10 Actors Who Just Stopped Working In Their Prime

Did Alison Lohman really get dragged to hell five years ago?

Actors, to make a sweeping generalisation, enjoy the spotlight. That's at least part of the reason they go in for the acting lark in the first place; to be seen by millions of people across the world, to be adored by strangers, to have their ego fed, to have people pay attention to them. So it stands to reason that when they decide to quit their chosen profession they go and make a big song and dance about it, too. Just look at the recent shenanigans of the kid from Even Stevens. There are exceptions to that rule, though. Actors who quietly disappeared, fading into obscurity rather than burning out in a blaze of self-promotion for whatever other field they're devoting their time to (which usually culminates in them returning to acting after all; I call this "Jay-Z retirement"). There are actors who don't necessarily intend to stop working, but whose IMDb pages haven't been updated in years. Work dries up. Skin sags. And people just disappear. Here's ten of those very thespians who inexplicably disappeared from Hollywood at the height of their fame.

10. Michael Schoeffling

Unless, like me, you're a John Hughes aficionado, you may be asking "who"? But let me assure you, for a brief period in the mid-80s, Michael Schoeffling was the proverbial hot stuff (and the literal, check out that tank top, phwoar). Breaking out with his debut role in Sixteen Candles, the teen movie classic starring Molly Ringwald, Shoeffling capitalised on the film's success by booking roles in eight films you've probably never heard of, and promptly fell off the face of the Earth. Since officially retiring in 1991, not seven years after his turn as Jake Ryan, Shoeffling has given few interviews. In the handful he has accepted, he admitted that he had trouble finding suitable roles and found himself with a growing family to provide for. So, naturally, he became a carpenter. He now owns a woodworking shop and creates handmade furniture to order. Jake Ryan, meanwhile, remains an iconic character in the John Hughes film pantheon, immortalised in synth-pop duo Summer Camp's song of the same name, and his legacy was discussed 20 years later in a Washington Post article called "Real Men Can't Hold a Match to Jake Ryan of Sixteen Candles".

9. Alison Lohman

The way things have turned out for her, you can't help but speculate that maybe Alison Lohman has fallen foul of some sort of gypsy curse. That was the fate that befell her character in Sam Raimi's 2009 horror Drag Me To Hell, which happens to be the last film Lohman has made to date. Where that film revitalized the career - or at least the average review scores - for the director of Spider-Man 3, it was a death sentence for Lohman. Since her first role in, ahem, Kraa! The Sea Monster, Lohman booked parts in films as diverse as Big Fish, Matchstick Men, Beowulf, and Gamer, yet she hasn't appeared on our screens since 2009. That last film is the real reason why, however: Not long after it's release (in the same year as Drag Me To Hell) Lohman married its co-director, Mark Neveldine, also known for his work on the Crank films. Since then the couple have had two children and, from the looks of things, Lohman has gone for the stay-at-home mom route. For the time being, at least.

8. Renee Zellweger

Bridget Jones. Beatrix Potter. Whatever she was called in Empire Records. What do all of these characters have in common? They were all played by Renee Zellweger, who up until recently was one of the most talented actresses working in Hollywood, as at home playing the perpetually single Brit Jones to Southern belle Ruby in Cold Mountain to a fish in Shark Tale. That is, up until a few years ago, where her CV begins to get a little more sparse. Romantic comedy New In Town and horror flick Case 39 were both heavily delayed, shot some years ago but only released in 2009 to mixed reviews; her most recent role was as a paralysed musician in 2010's My Own Love Song. Since then we've heard nary a peep from her, save for a TV pilot she co-created and produced that wasn't picked up last year. This one's especially weird because there doesn't seem to be any reason for Zellweger's disappearance from the radar, and nobody seems to have noticed, either. Shame.

7. Bridget Fonda

The Fondas are quite the dynasty in Hollywood. In the golden age of film Henry Fonda lit up the screen with star turns in the Grapes of Wrath and 12 Angry Men. His kids, Peter and Jane, helped to reinvent cinema with subversive sixties classics like Easy Rider and Barbarella. Then came Bridget, Peter's daughter, who looked like she was headed down a similar path, with memorable appearances in A Simple Plan, Jackie Brown and Single White Female. Well, maybe the last one less so. Except then she just seemed to peter out. She made her last film in 2002, a TV version of the Snow Queen. She had previously been linked with Ally McBeal when it was in development, but turned it down, and more recently was replaced in a role written especially for her in Lipstick Jungle. So what happened? Like with Zellweger, it's not clear. Neither actress seems quite old enough to have hit the film industry's stunningly sexist cut off for the point that they'll hire females in leading roles, neither has given any statement as to why they've stopped working, and both were at pretty good places in their careers. As with Lohman, however, the reason behind Fonda's disappearance might just be love. In 2003 she married Danny Elfman, the guy who does the music for every Tim Burton film (plus The Simpsons theme tune), so maybe she's busy...being busy?

6. Mena Suvari

In the summer of '99, you couldn't turn without hitting a film with America in the title and Mena Suvari in the cast list. Well I mean, I think there was only two - American Pie and American Beauty - but the young blonde actress was a big part of both of them, and seemed destined for greater things. Cut ahead to about 15 years later (ie the present day) and outside of a cameo appearance in the recent American Reunion, I can't say I've seen much of Ms Suvari. Except in the direct-to-video remake of Day of the Dead that I try really, really hard not to remember. Dammit, failed again. Stupid article. To be fair to Suvari, she hasn't quite finished with acting altogether, just faded from the public consciousness somewhat. Y'know, compared to when she starred in two of the biggest films of the year in the same summer. It has been a couple of years since she's appeared in anything, though, which means it's been about three years since she's been filming. besides a bit part in firefighting TV show Chicago Fire (that's a show about firefighters, not a show that fights fires itself). Suvari, sadly, just seems to be one of those lost souls that picked the wrong parts and is dealing with the consequences. I blame Kevin Spacey, personally.

5. Joe Pesci

What do you mean this article's funny? What do you mean, you mean the way I write? What? Funny how? What's funny about it? I'll have you know I'm no clown, and neither is Joe Pesci. At least not for the past few years, where the pint-sized rage machine has put in barely any on-screen performances, save for a cameo in his mate De Niro's The Good Shepherd and a role in little-seen 2010 drama Love Ranch. After coming up with Martin Scorsese with memorable parts in his movies Raging Bull, Goodfellas, and the casino-based remake of Goodfellas (Casino) - with a side order of hammy bad guy in the first two Home Alone movies, THE ONLY HOME ALONE MOVIES IF YOU ASK ME - Pesci announced his retirement from the acting game in 1999. Which is more than a lot of the people on this list have bothered doing, let me tell you. Of course he has appeared in bit parts since then, and in a terrible Snickers advert in 2011 for some reason (money, the reason was money). In fact the almighty dollar is probably the reason Pesci hasn't felt the need to act properly for over a decade, since he's instead been working as a producer on the Broadway/West End smash-hit stage musical Jersey Boys. No doubt the news that a film adaptation in the works will be good for his coffers, if not his career on screen. Still, at least he's not quit to pursue a musical career himself.

4. Greta Garbo

In a lot of ways Great Garbo was the original Shia Labeouf. And in a lot of other, much more accurate ways, she wasn't anything like him: she was one of the best and most successful actresses of both the silent and golden age of Hollywood films, a multiple Oscar nominee, and her name autocorrects as "Great Gatsby" on my phone. Suddenly, though, she threw that all away. At the tender age of 35, Garbo announced her retirement from both the silver screen and public life as a whole. Of course, that didn't stop people trying to coax her back into both. Producers were trying to tempt her back into acting roles right up until her death in 1990, aged 84, but the German-born actress wouldn't even compromise with cameo roles as some of the other "retired" actors we've looked at have. Her private life, meanwhile, was intensely scrutinised: she never married, never had children, and lived the majority of her adult life alone. This wasn't anything new, either, as during the height of her fame she rarely gave interviews, shirked fancy Hollywood parties and never signed autographs. Her studio bosses, initially frustrated, eventually capitalised on Garbo's mysterious nature. The tl:dr of this is, basically, Garbo was an incredibly talented and popular actor who got bored, didn't like the attention, and decided to live a quiet, simple life instead. Oh and she was an art collector, with a personal gallery with millions of dollars. So that probably helped.

3. Amanda Bynes

One of the saddest stories of celebrity troubles in modern times is that of Amanda Bynes. Starting as a TV star on kids channel Nickelodeon, Bynes parlayed her experience into teen movies like She's The Man, Syndey White and Easy A. She had a comedic timing that a lot of rom-com actresses lack, and looked like she could have been her generation's Alicia Silverstone...well, except more successful, ideally. Instead, Bynes fell prey to pretty much all of the darker temptations LA has to offer: drink, drugs, and plastic surgery. Since 2012 she has been arrested numerous times for driving under the influence, possession of marijuana and more. Not-so-coincidentally, 2012 was the year she announced her retirement from acting, although it had already been two years since her last job. Since then Bynes has been checked into a private facility for mental health issues. It would be nice if Bynes one day managed to recapture her initial promise, but what's really important is she gets healthy.

2. Gene Hackman

Like Pesci, he might not have been in his "prime" - that'd be the 70s, when he was as at home playing complicated cop Popeye Doyle and uncomplicated pantomime villain Lex Luthor - but in the early days of the new millenium, the notoriously prickly Gene Hackman seemed to be going through a latter-day career renaissance. He had already reprised his role from the paranoia classic The Conversation in Enemy of the State, and won a Golden Globe for his more grounded (or just OTT in a different way) part as the patriarch in Wes Anderson's masterpiece, The Royal Tenenbaums. But that's pretty much the last we've heard from Hackman. In films, at least. Over the past few years he has published three historical novels in collaboration with an undersea archaeologist, along with a Western book. In 2004, during an interview with Larry King, Hackman admitted he had no acting roles lined up, but it wasn't until he was promoting his third book in 2008 that he officially confirmed he had retired. Even then, nobody made a big song-and-dance about it. For most, Hackman just sort of dropped off the map. Which might be because his final screen role to date was opposite Ray Romano in the awful comedy Welcome to Mooseport, and we're all secretly hoping he'll do something else, and go out on the high he had been building too.

1. Thora Birch

We've gone through a lot of strange, sad and silly stories throughout this odyssey of missing actors, but perhaps the strangest, saddest and silliest is that of Thora Birch. Like Mena Suvari, her co-star in American Beauty, there was a period where Thora Birch was in every hip, successful film going, most notably her starring role in the cult classic Ghost World. She was also in that big-budget Dungeons and Dragons film, which probably seemed a good idea at the time. Maybe if she'd got a better roll on initiative... Anyway, after that brief period where she was one of the hottest young actors working she, well, stopped working. Or at least, stopped working in films of the quality and popularity of her breakout turns. So whatever happened to Thora Birch's career? Her weird dad, that's what. There's a reason we've not seen much of Thora as of late - her last film was in 2012, and I can say with some certainty you didn't see it - and that's because her dad is her manager. And her dad is insane. Besides doing creepy stuff like practically directing his daughter's sex scene in 2009's Winter of Frozen Dreams, the elder Birch - who was a porn actor in his heyday, and "acted" with his wife in not-a-Watergate-film Deep Throat - has lost his daughter/only client pretty much every stage and screen part she's been up for in the past five years by threatening anyone who goes near her, any director whose staging he disapproves of, and generally being a nutcase. Unfortunately for Birch, whilst firing your manager can be a tricky business, firing your dad is even harder. So I wouldn't hold your breath for a return by Enid Coleslaw any time soon, unless her dad comes up against a producer that's equally insane. And I really, really hope there isn't any such producer.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/