10 Appalling Comedy Films From People Who Should Have Known Better
In the film industry, every appalling thing you see is the result of a bad decision happening at some point during the production process. Sometimes you can put these decisions down to inexperience, overconfidence, or incorrectly predicting market trends but more often than not, they come from someone who really should have known better. Whether its because those people have experience in their respective fields that should have stopped those decisions dead in their tracks, or because the decision was stupid and/or utterly insane. And because comedy is a harder minefield to negotiate than other genres, there are a lot of appalling comedy films from studio executives and filmmakers who really should have known better...
10. Home Alone 4 (2002, Dir. Rod Daniel)
What Was The Comedy? A TV movie sequel to Home Alone that acted as a pilot for a potential TV series. Why Was It Appalling? Other than it being your standard Its for kids so lets not really put a lot of effort in type of film, it doesnt feel like a real Home Alone film. Two of Kevins four siblings are left out of the film with no explanation, Kevin and the two siblings who are in the film are played by younger actors than previously, and every returning character has been recast, giving it the air of a remake rather than a sequel. In fact, it could have easily been a completely unrelated film that had the characters names changed and a few token references to the other Home Alone films added at the last minute. Its a cheap attempt to cash in on a dead franchise without any of the original thematic elements other than cartoonish slapstick which itself is kind of pointless given that Kevin is never alone at any point, and that his decision to set traps for the villains is completely arbitrary since the house he is staying in has live-in staff, at least one of whom is always home at every point in the film. Who Should Have Known Better? The Disney and Fox executives who decided to try and revive the franchise. Why Should They Have Known Better? The premise of Home Alone lasts for exactly one film. Home Alone 2 was a stretch but at least had the original cast in a new setting to capture the spirit of the original, and Home Alone 3 was a disaster with completely new characters that felt more like a knock-off that appropriated the Home Alone title than a sequel. By this point there was nothing original that could be done with it other than changing the setting and coming up with a few new traps. Also, the Home Alone craze of the early 1990s where every filmmaker and his dog was ripping off the whole Plucky child sets traps for bad guys idea was long dead by this point. After Home Alone became a hit, everybody wanted a piece of that action and ran the idea into the ground within a few years until everyone had had their fill of it. Not to mention that sequels to a film with a premise that cant change very much need the original cast to attract fans of the franchise. Which would have never worked anyway since everyone from the original was far too old to do another Home Alone. Which makes this film a Catch 22 in terms of casting. They couldnt bring back the original Kevin McCallister because Macaulay Culkin was 22 years old when the film was released, and because whoever was cast as the new Kevin just wouldnt be as good as Culkin.
9. Fred: The Movie (2010, Dir. Clay Weiner)
What Was The Comedy? A TV movie based on Fred Figglehorn, a successful YouTube character created and played by Lucas Cruikshank, who was 17 years old when the film was released. Why Was It Appalling? Writing comedy is a tricky business that takes both life experience and talent that has been honed to the nth degree. Other than very rare exceptions like comedian Eros Vlahos who began his career at the age of thirteen, teenagers cannot write comedy. And although Fred: The Movie was written by seasoned comedy writer David A. Goodman, the bulk of it focused on solo skits performed and presumably formulated in part by Lucas Cruikshank. The film is generally just poorly written and performed as well as being one of those films that are just a string of random occurrences held together by the bare bones of a plot. Not to mention that Fred is an incredibly annoying and unsympathetic character (such as his reaction to a man speaking Spanish being Are you a spaceman?), and Cruikshanks digitally altered voice is worse than nails on a chalkboard. Who Should Have Known Better? The Nickelodeon executives who thought that three minute YouTube videos by a teenager would automatically translate to a profitable TV movie. Why Should They Have Known Better Even if they are popular, a series of three minute YouTube videos by a seventeen year old (who was fourteen when the character was first created) is incredibly unlikely to be a solid basis for a feature film. Runtimes of three minutes and eighty-five minutes are completely incompatible because, for a three minute video, only a small amount of material is needed. A feature length film requires considerably more depth than can be provided by expanding a one-note character. It would be like making a film about one of the characters from Little Britain. It just wont work because there isnt enough to build on and a huge amount of changes will be required to fit the new format that will most likely cause the appeal of the character to be lost in translation and thus alienate the films target market. And, as mentioned above, a 17 year-old is simply not capable of creating comedy that is of a high enough calibre to be broadcast on television or released in cinemas as the film was in the UK.
8. Son Of The Mask (2005, Dir. Lawrence Guterman)
What Was The Comedy? A belated sequel to The Mask. Why Was It Appalling? Apart from the more general flaws of poor writing and direction, Son Of The Mask had almost no connection to the original film. It was released eleven years after The Mask, had a different director, writers, characters, and cast, and the biggest flaw of all: no Jim Carrey. And since Carreys performance was what gave The Mask most of its most memorable and funny moments, his absence from the film really shot it in the foot. As did its huge disconnect from its predecessor and its considerable amount of pretty disturbing imagery and adult content such as the main character's infant son planning to have him sectioned and his dog wanting to kill his son. Who Should Have Known Better? The studio executives who just wouldnt let the project die despite it being in development hell for nearly a decade. Why They Should Have Known Better? If youre doing a sequel to a Jim Carrey film a decade after that film comes out, you need Jim Carrey. He was pretty much the biggest draw for The Mask and its one of his most well known roles. Hes the best known thing about the film so making a sequel not featuring him or his character is like spending the $84 million budget on building a hotel halfway up Mount Everest.
7. North (1994, Dir. Rob Reiner)
What Was The Comedy?A family film starring Elijah Wood as North, a young boy who divorces his parents and travels the world in search of a new family. Why Was It Appalling? While the overall concept is a good idea for a family film and allows for a lot of appearances by strong comedic actors as Norths potential parents, the way the film was written lets it down. Its main problem is that its thunderously racist. Every set of parents that North lives with are complete stereotypes like his adopted parents in Africa living in mud huts and wearing grass skirts, and his adopted Inuit parents queuing up to put their elderly relatives on ice floes and push them out to sea, as well as them being played by white actors in makeup. Also, some of the content is inappropriately adult like Norths adopted Hawaiian father saying that his wife is the only barren area on the island, and planning to use Norths fame to bring tourism to Hawaii with a moving billboard featuring an octopus pulling down his swimming trunks. Theres also a subplot of Norths friend planning to murder him, and Bruce Williss line about Miami: You ever been there in the summer? Your balls stick to your leg like Krazy Glue. And it uses the "It was all a dream" ending, a plot device that (unless you're very clever with how you use it) will lessen the quality of your film in an instant. Who Should Have Known Better? Director Rob Reiner. Why Should He Have Known Better? Reiner starred in the Til Death Us Do Part remake All In The Family as casual racist Archie Bunkers liberal Jewish son-in-law Michael Stivic. Given that racism was a frequent theme of that programme, starring in it should have made Reiner more attuned than most people to how the issue of race should be handled in comedy. But aside from that, a question that any director should ask himself when making a film is Could this offend anyone and cause a backlash? The script for North should have set alarm bells ringing on that front. Not to mention that adult content like some of the jokes in North belong in a more teenage-orientated film rather than a family comedy.
6. Run For Your Wife (2012, Dir. Ray Cooney & John Luton)
What Was The Comedy?An adaptation of the 1980 stage play of the same name about a bigamous taxi driver whose web of lies is uncovered after he is injured while stopping a mugging. Why Was It Appalling? It was phenomenally outdated by the time the film was made. The stage show may have had a successful nine year run but times have changed and the film's farcical style with characters stepping on rakes and losing their trousers doesnt carry much weight with cinemagoers in the 21st century. Not to mention that writer Ray Cooney (who also wrote the original play) was the co-director despite having not directed a film since 1984 and the film's other co-director John Luton only having one directorial credit prior to Run For Your Wife. Who Should Have Known Better? Writer and co-director Ray Cooney. Why Should He Have known Better? As an experienced theatre writer, Cooney should have realised that comedy has changed considerably since Run For Your Wifes West End debut in 1980 and should have updated some of the plays elements when writing the script for the film adaptation in order to create a version of the play that was more suited to the modern age. Also, as mentioned, he last directed a film in 1984 and should have handed over directorial duties to somebody with more recent experience or hired a more experienced co-director so that his knowledge of the source material and the talents of a director with more recent film experience could be combined. Instead, Cooney wrote the film solo and directed it with somebody with almost no experience. Which resulted in it being critically panned and taking less than £700 on its opening weekend.
5. Leonard Part 6 (1987, Dir. Paul Weiland)
What Was the Comedy? A spy spoof starring comedian and sitcom star Bill Cosby as retired secret agent Leonard Parker who embarks on a mission to stop an evil vegetarian from taking over the world. Why Was It Appalling? Its unfunny, self-indulgent pap thats full of incredibly blatant product placement for Coca Cola and has a ridiculous story, even for a comedy: An evil vegetarian is training animals to kill humans and retired spy Leonard Parker is recruited to stop her. His primary weapon against the vegetarians is magic meat that he receives from a gypsy, and the film ends with him flooding the vegetarians' base using Alka Seltzer and escaping by riding an ostrich off of the roof. God knows what Cosby had taken when he came up with that. Who Should Have Known Better? Bill Cosby. Why Should He Have Known Better? Cosby eventually did realise he was at fault and had made a terrible film but it was just a bit too late when the realisation finally came since the film had already been made. So he did his best to kill the film by urging people not to see it in all of his TV appearances promoting it. It worked and Leonard Part 6 was a box office bomb, only grossing a fifth of its budget. But the reason Cosby was at fault is that his success with his sitcom The Cosby Show gave him an insane amount of power. To the extent that he could pretty much do whatever he liked and not take suggestions or constructive criticism from anyone, at one point telling the films director You worry about construction, let me worry about funny. Having been a successful comedy star for so long, he should have realised earlier that no good could come from one person having such a huge degree of control, and that surrounding himself with sycophants and letting his ego reign supreme wasnt a good idea when it came to filmmaking.
4. Everything By Jason Friedberg & Aaron Seltzer After Date Movie (2007 Present, Dir. Jason Friedberg & Aaron Seltzer)

3. Breaking Wind Part 1 (2012, Dir. Craig Moss)
What Was The Comedy? A straight-to-DVD parody of Twilight. Why Was It Appalling? First of all, to give writer and director Craig Moss his due, (and its not a big compliment but is still something that bears mentioning) this film is largely on target in mocking Twilight and only slips into Friedberg and Seltzer territory a few times with scenes of characters planking and a Navi from Avatar turning up at one point as well as a few other random bits and pieces like an Angry Birds parody. But other than it largely parodying what it's supposed to (which is an increasingly rare thing in modern spoof films), this film is god-awful. As its title may suggest, Breaking Wind Part 1 has some of the biggest focus on scatological humour in the history of cinema. The title is a fart joke, the title card farts, and there are fart and turd jokes about every five minutes, with it even being a major plot element at one point. Also, logic dictates that this should either parody Twilight as a whole so that people who arent overly familiar with the franchise can be given a basic introduction to the story and understand the jokes, or of Breaking Dawn since thats what the title is based on and what the film was released to coincide with. Instead, it mainly parodies the third film Eclipse with some dialogue being lifted verbatim from it. Who Should Have Known Better? Writer and director Craig Moss. Why Should He Have Known Better? For a start, his previous film The 41 Year Old Virgin Who Knocked Up Sarah Marshall And Felt Superbad About It was almost as critically derided as the works of Friedberg and Seltzer (whose style he shamelessly ripped off in the first place), which should have been a big warning sign that he should immediately change his approach. As well as that, not only had the We hate Twilight bandwagon more or less stopped by the time Breaking Wind was released but the franchise had also been mocked into oblivion. Even Friedberg and Seltzer had already parodied Twilight two years before with Vampires Suck. Its like criticizing the Star Wars Prequels. Theres nothing more to say about it. And by 2012, Twilight had stopped being the hate sponge du jour and everyone had moved on, considering the franchise and its fans to be a mild irritant more than anything else. And finally, if youre going to do an in-depth parody of something, you need to fully research it and draw enough material from it that you can make comedic. With Twilight, there is a colossal amount of stuff you can work with; Bella having very little personality, Edward basically being a creepy stalker, the heavy-handed abstinence message, the endless staring. Its a goldmine of mockery. But instead, Moss just followed the basic plot of Eclipse and filled it with farting, sex jokes, and dwarves (because in his mind theyre apparently hilarious). The only thing in the film that even comes close to satire is when Edward starts handing out Team Edward merchandise in his schools cafeteria.
2. Movie 43 (2013, Dir. Various)
What Was The Comedy? An anthology of twelve comedic shorts overseen by Peter Farrelly with an all-star cast including Richard Gere, Kate Winslet, and Hugh Jackman. Why Was It Appalling? In short: its disgusting. And not Peter Farrellys usual brand of disgusting. This takes gross-out comedy to a whole new level and then punts it into outer space. The entire focus of the film is on gratuitous shock humour with one segment focusing around a teenage girl played by Chloe Moretz menstruating, another that includes Halle Berry deliberately squirting hot sauce into her vagina, and a third starring Anna Faris as a woman with a sexual fetish for excrement. Theres more focus on being shocking and edgy than on being funny. They tried to make a gross-out comedy but forgot to add the comedy. Who Should Have Known Better? Everybody involved. Why Should They Have Known Better? The content should have set alarm bells ringing right from the start and the stars should have jumped ship as quickly as they could but were locked into their contracts. Something that eventually led to most of them viewing Movie 43 as a shameful part of their career before it was even released. Any film with no real plot, and such a large focus on gratuitous shock humour and bodily fluids (and this film comes pretty close to winning Bodily Fluid Bingo) should automatically be a red flag to any film professional. But the real They should have known better moment goes to several of the actors who were reportedly only paid $500 for two days of filming and were apparently lured in by the promise of potential profit sharing, which obviously never materialised in any meaningful way.
1. Trail Of The Pink Panther (1982, Dir. Blake Edwards)
What Was The Comedy? The last Pink Panther film to star Peter Sellers as Inspector Clouseau. Why Was It So Appalling? Peter Sellers died before the film was made. I swear that I am not making a word of this up. After Peter Sellers death, production began on Trail Of The Pink Panther with the film relying on material that had been cut from the other Pink Panther films (mostly taken from The Pink Panther Strikes Again), with half of the film being about a character played by Joanna Lumley searching for Clouseau after he goes missing. The decision to construct the Clouseau scenes out of archive footage led to the whole thing being incredibly disjointed since it was attempting to connect archive material with new footage to make a coherent story. Who Should Have Known Better? Whoever was insane and money-grubbing enough to suggest that making a comedy starring a dead actor was both plausible and not in bad taste. Why Should They Have Known Better? It is a truth universally acknowledged by all but those with an IQ in single figures that any film starring a dead actor made after said actors death will be terrible in both quality and taste. Theres really nothing to be said beyond that. You just cant make a feature length film starring a dead man and expect it to be any good. Even with some of the focus on another character in a different but connected story. And this fundamental failure to grasp the concept of both human dignity and how the film industry works (mainly the part about how actors need to be alive in order to act) cost the studio $1.5 million after a successful lawsuit by Sellers widow who claimed that the film was a cheap insult to her husbands memory. Which appalling comedy films do you think should have been avoided? Leave a comment...