10 Actors Who Played Both Marvel And DC Characters Before Ben Affleck
Amongst the many complaints about the recent casting of Ben Affleck as Batman, people have repeatedly argued that he can't play DC's Dark Knight when hes already known as Daredevil in the Fox adaptation of the Marvel comic. The argument is that nobody should be allowed to play more than one superhero, let alone cross over between characters owned by these two age old rivals. Affleck, though, is far from the first actor to crop up in a film adaptation of both Marvel and DC properties. So what are his chances of transcending his previous role in the better-as-a-director's-cut blind lawyer flop to embody completely the billionaire gadget freak and so-called "World's Greatest Detective"? Well, for these 10 previous actors to have crossed between Marvel and DC, their attempts at reinvention have been a decidedly mixed bag. For all that its possible to appear in both sets of movies, the Oscar winning writer-director might not want to presume too much on a return to the acting A-list... 10. James Marsden
For Marvel: The square in the love triangle - one eyed monster Scott Summers AKA Cyclops in X-Men, X2: X-Men United and X-Men: The Last Stand For DC: Non-comic canonical news editor nephew and superbaby step-dad Richard White in Superman Returns How did the change work out? Marsden, an actor whose comic chops and charisma were apparent in Disneys lighthearted fairy tale spoof Enchanted, never got an awful lot to do as X-Man Cyclops. Supposedly the teams leader on the ground, the comics have often struggled to give the eye-lasered one a great deal of personality to justify his leading role. On the big screen there was a similar problem and Marsden was never able to imbue the character with enough interest to rival Wolverine for the hearts of the audience, even if he did defeat him in romancing psychic Jean Grey. Sequel X2 had the character go sort of evil briefly (under the influence of mind control), but this was more of a momentary diversion than a serious challenge for the more interesting characters. When X-director Brian Singer jumped ship to resurrect DCs big blue boy scout Marsden followed. It is often felt that this perceived betrayal accounts for the casual and callous way his character was quickly bumped off at the start of the third X-Men. Unfortunately for Marsden,. all he had to cross over into was another love triangle in which he offered the films leading lady a bland reliable guy instead of the always-running-off-someplace-else glamorous superhero. This time he didnt even get what he wanted onscreen.
9. Natalie Portman
For DC: Stockholm syndrome suffering terrorist backer Evey Hammond in V for Vendetta For Marvel: Alien Norse god-alike's arm candy Jane Foster in Thor and Thor: The Dark World How did the change work out? Not exactly lacking in Geek cred, the former Star Wars star and Harvard graduate showed impressive dedication to the role of Evey Hammond in the post-9/11 adaptation of the 1980s anti-Thatcher comic, having her head shaved and sporting an English accent. The Israeli actress said the role attracted her: "because terrorism and violence are such a daily part of my conversations since I was little". Despite criticisms to the contrary, the film manages to present a relatively nuanced view through Eveys eyes of its terrorist protagonist. While the vigilante in the Guy Fawkes mask is the title character, it is Portmans Evey who is the films real protagonist. Despite Portmans occasionally wandering accent, the film and her performance was a modest success. With Thor, and probably its upcoming sequel, she was part of a much more significant blockbuster success story, but at the expense of her character having much to do. With Thors developed relationships all being with male characters, notably brother Loki and father Odin, his romance with earthling Jane Foster felt tacked on and one of the weakest elements of Kenneth Branaghs film. Whether sequel The Dark World, which whisks Foster away to Thors home in Asgard, will give Portman a more interesting part remains to be seen.
8. Chris Evans
For Marvel: Overconfident flaming wiseass Johnny Storm AKA The Human Torch in The Fantastic Four and The Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer. Under-confident, earnest super-soldier Steve Rogers AKA Captain America in Captain America: The First Avenger, The Avengers and Captain America: The Winter Soldier For DC: Comic relief computer geek Jake Jensen in The Losers How did the change work out? Having played two Marvel heroes, Chris Evans may finally be able to claim to UK audiences that he is better known than the ginger TFI Friday presenter and former husband of Billie Piper. The bland Fantastic Four films may have been full of mis-casting, but Evans, as cocky Johnny Storm, stood out as one to watch should he be given a better movie. That opportunity came with a chance to head up his own superhero story as Marvels wartime patriot Captain America. Effectively conveying the weedy everymans journey through being a marketing tool to a genuine hero, Captain America showed an admirably different kind of hero to Marvel Studios' other ego-centric stars. Evans and Cap were kind of outshone by those self-centred co-stars in The Avengers, but his more humble attitude was necessary to provide a certain amount of balance. Both films showed enough quality for Evans to line up a return to the part in the sequels to both Avengers and Captain America. Less well remembered, though, was his part in the film of DC/Vertigo comic The Losers. Distancing himself from the action man roles he has played for Marvel, Evans appeared as the computer geek in a movie that paired him with a so hot right now cast including Zoe Saldana fresh off Avatar and Star Trek and The Wire-era Idris Elba. Despite the potential for a younger, cooler version of The Expendables, The Losers sank without a trace.
7. Mark Strong
6. Samuel L. Jackson/Scarlett Johansson
For DC: Evil behind the scenes manipulator The Octopus and his sexy, seductive underling Silken Floss in The Spirit For Marvel: Good guy behind the scenes manipulator Nick Fury and his sexy, seductive underling Natasha Romanoff AKA Black Widow in Iron Man 2, The Avengers and Captain America: The Winter Soldier (plus Iron Man, Thor and Captain America: The First Avenger for Jackson) How did the change work out? Gaining a co-director credit on Robert Rodriguez's visually stylish adaptation of his Dark Horse comic Sin City, Frank Miller got the impression that he could turn any comic property to his own style. The Spirit, originally an Eisner comic and now published by DC, has its own style and decades of history, but Miller's movie became a visual copy of Sin City with a tone that veered between murkily dark and bizarre slapstick. Samuel L. Jackson appeared as villain The Octopus in a succession of ridiculous outfits including a Nazi uniform. The costume of the most despised individuals of the 20th century was even more fetishized for entertainment by sidekick Silken Floss. Actress Scarlett Johansson was given no more role than looking good in form fitting, provocative outfits and plunging necklines. Despite The Spirits failure, both actors are big enough stars to feature in the far more successful Marvel Cinematic Universe. While they appear in multiple movies, their SHIELD agents remain part of the background. As with The Spirit its a case of looking cool in outfits that would look ridiculous on others for Jackson (eyepatch) and looking hot in outfits that are both tight and cleavage revealing for Johansson. By The Avengers both had been given a little character development. Who knows, maybe their appearance in the Captain America sequel will really give them something to do.
5. Tommy Lee Jones
For DC: Semi-disfigured coin tosser Harvey Dent AKA Two Face in Batman Forever For Marvel: Gruff but good hearted army officer Colonel Chester Phillips in Captain America: The First Avenger How did the change work out? Rumour has it that when Tommy Lee Jones was unsure about whether to take the part of Two Face in Batman Forever after Billy Dee Williams was dispatched with a generous pay off, director Joel Schumacher told him to read the script again only to imagine Academy Award winning actor Tommy Lee Jones in the role. If true then its a classic story of an actor letting his vanity get the better of him. For all Jones is a talented performer, in Batman Forever he is nothing but manic and irritating, bringing none of the darkness or tragedy Aaron Eckhart would to the same part years later. The Caped Crusaders campy day-glo re-imagining in Batman Forever is nowhere near the unmitigated disaster that its sequel Batman and Robin would be, but neither is it a particularly high point in Jones CV. 16 years later Jones cropped up in Captain America playing much closer to type. Colonel Chester Phillips is a part for which casting directors would undoubtedly be asking for a Tommy Lee Jones type. Its a small but decent role and Jones plays the stern but decent military officer like hes played the part a hundred times before. Largely because he has. He even recognised this himself, describing the role as: "the one you've seen in a thousand movies: the gruff, skeptical officer overseeing a team of slightly sarcastic, specially talented soldiers."
4. Halle Berry
For Marvel: Weather manipulating toad striker Ororo Monroe AKA Storm in X-Men, X2: X-Men United, X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men: Days of Future Past For DC: Stripperifically costumed undead feline Patience Phillips AKA Catwoman in Catwoman How did the change work out? Halle Berry was a rising star when she first signed on to play Storm in Bryan Singers X-Men film. By the second she was an Oscar winner and a Bond girl. Despite this, Berrys lack of a significant role within the mutant ensemble resulted in a falling out with Singer and Berry being quite publicly dismissive of both the character and the franchise. Although Singer-less threequel The Last Stand was much weaker on the whole than its predecessor, it was the one entry in the franchise that allowed Storm a central part in the plot. By then, though, she had already gone over to an iconic DC comics role, hoping for a solo lead in her own superhero franchise. Catwoman had been stuck in development hell for years. The film that eventually emerged with Berry in the lead as Patience Phillips was almost completely unrecognisable from the original concept and character. Universally panned, it "won" Berry a Razzie award for Worst Actress and allowed her to give an acceptance speech that ran: "I want to thank Warner Brothers. Thank you for putting me in a piece of shit, god-awful movie... It was just what my career needed." A run of flops since (including Movie 43, one of the few films worse reviewed than Catwoman) caused a return to the character of Storm in the upcoming X-Men: Days of Future Past. However, with Berry pregnant during filming, her involvement in large scale action sequences seems unlikely.
3. Michael Fassbender
For DC: Bowler hat loving sadist Burke in Jonah Hex For Marvel: Young incarnation of holocaust surviving metal manipulator Erik Lensherr AKA Magneto in X-Men: First Class and X-Men: Days of Future Past How did the change work out? Before he made his name in serious downbeat British dramas Hunger and Fish Tank, Michael Fassbender already had comic book pedigree, appearing as one of the leather pants wearing Spartans in the Dark Horse adaptation 300. He would go on to feature in the 2010 version of DCs supernatural Western bounty hunter Jonah Hex, playing the part of Burke, the main villains sadistic sidekick whose only notable feature appears to be a love of wearing bowler hats in a film full of stetsons. Like Wild Wild West before and The Lone Ranger since, Jonah Hex assumed a far greater audience appetite for the high concept Western action blockbuster than actually exists and the film flopped. Fortunately for Fassbender, his appearance as the young Magneto in X-Men: First Class followed swiftly after. The role presented the challenge of embodying a character previously strongly associated with the legendary Ian McKellan. Despite lapsing into his native Irish accent for much of the films final third, however, it was the scenes with Fassbenders Magneto where the film really came alive, turning this fun 60s prequel/reboot one of the high points in the whole X-franchise The result of this unusual level of success in swapping DC for Marvel is an ambitious uniting of Fassbenders version of Magneto with the classic McKellan part in the highly anticipated X-Men: First Class. If it works this could be the start of a successful run of movies focused around Fassbender as the master metal manipulator.
2. Hugo Weaving
For DC: Verbose vaudevillian vengeful vigilante V in V for Vendetta For Marvel: Mad scientist too mad for the Nazis Johann Schmidt AKA The Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger How did the change work out? This list has already touched on the difficulties of bringing Guy Fawkes masked anarchist terrorist V convincingly to the big screen. The biggest challenge was in casting an appropriate actor for a character whose face is never seen and who has to perform dialogue like the absurd list of alliteration screenwriters Andy and Lana Wachowski gave him for an intro. James Purefoy was originally cast but dropped out. Like Stuart Townsends last minute departure from Lord of the Rings or Tom Sellecks unavailability for Indiana Jones, Purefoys departure was a blessing in disguise. The Matrix and Lord of the Rings trilogies had turned respected Australian theatre actor Hugo Weaving into a blockbuster movie star and, having worked with the Wachowskis on The Matrix, he was their top choice for a last minute replacement for Purefoy. Even without showing his face, Weaving gave V presence and poise and his Shakespearean diction enabled audiences to take some of the more clumsily scripted dialogue seriously. A heroic character, even a more complicated one than most comic book heroes, is more unusual in Weavings Hollywood career than a villain and for Marvel he reverted to type as Captain Americas Red Skull. Again his face spent much of the movie hidden, this time behind a red skull prosthetic, but Weaving had a little less to sink his teeth into beyond that. Captain America was a fun movie, but, in its need to set up The Avengers, featured a villain that was all too easily dispatched.
1. Ryan Reynolds
For Marvel: Wisecracking ex-vampire turned vampire hunter Hannibal King in Blade: Trinity. Wisecracking mutant mercenary turned super-weapon Wade Wilson AKA Deadpool in X-Men Origins: Wolverine For DC: Wisecracking pilot turned intergalactic law enforcer Hal Jordan in The Green Lantern How did the change work out? As his career shifted from TV star to supporting actor to movie leading man, Ryan Reynolds has pretty much stuck to playing the charismatic loudmouth and thats the element that unites all his comic book roles. Blade: Trinity was a tedious mess of a movie with tax evading star Wesley Snipes only back for the money and Blade 2 director Guillermo del Toro replaced by writer David Goyer (also the man responsible for scripting the recent adventures of Batman and Superman), whose talents did not cross over behind the camera. Reynolds was one of the few elements to emerge positively from it, at least providing the film a little levity. If anything, X-Men Origins: Wolverine was a worse sequel than Blade: Trinity. Reynolds seemed perfectly cast as fan favourite fourth wall breaker Deadpool until the movie decided to take the merc with a mouth and sew that mouth shut before decapitating him. None of which, oddly, prevented a Deadpool spin-off going into development. That project never materialised, in part due to Reynolds having a better offer to star as one of DCs premiere heroes, Green Lantern. Reynolds solo performance in claustrophobic thriller Buried shows he has what it takes to lead a movie, but Green Lantern overwhelmed him, and the audience, with bad CGI effects. Since then, Reynolds has starred in a run of flops including Men in Black-alike RIPD and snail racing toon Turbo. A return to the wisecracking sidekick role is probably in his not too distant future. So, what does this mean for Affleck? Well, less than half the actors on this list have successfully made the crossover, so in that sense it doesn't look all that positive for Affleck. Partly, though, this just reflects the sheer number of below average comic book movies that are out there. The noteworthy thing about those that succeeded is that their DC movies were all so bad that they were soon forgotten when they switched to Marvel. If, like these actors, you can leave one flop behind, you can reinvent yourself in the audience imagination. Given that, it's probably all for the best in terms of Affleck's chances of cementing himself in people's minds as Batman that his Daredevil wasn't more successful. Like Fassbender coming from Jonah Hex to X-Men, it gives him much less in his own career to compete with. Like this article? Who have we missed? Let us know in the comments section below.
