10 Alternative Christmas Movies

Santa's mad as hell - and he's got a flamethrower!

Dead Snow
Euforia Film

It’s the most wonderful time of year, with the kids jingle belling and everyone telling you to be of good cheer. But this is 2021, so they can all go £$%& themselves.

Christmas is the ultimate middle finger to those burned by the last twelve months, and the idea that everyone can come together over mince pies, the Andy Williams Christmas Album and Mrs Browns Boys is a punchline worthy of Bill Hicks.

Your Christmas viewing should reflect the year you’ve just had – it should be violent, confused, bloody and very very strange. It should include movies with coke snorting Santas and Nazis who want to establish a Fourth Reich run by homicidal elves. Killer snowmen who attack Shannon Elizabeth in the shower. That sort of thing.

We need to avoid is the kind of disposable, insincere, crassly commercial movies that symbolize the holidays and focus instead on the films that turn frowns upside down. That make you want to party like it’s your last Christmas. Because it probably is.

10. Silent Night

Silent Night Deadly Night
TriStar Pictures

This is a remake of Charles E Selliers’ Silent Night Deadly Night (1984), but all that remains is the plot device of a serial killer in a Santa costume and a sequence where a female victim is impaled on a set of antlers. Everything else has been jettisoned in favour of a more traditional (to say nothing of entertaining) narrative where a small town’s police force search for the killer.

The film’s LA Times review should’ve been plastered across the DVD box: “The movie’s intended audience will be satisfied by its parade of gory mayhem, cheap thrills and groan-worthy dark humour. Everyone else: you’re on your own.”

Considering that the original was picketed on its release by groups who took issue with the portrayal of Santa as a homicidal rapist, that was probably a good idea. Then again, Steven C Miller’s film gives Santa a flamethrower and in one sequence has him chase a naked starlet through the snow before feeding her to a shredder.

Miracle On 34th Street, this is not.


9. Jack Frost

Jack Frost Shannon Elizabeth
A-Pix Entertainment

Not to be confused with the 1998 Michael Keaton movie of the same name, Jack Frost tells the story of a serial killer who, thanks to the kind of plot contrivances found only in horror movies, transforms into a killer snowman and takes revenge on the Sheriff who caught him.

The filmmakers were clearly under no impression that they were making a modern version of It’s A Wonderful Life, hence the scene where American Pie’s Shannon Elizabeth (in her acting debut) strips to the tune of 12 Days Of Christmas. She then has an encounter with the snowman and without giving too much away, here’s a hint: Mr Frost certainly finds a novel use for his carrot.

Aside from that, it’s a perfectly humdrum and forgettable outing notable mainly for its director: Michael Cooney later wrote the very different Identity (2003) and is also an accomplished playwright.


8. Dead Snow

dead snow nazi zombies
Euforia Film

Okay, so Dead Snow actually takes place during Easter, but there’s rubbish weather, lots of drinking and Nazi zombies, so it perfectly sums up the festive season.

When a Mysterious Stranger warns our heroes of an evil presence in the mountains where Nazi soldiers froze to death during WWII, the stage is set for a zombie movie unlike any other. Wearing its influences on its sleeve (one character wears a Braindead t-shirt), Dead Snow borrows liberally from The Evil Dead and even recycles the hand-through-the-window gag seen in every 80s Italian zombie movie, but that’s not to say that Tommy Wirkola’s movie is lacking in imagination.

When limbs aren’t being hacked off with chainsaws and characters aren’t swinging to safety on zombie intestines, the film asks important questions like “If a Nazi zombie bites you, and you’re half-Jewish, are you immune? Or should you amputate the limb just in case? If so, what happens if you get bit again?”

Played with its tongue very firmly in its cheek, this could be the greatest Nazi zombie film of all time.


7. Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale

Rare Exports
FS Film Oy

Imagine the Coen brothers remaking The Thing and you’ve got Rare Exports, Finnish writer/director Jalmari Helander’s bid to turn Santa Claus into a horror icon.

Following on from the shorts Rare Exports Inc and The Official Rare Exports Inc, where wild Santas are captured by hunters and trained to be child-friendly bearers of seasonal gifts, Helander shows us how it all began in this feature length prequel.

When a villager finds several local reindeer torn to pieces, he resolves to find the perpetrator and soon captures a snarling, bearded old man. Could this be connected to a local archaeological dig where a creature was discovered trapped in ice? It is, and it’s not long before the old man’s “little helpers” turn up to free him and assist him in wreaking havoc.

Dismissing the modern Santa as a commercialized myth, Rare Exports digs deep into Finnish folklore and returns the character to his roots as a figure more interested in punishing the naughty than rewarding the good. Expect lashings of violence and dark fun in the style of Gremlins.


6. Elves

Elves movie
Action International Pictures

The festive season has been fair game for the horror genre ever since Santa attempted to strangle Joan Collins in Tales From The Crypt (1972), but Elves is the first movie whose gonzo plot involves Nazis, inbreeding and a coke-snorting Santa.

Dan Haggerty plays a homeless ex-cop who having drunk himself out of the job hangs around a local department store begging for work, finally catching a break when their Santa has his nuts cut off by a Nazi elf. When he finds an occult symbol carved into the floor where his predecessor was emasculated, Dan recognises it as the original insignia of the Nazis and comes to realize that elves are in fact Nazi genetic experiments whose leader will mate with a virgin on Christmas Eve to produce the leader of the Fourth Reich. As is explained in The Book of Revelation.

There are ideas and (intentionally?) hilarious lines to spare in this overlooked gem, which is either the greatest horror comedy you’ve never seen or the best “bad” movie since Troll 2. Either way, it’s the best elves and Nazis movie ever shot in Colorado.


5. Die Hard

alan rickman die hard
20th Century Fox

Die Hard features everything you expect to see in a Christmas movie, including a pregnant woman, miracles, redemption and a resurrection. The film’s idea of “Christmas music” is Run DMC and Vaughn Monroe, though, so you can’t have everything.

“It’s Christmas, Theo,” says Alan Rickman at one point, “it’s the time for miracles so be of good cheer!” No sooner has he spoken than Theo achieves a truly miraculous feat – he backs an ambulance out of a truck that was empty earlier in the film.

Then there’s the most miraculous scene of all – Karl’s resurrection. Despite having been left hanging from a chain, limp and lifeless, he returns in the final scene to give Sergeant Al Powell his shot at redemption. You see, Al hasn’t been able to draw his weapon since he accidentally shot a kid, but when Karl appears, Al digs deep and rediscovers his passion for wasting bad guys.

Learning to kill again – it’s what Christmas is all about.


4. Silent Night Deadly Night Part II

Silent Night Deadly Night Part II
Anchor Bay

Don’t worry if you haven’t seen Silent Night Deadly Night Part I because this “sequel” recycles about 40 minutes of footage, adding a new plot about the homicidal brother of the first film’s sicko. Fortunately he’s played by Eric Freeman, a graduate of the Mommie Dearest school of acting, which means he has three settings: twitchy, over-the-top and MWAHAHAHAHA!!!

Narrating the flashback footage from inside an asylum that looks suspiciously like a corporate office building, Freeman reminds us that his brother saw Mom being raped by a Mr Kringle one Christmas Eve, which of course turned him into a psycho killer in a Santa costume. Such fixations must be genetic because pretty soon Freeman’s off on a spree of his own, spearing a loan shark with his umbrella and mowing down a redneck !*$% (whose girlfriend thanks him!)

Don’t miss the scene where Freeman sits in a theater, gazing in open-mouthed awe at the Coming Attractions before realizing the Feature Presentation is….Silent Night Deadly Night! Needless to say, this really sets him off, and before long he’s merrily strolling down the sidewalk shouting “Punish!” and “Naughty!” as he randomly shoots cops, motorists and garbage collectors.


3. Gremlins

Gremlins Phoebe Cates
Amblin Entertainment

Why is Gremlins one of the greatest Christmas movies ever made? Because you think it’s a movie about monsters attacking a small town, but it’s really a cautionary tale about how imbuing an arbitrary date with significance can impact on people’s lives.

You see, Kate (Phoebe Cates) was decorating the tree with her mom one year, waiting for dad to come home, but she didn’t know that he’d already finished work and was planning on surprising them both. Which he did: while dressed as Santa, he attempted to navigate their chimney, slipped and broke his neck, lying there until his 9-year-old daughter discovered his body hours later.

And that’s how she found out there was no Santa Claus.

Fast forward a few years and Gremlins are everywhere, exposing themselves to Kate when they’re not killing her neighbours or attacking her boyfriend, giving her yet another reason to hate Christmas.

For everyone else, there’s a perfectly decent reason to hate the festive season that has nothing to do with dead parents or a Mogwai’s bastard offspring. Spend a few moments in front of the tube on Christmas Day, and you’ll see what I mean.


2. Black Christmas

Black Christmas Jess
Warner Bros.

Inspired by a series of murders in Quebec, Black Christmas mostly takes place in a sorority house where a barely glimpsed killer is polishing off the girls one by one, their sudden absence explained by the end-of-term setting. Made four years before Halloween, Bob Clark’s movie does for the festive season what John Carpenter did for October 31st and imbues an otherwise innocuous season with an air of menace.

In Clark’s movie, crystal ornaments become lethal weapons and even carol singers (whose sudden appearance is intercut with one murder) seem sinister. You’ve never seen a lonelier, more desolate neighborhood than this street, and the one warm and inviting place – the sorority house itself – is the last place you’d want to spend your Christmas vacation.

All the genre hallmarks are here: there’s the lurking POV camera, the ineffectual cop, the final girl and red herrings galore, plus Clark throws in a surprise final twist. According to Jason Zinoman, Clark was at one point considering a sequel where the film’s killer, now incarcerated in an asylum, escapes on Halloween night and returns to the town to wreak havoc.

Sounds like an interesting premise for a movie….


1. Santa Claus Conquers The Martians

Santa claus conquers the martiand
Embassy Pictures

Shot in a converted aircraft hangar by an inexperienced crew, with thrift store costumes and props made from household items, Santa Claus Conquers The Martians is a perfect example of what happens when an enterprising producer attempts to make a children’s Christmas movie but can only afford to mount it on a budget of half a shoestring.

The Martians here are not the malevolent creatures depicted in War Of The Worlds but unemployed stage actors wearing green costumes, green face paint and, for some reason, TV antennae, which prompts one Earth girl to inquire, “Are you a television set?”

Ironically, the Martian children have intercepted Earth television signals and, exposed to broadcasts from the North Pole, become despondent at the prospect of never meeting a well-fed alcoholic in a red suit. Considering what the lack of a proper childhood did to Michael Jackson, it’s understandable that the parents decide to kidnap Santa and bring him to Mars, but the mission is endangered by Voldar, who we know must be the epitome of evil because he has a mustache.

Called “the worst science fiction flick ever made” by The Monster Times, the movie marked the screen debut of Pia Zadora, who is here surrounded by cardboard robots, a guy in a polar bear costume and aliens armed with Wham-O Air Blasters. The future ‘star’ has precious little screen time and says next to nothing, but boy did she start as she meant to go on.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'