10 Actors That Really Need To Stop Repeating Themselves

Same sh*t, different movie.

johnny depp pirates
Disney

The old saying goes that 'familiarity breeds contempt', and the phrase definitely applies to the movie business.

Whether it be too much of a good thing or a filmmaking trend that becomes so popular that it borders on the nauseating, Hollywood usually has no problem in running something into the ground. Think about the wave of gritty reboots that followed in the wake of Batman Begins, the Harry Potter-inspired rash of literary adaptations or the 'Avatar Effect' that saw seemingly every major movie given an often-shoddy 3D post-conversion.

Of course, this kind of repetition isn't just limited to movies themselves but often the people that star in them. We've become accustomed to expect a scene of Tom Cruise running, Shia LaBeouf's 'no no no no no' and Harrison Ford's continued concern for his wife and family to name but three. If an actor keeps repeating themselves, then it can quickly become an established part of their big-screen persona.

Matthew McConaughey managed to rehabilitate his career by keeping his shirt on, ditching the romantic comedies and reminding people that he was actually a great actor all along, but not everyone gets such a startling career reinvention. There are plenty of talented actors that have no problem doing the same thing in every movie, but in doing so run the risk of becoming stale.

10. Morgan Freeman

London Has Fallen Morgan Freeman
Focus Features

One of cinema's greatest-ever deliverers of exposition and perhaps its favorite wise old sage, the iconic syrupy tones of Morgan Freeman have been a constantly reassuring presence on our screens for decades now. Even at the age of 80 he shows no signs of slowing down either, appearing in seventeen movies in the last four years alone.

With his reputation assured as one of the all-time greats, Freeman has admitted that he still enjoys working, which is the reason why he takes on so many projects despite his octogenarian status. However, it would be nice to see him stretch his acting muscles a little more often as so many of his performances have become increasingly familiar.

Recent turns in the likes of Oblivion, Olympus/London Has Fallen, the Now You See Me franchise, Lucy, Transcendence, Ted 2 and Ben-Hur have all been variations on 'Morgan Freeman showing up to advance the plot', which has become something of an archetype unto itself.

While its always a pleasure to see the actor turn up and spout exposition like only he can, its been a long time since he's worked with material that he's really been able to sink his teeth into. The last time was arguably 2009's Nelson Mandela biopic Invictus, which was a well-known passion project for Freeman and scored him Best Actor nominations from the Academy Awards, Golden Globes and Screen Actors Guild. Less forgettable genre movies and more of that, please.


9. Liam Neeson

Liam Neeson Taken 2
20th Century Fox

Ever since his unlikely reinvention as one of cinema's most popular action heroes almost a decade ago, Liam Neeson has frequently returned to the well in the interim and kicked a lot of a** and taken a lot of names in the process. Yet having recently turned 65, there's only so much longer he can keep this up, as Taken 3 proved with some horrendously-edited action scenes that pointed out the Irishman's aversion to being seen running on camera.

In the wake of Taken's success, Neeson's career has largely been split into three distinct parts; that of the ageing bada** (Non-Stop, A Walk Among the Tombstones, Run All Night), voice work (the Narnia franchise, The Nut Job, The Lego Movie, A Monster Calls) and supporting roles in effects-laden genre movies (Battleship, the Titans series, The A-Team).

Given his recent penchant for more commercial fare it would be easy for people to forget that Neeson made his name as an acclaimed dramatic actor, one that has been nominated for an Academy Award, a BAFTA, three Golden Globes and two Tonys.

Now officially old enough to qualify for a pension, perhaps now is the time for Neeson to step away from increasingly-generic action thrillers and lend his undoubted gravitas to a wider array of projects. It can't be a coincidence that working with Martin Scorsese on Silence resulted in one of the actor's best performances in a long time.


8. Samuel L Jackson

Samuel L Jackson Captain America 2.jpg
Marvel Studios

One of the most prolific actors in the industry, Samuel L. Jackson has starred in well over 100 movies since his big screen way back in 1972. Since 2010 alone, the 68 year-old has appeared in 33 films with a further four set for release next year.

Although he likes to keep busy, one of the pitfalls of starring in such a high number of movies is that Jackson is frequently accused of phoning in his performances, and seems to have little interest in the material outside of the paycheck. While that may sound unfair, think of his disinterested work in Oldboy, RoboCop, Barely Lethal, The Legend of Tarzan, Kong: Skull Island and most of his tenure in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and you see an actor largely going through the motions.

It seems that only regular collaborator Quentin Tarantino can bring the best out of Jackson, with his performances in Django Unchained and The Hateful Eight standing head and shoulders above the rest of his output in recent years. A dedicated and motivated Samuel L. Jackson is still one hell of a talent, but the actor needs to stop coasting by on his natural charisma in a constant stream of average-at-best genre movies and rediscover the fire and passion that made him a star in the first place.


7. Michael Cera

Michael Cera This Is The End
Columbia Pictures

After the initial run of Arrested Development ended in 2006, Michael Cera broke out in a big way the following year with the one-two punch of smash-hit comedy Superbad and Best Picture-nominated Juno. The following decade has shown an inability to evolve, as the actor has remained firmly entrenched in his wheelhouse delivering the usual awkward schtick with little growth as a talent.

The strange thing is that despite being largely typecast as a quiet, soft-spoken geek in theatrical features, Cera has shown some versatility away from the multiplex. He executive-produced psychological thriller Magic Magic in 2013, served as both star and writer/director of several short films, co-created the meta television series Clark and Michael with Clark Duke and engineered, mixed, produced, sang and played all of the instruments on his 2014 debut album.

His outside interests show a performer capable of wearing many hats, but outside of his hilariously subversive turn as a cocaine-fueled a**hole version of himself in This Is The End, Cera has spent the great majority of his big-screen career essentially playing the same character over and over again. Whether this is the fault of the actor himself, or the casting directors that have pigeonholed him for the last ten years, remains to be seen.


6. Jason Statham

The Mechanic Jason Statham
Summit Entertainment

The 'Jason Statham Movie' has become an action sub-genre all of its own. Moderately-budgeted flicks that feature the chrome-domed star showing off his impressive martial arts skills are an almost annual occurrence and usually have uninspiring one-word names such as Chaos, War, Blitz, Safe, Homefront and Parker.

With bona-fide action heroes becoming a dying breed, Statham has become one of the genre's most recognizable and important faces almost by default. But he is capable of much more than his rather limited filmography would suggest.

His scene-stealing supporting turn in Paul Feig's Spy showed an ability to poke fun at his established persona and a surprising flair for comedy, while his unique brand of straight-faced charisma powered the gloriously demented Crank movies. Even his increasingly prominent role in the Fast and Furious has utilized his natural screen presence better than his last half-dozen star vehicles.

Now 50 years of age, Statham can't keep kicking generic henchmen in the face forever. Next year sees the actor stepping out of his comfort zone to headline the $150m prehistoric shark blockbuster Meg, which at least marks a refreshing change of pace form the usual repetitive beat-em-ups that have become his bread and butter over the last fifteen years.


5. Michelle Rodriguez

Michelle Rodriguez Fast and the furious
Universal Studios

The easiest way to describe Michelle Rodriguez' filmography is that she pretty much always plays what could be described as a 'Michelle Rodriguez-type character'. The 39 year-old actress has made a career out of playing strong, feisty women in action movies that can kick a** just as well (if not better) than the men, but in her very first big-screen role she received serious critical acclaim for her dramatic work.

The breakthrough role in question, as the lead in Karyn Kusama's 2000 sports flick Girlfight, showed genuine promise and saw Rodriguez win an Independent Spirit Award for Best Debut Performance and both National Board of Review and Gotham Awards for Best Breakthrough. However, Rodriguez' next role was as Letty in The Fast and the Furious and since then, she has almost exclusively played variations on the same archetypal character.

As well as five Fast and Furious movies we have also seen this strict adherence to type in two Resident Evils, two Machetes, SWAT, Avatar, Battle: Los Angeles, Walter Hill's controversial The Assignment and next year's Alita: Battle Angel. While Rodriguez should be commended for carving out a niche for herself in the male-dominated action genre, she has never lived up to the early promise shown in Girlfight by playing it safe and sticking to her established persona.


4. Bruce Willis

Precious Cargo Bruce Willis
Lionsgate

Formerly one of the biggest movie stars on the planet, Bruce Willis now finds himself mired in the same straight-to-video doldrums that Nicolas Cage has called home for the past few years. Willis' career has been on a downward trajectory for some time now, which may or may not have anything to do with his reputation for being increasingly difficult to work with but definitely has something to do with his recent habit of starring in entirely forgettable genre movies that nobody even watches.

As shown in Moonrise Kingdom and Looper, a motivated Bruce Willis can still give a great performance when he is genuinely interested, but that was five years ago. Since then, he's gone through the motions in sequels to Die Hard, G.I. Joe, RED, Sin City and The Expendables before ultimately being relegated to home video releases with bland titles like Extraction, Precious Cargo, Marauders and First Kill.

Eli Roth, director of the upcoming Death Wish remake, has said that the project can do for Willis' career what Taken did for Liam Neeson's. However, the most intriguing collaboration on the 62 year-old's schedule is M. Night Shyamalan's Glass. The writer/director has gotten great work from Willis before, so hopefully the actor puts some effort in because the last few years have seen him looking nothing but bored out of his skull in a series of repetitive genre flicks.


3. Adam Sandler

Adam Sandler
New Line Cinema

Adam Sandler became one of the most successful movie stars in the world thanks to his polarizing brand of comedy that usually saw him playing some form of man-child backed by a supporting cast of his close buddies, usually making d*ck and fart jokes. It may not have been for everyone, but the fact that twelve of his movies between 1999 and 2013 earned over $100m at the domestic box office showed that the man had his fans.

His recent exclusive deal with Netflix has been more of the same. The Ridiculous 6 may have been universally panned and hold a rare 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, but was viewed more times in its first 30 days than any other Netflix original movie. Follow-ups The Do-Over and Sandy Wexler were similarly vilified, but the streaming giant nonetheless extended their deal with Sandler for four more movies.

People still keep paying him millions of dollars to make terrible movies, so where is the incentive to change? What makes it even more infuriating is that the guy can genuinely act when he wants to.

Sandler received critical praise for his work in Punch-Drunk Love, Spanglish, Reign Over Me and Funny People, but is currently receiving the best notices of his career for what is said to be a fantastic performance in Noah Baumbach's The Meyerowitz Stories. Unfortunately, this will more than likely be nothing more than a minor blip before the actor reverts to type in another four interminable Netflix projects.


2. Johnny Depp

Johnny Depp Alice
Disney

Once the idiosyncratic poster boy of 1990s American independent cinema, the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise scored Johnny Depp his first Academy Award nomination and turned him into one of the biggest movie stars on the planet in the process. Since then, the actor has given very few genuinely memorable performances and seems more content to play dress-up and phone it in rather than re-establish his long-forgotten reputation as one of the finest talents of his generation.

These days, when people catch wind of a wig-wearing, heavily made-up and accent-sporting Johnny Depp their first instinct is usually to roll their eyes. And with good reason; the four Pirates of the Caribbean sequels, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Alice In Wonderland and its sequel, Dark Shadows, The Lone Ranger, Transcendence, Mortdecai and Kevin Smith collaborations Tusk and Yoga Hosers are hardly regarded as career high-points.

While the approach did yield critical acclaim in regards to Sweeney Todd and Black Mass, it has become rather tiresome at this point. After a string of box office bombs and his stock in the industry lower than it has been for over a decade, Johnny Depp really needs to lose all the trimmings and return to the character-based work that made him such an interesting actor in the first place.


1. Vin Diesel

The Fate Of The Furious Vin Diesel
Universal

Even though he broke into Hollywood by writing, directing, producing and starring in his own features, has worked with acclaimed auteurs Steven Spielberg, Sidney Lumet and Ang Lee during his career and founded the production company responsible for turning the Fast and Furious series into a blockbuster behemoth that boasts both a record label and video game studio as subsidiaries, Vin Diesel sure does love playing it safe.

How safe? Between the year 2000 when Pitch Black officially set him on the road to stardom and the release of the fourth Avengers movie in 2019, Diesel will have only appeared in seven projects outside of his established franchises, which isn't the kind of versatility you'd expect from a big-name star over the span of two decades.

In the interim, Diesel will have made eight appearances as Dominic Toretto, five as Richard B. Riddick, four as Groots of a various age and two as xXx's Xander Cage. The fact that most of his non-franchise projects have tanked at the box office surely factored into his decision to take such a safe route with his career, but for a guy that was touted as a genuine talent at the turn of the 21st Century it simply smacks of an unwillingness to take risks.


Contributor

I don't do social media, so like or follow me in person but please maintain a safe distance or the authorities will be notified. Don't snap me though, I'll probably break. I was once labelled a misogynist on this very site in a twenty paragraph-long rant for daring to speak ill of the Twilight franchise. I stand by what I said, it's crap.