10 Best Films With Unreliable Narrators
Every story depends on view of the person telling it.
The Unreliable Narrator is a literary tool whereby the story is told from the point of view of a person whose credibility has been seriously compromised. This can be for any number of reasons, including them being insane, exaggerating, joking, naïve, lying or deluded. The viewer is then left to decide how much of the narrator’s story is true or just their opinion.
Although the term wasn’t coined until the 1960s, the technique has been used from a much earlier time, often by characters who are trying to justify why they have done something bad, making it a great device for crime and mystery stories. Edgar Allan Poe’s The Tell-Tale Heart is a classic example where the anonymous narrator tries to convince the reader of his sanity, while also describing how he committed the perfect murder. He provides a rational explanation for his irrational actions, allowing the reader to sympathise and empathise with him.
Most films that use unreliable narrators tend to climax in a twist where you realise that you have been taken in by a biased view of events. This is often accompanied by the narrator realising that they have been mistaken, especially if the unreliability has stemmed from a mental illness.
Here are ten films where we were intentionally or unintentionally misled by the storyteller (warning - spoilers!).
10. Gone Girl (2014)
Gone Girl steps up the unreliability of the narrator by having two characters telling conflicting stories of the events of the film. The narration in the film switches between wife Amy and husband Nick. Amy’s narration is compromised as she is creating a story to cover her tracks. Nick’s narration is also unreliable, as he’s hiding the fact that he is having an affair, as if found out, this would further suspicions that he murdered his missing wife. Amy’s diary also appears to tell a third story, and Amy admits to fabricating the contents to further confuse the plot.
Each character presents themselves as the good party. In the first half of the film we are told Nick’s side of the story, and we believe that he didn’t kill Amy, but then we get to find out that Amy is still alive and framing Nick for her murder in retaliation for him cheating on her. The story of Gone Girl appears to be presented with the purpose of the characters both fighting for the viewer to take their side in the conflict, and each of them shows repeatedly that they are not above being deceitful in order to achieve this aim.
9. Memento (2000)
Narrator Leonard Shelby has no short-term memory since he and his wife were attacked in their home and his wife was killed. In order to enable the viewer to experience the story in the same way as he does, the movie is told in reverse order, allowing us to piece together bits of the story in the same timeframe as he does.
The film does an excellent job of making it nearly impossible to tell which characters are helping Leonard and which are using him or have ill intentions towards him. Even the ‘facts’ that he supposedly finds out are often shown to be flawed as they have been manipulated by other people.
The story is often frustrating to watch when we see Leonard realise when someone is using him but they are aware of his condition so engineer the situation so he cannot record what he has learned. Natalie is especially good at this, removing all writing materials before she starts to insult Leonard’s wife, knowing that he will forget what she has said by the time she next sees him.
Teddy is the one who informs Leonard that he was the one who accidentally killed his own wife, but even this is not confirmed to be absolutely true, and could just be another manipulation by a man who has admitted he has been using Leonard. It also appears Leonard is aware enough to repress painful memories, preferring to live in ignorance.
8. Life of Pi (2012)
‘Pi’ Patel tells his story to a writer who wants to write a book about his life. He describes how, as a boy, he was on a ship that capsized with many animals from his family zoo. He managed to survive by boarding a lifeboat with a zebra, an orangutan, a hyena and an angry tiger named Richard Parker.
The hyena kills the zebra and orangutan before it is killed by the tiger. There are many other events that happen during his voyage that seem to stretch the limits of believability. The relationship Pi develops with the tiger is especially interesting as it seems unfeasible that it would leave him alive when so starved of food. They eventually make it to shore before Richard Parker wanders off into the jungle, with Pi sad that he didn’t even look back as he walked away, further anthropomorphising the animal.
Pi is brought to a hospital where he tells insurance investigators a different story where he is on the boat with his mother, a sailor and a cook, all who end up meeting grisly fates. The implication is that Pi has created the story with the animals as a more pleasant to what actually happened. The writer and the viewers are left to decide which story is the truth.
7. Forrest Gump (1994)
Forrest Gump is a slightly different unreliable narrator, in that the viewer is not being deceived by him, merely told stories that they already know but from a different perspective. A lot of the fun of the movie comes from trying to work out what events he is describing when his understanding of them is often naïve or biased.
He is apparently involved in several key occurrences in American history, and he often deals with some serious issues such as war, child abuse and HIV. His misunderstanding of Jenny’s relationship with her father and the subsequent path that her abuse leads her down is particularly heart-breaking. His unwavering belief that Jenny always has his best interests at heart is also quite hard to watch, as is his sadness when she dies.
Forrest generally has a rose-tinted view of the world, however, and little touches like him investing in the ‘fruit company’ Apple and teaching Elvis to dance are nice because he doesn’t realise the magnitude of what is happening. Other events are questionable, such as his run across America, which seems to be physically impossible, but we gladly suspend our belief because of the feel-good nature of the story.
6. The Usual Suspects (1995)
Con-man Roger ‘Verbal’ Kint is presented as the viewpoint character through whose eyes we are seeing the story of the events that led up to a massacre and fire on a ship after a drug heist. He recounts his version of what happened during an interview with US Customs Agent Kujan, where he presents himself as very much a side character, involved with a group of criminals led by a Turkish crime lord called Keyser Söze.
As the viewer, we are essentially in the same position as Kujan as we find out the details of the story as Kint is relaying them. There is no hint throughout the flashbacks in the film that he is anything other than what he says until he is released on bail and we realise, along with the agent, that the whole story has been an elaborate lie and Kint is in fact Keyser Söze.
The film makes good use of voiceovers, which help to unravel the jumps in timeline and also have the effect of separating events into presumable reality, with scenes containing Agent Kujan, and possible fiction, with sections told by Kint.
5. Shutter Island (2010)
Shutter Island is told from the point of view of U.S. Marshall Teddy Daniels, who is sent to Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane on Shutter Island with new partner Chuck to investigate the disappearance of a patient called Rachel. He confides in Chuck that he believes the facility is conducting illegal experiments on the patients, so this gave him an opportunity to examine this too.
Teddy starts to have nightmares and hallucinations of his time working as a soldier on a concentration camp and of an arsonist called Andrew Laeddis, who killed Teddy’s wife. He also starts to witness unusual occurrences and people acting strangely around him, furthering his conspiracy theory that there is something nefarious going on at the facility.
When we are finally presented with the truth, that Teddy is Andrew Laeddis, a violent patient who killed his wife after she drowned their three children, we start to understand and empathise with his mental state. He has repressed the memory of this as well as the trauma of the concentration camp, and the doctors were trying to let him play out his fantasy to try and bring him back to reality.
He ends up choosing to let the doctors lobotomize him, as it would be too painful to live as a ‘monster’, choosing instead to ‘die as a good man’ by essentially killing off his personality and memories as Andrew.
4. Identity (2003)
Intriguingly, on second viewing, the title sequence of Identity gives away the twist in several ways. A child’s drawing is shown with a boy, his mother and several stick men, and the doctor is even recorded as asking serial killer Malcolm who he is speaking to. The ambiguous timeline doesn’t hide that Malcolm is the murderer, but the motel story is presented as a flashback, recounting murders that he committed in the past.
It is easy to assume John Cusack’s Ed is the narrator and is telling the tale of a simple murder mystery involving ten strangers trapped in a rainstorm. The story is so well crafted that even when the shocking identity of Malcolm is revealed, showing that all the characters are his multiple personalities, it is still a further surprise when young Timmy is exposed as the monstrous homicidal part of him that the doctors have been trying to destroy.
Malcolm has no idea that his other personalities existed, making him the ultimate unreliable narrator as he is not only the protagonist, but also unknowingly the antagonist. The doctors’ treatment to get him to ‘reduce’ the other personalities succeeds, but ultimately fails when the one remaining psychopathic personality takes over completely after terminating all the others, removing Malcolm’s last trace of morality.
3. Fight Club (1999)
Edward Norton’s narrator in Fight Club is never named, and is given few redeeming qualities, meaning that it proves difficult for the viewer to empathise with him. We watch him almost pitifully as he deals with his unfulfilling life and infiltrates support groups to gain some kind of meaningful human interaction in his life.
This only serves to emphasise how believable it is that he would be attracted to handsome, charming Tyler Durden. He is enticed by Durden’s rejection of commercialisation and enhanced masculinity. His acceptance of chaos and the lure of being part of a bigger organisation is one that soon entices others into his world.
We get to live vicariously through his activities, and he becomes more relatable the deeper he is sucked into the darkness of Durden’s fantasies, showing that we are all susceptible to wanting to belong and conversely wanting to change the world.
The narrator’s final realisation that Durden is part of his dissociative identity disorder is as much as shock to him as the viewer, leaving you wondering how much of the film happened, as you are shown a smattering of scenes as they really occurred, but others are left to the imagination.
2. American Psycho (2000)
Patrick Bateman’s narration of his life and activities is essentially a confession, which is echoed throughout the movie. He repeatedly tries to confess his ‘crimes’ to different people, all who believe his claims to be unbelievable and outlandish, often leading to their demise. The viewer is similarly asked if they can accept what he is doing, despite the stories becoming more and more disturbing and gruesome.
A perfectionist misogynist, who is essentially emotionless and self-centred, his victims are either colleagues who challenge his status, or nameless people from the lower classes, who he views as disposable after he has had his fun with them. The fact that these people are tramps or prostitutes mean it is very difficult to prove whether their murders actually happened or if they were all in Bateman’s mind.
His narration never waivers from giving the impression that he is anything other than desirable, with men and women alike all attracted to him. When he is told that the first man he murdered is still alive, you join him in trying to work out whether he managed to get away with everything or if none of it was real in the first place.
1. The Sixth Sense (1999)
It is easy to forget how ground-breaking the twist in The Sixth Sense was, as it is now so well-known. Following his attack, we are never shown protagonist Malcolm recovering or having any kind of interaction with his wife, but we accept this as our mind makes sense of the gaps in the best way that it can. Malcolm simply believes that his relationship with his wife has drifted apart, and because we are only shown glimpses of his time with her, we do not question this. If we were to see an entire day with the couple it may have become more obvious what was happening, but we can accept that a meal or a shared moment in their living room could justifiably occur without talking.
Cole does not do anything to further raise our suspicions, as he simply converses with Malcolm as you would expect a patient to talk to his doctor. It is only when the twist is revealed that you realise no one else has spoken to Malcolm in the film and because the story has always been told from his point of view you are never given the opportunity to see anything odd. We assume that the way Cole perceives Malcolm is the same as everyone else does, when if we had been shown the perspective of other characters, Cole’s behaviour would have revealed the twist instantly.