10 Actresses Whose Careers Went Downhill After Winning An Oscar

For these actresses, winning an Oscar flip-turned their careers upside down.

Winning an Academy Award is supposed to signify the ultimate dream when you work in Hollywood. There are dozens of precursor awards that take place between December and February of every year, but there is something special about the Oscars. It's not just the glitz and glamor - it's the fact that you're officially a part of history. While we often get cynical and complain about the Oscars on a yearly basis, no one can blame an actor for getting excited about winning. It could potentially mark the moment that ultimately signals the highlight of their entire career. Of course, there are no guarantees in life and winning an Oscar does not mean you are guaranteed to find work for the rest of your career. Hollywood is not obligated to call you first for every movie role that's available thereafter, and there have been many actresses who have found this out the hard way. They've gone from being A-list actresses to yesterday's news within just a couple of years, with people wondering what happened. For those of us on the outside, it does not seem to make much sense. But, as this list proves, it's just the brutal nature of show business. This is a list of 10 actresses whose careers went downhill after they won Hollywood's biggest prize. Many of them still work today, but for some reason, they keep appearing in only bad movies. Is it their own fault for making these choices, were they always less talented than we thought, or has Hollywood condemned them to a life of mediocrity for seemingly no reason at all?

10. Jennifer Connelly

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, A Beautiful Mind (2002) Jennifer Connelly's descent into mediocrity was not immediate. For a few years after her Oscar win, she did star in a handful of solid films such as House of Sand and Fog and Little Children. Since then, she has consistently appeared in movies that range from disappointing to just flat out terrible. The absolute nadir of her acting career would have to be 2012's Virginia, a movie that received universally negative reviews and only grossed $12,000 in the box office. Now, you can hardly blame her for wanting to star in the film. Months before production began, writer/director Dustin Lance Black won an Oscar for Best Original Screenplay. Who could have predicted that his directorial debut would turn out so badly? Jennifer Connelly has also starred in promising films like Reservation Road and Creation which were botched in the execution as well. Perhaps the Oscar-winning actress just has bad luck. On the bright side, she will star alongside Russell Crowe in Noah, which comes out next month. This will be her first collaboration with director Darren Aronofsky since 2000's Requiem For A Dream, a film that helped Jennifer Connelly break through to the mainstream. Can Noah be the film that steers Connelly back on the right track? Fingers crossed.

9. Reese Witherspoon

Oscar Win: Best Actress, Walk The Line (2006) When Reese Witherspoon won an Oscar for Best Actress in 2006, she was a proven box office draw. In the past eight years, however, she's had just one hit: the critically-panned 2008 film Four Christmases, which co-starred Vince Vaughn. Yikes. You might think her Oscar-winning performance in Walk The Line was an anomaly, but when she initially started out, Reese Witherspoon's career could not have been any more promising. Fear, Overnight Delivery, Pleasantville, Cruel Intentions, Election, American Psycho - not all of these movies were great, but at the very least, she played interesting characters. It seems the breakout success of Legally Blonde in 2001 has since typecast her in other similar, rom-com roles even after the acclaimed she received for portraying June Carter Cash. The good news is that Reese Witherspoon finally seems ready to break out of her comfort zone. After appearing in the critically-acclaimed film Mud last year, Witherspoon hopes to build on that success with roles in Paul Thomas Anderson's Inherent Vice and Jean-Marc Vallée's Wild. Jean-Marc Vallée's last film was Dallas Buyers Club, which has seen Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto pick up dozens of awards. Can the director also breathe some new life into Reese Witherspoon's career?

8. Halle Berry

Oscar Win: Best Actress, Monster's Ball (2002) The only thing that keeps Halle Berry from being on the top half of this list is the success she's had with the X-Men series. When she's not portraying Storm, she's starring in Gothika, Perfect Stranger, New Year's Eve, The Call, Movie 43... and then, of course, there's Catwoman. Almost all of the films she's made in the past decade have been poorly received with disappointing box office figures. When will she fire her agent? Better yet, was Halle Berry ever a great actress to begin with? Despite becoming the first African-American woman to win an Oscar for a leading role, there was a great amount of controversy surrounding her role in Monster's Ball. A number of notable detractors of the film, including actress Angela Bassett, have said that the film was stereotypical and demeaning towards black women. Nowadays, people have started to wonder if Halle Berry really deserved the golden statue. She would have silenced the haters if she had continued success after winning, but that has not been the case thus far. With only X-Men: Days of Future Past on the horizon, it does not seem as if Halle Berry will change people's minds anytime soon.

7. Kim Basinger

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, L.A. Confidential (1998) If you grew up in the '80s/early '90s, you most likely remember the days when Kim Basinger was the hottest actress in Hollywood. Starring in movies like Nine 1/2 Weeks definitely helped her gain sex appeal, but she also took on big roles such as Vicki Vale in Tim Burton's Batman. When she won a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her performance in L.A. Confidential, she appeared to be at the peak of her career. Unfortunately, that peak would not last long. In the past 15 years, Kim Basinger's only noteworthy performance is playing Eminem's mother in 8 Mile. Other than that, the movies she's appeared in since L.A. Confidential have been largely disappointing and forgettable. Once she won her Oscar, it seems as if Hollywood stopped paying her much attention... even when she appears in high profile movies. Last Christmas, she starred alongside Robert Deniro, Sylvester Stallone, Alan Arkin, and Kevin Hart in Grudge Match; of those five actors, the Oscar-winning actress was nowhere to be found in the movie trailers. That's cold.

6. Catherine Zeta-Jones

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, Chicago (2003) Looking back now, Catherine Zeta-Jones's reign as an A-list actress seems very brief, doesn't it? She first caught everyone's attention when she starred opposite Antonio Banderas in The Mask of Zorro. The success of that movie soon lead to more high profile roles in Entrapment, The Haunting, Traffic, High Fidelity, America's Sweethearts, and Chicago. All those movies came out within a five-year span. She would star in a couple more decent movies after she won her Oscar, but by 2007, she was already in the middle of her decline. Of course, marrying Michael Douglas and having two children most likely shifted her priorities, but you would think being an Oscar winner would find yourself in better movies than Playing For Keeps and Broken City. Last year, her role as Dr. Siebert in Steven Soderbergh's Side Effects proved that Catherine Zeta-Jones can still be sexy and compelling. At this point, she probably cares more about taking care of her children than anything else, but it's hard to believe that her days as a high-profile leading actress are completely behind her.

5. Mira Sorvino

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, Mighty Aphrodite (1996) It's pretty easy to explain why Mira Sorvino's career went downhill after her Oscar win: she peaked too early. After appearing in just four movies, Sorvino landed a huge role in Woody Allen's Mighty Aphrodite which catapulted her into stardom. Suddenly, with an Oscar under her belt, the young actress was starring in mainstream movies such as Mimic and Romy and Michelle's High School Reunion. In 1999, she co-starred alongside Val Kilmer in At First Sight, and after yet another box office bomb, Mira Sorvino quickly faded from the spotlight. No one can blame Sorvino for the career choices she made after winning an Oscar. She went from being an unknown actress to suddenly having tons of acting opportunities and she struck while the iron was hot. It's just too bad she wound up starring in so many terrible movies, as a result. These days, Mira Sorvino is married and has four children. The movies she's appeared in lately tend to get released directly to DVD, but she mostly uses her celebrity status to support charitable causes and she has spoken in front of Congress against human trafficking. So, good for her.

4. Hilary Swank

Oscar Wins: Best Actress, Boys Don't Cry (2000)/Best Actress, Million Dollar Baby (2005) It may be odd to see a two-time Oscar winner on this list, but Hilary Swank has had an odd career. When she won her first Oscar, her career was on the rise, as expected. She starred in critically-acclaimed movies such as Insomnia and 11:14, and then took audiences by storm with her powerful performance in Clint Eastwood's Million Dollar Baby. At age 30, with two Oscars, it seemed Swank could not do anything wrong. But the films she's appeared in since Million Dollar Baby have mostly been stinkers. If they weren't complete bombs (such as The Black Dahlia, The Reaping, Amelia), then they were general disappointments. While her movie choices may not seem as egregiously bad as other actresses on this list, seeing a two-time Oscar winner star in mediocre movies for almost a decade just seems wrong, doesn't it? She does not have many upcoming films on her slate, but let's hope she still has more great performances up her sleeve.

3. Renée Zellweger

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, Cold Mountain (2004) The movies Renée Zellweger has appeared in since Cold Mountain have not been uniformly terrible, but she seems to have fallen off the face of the earth these past few years. After initially gaining fame for playing Tom Cruise's love interest in Jerry Maguire, Zellweger continued that success in a string of box office hits such as Me, Myself & Irene, Bridget Jones's Diary, and Chicago. Her performance in 2002's Chicago, in particular, garnered a great amount of positive press. Many wonder if her subsequent Oscar win for Cold Mountain was really the Academy's way of apologising for passing her over that previous year. Either way, considering her career was well-established by the time she won her Oscar, it comes as quite a shock to see how little attention she's received over the past ten years. While she's put forth solid performances in Cinderella Man and the underseen 2008 film Appaloosa, her career seems to have taken a slow and steady dive into obscurity for seemingly no reason. And as for the future? Renée Zellweger has not appeared in a single film since 2010 and there is no news regarding any future projects. So, is she no longer interested in acting or is Hollywood no longer calling? Either way, it's strange to see an actress completely disappear just a few years after winning an Oscar. Her career didn't just go downhill, it went off a cliff.

2. Mercedes Ruehl

Oscar Win: Best Supporting Actress, The Fisher King (1992) While Mercedes Ruehl has had a long, successful career on the stage over the last thirty years, her movie career has been spotty at best. Her most prolific period on screen was in the late '80s/early '90s, appearing in supporting roles in such films as Big, Married To The Mob, Lost In Yonkers, and Last Action Hero. And then, in the middle of this period, she won a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her performance in The Fisher King. Anyone who has seen the movie would know that the victory was 100% deserved, but apparently no one in Hollywood took much notice. Mercedes Ruehl's movie career bottomed out completely just one year after winning that Oscar. Since 1994, she's mostly appeared in made-for-TV movies or films that go straight-to-DVD. How does this happen to an Oscar-winning actress? How does she go from getting small roles in successful movies to suddenly being shunned altogether within a year? There really does not seem to be a substantial explanation.

1. Faye Dunaway

Oscar Win: Best Actress, Network (1977) The rise of American cinema in the '70s gave us a lot of great actors, many of whom are now household names. Jack Nicholson, Warren Beatty, Robert De Niro, Al Pacino... back in the day, these actors could do no wrong. And for a ten year period, the same could be said for Faye Dunaway, an actress who broke out in the 1967 classic Bonnie and Clyde. Her role as Bonnie Parker received a lot of acclaim and she soon landed leading roles in such films as The Thomas Crown Affair and Little Big Man. Then, for a three year period, Faye Dunaway starred in three '70s classics in a row: Chinatown, Three Days Of The Condor, and Network. Her performance in Network is, without a doubt, her best. In the film, she plays a heartless, ambitious TV network programmer who stops at nothing in order to get what she wants. It's an incredibly difficult part to pull off, yet Dunaway nailed it. Rightfully, she won an Oscar for the performance. And like so many other actresses on this list, Dunaway's career began to fall apart shortly after her victory. At just the age of 36, Dunaway's career would hit a peak that she would never again replicate. She starred in a few forgettable films during the rest of the '70s, but things really took a turn for the worst when her portrayal of Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest was critically panned. The film subsequently became a cult hit, but that does little to repair the damage that it did to Dunaway's career. Don't worry: I'm not just picking on actresses. Look out for my article on Oscar-winning actors which will be posted later this week. Did I miss anyone here? Let me know the comments section below...

Contributor
Contributor

Ken writes movie reviews on his blog, kenoncinema.blogspot.com. He currently resides in New York City. Twitter: @keng324