10 Actors Who Weren't Able To Let Star Wars Go

Anthony Daniels C3po

The buzz surrounding Star Wars: Episode VII continues to grow with the recent announcement of open auditions running across the UK until November 24th. The first such audition in Bristol (near my neck of the woods) saw thousands of teenagers and early-20-somethings turning up for the chance to be part of the most popular saga in fantasy history. Despite my initial misgivings about Disney buying Star Wars, and about J. J. Abrams in general, I'm going to keep an open mind about the film until its release in 2015. But these auditions are as good a time as any to sound a note of caution about becoming part of the Star Wars universe. To all those who manage to audition over the next few days, enjoy it but be warned: once you're in Star Wars, it's almost impossible to get out. Now, a great many among you wouldn't turn up your nose at screen immortality within a franchise that has captivated the world since the 1970s. And you might argue that since George Lucas is no longer in control, there's less chance of anything bad happening. But all too often the talented actors involved in the franchise have had their careers completely overshadowed by it, or sometimes had no real career at all. Sure, Harrison Ford has done pretty well for himself, and Ewan McGregor and Natalie Portman escaped largely unscathed, but how many others can claim that? Here then is my list of ten actors who, for all their talent and hard work, still live in Lucas' all-encompassing shadow. In each case, I'll be evaluating whether they deserved their fate, and highlighting other work of theirs which deserves recognition. Let's begin with a certain Admiral...

10. Kenneth Colley

Kenneth ColleyCharacter & Films: Admiral Piett, The Empire Strikes Back & Return of the Jedi. Before Star Wars: Colley was rubbing shoulders with some of Britain's most talented directors. He worked with Richard Lester on How I Won The War, Nicolas Roeg in Performance, and Ken Russell on both The Music Lovers and Lisztomania. He also worked with Terry Gilliam twice, having a cameo in Jabberwocky and playing Jesus Christ in Monty Python's Life of Brian. After Star Wars: Aside from brief appearances in Brassed Off and Mike Hodges' The Rainbow, Colley's career after Star Wars has been largely built around TV. He has continued to work solidly, with longer parts in Holby City and Eastenders, but nothing up to his former glory. Did He Deserve Better?: Probably. Lucas must have seen something in Colley's abilities, since his character is the only Imperial officer to last more than one Star Wars film. Look No Further: Frédéric Chopin in Lisztomania (1975). Only Ken Russell would cast Ringo Starr as the Pope.

9. Richard LePartmentier

Star Wars Force ChokeCharacter & Film: Admiral Motti, A New Hope. Before Star Wars: Very little, aside from brief appearances in Stardust (alongside David Essex!) and the original version of Rollerball. After Star Wars: LePartmentier's only big post-strangle role was Lieutenant Santino in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. He also made brief appearances in Superman II and Octopussy (which I covered in my Bond article here), along with TV work like The Professionals and Reilly: Ace of Spies. He was in addition a regular on the conventions circuit until his death earlier this year. Did He Deserve Better?: On the face of it, no. But considering how iconic his moment in Star Wars became, you'd have though he would have found it easier to get decent parts. Look No Further: Lieutenant Santino in Who Framed Roger Robbit (1988). Don't go near the dip.

8. Kenny Baker

R2D2Character & Films: R2-D2, in all of them. He also plays Paloo in Return of the Jedi (the Ewok that steals the speeder and goes flying off in to the forest). Before Star Wars: Not a great deal. Aside from a couple of TV appearances, Baker spent most of his early life as a circus performer or stage actor. Just before he was spotted by Lucas, he performed as 'The Minitones' with fellow dwarf actor Jack Purvis. After Star Wars: Baker has continued to work solidly since the 1980s, appearing in the cult classic Flash Gordon, the Oscar-winning Amadeus, Ron Howard's Willow and Michael Winterbottom's 24 Hour Party People. He is a favourite actor of Terry Gilliam's, having appeared in Time Bandits, Brazil and The Adventures of Baron Munchausen. He has also worked as a stand-up comedian. Did He Deserve Better?: Hard to say. Notwithstanding the success of Peter Dinklage, film opportunities for dwarf actors are still quite limited, so it's not entirely surprising that Baker's subsequent career has not kept him as much in the limelight. Look No Further: Fidgit in Time Bandits (1981). Apparently he represents Michael Palin.

7. Billy Dee Williams

landoCharacter & Films: Lando Calrissian, The Empire Strikes Back & Return of the Jedi. Before Star Wars: Williams was one of the leading black actors of the 1960s and 1970s. Having cut his teeth with small parts in Mission: Impossible and The F.B.I., he came to prominence on film with Lady Sings The Blues and Mahogany, along with an uncredited appearance in Francis Ford Coppola's The Conversation. After Star Wars: Aside from a prominent role in Dynasty and playing the original Harvey Dent in Tim Burton's Batman, Williams' career has always been slightly under the radar. He's had no trouble finding work, but there's no real cinematic stand-outs. He also reprised his role as Lando for episodes of Robot Chicken and parodied his performance on Scrubs. Did He Deserve Better?: Definitely. He's one of the most charismatic actors in the Star Wars universe, and one of the most interesting characters. His first scene in The Empire Strikes Back is pure testosterone as he goes head to head with Harrison Ford. Look No Further: Sergeant Matthew Fox in Nighthawks (1981). A pivotal performance to balance both Rutger Hauer and Sylvester Stallone (no easy task).

6. David Prowse

david prowse vaderCharacter & Films: Darth Vader (body only) in the original trilogy. Before Star Wars: A body-builder by trade, Prowse's early career revolved around his physical appearance - making it all the more ironic that his face is never seen in Star Wars. He played Frankenstein's monster twice, in Casino Royale and The Horror of Frankenstein, and appears briefly in A Clockwork Orange, The Tomorrow People and as the Minotaur in two episodes of Doctor Who. In Britain he also headed up the 'Green Cross Code' TV campaign. After Star Wars: He got Christopher Reeve into shape for the Superman films and trained Cary Elwes for his role in The Princess Bride. He continued to appear in 'muscle man' or bodyguard roles on The Benny Hill Show and Morecambe and Wise until his health began failing in the 1990s. He now works as an arthritis campaigner and was a regular on the convention circuit until 2010. Did He Deserve Better?: Partially. Prowse can feel aggrieved for not having his voice used for Darth Vader, and Lucasfilm has not treated him kindly (he still hasn't been paid for Return of the Jedi). But he's had a pretty good career considering that we never got to see his face. Look No Further: Julian in A Clockwork Orange (1971). He makes the dinner table scene all the more intimidating.

5. Carrie Fisher

214993-princess-leia-star-wars-episode-vii

Character & Films: Princess Leia Organa in the original trilogy - and confirmed for Episode VII. Before Star Wars: Very little, other than a TV film with Debbie Reynolds and a supporting role in Hal Ashby's Shampoo. After Star Wars: Fisher's battle with drug addiction and depression has received considerably more attention than her acting career. It's a career of highs and lows, the highs being Hannah and Her Sisters and When Harry Met Sally..., and the lows including Drop Dead Fred and Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle. She has, however, found success as a writer and has gamely parodied herself on Robot Chicken. Did She Deserve Better?: Probably. Because her pre-Lucas career is so brief, it's hard to say how good she would have been without the drug problems. Hopefully reprising her role in Episode VII will lead to a reappraisal of her career. Look No Further: April in Hannah and Her Sisters (1986). It might just be Woody Allen's best film.

4. Hayden Christiansen

Anakin-Skywalker-anakin-skywalker-28518876-879-391Character & Films: Anakin Skywalker, Attack of the Clones & Revenge of the Sith. Before Star Wars: Christiansen made his name as a teen star, appearing in episodes of Goosebumps and Are You Afraid of the Dark? before his big adult break in Sofia Coppola's The Virgin Suicides. He also has a cameo in John Carpenter's H. P. Lovecraft homage In The Mouth of Madness. After Star Wars: Aside from leading roles in Shattered Glass and Jumper, Christiansen has kept a low-ish profile. He appeared in the Bob Dylan-esque role Billy Quinn in Factory Girl, as well as Takers, Awake, Vanishing on 7th Street and New York, I Love You, none of which were particularly successful either critically or commercially. He has four films due out in 2014. Did He Deserve Better?: No. Pretty much everyone is agreed that he can't act, and his casting is one of the worst decisions Lucas ever made. He may be a nice guy in person, but we won't be wishing for a cameo in Episode VII any time soon €“ nor for any more unsolicited appearances in the original trilogy. Look No Further: Stephen Glass in Shattered Glass (2003). Not great, but probably the best he can do.

3. Anthony Daniels

Anthony Daniels C3poCharacter & Films: C-3PO, in all of them - and rumoured for Episode VII. He also plays the humanoid Dannl Faytonni in both Attack of the Clones & Revenge of the Sith. Before Star Wars: Nothing, other than one episode of the TV series Centre Play. After Star Wars: Daniels voiced Legolas in Ralph Bakshi's The Lord of the Rings, which I covered in my article on John Hurt here. He has also made appearances on The Bill, Prime Suspect, The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles and the relaunched Randall & Hopkirk (Deceased). Did He Deserve Better?: No. Daniels owes his entire career to George Lucas, and he's been happily milking C3PO for all his worth since 1977. He's appeared in character for video games, the Clone Wars TV series, drug PSAs and even a Star Wars fan film. Long may he continue to do so. Look No Further: Legolas in The Lord of the Rings (1978). But he's no Orlando Bloom.

2. Mark Hamill

Star Wars Mark HamillCharacter & Films: Luke Skywalker in the original trilogy - and rumoured for Episode VII. Before Star Wars: Hamill was almost exclusively a TV actor before Star Wars, beginning with appearances on The Bill Cosby Show and General Hospital, and lending his voice to Jeannie. His only film credit prior to A New Hope is the voice of Sean in Ralph Bakshi's Wizards. After Star Wars: Hamill has had an extensive voice acting career, being most famous for playing the Joker in Batman: The Animated Series. He also lent his voice to the English dubs for two Hayao Miyazaki films, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind and Castle in the Sky. He has occasionally appeared on stage, playing John Merrick in The Elephant Man and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart in Amadeus (a year before the Oscar-winning film version). Live action roles include The Big Red One and John Carpenter's remake of Village of the Damned. Did He Deserve Better?: Yes. Hamill's had a wonderful career as a voice artist, but even with his unfortunate accident in 1977 he should have been a big live-action star. He's done very well for himself, but you can't help but wonder what might have been. Look No Further: The Joker in Batman: The Animated Series (1992-94). Before Heath Ledger came along, his Joker was the best around.

1. Sir Alec Guinness

Star WarsCharacter & Films: Obi-Wan Kenobi in the original trilogy. Obviously. Before Star Wars: Where do you start? Alec Guinness remains one of the greatest actors of the 20th century, and his career is filled with fascinating characters. Professor Marcus in The Ladykillers, Fagin in Oliver Twist, an entire family of aristocrats in Kind Hearts and Coronets - there was no end to the man's talents. He worked with the great David Lean on six occasions, winning an Oscar for his Colonel Nicholson in The Bridge on the River Kwai. He also had a successful stage career, treading the boards with both John Gielgud and Laurence Olivier. After Star Wars: Guinness played George Smiley in the TV versions of Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy and its sequel Smiley's People. He worked with Lean once more on A Passage to India before winding down in the 1990s. He died in 2000 aged 86. Did He Deserve Better?: Yes. Guinness became so resentful of people only knowing him for Star Wars that he eventually stopped opening fan mail that was sent to him. Considering his rich body of work before Star Wars and his excellent TV work afterwards, it's a crying shame that so many still only see him as "that old fossil". Look No Further: The entire D'Ascoyne family in Kind Hearts and Coronets (1949). Eight great performances in one of Britain's darkest comedies. --- Be sure to drop a comment below if I've overlooked anyone, or visit Mumby at the Movies for more film reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.