10 Best Disappointing Movies Ever

Don't believe the hype... entirely.

Rey BB-8 Star Wars Force Awakens
Disney

There are times when filmmakers are faced with an impossible task - living up to expectations that simply cannot be met.

This happens all the time in Hollywood and when it does, it doesn't necessarily mean the movie was terrible, or even bad for that matter.

Often it's a case of the hype machine kicking into overdrive in the run-up to release, raising the bar higher as launch day draws near, until it's out of reach entirely.

This is common when the movie in question is a follow-up to a much-loved classic or a the next entry in a fan-favourite series, but there are times when studios do themselves no favours by overselling the end product.

Of course, some over-hyped films flop hard because they're just plain average - Star Wars: The Phantom Menace and The Matrix Revolutions are two high-profile examples that spring to mind - yet just as frequently such films turn out perfectly well, but couldn't possibly meet the lofty standards they were set.

10. On Her Majesty's Secret Service

On Her Majesty's Secret Service Tracy Death
MGM

When the great Sean Connery stepped away from the James Bond series after You Only Live Twice, the studio's decision to replace him with an Australian model who was best known for advertising Fry's chocolate was met with widespread derision.

So it came as little surprise that George Lazenby's sole 007 outing, On Her Majesty's Secret Service, was savaged by fans and critics upon release.

Although nobody realised it at the time, Lazenby's Bond was a breath of fresh air for the series and it's only crime was being two decades ahead of its time.

On Her Majesty's Secret Service introduced us to a more vulnerable 007, with human fears and emotions, who becomes disillusioned with his secret agent career after the woman he loves is gunned down by his enemies.

Does this remind you of a certain casino frequented by Daniel Craig?

When the concept of a more human Bond was tabled years later, the world was ready for it, but On Her Majesty's Secret Service was simply too bold for 1969.

Sure, Lazenby is no Connery (who is?) but his sole 007 mission has a flavour all of its own and should be celebrated for daring to deviate.


9. The Dark Knight Rises

Batman The Dark Knight Rises
Warner Bros.

Christopher Nolan did himself out of critical acclaim with the outstanding Dark Knight, a masterclass in comic book adaptation that no sequel could possibly live up to.

Nolan did a lot of things right with its follow-up, The Dark Knight Rises, which boldly reconstructed heroism by introducing us to a fallible, battle-weary Caped Crusader against seemingly insurmountable odds.

There were a few missteps along the way, like putting a charisma-sapping muzzle on Tom Hardy, revealing the main villain too late in the game and the occasional plot hole, but Rises was a solid sign-off from Nolan.

By the end of the film, he reinforced the concept of Batman as an enduring symbol and took the series full circle in satisfactory fashion.

The only problem was, satisfactory wasn't good enough for the Caped Crusader in a post-Dark Knight world.


8. Prometheus

Prometheus Giftbearer
Fox

Ridley Scott will have learned a great deal from the way Prometheus went down.

The fans wanted an Alien prequel, and when he dared make something daring and original, all hell broke lose and the box office takings failed to stack up.

We're not for one second claiming Prometheus is a perfect movie, but it has some significant positives that are often overlooked.

By introducing us to the Engineers, an extraterrestrial master race who created humanity in the Alien universe, Scott sparked intelligent discussion around a weighty question - where did we come from?

For all of the film's faults, it did encourage cinemagoers to take a moment to ponder this matter, and that alone makes it better and more ambitious than most blockbusters.

Plus Michael Fassbender is just fantastic as the mechanically menacing David.

Much of Prometheus' problems lie in the way the film was marketed in the run-up to release. We can't blame fans for wanting their Alien prequels to have actual aliens (the kind that burst from their victim's chest) in them.

And while it asked all of the right questions, it failed to provide any answers.


7. Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Star Wars trio rey poe finn force awakens
Lucasfilm

How can a movie made by mere mortals live up to the hype a galaxy far, far away generated during its heyday? The short answer is it can't.

Is Star Wars: The Force Awakens a great film? Absolutely - it mended the galactic fences damaged by George Lucas's reviled prequel trilogy, won back scores of fans and caught a generation of new ones in its tractor beam.

The trouble is, nothing in the cosmos will ever be considered equal to A New Hope and Empire Strikes back, no matter how well it pays homage to their formula.

JJ Abrams played in safe with The Force Awakens, bringing us an old-school Star Wars film that doesn't skimp on thrills or fan service, but that didn't quite suffice.

Star Wars is more than a line of movies to its most ardent fans. It's a freaking religion, and when something is considered so sacred there's no living up to the hype.


6. Watchmen

Watchmen  The Comedian Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Warner Bros.

Zack Snyder's Watchmen ended up being the movie equivalent of Marmite, but it was the best possible adaptation of the revered source material we could have hoped for.

Snyder was loyal to Alan Moore's graphic novel to a fault, right up until he wasn't.

Many hardcore fans could never forgive the director for deviating from the source material right at the end, but let's be honest, that giant alien squid thing would have looked rubbish on screen, and its appearance would have marked a jarring tonal shift towards all-out sci-fi-fantasy.

Some things work well on the page, but not so well on cinema, and Snyder made the right call for the medium he was working in.

Deviations aside, Watchmen was a dark, unique entry to the superhero genre that came as close as humanly possible to meeting its lofty expectations.


5. Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome

Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome
Warner Bros

Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome is a curious beast - some fans and critics would have you believe it's the pinnacle of the series, while others rank it firmly at the bottom.

The first two instalments and the more recent Fury Road received widespread acclaim but the Road Warrior's third outing has a tendency to polarise.

It's unfair that Thunderdome goes down as an off day for Max Rockatansky because it was another gratifying romp through the post-apocalyptic outback.

The Bartertown sequences are memorable, the Thunderdome fight scenes are unforgettable and the vehicular action lived up to that of its predecessors.

Thunderdome would arguably have been as well received as the other Mad Max films if it had omitted that irritating gang of kids. Oh, and Mel Gibson's weird mullet too.


4. Pacific Rim

Pacific Rim Kaiju
Warner Bros.

There's nothing particularly wrong with Pacific Rim. It's a solid creature feature that was buried beneath the weight of the hype generated by its epic trailers.

Guillermo Del Toro promised us a Goliath new IP in a world of sequels and reboots - giant monsters versus screen-filling robots? Who wasn't sold there and then?

When Pacific Rim finally arrived, people complained it wasn't the earth-shatteringly original experience it was hyped up to be, but it was a good movie with an unabashed sense of fun and some neat special effects.

Sure, there's things were prioritised over characterisation, but there's a place in Hollywood for Kaijus and Jaegers kicking the snot out of each other.


3. The Godfather Part III

The Godfather Part III Al Pacino
Paramount Pictures

The Godfather Part III is easily the lowest point in the gangster trilogy, but it was assassinated by expectation alone.

The game-changing original arrived in 1972 and it's revered sequel followed in '74, but the third chapter didn't land until well over a decade later in 1990, and the hype spiraled out of control during the gap years.

In truth, the third Godfather is far from terrible. There are terrible things about it, sure - like Sofia Coppola's performance - but there are also positives to pick out.

Al Pacino brings as much gravitas as ever to the role of Michael Corleone and the film's theme of corruption within the Vatican is perhaps even more relevant today.

Another criticism of The Godfather Part III is its inability to stand alone, and while that remains true, it works well enough as a footnote to the series if you can resist comparisons to its superior predecessors.


2. Return To Oz

Return To Oz Jack
Buena Vista

The Wizard's dark, misunderstood sibling got a bad rap from critics when it arrived in 1985 and is considered a source of embarrassment for Disney, but Return To Oz was nothing to be ashamed of.

Cheery optimism and catchy songs were replaced by nightmarish visuals and all-round weirdness in this eerie sequel of sorts, which simply wasn't what audiences were expecting.

But Return To Oz should be lauded for its faithful adaptation of the original L. Frank Baum novels, not to mention its creative creature design and resistance of Disneyfication.

It's a spectacle everyone should see. Well, maybe not young children because those Wheelers are sure to give them nightmares for weeks.


1. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

The Hobbit An Unexpected Journey Gollum Bilbo Baggins Martin Freeman Andy Serkis
Warner Bros. Pictures

Here's the problem with The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, and the entire trilogy for that matter - Peter Jackson attempted to adapt it on the same scale as his Lord of the Rings movies, but the source material is not in the same league.

The Hobbit is a wafer-then children's book beside the epic tome that is LOTR, and Jackson's efforts to pad the story to fill three films created pacing issues - an unexpectedly sluggish journey from the off.

Bilbo's adventure should have been two films tops, but that doesn't mean there isn't a lot of enjoyment to be found in An Unexpected Journey.

Had the Lord of the Rings movie trilogy never existed and this was Jackson's starting point, it would have been celebrated for its dizzying set pieces, spectacular effects and faithful recreation of classic literary characters.

Admittedly, those effects had barely moved on since Lord of the Rings, but if you can silence your inner cynic, The Hobbit is more fun that it ever was disappointing.


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw