10 Best Comfort Horror Movies
"You're gonna suffer, but you're gonna be happy about it."
There is something undeniably comforting about giving your emotions over to another entity for a couple of hours, allowing yourself to feel the whole spectrum of emotions within the confines of a familiar fiction, before returning to the excitement or mundanity of your reality.
For some of us, this comes in the form of horror films, where we got to get our rocks off and be scared witless. Sure, there are demons and serial killers and creatures from outer space, but each of these hold in them the key to unlock feelings of familiarity, recognition and a sense of sanctuary.
Maybe the aesthetics are easy on the eyes they're pulling out, maybe the characters are super smooth and offer us some solace as they plunge to their deaths, or maybe there are themes that just resonate with us on a deeper, darker level. Whatever the symptom, these films are the cause. More than anything, we often crave the feeling of safety and control – even in our horror films – and these ten deliver the goods every single time.
10. The Beyond (1981)
Lucio Fulci's 1981 Italian-made The Beyond is not the most obvious choice for comfort horror, and yet something about the rhythm and unreality of it all makes it compelling and unchallenging viewing.
Liza Merril (Catriona MacColl) inherits an old hotel in New Orleans, with the intention of refurbishing and reopening it, not knowing a devotee of the dark arts was lynched there 50 years prior. The hotel sits on a gateway to Hell, and all manner of happenings befall her and her companions: Bleeding hands, tarantulas, eye gouging, spectral forces, and the resurrection of the dead – basically everything you need to make your new hotel project a home away from home.
Originally (and perhaps unfairly) branded as a video nasty - alongside some seriously grim features, such as Cannibal Holocaust (1980) and I Spit On Your Grave (1978) - The Beyond was made at a time when horror was still hoping and praying for the kind of budgets these films command today. Its scares are so crazy and OTT, and presented within such a scattered and improvisational plot, that they don't interrupt the rhythm of the film. In fact, it is so saturated in elementary gore effects that it all becomes part of the scenery; moving wallpaper for an easy evening of blood and guts.
9. Coraline (2009)
Neil Gaiman-penned dark fantasy horror Coraline (2009) is a no-brainer when it comes to comfort watching, never mind that there are button-eyed doppelgängers and that souls get stolen and that a malevolent creature in the guise of a little girl's mother tries to sew up her eyes and keep her in a netherworld forevermore...
Coraline (Dakota Fanning) discovers a secret door in her new home, behind which lies the Other World, a mirror dimension that, unlike similar fare in Stranger Things (2016–) or Us (2019), actually seems better than reality. The doppelgängers of her parents (voiced by Teri Hatcher and Jon Hodgman) have her feeling quite at home, until a plan is revealed to kidnap her real parents and try and keep her there indefinitely.
Stop-motion animation lends Coraline additional airs of familiarity, harking back to the Wallace & Gromit adventures of our youth; and creepiness, in the relative unreality of characters' movements and the way in which the form facilitates every kind of dark, Burtonesque vision. Nevertheless, the voice cast (which also includes Dawn French and Jennifer Saunders) root our minds in popular TV and cinema, allowing us to journey as deep as the rabbit hole goes without ever feeling out of our depth.
8. Army Of Darkness (1992)
Sam Raimi's Evil Dead (1981) began a tradition of schlocky, tongue-in-cheek horror filmmaking that used the acting, aesthetic and budget of B-movie films in a more crowd-pleasing, mainstream context – though the trilogy took decades to break free of its kooky cult status.
The first of the series is as straight up as a film can get while still being a Raimi joint, following a group of friends to a cabin in the woods where they encounter evil spirits summoned from the demonic text the Necronomicon. While it certainly packs in a few laughs and unexpectedly fun moments, it still has enough seriousness to be scary. Its successor, Evil Dead II (1987), built on this legacy while simultaneously smashing it down, retconning the first film and starting somewhat afresh with a more wacky tone that made the best of Bruce Campbell's comic sensibilities, even if it lacked in story.
The '90s offering of the trio, Army Of Darkness (1992), turned the comedy up to 11 and took the Chin back to the middle-ages, with a chainsaw, an Oldsmobile and a crazy plot that sees Lord Arthur take on the army of darkness in a battle for the future of the human race.
What the film lacks in production value, it makes up for in one-liners, callbacks and ridiculous, off-the-wall undead ass-kicking, and there's never a bad time to stick it on, kick back and get groovy all over again.
7. Beetlejuice (1988)
Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice!
No, nothing? Well, it was worth a try.
In Tim Burton's 1988 horror-comedy, Barbara (Geena Davis) and Adam Maitland (Alec Baldwin) die in a tragic car accident and find themselves haunting their former home, where the Deetzes (Catherine O'Hara and Jeffrey Jones) and their daughter Lydia (Winona Ryder) have taken up residence. The pair invoke the spirit of Beetlejuice (Michael Keaton), a stripy-suited bio-exorcist whose help is more than they bargained for.
There are few people this side of Antarctica who don't know the story of the spectral trickster, many of us having grown up with it or simply grown to love it – and with good reason. It's spooky, it's silly, and it's infinitely rewatchable, for Michael Keaton's career-defining role (take that, Batman/Birdman) if nothing else. Sure, it's not the scariest horror flick ever, but what it lacks in terror it makes up for in that warm fuzzy feeling it gives you every viewing.
However, although the movie is called Beetlejuice, the character only appears in 17 of its 92 minutes, leaving many of us wanting more. And, after over three decades in development hell, a sequel seems to finally be on the way, with Keaton and Ryder reprising their roles!
6. The Thing (1982)
Whether it's the horrific visuals of a shape-shifting extraterrestrial, the intense sense of claustrophobia, or the fact that pretty much everyone (and the dog) is dead by the film's conclusion, fewer films have been less obviously comforting than John Carpenter's The Thing.
Adapted from the John W Campbell Jr novella Who Goes There? (1938), The Thing tells the story of an American research team in Antarctica who encounter a parasitic alien that assimilates other organisms. Neither audiences nor critics took well to the 1982 body horror flick to begin with, condemning it as one of the worst films of all time. Nevertheless, it gradually found a foothold in the horror canon as a cult favourite, and in recent years has undergone a dramatic reappraisal and broken through to achieve mainstream appeal.
Perhaps it's the charisma of Kurt Russell (as helicopter pilot RJ McReady), or the familiarity of plot and characters that comes with repeat viewings and a deep penetration of pop culture, but most likely the film fills us with a warm glow because of the nostalgia factor. The rejuvenated appeal of the 1980s to contemporary audiences is apparent in the enduring demand for synth-laden, neon-coloured films and such hugely popular TV as Stranger Things.
Whatever the reason, we're thankful The Thing is there to turn to when we need it.
5. Zombieland (2009)
Woody Harrelson and Jesse Eisenberg star as an unlikely duo of survivors who must navigate the new world, post-zombie-apocalypse, while trying to save the damsels in distress, trying not to kill Bill Murray, and trying to overcome their hatreds of uncleanliness and clowns. Not exactly a guaranteed winner for the next big zombie movie, but something about Zombieland really hit home.
As a result, Ruben Fleischer had us all on the back foot in 2009 with his debut feature -- an improbable 88-minute zombie-horror-comedy flick – but it made bank at the box office, spawned its own sequel and helped popularise a genre-bending shift in cinema alongside such contemporaries as Matthew Vaughn's Kick-Ass (2010).
Be that as it may, many of us would have expected it to be a flash in the pan. Alas, it is still as strong as ever, and arguably gets better with every watch. The combination of the road trip format, the tangible chemistry between its four leads (with Emma Stone and Abigail Breslin rounding out the squad) and the pervasive zombie threat just work. Despite the blood, guts and tear-jerking backstories of heartbreak and loss, Fleischer's is a world that's so easy and enjoyable to return to, it has us wishing against our better interests that we could go there for real.
4. Gremlins (1984)
Anyone who says Die Hard (1989) is the greatest Christmas movie ever made has clearly never seen Gremlins (1984).
Joe Dante's monster flick sees Billy Peltzer (Zach Galligan) get the greatest Christmas gift a boy could ever ask for: the Mogwai Gizmo; a creature so memorable, so original, so downright cute it even had a band named after it. Sure, Gizmo's a furry little monster with supernatural origins, but everything will be fine so long as Billy follows the rules and doesn't feed him after midnight, doesn't get him wet, and doesn't expose him to sunlight.
Needless to say, he somehow manages all of the above, and soon Gizmo is sprouting vicious little clones who turn green and scaly and homicidal all over Kingston Falls.
Perhaps it's the seasonal setting that makes it so easy on the eyes, but there's something about Gremlins – in spite of the yuckiness and gore – that makes it candy for the brain. Whatever the case, this is a unique horror film that manages a careful balancing act between cute as hell and simply hellish, leaving us wanting more – and you know what, despite its flaws, 1990's Gremlins 2 delivered.
3. Shaun Of The Dead (2004)
Take car, go to mum's, kill Phil, grab Liz, go to the Winchester, have a nice cold pint, and wait for all of this to blow over. Or, you know, just stick on Shaun Of The Dead (2004). Whichever's easier.
The first of the big mainstream horror comedies, Shaun Of The Dead took director Edgar Wright's love of '70s and '80s horror (particularly the films of George Romero) and reanimated it for the 21st century.
Morose salesman Shaun (Simon Pegg) is just going through the motions, until one day his whole life is upended by the onslaught of the zombie apocalypse. Accompanied his best friend Ed (Nick Frost), he must navigate the undead-ridden gardens, alleyways, corner stores and flats of their North-London borough in order to get to the pub and, well, wait for things to blow over.
Featuring a splattering of authentically scary moments, and a few jump scares, Shaun Of The Dead brings little England to the afterlife and gives us a heady dose of everything we know and love about Britain, with a bonkers pop culture spin. It's got romance, it's got action, and it's got Queen. Plus, it has a pretty happy ending for a zombie movie – even if Ed is technically no longer with us.
2. Scream (1996)
Scream (1996) is the movie that rejuvenated the slasher genre, defined horror for a generation of fans, and ushered in the kind of meta humour that has permeated popular cinema over the past 20-odd years.
In case you've forgotten, Neve Campbell plays Sidney Prescott, a high schooler with a dead mother and a deadbeat boyfriend, who is the target of the new killer on the block, Ghostface. Teaming up with David Arquette's police officer Dewey and Courtney Cox's hack journalist Gale Weathers, Sidney foils the killer's – or, as it turns out, killers' – plans and returns peace to the leafy suburb of Woodsboro.
While Scream has lost none of its appeal in the 26 years since its release – something evidenced by the numerous sequels and TV show – it is no longer the scariest thing since sliced brains. What once was edgy and extreme is now horror comfort food, taking us back time and again to Woodsboro High, where the fun is plentiful, the characters are familiar and pretty much everyone who matters is safe (especially Dewey).
1. The Cabin In The Woods (2011)
Buffy alumni Drew Goddard and Joss Whedon's The Cabin In The Woods (2011) assembled a killer cast comprising Whedon regulars and horror and sci-fi big-hitters, such as Sigourney Weaver, Amy Acker, Fran Kranz and Chris Hemsworth, to fight off every kind of evil imaginable.
A group of young friends go on a break to a remote cabin, where they encounter all manner of strange objects, unseasonable weather and creepy entities. Turns out, they're the next sacrifice in a scheme of manufactured scares designed to appease the Ancient Ones, a race of godlike beings who slumber beneath the earth's surface, requiring ritual sacrifices every year to keep them chipper.
Capitalising on the audience's knowledge of the horror canon, the film draws on influences as diverse as Hellraiser, American Werewolf In London and The Evil Dead in order to assemble the meta horror to end all meta horrors, all wrapped within the eternal horror trope of the titular isolated cabin in the woods. It's got demonic puzzle cubes, zombie hillbillies, mermen and even an evil unicorn. Basically everything you need for a good night in.
Something about the familiarity of the film's terrors makes an endearing and comforting watch, opening us a window behind the blood and guts, where we can watch in safety as the world tears itself apart. And good riddance to it.