10 Actresses Who Could Play Captain Marvel

Which one of these ladies would make the perfect Carol Danvers?

October's announcement from Marvel Studios of their upcoming schedule of films sent shockwaves through the industry and invigorated fans worldwide. With a full slate of movies taking us all the way to May, 2019 culminating in the second of a two part Avengers: Infinity War epic, Marvel's news immediately quelled the interest stirred up by DC's similar maneuver. Since taking the reins over many of their film properties, Marvel has inspired great confidence in their ability to tell an exciting story that will appeal to more than just comic fans while still managing to stay reverent to the source material. Were it not for their track record of exceeding expectations with properties such as Guardians of the Galaxy, upcoming films like Inhumans and Black Panther might not stoke the flames of anticipation quite the same. One such property is Captain Marvel. The first female-led Marvel Studio film on the schedule (and not the one we expected), this will feature Carol Danvers and be a mix of Earth-bound and outer space adventure. Captain Marvel has an interesting backstory and has enjoyed somewhat of a revival in importance among the Marvel Universe in recent years. So the real question is who will play her? While nothing has been discussed in terms of casting thus far, let's break out our wish lists and speculate on ten actresses who could don the Kree-powered mantel. Also, the most iconic outfit or GTFO:

10. Katee Sackhoff

Let's get the obvious one out of the way first. Long before the announcement for Captain Marvel was even made, fans online were practically petitioning for Katee Sackhoff to play her. Aside from bearing a strong resemblance to Carol Danvers, perhaps the most appealing thing about Sackhoff in the role is that she already has the geek credibility, with her stint as Kara Thrace on Battlestar Galactica. And her portrayal as Dahl in 2013's Riddick shows she has the physicality required to play an immensely-powered character. Not to be disparaging, but she's still relatively under the radar as far as Hollywood stars go, and would be much easier for Marvel to lock into a multi-film contract should she decide to accept the role. The campaign for Katee to join the Marvel Cinematic Universe is in full-force, and it wouldn't be the least bit surprising if Marvel reaches out to her in the very near future to discuss the role.

9. Jessica Chastain

5_-Best-Supporting-Actress-Jessica-Chastain-The-Help_gallery_primary Few actresses are as highly sought-after and well-regarded as Jessica Chastain. The two-time Academy Award nominee took the industry by storm with her starring turns in The Help and Zero Dark Thirty, receiving critical acclaim and firmly cementing her as one of the finest thespians of her generation. Chastain has flirted with the superhero genre twice already, nearly snagging the role of Black Widow in Iron Man 2, and then again almost ending up as Dr. Maya Hansen in Iron Man 3 before having to drop out due to a scheduling conflict. But she's clearly interested in powering up, being quoted in several interviews as having a strong desire to play a comic book character and partake in over the top fight scenes. The real kicker here is her availability, and if an actress as in-demand as Chastain would be willing to commit to the kind of deal Marvel would be looking for to make Captain Marvel an onscreen reality.

8. Margot Robbie

Margot Robbie Another starlet who has quickly become a hot property, Margot Robbie would make a headline-grabbing choice to slither into the Captain Marvel uniform. She made a huge impact with her starring role alongside Leonardo DiCaprio in Martin Scorsese's The Wolf of Wall Street, baring it all (literally) onscreen in one of 2013's most successful and acclaimed movies. She's parlayed that success into starring roles in the upcoming Focus, Z For Zacharia and Tarzan, which all look to be high-profile films that will only increase her drawing power. If she's of interest to Marvel, they would do well to secure her now before her booking slate gets completely full, because this is a young woman whose career is skyrocketing.

7. Emily Blunt

Here's another favorite who could easily wind up in the role if both parties can reach an agreement. Add Blunt to the list of up-and-coming actresses whose careers are on the ascent, spearheaded by her portrayal of bad*ss Sgt. Rita Vrataski in the highly-underrated Edge Of Tomorrow. The starlet has proven she has the chops to play Danvers, a decorated Air Force Major, bears enough of a resemblance and is yet another talent who has shown previous interest in working with Marvel. She was the early choice for Black Widow, dropping out due to the dreaded scheduling conflicts, and then was offered the role of Peggy Carter but turned it down. Has she been holding out for a starring spot in the MCU? If so, this is her perfect chance, as Captain Marvel could become an important centerpiece for years to come.

6. Brie Larson

Here's a young lady who's enjoying a surge in popularity amongst the same community (pun intended) who get fired up over every Marvel release. Brie Larson is a quirky choice for Captain Marvel, with most of her work coming in the comedic genre, but as we've seen already, Marvel Studios has a tendency to take characters who wouldn't necessarily be seen as humorous and plop them down into hilarious adventures without sacrificing the spirit of the character. Carol Danvers is very similar to Guardians of the Galaxy in that her origin is so far out of this world that you almost have to play it lightheartedly, and Larson is the perfect choice to do so. She's charming and unique, just old enough to make the cut, and with her incredible performance in Short Term 12, someone who can turn up the dramatic range when necessary.

5. Rosamund Pike

Hot off her show-stealing performance in David Fincher's masterpiece Gone Girl, Rosamund Pike is someone Marvel should play close attention to. Prior to her role as Amy Dunne in the film based on Gillian Flynn's bestseller, Pike had failed to breakthrough to the mainstream, with her stint alongside Tom Cruise in Jack Reacher her most high-profile performance. But with Gone Girl setting box offices on fire and Oscar buzz surrounding her portrayal of Ben Affleck's demented spouse, Pike now has the Hollywood "it factor". She's been criticized as being somewhat wooden in past films, so it would be interesting to see if she has the charisma necessary to pull of such a role. But if Marvel is looking to make a big splash with their casting, Rosamund Pike would be a timely selection.

4. Alice Eve

Alice Eve definitely has the physical attributes to pull off Carol Danvers. Perhaps best known for her portrayal as Carol in 2013's Star Trek: Into Darkness, Eve has yet to truly snag that career-defining role that could catapult her to the next level of stardom. Obviously a starring turn in a Marvel Studios juggernaut would do just that, and we think she would make a fine choice. She has the necessary commanding presence for a leading character, and would fit nicely in Captain Marvel's costume. She's already been linked to several comic book roles already, after dropping out of playing Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class over disagreements with script changes and was rumored to be in line for both Peggy Carter and Sue Storm in the Fantastic Four reboot. Clearly it's just a matter of time before she finally appears in a superhero film. Could Captain Marvel be the one?

3. Yvonne Strahovski

Yvonne Strahovski Yvonne Strahovski is running neck-and-neck with Katee Sackhoff as someone who the fans are rallying behind to be cast as Carol Danvers. Her resume isn't nearly as impressive as many others on this list, but that hasn't hindered her from garnering a tremendous amount of fan support. She was quite popular during her five-year run on NBC's Chuck, netting Teen Choice and TV Guide Awards for her performance, and she's carried that cult following along with her every since. Strahovski is a beautiful young woman who certainly has the presence necessary for Danvers, and could be a breakout star for Marvel should she be granted the role. We could be looking at the female version of Chris Hemsworth, an under-the-radar actress who soars to fame through the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

2. Natalie Dormer

Despite the fact that Natalie Dormer has previously appeared in a Marvel film as a different character - a lesser part as Pvt. Lorraine in Captain America: The First Avenger - that shouldn't exclude her from headlining as another Captain in the Marvel Universe. Stealing scenes and hearts of fanboys as Margaery Tyrell in the HBO's ratings steamroller Game of Thrones, Dormer has a captivating energy about her that would make her a great fit for Carol. And now her career is set to reach even bigger heights with her turn as Cressida in The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Parts 1 & 2. And let's face it, the hairstyle just puts her over the top as a great choice to play Captain Marvel.

1. Katheryn Winnick

Unless you've been following the savagery of The History Channel's scripted drama Vikings, you're probably not at all familiar with Katheryn Winnick. As shieldmaiden Lagertha, Winnick absolutely owns the screen every time she appears, with an incredible presence in a role that makes her the epitome of a strong female character. She's a total bad*ss and the best reason to watch the show. In addition, she's got an impressive background to accompany her acting chops, holding belts in both Tae Kwon Do and Karate, as well as being a licensed bodyguard. If you're looking for a powerful woman to go head to head with characters like Thor and Hulk, look no further than Katheryn. She has all the tools necessary to excel in the role and turn Captain Marvel into another of Marvel's successful film franchises. Is there anyone you'd rather see play Captain Marvel? Let us know in the comments section.

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.