10 Actors Who Should Replace Cavill As Superman

Worlds of DC needs a new Man of Steel, but who will it be?

Henry Cavill Man Of Steel 2 Superman Solo
Warner Bros.

If fans were to write a Mary Poppins style Superman Wanted advertisement in the wake of the news that Henry Cavill has left the DCEU, there's a good chance they'd choose defining characteristics that set the replacement well apart from Zack Snyder's version.

He should be charming, likeable (above all else), a real beacon of hope (and not likely to be grumpy or undead in any sort of way) and he absolutely, definitely should not have a moustache of any sort. Or even a small beard. That's a deal breaker.

So who could step into Superman's red underpants now that Cavill's tenure as the Blue Boy Scout is over? There are some pretty good candidates out there, assuming Warner Bros are eventually going to try again with an adult Supes...

10. Taron Egerton

Kingsman The Golden Circle
Fox

It's skewing younger a little bit, but Taron Egerton has already proven he has what it takes to play both country-boy Clark Kent as well as his all-powerful alter-ego. The two Kingsman films established him as a charismatic leading man as well as an imposing on-screen presence who's more than capable of bringing the intensity of Supes' no-nonsense crime-fighting to life.

And while he has so far excelled in playing cocky heroes, Egerton has always maintained a relatable vulnerability at the heart of his performances. He's achieved success by ultimately presenting himself as the boy down the street (who admittedly looks like a GQ model), something which he could channel brilliantly as Clark Kent.

The only problem would lie in the fact that, outside of his collaborations with Matthew Vaughn, the actor is yet to prove himself in the mainstream. With only a couple projects to his name, Egerton is relatively unknown, but that could all change depending on how his turn as Elton John in the upcoming biopic Rocketman - as well as his effort as the titular character in Robin Hood - end up being received.


9. Channing Tatum

Channing Tatum Superman
Warner Bros.

Channing Tatum might have had some duds in his past, but more recently he's proved that he has the legitimate acting chops to pull off weightier roles. And with his Gambit project looking more and more unlikely with each passing month of inactivity, he deserves something in the comic book movie world.

Tatum is also very much a bankable figure thanks to his established profile and he absolutely has the physicality to convince as the Man Of Steel as well as the chops to handle taking on Clark Kent as well. Some might consider him too much of a traditional "jock" model, but that might not be the worst thing.

And interestingly, of course, he's already played Superman before in The LEGO Batman movie, so he'll have at least SOME familiarity with the role.


8. Ryan Gosling

First Man Ryan Gosling
Universal

Another actor who has more recently been linked with the role of Batman, Gosling may be Canadian but, since he’s already impressing playing one great American hero, there’s reason to believe he could do so as another.

A lot of what Gosling brings - his charisma and good looks, for instance - are obvious traits in any superhero really, but what really appeals to his Superman, much like it does his Batman, is that otherness he has about him.

It’d lend itself well to not only playing someone from another planet, but also as the unassuming journalist Clark Kent who is hiding a huge secret. Add in his dramatic chops - he's likely to get another Best Actor nomination at next year's Oscars - and he'd be a great fit to take the role up, up, and away.


7. Matthew Goode

Ozymandias Matthew Goode Watchmen
Warner Bros.

Back when Cavill was hired to play Superman for Man Of Steel, rumours emerged that it was Watchmen's Matthew Goode that he'd beaten to the role and he was said to have been the studio's back-up option.

Surely that means that he's under consideration now that there's room for a new actor to step into the role? How long do those sorts of back-up retainers last exactly?

There may be some backlash to Warner Bros again hiring a Brit, but Goode certainly has the right credentials to play the Man of Steel, particularly with his past work on Watchmen. Adrian Veidt may not have been the closest character to Superman in terms of his writing, but there was a certain poise to him that you could see ported across.

He'd also really look the part as Clark Kent, which is an under-appreciated consideration for Superman casting these days.


6. Michael B. Jordan

Fantastic Four Michael B. Jordan
Fox

According to Deadline, Michael B. Jordan’s name has already been mentioned by Warner Bros as a potential Cavill replacement, although any move would be some way down the line.

While casting a black actor as Superman would undoubtedly bring a fair amount of controversy, there’s something to be said for Jordan landing the part. He’s already been in two comic book movies - one great, one, er, not - and he’s impressed in pretty much everything he’s done in his still young career.

He’d offer up a different take on the character to what we’ve seen before, since he’s an actor who often brings a lot of intensity to his roles, but there’s plenty of charm and humour there too. He’s effortlessly cool and we already know he can do superhero action, and he’s got the dramatic range that few actors to take on the role could match.


5. Zac Efron

Zac Efron Superman
Warner Bros.

Though his career started with the double-edged sword of success that was High School Musical, Zac Efron has done incredibly well to cast off the shackles of typecasting and proved himself a gifted and charismatic actor. He has the right sort of look, can train himself into incredible shape (thanks Dwayne) and is hugely likeable, which we're going to need for the next Superman.

Rumours abound that he actually turned the role down in Man Of Steel (pass the salt, please), but the very fact that his name came up in that conversation suggests he might not be an outrageous choice.

For anyone looking for further evidence of why he'd suit the role, look no further than the fact that he looks a lot like Tyler Hoechlin, the most recent actor to play Superman on TV. It's not concrete by any means, but it certainly offers visual precedent.


4. Oscar Isaac

Poe Dameron Oscar Isaac Star Wars: The Force Awakens
Lucasfilm/Vanity Fair

Although the DC part Oscar Isaac was most recently optioned for was that of Batman (a part he would undoubtedly nail, it must be said), it’s Superman where the actor’s talents could best be put to use.

Not only does Isaac possess the grade-A hair any Man of Steel has to have, he’s already demonstrated an ability to play both sides of the character. Having already dominated scenes in Star Wars as Poe Dameron (a character equally famed for his rugged never say die attitude as he is his compassionate streak), the door is well and truly open for Isaac to take the next step and lead the Justice League as a Superman equally capable of smashing mythical Apokoliptian New Gods, as he would be lending a helping hand to a citizen in need.

Also important to note is that Warner Bros. are said to be reevaluating how to proceed with the DCEU/Worlds of DC franchise going forward. Cavill’s Superman, regardless of how divisive his portrayal ended up being, was never going to work for this new world. Isaac, on the other hand, can take the role in a new direction.

Mimic the relationship Poe has with BB-8 and have Krypto involved instead, and you have the perfect Superman film just waiting to be made.


3. Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer Superman
Warner Bros

Magic Mike star Matt Bomer has actually come close to playing Superman before when Brett Ratner wanted him to play the Man Of Steel for Superman Flyby, but ultimately that didn't come off. Unfortunately, rumours then erroneously spread that he wasn't hired because he was gay, which proved to be unfounded.

Bomer's appeal isn't just in the fact that he looks like the real American as Apple Pie Blue Boy Scout with his Ken Doll complexion and how well he wears a pair of glasses, but he's also a formidably talented actor to go along with the physicality. He also has real range - as anyone who saw the exceptional The Normal Heart will attest - and he'd be a very safe choice for Warner Bros.

Given what's happened with the DCEU, safe choices shouldn't be discounted.


2. Noah Centineo

Peter Kavinsky To All The Boys Ive Loved Before
Netflix

Noah Centineo is breaking out in a big way thanks to Netflix’s To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before, and Warner Bros can really benefit from that hype.

Centineo is still relatively unknown though, and there’d be something refreshing about him taking on the cape rather than a proper A-lister. Only 22-years-old, he’s someone who could really grow into the role and mould it into his own for years to come, in a similar vein to Chris Evans’ Captain America.

He’s got the sort of classic good looks you need for Superman - and it’s easy to imagine him absolutely rocking that hair curl - and is so easily likeable that even the most discerning audience members should quickly take to him.

After years of a darker, more serious Superman, he’s someone who could bring a slight air of youthful exuberance and lightness to the character, while he should also be able to balance that well with being a nerdy and earnest Clark Kent.


1. Armie Hammer

Armie Hammer
Imagine Entertainment

You want someone to play the All-American hero, so who better than the most typically All-American actor?

Not only does he just look like a comic book hero, but it’s easy to imagine him playing the symbol of Truth, Justice, and the American Way. He’s got charm and charisma in spades, but also the ability to play someone slightly aloof, or rather, alien.

He could do a more arrogant take on Supes, or a version who is purely good and honourable, while he’s also shown the kind of range that would lend itself to someone masking his identity and wrestling with a dual life.

Hammer feels destined to eventually land a major superhero role, after being cast as Batman in George Miller’s doomed Justice League Mortal, but while his chances of playing the Dark Knight may have gone, he’d be just as good, perhaps even better, as the Man of Steel.

Who do you want to replace Henry Cavill? Let us know down in the comments.


We love teamwork! Who doesn't? This article is a collaborative effort between Simon Gallagher, Josh Brown, Ewan Paterson and James Hunt.
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.

Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.