10 Badly Miscast Actors In The Marvel Cinematic Universe
Not everyone ends up pulling a Robert Downey Jr., you know.

At this rate, by the year 2030, every single actor in Hollywood will have probably had a part - or something to do with - the Marvel Cinematic Universe, because doesn't it kind of feel a bit like that already? Absolutely everybody, from high ranking masters of their craft such as Sir Ben Kingsley, to fresh-faced pretty boys like Chris Hemsworth, have found their way into the world's biggest film franchise.
And for that most part, it's a good thing, because the MCU often allows actors of all types the chance to show a new side to themselves; to try something different. Still, not everyone who enters the Marvel Cinematic Universe ends up gelling with the established world as well as they might've hoped - and some actors who might've seemed perfect for their roles sometimes up being anything but suitable.
They look out of place, or fail to make an impression, or don't seem to understand that they're in a comic book movie. Join us, then, as we take a look at the 10 most miscast actors in the Marvel Cinematic Universe to date - actors who, unlike Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, and Tom Hiddleston, seem like they don't belong.
10. Scarlett Johansson - Black Widow (Iron Man 2)
"What?!" you suddenly find yourself screaming into your computer screen, wondering what the hell is going on with this list already. "Didn't you see Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Sam? Scar-Jo was very nearly the best damn thing in it!"
Hold your horses, cowboy; you're absolutely right. But if we're going to get real about this Scarlett Johansson as Black Widow thing, let's be honest with ourselves: Johansson seemed horribly miscast in the role until that very movie; in both Iron Man 2 and The Avengers, she was actually kind of yawn-inducing. Which is to say, up until she decided to play the role with a little more gusto and personality in the second Captain America movie, Johansson seemed at total odds with the likes of Black Widow; there was a lacking sense of believability about her performance, and she appeared to have just opted to play it in the most generic way possible, adding nothing to the character.
Were we really convinced that Johansson was a super spy? Sure, she nailed the "hot" aspects of Black Widow's persona, but the rest seemed a little flat. Still, at least she's improved somewhat since.
9. Terrence Howard - James Rhodes (Iron Man)
Remember when Terrence Howard was Rhodey instead of Don Cheadle? Yeah, that was weird, wasn't it? At the very dawn of the MCU, then, in its very first movie, Terrence Howard signed on to play Tony Stark's good buddy James "Rhodey" Rhodes, who eventually becomes superhero War Machine (and later on the Iron Patriot).
Despite the fact that, at the time, we didn't really know what to expect from the MCU, Terrence Howard seemed like an okay choice for this character: it's only in retrospect, and compared to Cheadle, that he feels miscast. The biggest problem with Howard's take on Rhodes stems from the fact that it's too hard to believe that he would become War Machine. There's no sense of "superhero" in him - going on his performance in Iron Man, Howard could have been playing a character in a very serious army movie.
He's not tough enough and there's a lacking sense of authority that renders his character as... well, a little pathetic, to be frank. Is it really surprising that, for whatever reason, Howard went the way of the dodo come time for Iron Man 2? Don Cheadle: a lot, lot better.
8. Guy Pearce - Aldrich Killian/The Mandarin (Iron Man 3)
Whoever Guy Pearce was supposed to be in the end, there's no doubting the fact that this usually-very-good-in-everything actor ultimately wasn't right for his part in Iron Man 3, despite some very good moments. Fact is, the convoluted, twist-related nature of Shane Black's film meant that - for the most part - Pearce spent his time playing a fairly run of the mill villain named Aldrich Killian.
Okay, fine. By the time the credits had rolled, though, we're all supposed to have outright accepted that Guy Pearce had been playing the Mandarin all along? No way! Because, let's face it: Pearce was fine when he was Aldrich Killian. But trying to tell us that, ultimately, it was Guy Peace who was the "real" Mandarin (and over Ben Kingsley, no less!), well... that's "miscasting" pretty much defined, really.
Pearce has some brilliant bits in the movie, especially those that have him pegged as a nerd in the flashback sequences - he's hammy and entertaining. Even if he were just supposed to be Killian, we could go along with it. But given that he's absolutely nothing like the Mandarin of the comics (at all), it's a severe miscast.
7. Idris Elba - Heimdall (Thor)
There is something very, very strange about watching Idris Elba, an immensely talented actor, playing the role of Asgard's guardian sentry in the Thor movies, because you can't help but wonder why, of all people, they got him in for the part.
That's not to say that he's entirely terrible; just that his being there feels unnatural to the point where it's genuinely a little bit off-putting. Is it the very self-conscious British accent that makes it weird, despite the fact that Elba is British? Is it that slow, padded way in which he talks, like he's been plugged with morphine?
You might remember back when Elba was first cast that a lot of people were peeved on account of the fact that he was black, and Heimdall has traditionally been written and drawn as white. That matters not, of course, and we bring it up again here again to clarify that his presence on a list of miscast characters has nothing to do with race - who cares? The point is, Elba doesn't really seem to know what to do with the role. His performance is dull and actually kind of awkward; he doesn't really bring anything to character of Heimdall, which is a crying shame.
6. Gwyneth Paltrow - Pepper Potts (Iron Man)
Gwyneth Paltrow is one of those actresses who is inherently annoying for reasons nobody can really put their finger on. But unlike in the case of, say, Anne Hathaway, who is also annoying but manages to be non-annoying in her film roles (go figure), Paltrow is annoying no matter what she does - and the trait extends to pretty much all of her characters.
So the actress, who won an Oscar for her turn in Shakespeare In Love (which tells you all you need to know, really), was cast as Tony Stark's love interest in the Iron Man series. Did it pay off, we wonder? Well, let's be honest about it: Paltrow isn't terrible in this role. And she's reprised it three times since making her first appearance as Potts. She's bearable.
The reason she's miscast? Simply because - when placed next to the endlessly charismatic Robert Downey Jr. - she just doesn't feel like an equal. It's super tough for us to believe that this woman could really be the object of Tony's desire because she's so freakin' annoying. And since Paltrow doesn't really manage to be properly sexy or properly nerdy (she's pretty much herself), it all falls a little bit flat.
5. Natalie Portman - Jane Foster (Thor)
Natalie Portman isn't "miscast" in the same way that most of the other actors on this list are. And the main reason for that, ultimately, is that Natalie Portman isn't wrong for the role of Jane Foster, in as much as she just should not be playing the role at all.
It's as simple as that. An actor of her calibre, with an Oscar for Best Actress under her belt, playing a vague and mostly uninteresting love interest in a Marvel movie? It just doesn't make sense. So as much as she plays Jane as well as such a bland character can be played, the fact that she's here is insane. Actually think about it: Portman has featured in two Thor movie thus far. In the first one, the role seemed like something unworthy or her talents, but we sort of went along with it, 'cause hey, Natalie Portman is hot. By the time Thor: The Dark World swung around, though, Jane had been reduced to a mere plot point - a character who literally spent the movie in a state of unconsciousness.
That's not a joke. And the fact is, absolutely anybody with even mild acting capabilities could play her part. For squandering her talents alone, this is major miscasting.
4. Sebastian Stan - The Winter Soldier (Captain America: The Winter Soldier)
Choo choo! All aboard the controversial opinion train. Okay, so it seems somewhat ridiculous given how much praise Sebastian Stan received for his turn as The Winter Soldier, which was about as bland and flat as the worst kinds of comic book movie performances (the forgettable ones, we mean). Thing is, Sebastian Stan ended up bagging a role that he would have never have been gifted with unless he'd been cast as Bucky Barnes in the first Captain America movie, at a point when the studio had no real idea that he'd become a major villain later on.
After all, in the original, Barnes was a secondary character - and Stan did fine in the role, delivering the sort of performance that you'd expect from a TV actor cast in a small part in a Hollywood movie. Marvel, who are suckers for continuity, of course, decided that they'd let him reprise the role for The Winter Soldier and gave him the opportunity to play the major freakin' villain. But make no mistake; Stan isn't memorable enough an actor for this role. He's deftly miscast and should feel lucky that, in this case, Marvel just opted to keep the continuity in line.
3. Micky Rourke - Ivan Vanko (Iron Man 2)
If there was any single Marvel Cinematic Universe movie charged with the most instances of "miscasting," then Iron Man 2 takes the prize. That's to say, aside from miscasting Scarlett Johansson and Pepper Potts as previously mentioned, Marvel opted for Mickey Rourke when it came time to cast villain Ivan Vanko (otherwise known as Whiplash).
On paper, this actually probably looked like something of a good decision - unfortunately for the movie, and for Rourke, he delivers a strange, half-a*sed, near drunk (?) performance. It's partly down to the mostly ineffective script that Rourke flounders in his role here, but he also phones in "generic foreign bad guy" and offers up nothing else of interest.
Looking at Whiplash in the comics, however, it should have been a bit more obvious that Rourke probably wasn't the right man for the job to begin with. A younger, far more nimble guy with some actual personality would have gone a long way - and given Rourke's tendency to phone in his performances unless he's in the right mood, we just ended up with a lumbering, ugly mess of a villain.
2. Edward Norton - Bruce Banner (The Incredible Hulk)
There are many comic book fans out there who think that Edward Norton made a brilliant Bruce Banner, though there also seems to be an equal number of human beings who think he was near-on disastrous in the role.
Though the level of his acting on show in The Incredible Hulk, perhaps the MCU's most forgotten movie (yep, it's part of the official canon and everything) is serviceable, and Norton clearly took his time and made a lot of effort to try and do the character justice, he just feels wrong for the part in the same way that acid feels wrong as food. Which is an incredibly lame way of saying: Norton just isn't Bruce Banner.
Despite the fact that he arguably put more effort into rendering his character than Eric Bana and Mark Ruffalo put together, for the entire runtime of the movie, Norton fails to convince. It might seem unfair to suggest that Ruffalo felt like Banner the moment we saw him for the first time in The Avengers, but it's sort of true; he came to us fully-formed, without all the strain and overreaching inherent to Norton's performance. It's just too much of a stretch that Norton could be the Hulk!
1. Jeremy Renner - Hawkeye (The Avengers)
It's probably true that nobody, most of all Jeremy Renner, really knows what happened with Hawkeye. As a character in the MCU, he's sort of like the last kid picked for sports teams during gym practice: you sort of feel sorry for the guy, but meh, he isn't really helping himself, so screw it, right?
The biggest problem inherent to this casting decision isn't really the undeveloped nature of Renner's character, then, but the fact that - generally - the actor plays him so straight-laced and po-faced that he gives Captain America a run for his money. "Why... so... serious?"
Sure, it doesn't help that both of Hawkeye's appearances thus far have reduced him to something of a plot device: first time we met him in Thor, he had about two minutes on screen, and for most of The Avengers, he was a pawn under Loki's control.
Still, that doesn't excuse the fact that Renner has obviously been misguided or whatever in his take on the character; he doesn't feel like Hawkeye at all, who - in the comics - is a cocky, confident character. Nothing like the wet mop that's been left out in the sun that Renner is channeling here.
-
Like this article? Agree or disagree with our choices? Let us know in the comments section below.