10 Baffling Casting Decisions That Turned Out To Be Awesome
As the title suggests, this article is a list of casting decisions that didn't make any sense at the time yet ultimately proved to be strokes of genius. Of course, such a list can only ever be subjective and one man's meat is another man's polonium-210, but I'm happy enough that the people who've made this list will be met with nods of approval from the vast majority of people (excluding the film nerd who'll rant and rave because someone from a little-known Polish/Iranian/Korean film didn't make the cut). The list is compiled in no particular order and the rules applied in its creation were simply that an actor could only appear once (Tom Cruise had multiple entries before that little ditty was invoked), the bafflement had to be on an international scale, and only feature films could be used. Ready? Let's do it! 10. Daniel Craig - James Bond
Arguably the most hotly contested casting decision of the century - Daniel Craig as Bond. Claims of being too ugly, too short - too blonde - were lashed around. There was even a website - www.danielcraigisnotbond.com - set up by people with nothing of note in their lives. The world, it seemed, was doomed. Sod the Hadron Collider blowing through the earth's mantle and creating a black hole that would devour the entire planet, Daniel Craig playing Bond was the most terrible and terrifying that could ever happen! Errr, and then Casino Royale exploded onto our screens, knocked our socks off, and installed Craig as the best Bond ever. Cold, ruthless, determined - a spy that finally looked like he killed for a living. Built like a Tonka truck and looking like he can handle himself in a fight (without fear of his hairpiece coming loose), Craig burst into life, chasing a guy over a construction site obstacle course that would make even Peter Parker think twice. And those people at danielcraigisnotbond.com? They suddenly realised how stupid they'd been. All except a handful - but theyre probably members of the Flat Earth Society so.
9. Matt Damon - The Bourne Identity
Much like Daniel Craig, Matt Damon got tons of flak for taking on Jason Bourne. "He's too young, "he's too nice", "he's not a trained assassin". Apparently, fans of the book had a hard time in wrapping their heads around the fact that actors, y'know, act for a living. Just like they failed to credit casting agents and directors and producers with screen testing to ensure the star they have in mind to carry their $150m movie actually has the chops to pull it off. They also had a struggle wrapping their brains around the obvious concept that a successful, deadly black ops agent will not look like a successful, deadly black ops agent. In fact, he'll look rather anonymous and blend in, otherwise the bad guys will easily spot his attempts at surveillance and subterfuge and shout: "over there! The 6 foot four guy with bulging muscles, combat paint, a Glock, Beretta, AK-47 and hunting knife, performing high velocity roundhouse kicks and with a stare that can cut through steel - he's the agent that's been sent to infiltrate us!" And now we're three movies in, cannot imagine anyone else playing the role, and wishing we didn't have to suffer the woeful Jeremy Renner in The Bourne Legacy.
8. Tom Cruise - Interview With the Vampire
If Daniel Craig got the most flak this century for being cast in a movie then Tom Cruise takes that mantle for the last century when he signed on to play Lestat in Interview With The Vampire. Even the book's author - Anna Rice - took out a full page newspaper ad denouncing the decision. And everyday folk walked out on their day jobs to grab pitchforks and storm the castles of Hollywood - or so the furore would have us believe. And then Tom Cruise turned in the performance of a lifetime and stole every scene he was in as the lecherous, devious, thoroughly charismatic vampire and Anna Rice felt so moved as to post a full page ad apologising for her hasty derision.
7. Ben Kingsley - Don Logan
If ever a performance defied expectation and all sorts of Einsteinian theories it was petite Ben Kingsley's turn in Sexy Beast. Here, the man renowned for Gandhi, expertly and unnervingly brought to life the psycho that is Don Logan. A wiry man of nervous ticks and twitches, likely to lash out in the blink of an eye. His was a performance of barely concealed rage and hate, a seething mass of anger bubbling under a tetchy surface. Don Logan intimidated everyone he came into contact with - even guys twice his size - and that fear was palpable even to us. Just the mere sight of him storming through the airport with purpose and pressure-cooker vitriol was enough to put us on edge. And who would have thought that anyone could have performed such an atypical performance - let alone Gandhi? Rapid fire dialogue followed by rapid side-to-side eye movement like a lizard, words exploding with more hate than the combined force of the entire KKK. And all perfectly summed up in this diatribe: "Shut up, c*nt. You louse. You got some f**kin' neck ain't you. Retired? F**k off, you're revolting. Look at your suntan, it's leather, it's like leather man, your skin. We could make a f***** suitcase out of you. Like a crocodile, fat crocodile, fat b****. You look like f**king Idi Amin." Had any one told you Kingsley would play a violent psychopath you would have laughed them out of the room. As it was, you were left cowering behind your sofa. Just like the rest of us.
6. Charlize Theron -Aileen Wuornos
Is there a woman more beautiful than Charlize Theron? No. The answer is no. I don't care who else you were going to name, you're wrong. Yes, even you. So who better to portray the fat and ugly Aileen Wuornos - a prostitute who had a lesbian love affair and killed her clients so she could get their money without giving them sex? Okay, okay, apart from Bella Emberg? Like Craig and Damon, no one took the dazzling beauty seriously. But, true to her art, she stocked up on Domino's and Ben & Jerry's and pigged her way to a jumbo sized tub of lard. Add in prosthetic make up (there's no way conventional make up could ever make Charlize ugly, c'mon!) and lo and behold, we had a fat and ugly woman in front of our eyes (kinda like when you wake up after the night before). Personally, I felt Charlize's choice of role was one of those "look at me, I'm a serious actor, gimme an Oscar" moves - like Tom Cruise when he was going through his Born on the Fourth of July/Rain Man phase. But, to her credit, it worked. And it's hard to believe this was the same sex-strumpet who beguiled penises everywhere with her spandex-clad turn in Two Days In The Valley..
5. Michael Keaton - Batman
Craig and Cruise took the title of Most Criticised Casting in the 00s and the 90s but who took the award in the 80s? Why it was none other than Michael Keaton when he agreed to don the cape in Tim Burtons Batman. It was the same old schtick that Craig endured for Bond: hes not tall enough, hes not cool enough, hes not good looking enough and yet hes fondly remembered as the best Batman of them all. But back in 1989, Keaton and his receding hairline wasnt A-list, he wasnt in big blockbusters and he wasnt a heart throb. He was a solid actor but nothing special and deemed rather an odd choice for the role of the Caped Crusader. In fact, by April 1989 the only thing more talked about than Keatons unsuitability for the role was who really shot JFK (and even Lee Harvey Oswald was seen as a better fit for Batman). But Keaton had something the detractors didnt count on: acting chops. And something else: charisma. He owned the role so much that you didnt laugh when he, and his receding hairline, had Kim Basinger eager to open her legs. He was the rich-beyond-belief Bruce Wayne and he was the pointy-eared vigilante. And it was all perfectly believable. But not as believable as the films attempts to portray him as a 6 footer. That was just too much of a stretch!
4. Heath Ledger - The Joker
Heath Ledger was a diverse actor, often choosing roles that defied convention and obvious blockbuster success. He featured in the excellent, yet frothy, Ten Things I Hate About You and immediately changed tack - and gears - to play alongside Mel Gibson in the lets-bash-the-English film The Patriot. From there he jumped back into the teen-girl zone with the atrocious A Knights Tale before doing another 180 and taking a role as a bullied son who blows his brains out in the Halle Berry led heavy drama, Monsters Ball. So really no one should have doubted him when he was cast as The Joker in The Dark Knight. Yet the naysayers and doom mongers were not to be denied (as they had the collective brain power of a dead sheep) and so dusted off their Michael Keaton is not Batman placards (which had been Tip-Exed out and replaced with Daniel Craig is not Bond) and took to the streets en masse to protest that such a coveted and iconic role - personified by Jack Nicholson - could be given to the poodle-haired Australian. What were Hollywood producers, directors, executives and casting agents thinking? They only work in the industry for a living - not like these outraged fans who group together to suck the life out of all thats good in the world. Usually over a super-sized milkshake at their favoured internet café. And how did Ledger react to such criticism from the hordes who still lived with their parents and read comics all day? Oh, nothing much. Apart from turning in a stellar performance and making the role his own. The image of his lipstick smeared character was iconic even before he sadly passed away - such was the power of his performance. And did the pitchfork wielding villagers finally learn their lesson and learn to trust the Hollywood insiders who make films for a living? Finally? Of course not. They didnt even hold their hands up. Instead theyre doing the rounds for Tom Cruises casting as Jack Reacher in One Shot. Thats right - the same Tom Cruise who already proved the cretins wrong with Interview With The Vampire. Ah, theyll say, but this is different. No, it isnt. Now hurry up, your super-sized milkshake is melting.
3. John Travolta - Vince Vega
Once upon a time, John Travolta was the most happening dude on the planet. Tall, good looking and with hips that could hypnotise women and gay men in a heartbeat. Not long after, he was in straight to video nonsense, providing voices for cute, ickle babies. And not long after that those lethal weapon hips were buried under approximately 30 pounds of flab courtesy of the fast food industry. So it was with a collective raised eyebrow that the world greeted the news of his casting as the hitman Vince Vega in Quentin Tarantinos Pulp Fiction. In fact, just being cast at all caused everyone to do their very best Roger Moore impression. Had the praise for Reservoir Dogs and True Romance got to the enfant terribles head? Was he now proving himself to be a one hit wonder? Which came first - the chicken or the egg? All these questions, and more, abounded. Now, usually when an out of shape star is cast, said star is teamed up with a world-class physical instructor and a glut of carefully prescribed steroids.ahem.chicken and protein shakes. But not our John. John turned up as is - a look that is de rigeur out in the mobile home park of Honkyville, Tennessee. But Tarantino, and Travolta, had pulled the rabbit out of the hat once again. Travoltas turn as the laconic, pop-cultured, drug dabbling, pop tart-snacking killer was a revelation - and was the Ying to Samuel L Jacksons fire-and-brimstone Yang. Take your pick from blowing a kids head off, to arguing about cleaning it up, to debating the virtues of not eating pork, to debating the metric system, to dancing with Uma Thurman, each once is iconic in and of itself.
2. Billy Zane - The Collector
Billy Zane - youll either know him as the ex-squeeze of Kelly Brook or as the psycho killer who smiled everyone to death in the Aussie thriller, Dead Calm - but hes also known for causing puzzlement when the Handsome One was cast as The Collector (aka: the Devil) in the criminally underrated Tales From The Crypt: Demon Knight. But despite shocking the world by using the film to showcase his baldy, cue ball noggin, he was able to steal the film from under the nose of every actor around him, including Jada Pinkett and perennial scene stealing, bit-part actor, Dick Miller. With his tongue firmly planted in his cheek, and casting caution to the wind, he was both intimidating, suave, hilarious and captivating in equal measures. All whilst trying to kill everybody in his way and unleashing demons upon the world. Of course, Zane was aided by brilliant dialogue, like All right, I know what you're thinking. You give up your soul, you turn into a demon, you look like s***. Where's the payoff, right? and humans. You're not worth the flesh you're printed on! but it was Zane that brought the words - and the character - to life. It shouldnt have worked, he was too pretty boy and too lightweight (apparently) but, as with everyone else on this list, he did it with aplomb. And gave balding guys around the world the confidence to go cue ball.
1. Brad Pitt - Mickey O'Neil
The final entry on this list is unique - in that it was a brilliant bit of casting even though we never understood a single word they spoke in the entire film. Im talking, of course, about Brad Pitt in Guy Ritchies magnum opus, Snatch. For those whove been living in a bin for the past 12 years, Brad Pitt played a gypsy who just so happened to be a bare-knuckle champion fighter and he spoke an unintelligible mush of English and Irish. Now at this time, Brad was still viewed as a good looking hunk of meat and not much else. Women were boring men to tears with giggle-filled talk of his role in Meet Joe Black, men hated (yet secretly admired) his looks and style in Fight Club, and critics were dismissing him as a serious actor. Did he do Snatch for the accolade? Which is the only reason why any A-list actor treads the boards in Londons West End, by the way. Who knows? All we know is that Guy wanted him for some Stateside appeal and that Pitt knocked it out of the park. It was the first film of his I watched without thinking, thats Brad Pitt. I just saw Mickey, the wiry Pikey who lives in a caravan and sparks out guys the size of bulldozers with just one punch. Considering Snatch had dialogue sharper than a roomful of razor blades and the plot was more twisty-turny than a twisty-turny thing, it takes some doing to be the stand-out performer in every scene you're in - yet Brad did it. Dodgy tats n' all.