10 Amazing Unmade Alien Films

In space, nobody can hear you scream. Speculate, though? Sure!

In space, nobody can hear you scream. Speculate, though? Sure! Knock yourself out with the speculation! Nobody's gonna stop you from speculating, not even in the vacuum of space! The Alien franchise looks like it emerged fully formed, with its groundbreaking female protagonist, severe but sensical genre shifts, and a xenomorph plucked straight from your nightmares. Really, though, the life cycle of the Alien films has much more in common with that of the titular monster. It's violent, messy, and almost resulted in the death of John Hurt. Ever since screenwriter Dan O'Bannon had twenty-some pages of a project called Memory €“ where some space-farers wake up from cyro-sleep due to a distress call on a nearby planet €“ but couldn't figure out where to go next, the franchise has been in a state of flux. From the haunted house horror of Alien to the hoo-rah action of the sequel, from the downbeat prison drama of the third film to whatever Alien: Resurrection is supposed to be, these movies have gone through some pretty seismic changes between each instalment. But if half of the planned sequels had gone ahead, man, you wouldn't know the half of it. Alien 3... but it's set on a planet made of wood, populated by monks! Alien 5, by Joss Whedon! Something called Star Beast, which is a way less snappy name (but just as descriptive!) Here are ten amazing unmade Alien films.

10. Neil Blomkamp Brings Back Hicks

The reason anybody's been brave enough to jump back on board the USS Nostromo after all these years is thanks to a recent revival of interest in the Alien films. There was the critically acclaimed video game Isolation, which mimicked the fear and lack of firepower of the first movie; oh, and Neill Blomkamp revealed the Alien film he wanted to make. The South African director of Oscar-winning extraterrestrial apartheid allegory District 9 and the surprisingly subversive action flick Elysium is one of the most exciting science fiction filmmakers working today, and the revelation that he was working on an Alien film is hella cool. That it won't get made? Less cool. Blomkamp started €œleaking€ concept art for his project on his Instagram account last week, albeit without much context. There's still plenty to chew over, though, like a redesigned facehugger, a resurrected Corporal Hicks, and Ripley wearing a space jockey helmet...

9. The Original Alien Vs Predator

When Paul WS Anderson's Alien Vs Predator finally hit in 2004 fans had been waiting the better part of two decades for the two iconic, cinematic extraterrestrials to duke it out on the big screen. 1990 was the year that Predator 2 came out, and a brief glimpse at a xenomorph in the hunter's trophy room drove eagle-eyed audiences wild. Since then there have been countless Alien Vs Predator comics, just as many novels, and a embarrassment of video games of varying quality (you can't beat the original one for the Atari Jaguar, just as you probably can't source an actual Atari Jaguar). Anderson's movie wound up being a disappointment, though, because he is the man who has directed 70% of those terrible Resident Evil films and The Three Musketeers starring Ray Stevenson. Which is a double shame when you consider a draft script from the early nineties was based on the 1989 comic book, from Hellboy screenwriter Peter Briggs, and it wouldn't have taken place on Earth.

8. James Cameron's Aliens (First Draft)

20th Century Fox hadn't even begun to consider a sequel to Alien. It was incredibly successful, sure, but this was in the halcyon days when every so often a studio would consider not turning everything into a long-running franchise with increasingly diminishing returns (John McClane, whatever happened to you?). It was only when James Cameron expressed an interest to his producer that Aliens got off the ground. The hotshot young director had just come off the blockbuster hit of his first Terminator film, and the world was his oyster. Apparently that oyster looked a lot like a facehugger egg to him. Not just one, but dozens, with the second Alien film being an all-guns-blazin' affair. In fact Cameron was so jazzed at the idea of a sequel he'd written a spec script before the Terminator even got made. Fox waited to see how that turned out before officially giving him the gig, with his second draft cutting out a whole bunch of neat stuff: more time with Newt€™s family, Ripley calling the facehugger €œa walking sex organ€ and tiny albino warrior aliens in the egg chamber.

7. Joss Whedon's Alien 5

Apparently Cameron briefly spent some time on board an unmade fifth Alien film, which ended up getting stuck on the backburner when Alien Vs Predator finally made it into production. "To me, that was Frankenstein Meets Werewolf. It was Universal just taking their assets and starting to play them off against each other...Milking it," he said, believing it would kill of the franchise's credibility. Which he was right about, to a degree. Arguably it was the sequel, or possibly even Prometheus, that was the real nail in the coffin. Anyway, with Cameron off the project Alien 5 officially died a death, but not before Joss Whedon had penned a script €“ presumably to atone for the sins dealt in his writing of Alien: Resurrection. In fact one of Whedon's alternate endings to Resurrection had Ripley and Call crash-landing on Earth, and it's there he hoped to set a fifth Alien film. Unfortunately Sigourney Weaver was not interested in this setting, and sought to return the story to the planet from the first film. Which made Alien Vs Predator the first earth-bound entry in the series...

6. Pitch Black: Aliens

Alien 3 had a particularly tortured production cycle, something that would probably make a really great tell-all book at some point, were it not for all the non-disclosure agreements it would be breaking and libel lawsuits it would inspire. One of the many screenwriters to take a crack at it was David Twohy, who's been remaking his first big hit Pitch Black for thirteen years. Before he ever cottoned onto the idea of a psychopathic Vin Diesel who can see in the dark kicking ass on a planet where monsters come out at night time €“ and then ran that idea right down into the alien planet's core €“ Twohy was a jobbing script monkey, contributing to everything from The Fugitive to Critters 2: The Main Course. His early draft of Alien 3 came in 1989, and was possibly genius, possibly absolute nonsense. To start off with, Ripley was gone. Instead, Twohy's script focussed on a new set of characters on a prison planet-cum-ore refinery, who discover a facehugger embedded deep within the rock. Fox weren't having any of that, with Sigourney Weaver one of the big draws of the franchise, and Twohy retooled most of his ideas for Pitch Black instead.

5. Star Beast

Before there was Alien, there was Star Beast. Even before they had that, Dan O'Bannon had written the aforementioned first act of a script called Memory, but had yet to figure out what was going to happen to the curious crew of a ship called to an undiscovered planetoid. It was only when he went to France to work on an aborted adaptation of Dune that it all came together. Gonzo director Alejandro Jodorowsky's film fell through, but being in Europe allowed O'Bannon to meet up with a bunch of creative sci-fi minds...including eventual father of the xenomorph, H.R. Giger. With his antagonist in place O'Bannon had somewhere to go with his script. But that first draft remains very different. For one thing, it was called Star Beast, which is just terrible. There was no Ash, with the whole subplot of The Company entirely absent. Ripley was a dude, although the script specified that the crew was unisex (hence the names could be used for male and female actors). Oh and the ending would've involved the alien killing Ripley, then imitating her voice to gain access to Earth on her escape pod...

4. William Gibson's Alien 3...

As previously mentioned, making the third Alien film was like pulling teeth. But pulling teeth out a xenomorph involves to separate sets of jaws, which just makes it all the more painful and time-consuming. Pitch Black's David Twohy was far from the only screenwriter to be given a shot at making the film work, with Fox apparently contracting everyone and their mother to have a go. One of their more interesting attempts at getting a decent script for Alien 3 saw them bringing William Gibson on board. Whilst only a couple of his screenplays have actually been produced, Gibson is a prolific, popular and influential science fiction writer, creating the subgenre of cyberpunk pretty much single handedly. It's probably the success of Neuromancer €“ and the constant attempts to make it into a film €“ that got Gibson hired to do an Alien 3 script, which he later characterized as "Tarkovskian". His film also shunted Ripley out of the picture, put in a coma, with Hicks and Newt fighting xenomorphs on a spaced-based mall, with the aliens now spreading through an airborne virus that was supposed to be like AIDs.

3. ...And Eric Red's...

That version of Alien 3 strayed a little too far off the straight and narrow for Fox's liking, and so they eventually passed on Gibson's take (it probably also didn't help the xenomorphs were somehow genetically modified with some of the goo from Bishop€™s innards, which doesn't make any sense). The second attempt to crack the shell of Alien 3 came from Eric Red, best known for writing the horror films The Hitcher and Near Dark. Red's script was produced under duress, with the writer managing to spin out a finished draft in less than two months. He would later describe the draft as "the one script I completely disown because it was not 'my script". It was the rushed product of too many story conferences and interference with no time to write, and turned out utter crap." Which is a bit harsh. There were some solid ideas in there, beginning with some more Space Marines finding the Sulaco from the end of Aliens torn apart by xenomorphs, with the creatures eventually settling down on a small-town USA city in a type of bio-dome in space, culminating in an all-out battle with the townsfolk facing hordes of Alien warriors.

2. ...And Vincent Ward's

That was a little too out-there for the Fox executives, too, with the rushed nature of Red's script probably not helping matters. This was around the time they envisioned producing two sequels simultaneously, which they gave up on when Red diverged from their story map too radically. Then Twohy got his turn, which nobody much liked either. Which is when they turned to Vincent Ward. The visionary director of What Dreams May Come and Map Of The Human Heart initially resisted, sure that he wasn't interested on working on a sequel. Eventually the studio managed to pique his interest (probably with bags full of money), and he developed a pitch involving Ripley's escape pod crash landing on a monastery-like satellite. Yay! Ripley's back! And she's returned to one of the weirdest Alien ideas to ever get greenlit, with the whole film set on this planet populated by Luddite monks. Which is made of wood. A planet made of wood. This one got so far into production they actually built all these wooden sets, with the monks believing the xenomorph is some sort of religious trial for their sins.

1. Alien: Engineers

The general consensus with Prometheus is that it was a missed opportunity. Or else a complete f*cking shambles. Thirty years after he started the franchise Ridley Scott finally came back to tie up some loose ends from the original Alien film: what exactly is the Weyland-Yutani corporation after? What was up with that space jockey guy on the planet the Nostromo crew visited? And where did the xenomorphs come from? Not necessarily questions that needed answers, but the promise of Scott returning to the series was exciting. At least it was until audiences actually saw the film, and it was a sort of half-arse Alien prequel that was coy about ever identifying itself as such, instead going in for dodgy internal logic and semi-philosophical musings. Which is very different from how it could have been. The original draft of the script - dubbed Alien: Engineers - is still far from perfect, but it's a damned sight better than what we actually got. In the end Prometheus offered no answers. Jon Spaihts revealed the aliens were a weapon created by a master race, Michael Fassbender's android was more evil, Noomi Rapace's scientist less religious. Oh and it hinted that Jesus was an Engineer, and that xenomorphs were created to punish humanity for crucifying him. How's that for an origin story... Would any have these have been better than what we got? Probably. Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/