10 Annoying Problems With Found Footage Movies

If you're being chased by a serial killer, make sure to hang on to your camera.

Diary of the Dead
The Weinstein Company

Every generation of horror is defined by some new gimmick, and for the past decade that's been found footage. The subgenre was revived thanks to Paranormal Activity in 2009, and now some of the most successful low budget films in recent years have made use of this device. So why is found footage so popular?

On a creative level, it's a way of placing the audience that much closer to the action, making it easier to relate to the main characters while experiencing their point of view. Found footage also helps establish these films as taking place in the real world as opposed to some fictional movie world, so when crazy things start happening, it's that much scarier. When done well, this first person style can result in some pretty amazing films. 

Yet there are plenty of annoying problems with this gimmick that a lot of films suffer from, annoyances and questions that pop up in even the best entries. These 10 issues are ones that the directors hope you'll just forget about, but when they happen over and over, they can really suck you out of the film. With the opening of The Gallows proving that found footage is still going strong, let's take a look at 10 annoying problems with the genre.

10. Who's Editing This Footage?

Megan Is Missing
Trio Pictures

Here’s a question every found footage movie hopes the audience isn’t asking: who exactly is editing this footage together and presenting it to you?

With a lot of these films, this is apparently supposed to be footage directly from the camera. Yet there are clearly edits all throughout, with movie-like timing and cuts between scenes where it doesn’t make sense for the person to have just stopped recording. Sometimes there are even things added into the film in editing, like time stamps, title cards and music, so within the movie’s reality, there’s obviously an editor that combed through the tape and is presenting it to the audience.

But barely any of these movies ever address this (unless they're in the style of a fake documentary), and that creates a weird disconnect. Someone is obviously editing the footage, yet they don’t take out bits that clearly don’t need to be there, such as the scenes of characters just sitting around by the pool talking. So by the movie's logic, was this footage of people’s actual deaths acquired by some film studio that then hired an editor to piece it together into a scary movie? If so, that’s almost more messed up than anything in the actual films.


9. Why Are They Still Holding The Camera?

The Last Exorcism
Lionsgate

Nearly every found footage movie struggles with the fact that in many of these circumstances, it makes absolutely no sense for the person to still be holding the camera and pointing it at the action.

Of course, they have to do so because otherwise there's no movie, but when a giant monster is attacking New York City, would you really still be carrying around a camcorder and filming everything? When you drop the camera in the midst of people dying all around you, would you really run back and grab it? Would you still be filming as everyone's life is at risk including your own?

Some of these movies try to deal with this by explaining that filming helps the main character deal with the situation at hand, like in Chronicle where Andrew starts recording as a coping strategy. Other films have gotten more innovative over time and placed the camera out of the characters’ hands to avoid this problem, such as a segment in V/H/S where the camera is on the character’s head.

But for any movie that involves a person actually holding a camera, there is almost always the inevitable moment where any reasonable person would have dropped that thing already.


8. Lots Of Filler

Paranormal Activity 2 Women
Paramount Pictures

In the best found footage movies like the original Paranormal Activity, there’s a lot of buildup in the beginning that just makes it that much scarier when things go south. You need to establish some normality before the craziness starts, so these scenes make sense.

Yet many imitators (including the Paranormal Activity sequels) just take that way too far, with too much time in the first act dedicated to just completely useless filler scenes. The characters film themselves goofing around for giant stretches of time with the excuse being that if this footage was found on someone’s personal camcorder, a lot of the tape would be of them just doing their thing and hanging around.

And yeah, that’s true, but there’s only so much of this that the audience can take, especially when nearly half the movie is of no importance and is just annoying characters goofing off. When done well, the opening bits can really help establish these characters through seemingly meaningless footage, yet when done poorly, it just feels like the movie is completely wasting your time.


7. It Can Be An Excuse To Not Show Anything

Hollow Movie
Metrodome Distribution

A lot of times what you don’t see is scarier than what you do, and the best of these movies capitalize on that. The Blair Witch Project, for example, never actually shows any witches, yet it’s one of the scariest films of all time.

But a lot of lesser films take that too far, thinking that just pointing the camera at the ground as the characters scream is enough to be scary. This gimmick is too often used as an excuse to shrink budgets and to not have to show anything. But this is only acceptable when the filmmakers clearly understand tension and are using the POV style for a purpose. When done poorly, it just feels like you’re being ripped off and the director doesn't have the money to show anything but dark shots of people's feet.

Cloverfield is a great example where the film shows very little in the opening two acts, but it still does reveal the monster towards the end and gives you what you paid for. But then other movies like Hollow simply have the characters whip the camera around wildly and scream, and you’re supposed to imagine the entire movie. 


6. Forced Dialogue

VHS Movie
Magnet Releasing

These movies typically present what you're watching as footage that just happens to be on these cameras, but because of that some of the dialogue can often feel really forced. Isn’t it convenient that these characters are explaining this entire situation while they happen to also be recording?

Take a scene towards the beginning of the first V/H/S movie. The characters are recording while goofing around in the car when they suddenly explain that they’re being sent to this house to recover a VHS tape. Wouldn't everyone in the car know what they're doing, though? It’s being said just so the audience can hear that information, but it feels so painfully forced.

That happens way too often in these movies. The dialogue should feel completely natural and like the viewer is a fly on the wall, but a lot of times it's far too calculated, with the characters explaining things they wouldn’t naturally be explaining and expressing their emotions out loud in really obvious ways.


5. Forced Exposition

Paranormal Activity The Marked Ones 2
Paramount Pictures

Similar to the problem of forced dialogue, how many times have you seen this scene in a found footage movie: the characters are facing this big mystery, so they go online and Google around about it before coming across a website that perfectly explains everything, and they then read from it to their friend holding the camera.

This happens all the time, especially in movies involving possession where the characters end up on a website with a black background and red text from some demonologist who conveniently can explain everything. Sometimes they’ll get him on Skype to chat or maybe he’ll pay a visit in person, and within a minute or two everything the audience needs to know is revealed.

Forced exposition is obviously a problem in non-found footage movies too, but it’s even more prominent in this genre. The characters practically explain right into the camera what’s going on, and because these films have such short running times, it very often only takes about 30 seconds of them scrolling through the web or reading a dusty old book. In a good film, the explanations of things should be gradually and naturally revealed, but that’s all too rare in found footage films that often just rely on a massive, awkward exposition dump.


4. Forcing In Multiple Cameras

Chronicle Floating Cameras
20th Century Fox

Some of these films use multiple cameras, which is obviously a way of providing more angles and getting around the limitations of only having one point of view. This can be effective, but at some point it just feels like the director is bored of the gimmick and just wants to go back to making a normal movie, and then what’s the point of making this found footage at all?

Take a moment at the end of Chronicle where dozens of cameras are forced into the scene, floating in the air around the action. This basically allows Josh Trank to cut to wherever he wants to, and it feels like this was written just so the scene could function more like a regular movie, as if by this point Trank was really tired of found footage and wanted to be able to cut around.

Having an additional angle can be fine in cases where the movie focuses on a documentary crew, for example, but too often it feels like the other cameras are just forced and unnecessary. 


3. Using Music

Diary of the Dead
The Weinstein Company

Most found footage movies thankfully avoid this, but it’s popped up enough times to be a really annoying trend.

A few of these films actually add music and sound effects into scenes to make them more closely resemble a traditional horror film, as if audiences can't possibly be scared without this. Just like with adding multiple angles, if you’re making a found footage film, you should commit to that gimmick. Having music just feels like the director is chickening out and reverting back to standard movie cliches.

Take George Romero’s Diary of the Dead, meant to be assembled from documentary footage but which has lame horror movie music all throughout that completely detracts from that. It’s hard not to imagine the editor within the film’s universe, assembling all this footage of people literally dying on camera and overlaying a cheesy film score.

When working with found footage, half the fun is committing to those limitations and being creative with them. Using things like music and sound effects just takes the audience out of that experience and reminds them that they aren’t actually watching footage from someone’s camera. They’re watching a Hollywood movie.


2. The Technology Often Makes No Sense

Cloverfield Ending
Paramount Pictures

This is one of those things that you just have to overlook when watching a found footage movie, but half the time, the technology presented makes no sense. Sometimes the footage will be filled with weird stuttering to make things more dramatic, presumably because the camera is damaged, but those glitches aren’t anything that ever actually happens with a damaged camera.

Then there are specific issues, like how in Cloverfield it keeps cutting back to old footage at moments that it doesn’t really make sense for the tape to be doing that. A few movies use this idea of cutting to the tape the characters are recording over, but half the time the old tape comes on whenever it's necessary for the plot and not when it would make technological sense.

There’s also the giant elephant in the room in many of these movies that you’re watching footage supposedly from a person’s personal camcorder or from a camera recording on VHS tapes, yet it's all beautiful HD movie quality and looks like it was shot with cameras that cost thousands of dollars. But that’s a fair tradeoff if it means not spending 90 minutes watching a film that looks grainy and terrible.


1. No Endings

The Devil Inside
Paramount Pictures

Over and over in found footage films, the action will be gearing up, and then just as the characters are in grave danger and everything is getting insane, they drop the camera, they're killed off screen, and that’s it. But a completely unsatisfying ending like this is supposedly okay because this is how real footage would end! Really, it’s just an excuse to cop out of giving the audience any sense of resolution.

Easily the worst example of this was in The Devil Inside. Everything’s really heating up when the characters get into a car accident and the camera cuts to black. A title card comes up saying that the case of these people is still unresolved and the audience can visit a website for more information. In no other genre would it be acceptable to suddenly cut to black and just redirect the audience to a website.

Obviously it’s okay to end with the camera being destroyed and the characters being killed if there’s a sense of finality and resolution, like the end of Cloverfield. But too often these movies simply cut the audience off right as things are getting good. After all, they’ve already wasted the audience’s time and made plenty of excuses to not show them anything as a way to save money, so why give them a real ending? 


Contributor
Contributor

Lover of horror movies, liker of other things. Your favorite Friday the 13th says a lot about you as a person, and mine is Part IV: The Final Chapter.