10 Actors Who Blew Their Big Chance Before They Got Going

"I see unfulfilled careers..."

Breaking into film is a lifelong dream for many a struggling actor, and it's one which is notoriously difficult to achieve. But what about the few who hit the big time and are tipped for greatness, then just as quickly slip back into obscurity? The actors on this list all seemed to have true movie stardom ahead of them, only for their careers to stall before they even got going. Some had substance abuse problems, others were difficult to work with, and a few just consistently chose awful movies. Many continue to act, but never reached the dizzying heights which their early success seemed to guarantee. Robert De Niro can make as many terrible comedy films as he wants €“ and unfortunately for all of us it seems that he wants to make a lot of them €“ because he's still Robert De Niro at the end of the day, and he's got some (diminishing) goodwill built up. For the many actors who aren't Robert De Niro, Hollywood is still a cruel and fickle place. So get ready for a list which proves that talent only gets you so far, and that your dreams can be snatched away even if they come true. It's like all your favourite childhood films were lying to you.

10. Brandon Routh

Eight years on from Superman Returns, we've seen a whole lot of comic book movies, some of which have been abysmal (R.I.P.D., Jonah Hex), and some of which have utterly failed to live up to the source material no matter how excellent it is (Watchmen). Superman Returns, and by extension its star Brandon Routh, committed the crimes of being mediocre and trying too hard to respect Christopher Reeve, and in retrospect the huge backlash seems excessive to say the least. Routh picked up a poisoned chalice, replacing a beloved actor who was so accomplished in the role that you can understand why Metropolis might believe Clark Kent and Superman are two different people. As he was technically playing Reeve's Superman, he was caught between copying his predecessor and defeating the point of the continuation, so settled for a milquetoast performance which was entirely forgettable. And just like that, his big chance at fame went up in smoke. After Superman Returns he disappeared for two years, only to resurface in bit parts in 2008 still committed to a Superman sequel which never happened, saying that he just needed to 'take a break'. By that time his moment had passed and despite an entertaining turn on Chuck, it seems unlikely that he'll return as a leading man.

9. Sean Young

Sean Young is probably best known as the female lead in 1982's sci-fi classic Blade Runner. She had a couple of other hits in the 80s (including Dune), but the intensity of her performance opposite Harrison Ford suggested that she was destined for greater things. However, towards the end of the decade, Young began to get a reputation for disruptive behaviour on set. She clashed with Oliver Stone during the filming of Wall Street which reportedly led him to cut her role down. After a rocky time filming the 1988 movie The Boost, her co-star James Woods sued her for millions for harassment. It was settled out of court in 1989, according to EW. She has starred in a long list of TV movies in recent years, and the sheer volume of credits on her IMDB page suggests that she may be trying to make ends meet. Since 2008, Young has been in and out of rehab for alcoholism, and is periodically featured in the tabloids for drunken conduct such as an attempt to break into a post-Oscars ball in 2012. Here's hoping that Young can deal with her demons and find her way back to roles worthy of her talent.

8. Crispin Glover

Crispin Glover is still best known as George McFly in Back to the Future, but famously refused to return for the sequel. His turn as George is both funny and slightly tragic for those of us who empathise a little too closely with him, but Glover would not reprise the role despite the recognition it brought him. In an interview with XM Radio in New York last year, he said that his decision was primarily because of a disagreement with director Robert Zemeckis over a change in ending to Back to the Future II, and also because he was to be paid less than co-stars Lea Thompson and Thomas F. Wilson. Glover cemented his estrangement from the A-list with a bizarre appearance on Late Night with David Letterman in 1987, in which he appeared in character as Rubin from his new film Rubin and Ed. He wore platform shoes and a wig, argued with an audience member and arm-wrestled with Letterman, who had no idea what was going on and eventually just gave up and walked out. Rubin and Ed didn't come out until 1991, so for four years, everyone just assumed Glover had lost it. The moral of that story is that appearing in character on talk shows should be strictly reserved for Dame Edna Everage.

7. Jennifer Grey

Jennifer Grey's story is one of the more unusual on the list, but it still amounts to a decision which blew her chances of making it as a film siren. Her starring role as Frances 'Baby' Houseman in Dirty Dancing opposite Patrick Swayze left her in an excellent position to capitalise on her success in a film which somewhat inexplicably still endures today. Instead, she took roles in a string of TV movies, which Grey blames on her nose. It turns out that she was so unhappy with her nose (which was unusual but definitely not unattractive) that she had a nose job, which completely changed her face. Suddenly, all the publicity of Dirty Dancing was rendered moot. Grey went from a relative unknown to one of the most recognisable actresses in the mid-80s and back to an unknown again in record time. In the last few years, she's won Dancing with the Stars in the US and judged Strictly Come Dancing in the UK, and this year will be starring in a film penned by Joss Whedon, so perhaps her star is rising once again.

6. Linda Blair

After an Oscar-nominated performance in The Exorcist in 1973, 15-year-old Linda Blair unsurprisingly didn't seem quite sure how to follow such critical acclaim. At director William Friedkin's insistence, she was kept away from the more gruesome effects in the horror (including the most famous of all, the spinning head, accomplished with a dummy) and her luck began to turn as soon as this was leaked, diminishing her claim to the Oscar. Blair starred in a few underwhelming films and reprised her role as Regan in the sequel to her big hit in 1977, before succumbing to a drug addiction which left her unpopular in Hollywood. Since getting clean, she has combined nostalgic interviews and documentaries about The Exorcist with steady work in TV. Blair seems to have made peace with her status as the equivalent of a one-hit wonder, and in the meantime has founded a successful animal welfare charity.

5. C. Thomas Howell

The core Brat Pack members, from Judd Nelson to Molly Ringwald, are probably used to the phrase '80s heyday'. C. Thomas Howell of The Outsiders fame is no exception, and although he's forged a decent career as an adult actor, he never made it big after his turn as Ponyboy. With some of the entries on this list, it's difficult to pinpoint when exactly their time in the spotlight had passed, but Howell's can be traced quite convincingly to a 1986 film called Soul Man. Want to kill your career, teen heartthrobs? Do a film in blackface. Howell still stands by Soul Man, which has a 14% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and says it isn't offensive in tone, although the synopsis isn't promising: a white student pretends to be black to get a scholarship and is shocked to learn that racism exists. Needless to say Soul Man wasn't well received by audiences or critics and two years later Howell was working on direct-to-video projects. As career-destroying moves go, blackface is up there with the best €“ or the worst, if you're Howell, I guess.

4. Edward Furlong

Forget Avatar and Titanic, because Terminator 2: Judgment Day is easily the best film in James Cameron's repertoire, and Edward Furlong as a young John Connor is an integral part of that. Of course, the film has Linda Hamilton's dark Sarah Connor and Ahnold doing what Ahnold does best (i.e. playing up to his accent and punching people) but Furlong won himself a well-deserved Saturn Award for his performance. He took some roles in critically acclaimed indie films and American History X with Edward Norton, but Furlong's career was cut short by alcoholism and drug addiction. Now 36, he has admitted that his early twenties were spent addicted to cocaine and heroin, and roles subsequently dried up. He spent 2013 in rehab and is serving time for a probation violation after a string of domestic violence allegations.

3. Haley Joel Osment

Another child star who had the potential to make it big as an adult, Haley Joel Osment is still only 25 and popped up in The Spoils of Babylon this year, so might yet make a comeback. Nonetheless, he blew his chance at longevity in Hollywood simply by growing up. Apparently Hollywood was less interested in the teenager he became than they had been in the cute kid who'd starred in The Sixth Sense and A.I. Artificial Intelligence, and from 2002 he began to take roles voicing cartoon sequels and video games. Osment's talent is clear from his two biggest parts to date, and given his only crimes were putting on weight and getting (slightly) taller, he'll hopefully find a way back to our screens.

2. Alicia Silverstone

Perhaps Alicia Silverstone should have seen the signs. Batman Forever had been a box office success but wasn't exactly critically acclaimed, and Batman (Val Kilmer in the previous instalment) had once again been replaced €“ but that replacement was George Clooney, and Silverstone's other co-stars, including Uma Thurman, were hardly slouches either. Of course, the rest is history: Batman & Robin was infamously panned by critics and Silverstone won the Razzie Award for Worst Supporting Actress. Since then, she's starred in a few TV pilots which haven't been picked up and has popped up in bit roles in mediocre films, and she has some theatre credits to her name as well. Silverstone carried the 1995 comedy Clueless, a loosely adapted version of Jane Austen's Emma which has now achieved cult classic status, but it's her bland co-star Paul Rudd who's gone on to have the most profitable career. Batman & Robin now has a notorious reputation as a career-killer for both Silverstone and Chris O'Donnell (Robin), but Silverstone couldn't have known that in signing on the dotted line she was also signing away her chance at the big time. It's the best example of how bad luck and terrible timing can send an actor's career trajectory spiralling down into the abyss.

1. Thora Birch

The rise and fall of Thora Birch is a particularly sad story, because her performance in 1999's American Beauty still wows new viewers today; she's natural and vulnerable onscreen and if you go to seek out her work sure to find a list of credits as long as your arm, you'll be confronted by 2001's Ghost World and not a lot since. Although several news outlets have attributed this solely to her father, a former porn star and his daughter's manager who allegedly physically threatened one of Birch's co-stars in an off-Broadway revival of Dracula in 2010, Birch herself admits that she was an abrasive presence on set. Although acting like a diva is grudgingly permitted if you're an established A-lister guaranteed to rake in millions, young actors can't afford to be unprofessional, and Birch seems to have earned herself a reputation as difficult. In a recent interview with The Guardian she cites her firing from Alexander Payne's Election at the age of 14 for instigating several disagreements with the director as an example of her refusal to conform. Normally the manager would intervene to sort this out, but Mr. Birch's priority appears to be ensuring that Thora's sex scenes are filmed correctly, if a report in 2009 is anything to go by. Apparently he gave the director of crime drama Winter of Frozen Dreams tips on how to make his daughter look good, and was a constant presence behind the camera although Birch was then in her late twenties. With all the baggage Thora Birch seems to bring to a set, it's not surprising that she's no longer in Hollywood's inner circle and now sticks mainly to direct-to-video films. As with her fellow new talents who blew it, there's a phrase which immediately comes to mind: what a waste.

Contributor

Grace Murray hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.