10 Best Acting Performances In The Hannibal Lecter Trilogy
The Silence of the Lambs. Hannibal. Red Dragon. Which performance comes out on top?
With Halloween fast approaching, the time for spooks and scares is close at hand, and maybe the most chilling kind of horror is the horror that is real. While the tales of serial killer Hannibal Lecter are fictitious, there is something extremely chilling about seeing horror villains depicted without fantastical or supernatural abilities, and instead just being everyday people with very real and dangerous attitudes.
Bringing these sick and twisted shades of humanity to life on the screen is no easy feat and requires considerable talent from the actors involved. While the legendary, bone-chilling performance of Sir Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal the Cannibal is no secret to audiences, the Hannibal Lecter trilogy features numerous other intriguing characters which are masterfully brought to life before our very eyes.
This list will count down the ten best acting performances from The Silence of the Lambs (1991), Hannibal (2001) and Red Dragon (2002), or the Hannibal Lecter trilogy, essentially - the three with Anthony Hopkins.
Therefore, the films Manhunter (1986) and Hannibal Rising (2007), as well as performances from the TV show Hannibal (2013-2015), won't apply.
MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!
10. Philip Seymour Hoffman as Freddy Lounds
Philip Seymour Hoffman appears in 2002’s Red Dragon as the
sleazy journalist Freddy Lounds working for the fictional magazine called the ‘National
Tattler’. While having a relatively minor role for the first half of the film,
his performance really shines through after he is kidnapped by Francis
Dolarhyde. The ensuing scene sees a wonderful back and forth between Ralph
Fiennes’ Dolarhyde and Philip Seymour Hoffman’s Lounds, in which Lounds does
everything he can to cooperate with the mentally unstable killer in an attempt
to escape with his life.
The beauty of the scene is truly enhanced by Hoffman’s performance. Due to his character currently being glued to the wheelchair, he is limited to expressing the character through nothing but his facial expressions and voice. You can hear the panic and terror in his voice as he begs Dolarhyde to release him, and you can hear the disgust and fear at being shown the photos of the mutilated victims.
While at first it appears to the audience, and Lounds, that
he was able to convince Dolarhyde that he agrees with his perspective, the
scene ultimately climaxes with Lounds’ brutal death as his lips are bitten off
before being burned alive. The scene is honestly uncomfortable to watch due to
the realism of both Fiennes’ and Hoffman’s excellent performances.
9. Emily Watson as Reba McClane
Emily Watson appears in 2002’s Red Dragon as Reba McClane, the blind love interest of Francis Dolarhyde. She essentially acts as a foil and moral compass, albeit unknowingly, to Dolarhyde’s ‘Red Dragon’ personality for the majority of the film by causing him to develop a conscience around his actions. This ultimately backfires in the third act when McClane’s work colleague Ralph Mandy, played by Frank Whaley, takes her on a date, causing ‘the Great Red Dragon’ to emerge, killing Mandy and kidnapping McClane.
A scene which particularly stands out sees McClane and Dolarhyde sitting together to watch a VHS tape which he claims is for “work”. Unbeknownst to her, the tape actually is another home video which he is studying to case out a home. Watson is able to magnificently embody McClane’s innocence and unknowing ignorance to her surroundings as she flirts with Dolarhyde while he is focused on the tape and on watching his next victim.
Watson’s portrayal of the blind character is masterfully done, achieving the difficult task of avoiding eye contact with both actors and the camera to give a true sense of disconnect between her and the sighted characters she skilfully plays off of. It is comparable to the portrayal of Matt Murdock by Charlie Cox in the Netflix show Marvel's Daredevil, another blind character. These unique mannerisms make her character stand out with her co-stars, specifically Ralph Fiennes with whom Watson shares most of her scenes.
8. Gary Oldman as Mason Verger
Gary Oldman appears in 2001’s Hannibal as the paralysed disfigured millionaire Mason Verger. He was a former patient of Lecter’s, due to being convicted of child abuse, and during an event in his house, he was drugged by the cannibal and forced to use a broken mirror to remove his own face. This incident left Verger with a broken neck and horrific facial scarring.
Due to the character of Verger being paralysed, Oldman is motionless for most of his scenes, being able to use nothing but his voice to give life to the character. Oldman gives him a unique voice to lean into the characters physical weakness. This is particularly noticeable when he converses with Julianne Moore’s Clarice Starling near the start of the film where, for a considerable amount of the scene, he simply monologues to Starling, his voice the only audible presence.
Oldman is also totally unrecognisable behind heavy makeup and prosthetics, his right eye clamped open to portray the disfigured Verger. This combination of makeup and voice is what truly makes such an inhuman character come to life on screen, and Oldman’s dedication to the role is visually, and audibly, apparent in each of his scenes.
7. Julianne Moore as Clarice Starling
Julianne Moore appears in 2001’s Hannibal as FBI Agent Clarice
Starling, replacing Jodie Foster after she decline to reprise her role from
1991’s ‘The Silence of the Lambs’. Moore was actually recommended for the part
by Anthony Hopkins himself, which certainly seems like a high seal of approval.
Moore’s portrayal of the character is significantly different than that of
Fosters, with the timid determination Foster gave to the character replaced
with a sense of vulnerability.
In the opening scene Starling is tasked with taking down Evelda Drumgo, played by Hazelle Goodman, in a drug raid that goes wrong. She is blamed for the botching of the drug raid, which ultimately take a toll on her mental state. This is further hindered as she is reintroduced to Hannibal Lecter after receiving a letter from her former acquaintance.
Moore only truly gets to embrace the character in the film’s final act, as the first two acts mostly centre on Giancarlo Giannini’s Rinaldo Pazzi and Lecter in Florence. By the time Starling becomes more central to the plot, Moore feels overshadowed by Hopkins’ ever-stunning performance.
The scenes which feature the pair often see her taking a back seat to Lecter, with Starling almost taking the part of damsel in distress. While Moore’s performance is certainly solid, the character she plays has a very apparent disconnect to that of Foster's.
6. Edward Norton As Will Graham
Edward Norton appears in 2002’s Red Dragon as former FBI
profiler Will Graham. It was Graham who initially caught Lecter back in 1980, an
event which caused him to retire from the FBI. During the events of the film, Harvey
Keitel’s Jack Crawford convinces him to help the FBI on the Tooth Fairy case,
and Graham often elicits the help of an incarcerated Lecter to assist.
Once you are able to move past the weird decision to bleach Norton’s hair blonde, it is clear that the actor marvellously carries the majority of scenes in which he appears. Norton is able to stand out in scenes with both Harvey Keitel’s Crawford and Anthony Hopkins’ Lecter, playing well off the strengths of these veteran actors.
Norton’s best scenes are when he is the only character, such as when Graham visits the crime scene at the Leeds family home. In this scene, Graham is mostly silent, experiencing the crime scene along with the audience, before monologuing to his recorder about the events. It's very tense with disturbing visuals and alarming audible cues.
You can see the emotion in Graham through Norton’s performance, conflicted by the need to do his job and stop the murders but also uncomfortable in the way he connects with killers like Lecter and Dolarhyde.
5. Giancarlo Giannini as Rinaldo Pazzi
Giancarlo Giannini appears in 2001’s Hannibal as Rinaldo Pazzi, a police detective in the city of Florence. He leads the majority of the film's first two acts as he unwittingly stumbles across Lecter, who is masquerading as a museum curator named ‘Dr. Fell’, and decides to take it upon himself to take down the serial killer for a reward of $1 million.
Giannini has numerous scenes with Hopkins. Lecter’s weird, creepy behaviour and tendency to be silent makes the scenes uncomfortable and Giannini is able to perfectly encapsulate the same awkwardness that the audience experiences in these scenes.
Perhaps Giannini’s best scene with Hopkins is when he goes to confront the cannibal in the museum while he is giving a talk. His awkward silence as Lecter proceeds to be creepily polite to him is again masterfully portrayed. The scene ultimately culminates in Pazzi being captured by the cannibal before being disembowelled and hung.
Giannini is also able to encapsulate the other aspects of Pazzi’s character, such as his nonchalant attitude towards Lecter when he is attempting to take him down. Scenes such as the phone call with Moore’s Clarice Starling, in which Pazzi pretends to be unaware of the serial killer, best encapsulate this.
4. Ted Levine As Jame Gumb/"Buffalo Bill"
Ted Levine appears in 1991’s The Silence of the Lambs as serial killer Jame Gumb, dubbed “Buffalo Bill” by the press. A former patient of Hannibal Lecter, Gumb believed himself to be transsexual but was denied sexual reassignment surgery due to his history of violence and years of trauma. This suppression of what he believes to be his identity eventually drove him to murder, as he hunted down and killed various women so he could use their skin for his “woman suit”.
Gumb’s cold and dehumanising treatment of Catherine Martin, portrayed by Brooke Smith, is honestly sickening to watch at times, especially during scenes where he simply refers to her as “It”. This is due to the authenticity of Levine’s performance, specifically in the emotionless mannerism he exhibits when he interacts with her and his lack of reaction to her emotions.
Levine’s best scene is where ‘Buffalo Bill’ is fantasising about himself in the mirror, doing his own makeup and wearing a victim's scalp. During this scene, Martin is able to use the scraps of food Gumb has provided her to lure his dog, Precious, into the well where she is being kept, all the while Gumb is absorbed in his fantasy, dancing to ‘Goodbye Horses’ by Q Lazzarus.
Gumb is totally unaware of anything happening around him. The way Levine portrays the self-obsessive mannerisms of the character here help make this scene so creepy, and really works to sell the audience on the character's mental state.
3. Jodie Foster as Clarice Starling
Jodie Foster appears in 1991’s The Silence of the Lambs as Clarice Starling, an FBI Trainee who is assigned to the incarcerated Hannibal Lecter with the task of probing him for insight and information on the Buffalo Bill case.
She bounces between interactions with the doctor, and working with Jack Crawford, portrayed here by Scott Glenn, in an attempt to catch ‘Buffalo Bill’. Foster is able to perfectly embody the role, at times showing the nervous and timid nature of an FBI Trainee while at others showing her confidence as she grows closer and closer with Lecter.
Her eerie nature perfectly plays off of Anthony Hopkins’ chilling performance as Hannibal during their scenes together. Foster is able to create a sense of disconnect from her emotions and fear of the cannibal, especially during their initial meeting. This shows to the audience Starling's way of attempting to prevent herself from falling into any of Lecter's psychological traps throughout the scene.
Starling eventually shows this fear in her confrontation with Gumb. As the pair are in the basement of Gumb’s house, he plunges them into darkness and proceeds to watch Starling with his night vision goggles. Foster portrays both the fear and determination that Starling feels here. It is Foster’s ability to masterfully display both of these emotions, at times simultaneously, which makes her character stand out among the cast.
2. Ralph Fiennes As Francis Dolarhyde/"The Tooth Fairy"
Ralph Fiennes appears in 2002’s Red Dragon as serial killer Francis Dolarhyde. He works as the production manager for a VHS Home Video Production Company and uses these tapes to case the houses of his victims.
He earned the
nickname ‘The Tooth Fairy’ from the press due to his tendency to bit his
victims. Fiennes essentially portrays two characters through the film, as Dolarhyde
has two distinct personalities: one quiet, timid and traumatised as a result
his abusive grandmother and the one of ‘The Great Red Dragon’ - his “reborn”
form which he believes the killings help him embody.
Dolarhyde has a variety of complex emotions which Fiennes is able to perfectly display. This ranges from the sick sense of pride he feels when showing images of his victims to Lounds, to the fear and pain he feels as he begs the Red Dragon painting to spare McClane, to the anger he feels towards Graham at the films climax as he is reminded of his painful childhood.
In all these situations, Fiennes makes the emotions believable to the audience, something which is especially notable in the scenes with the Red Dragon painting. Here, Fiennes is essentially carrying a conversation with nothingness in a way that accurately portrays to the audience the loss of reality in Dolarhyde’s mind.
1. Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter
Was it really going to be anyone else?
Anthony Hopkins first appeared as Hannibal Lecter in 1991’s The Silence of the Lambs, but reprised the role in both 2001’s Hannibal and 2002’s Red Dragon. Hopkins’ legendary portrayal of psychiatrist and serial killer Dr. Hannibal ‘the Cannibal’ Lecter brings a perfect balance of cold terror and chilling intelligence to life on the screen.
An obvious example of this is his introduction in ‘The Silence of the Lambs’ where he first meets Foster’s Clarice Starling. The way he, unlike the other inmates, is eerily stood in the centre of the room gives off an almost unnatural vibe to the audience, something which is carried on throughout the scene due to his discomforting politeness and excellent skill at reading the room.
Hopkins is able to transform from nonchalant to aggressive to violent in the blink of an eye, keeping the audience on the edge of their seats. Seeing this dark side to Lecter through Hopkins makes it all the more chilling to see him act so personably when interacting with characters like Giannini’s Rinaldo Pazzi in Hannibal and the dinner guests in the opening of Red Dragon. The achievement of the portrayal is enhanced, particularly in The Silence of the Lambs, by the use of extreme close ups of Hopkins’ face, filling the screen with nothing but pure intensity.
Lecter’s commanding presence and ability to know things before both the audience and other characters gives a sadistic sense power to the character. To Lecter, the events of the series aren’t much more than an elaborate game, and Hopkins certainly brings us all along for the ride.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Hannibal?