to be playing two parts," the actor - who has also appeared in the likes of Horrible Bosses, The Switch and Identity Thief (all terrible) said in an interview. "It's the funniest script ever read so when I finished it I immediately emailed the studio and said, 'Please, please let me do this movie.'" Who knew it was possible for Hollywood actors to lobby for the parts they want over email? He got it, of course; no news yet as to whether he regrets declaring it the "funniest script ever," though.

5. Anne Hathaway - Les Miserables

Anne Hathaway near enough blew audiences away with her portrayal of Fantine in the filmic adaptation of the smash hit musical Les Miserables, which was helmed by acclaimed director Tom Hooper. Despite the fact that she went on to win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress for her brief turn as a terminally ill prostitute, and was responsible for what is arguably the film's best and most emotionally harrowing scene (not to mention she can actually sing - sorry, Russell Crowe), Hooper and company weren't originally convinced she was the right choice. So unconvinced were they that Hathaway could play Fantine, in fact, that they initially refused to see her in relation to the role. "I'm just very lucky that at this stage in my career, unless there's really stalwart opposition, I can usually get myself into a room," she said. "Once you're in there, all bets are off. You can change people's minds. I did it, and I've done it before." Hathaway's mother, also an actress, had played Fantine on stage in her younger years, and so - in the actress's own words - she "literally grew up hearing her practicing and singing it." Nice job, Anne.

4. Leonardo DiCaprio - Gangs Of New York

Leonardo DiCaprio is still probably best known for his turn as heartthrob Jack Dawson in Titanic, but the role that put him back on the map as an actor after he struggled to find the right projects in the years after that movie's phenomenal success was Gangs of New York, which would be the first of many successful team-ups with director Martin Scorsese. Playing Amsterdam Vallan in the period movie (which co-starred Daniel Day Lewis and Cameron Diaz), Gangs showed Leo in a new light and poised him as the toughest character of his entire career. But Scorsese, who has worked with DiCaprio five times in all (their most recent and arguably best collaboration was The Wolf of Wall Street), never originally sought about the actor for a part in the movie - DiCaprio had to pretty much beg the director to be involved. As he recalls, "As soon as I got the opportunity to finance a movie based on my own name, the only person on that list to be able to work with was Martin Scorsese. So I tracked down the only screenplay I knew had a character for me in it, and that was €˜Gangs of New York.'" Thank God you did, Leo.

3. Carrey Mulligan - Shame

It would have been a real shame had Carrey Mulligan not nabbed her part in Steve McQueen's harrowing drama about sex addiction, Shame, which had the actress playing the sister to Michael Fassbender's troubled protagonist. As Sissy, Mulligan is electrifying, and the performance is perhaps the most complicated and rounded one to her filmography to date - unlike in some of her more recent roles, where she has been branded as mildly interesting love interests, Shame shows the actress in full force; it's a incredibly brave and revealing performance. But Steve McQueen wasn't always convinced that Mulligan was the right actress to bring Sissy to life. For a character who is required to turn up and turn Fassbender's sex addict's life upside down in a hurricane of champagne bottles and nudity, it seemed McQueen felt like she was missing something. Reflecting on their initial meeting about the role, Mulligan said: "€˜Steve kept trying to leave the meeting. I sat him back on his chair and said: 'What do I need to do to get this job?'" Whatever he told her on that day, then, she obviously got it right.

2. Sally Field - Lincoln

Sally Field is an inspiration to actresses everywhere, having bagged two Oscars for her roles in Norma Rae and Places in the Heart. Those accolades alone should mean that Field shouldn't have to beg to be considered for an audition, at least, and yet that's exactly what happened when she lobbied for the part of Abraham Lincoln's wife, Mary Todd Lincoln, in Steven Spielberg's Oscar-winning biopic. So, why, exactly, did Steven Spielberg, one of Hollywood's most respected filmmakers, initially reject Field, one of Hollywood's most respected actresses? On account of her being too old, actually. "I'm 10 years older than Daniel and 20 years older than Abraham Lincoln's wife was and Steven told me he didn't see me in the role," she revealed in an interview. "But I knew I was right for this part and begged him to let me audition for it. He was kind enough to do that and Daniel is such a sweetheart that he flew over from his home in Ireland to screen test with me. I'll love him forever for that." Of course, Field's casting paid off; aside from being a wonderful Mary Todd, she won a Best Supporting Actress nomination.

1. Kate Winslet - Titantic

It's nearly impossible to think about Kate Winslet without thinking about Titanic at the same time, and though the actress has accomplished great things on the silver screen since she shot to worldwide fame in that movie (she won an Oscar in 2009 for her role in The Reader, you'll remember), her performance as Rose DeWitt Bukater in James Cameron's billion dollar behemoth remains her most memorable and recognised role, for good or for worse. What's surprising is that James Cameron was originally unsure about her; she really had to convince him. And by "convince" him, we mean that Winslet had to beg Cameron to let her play Rose, and spent many months campaigning for the role, even as the director sought out other actresses. In order to sway his judgement, then, Winslet sent Cameron daily notes from England, which eventually got her invited for an audition. She later sent him a rose saying "From Your Rose," and told him over the phone: "You don't understand! I am Rose! I don't know why you're even seeing anyone else!" Eventually Cameron caved and the rest, as they say, is history. Like this article? Got any to add? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.