10 Best Horror Movie Performances Nobody Talks About

These brilliant performances in horror movies deserve more love than they got.

Megan Fox Till Death
Screen Media Films

When an actor gives their absolute all to a role, it can truly elevate a film and cement both the character and person playing them into the pop culture lexicon. This is no different in horror, with greats such as Linda Blair and Robert Englund being of near legendary status. More recently, actors such as Toni Collette in Hereditary, Daniel Kaluuya in Get Out and Elizabeth Moss in The Invisible Man have transcended the genre and been lauded for their acting chops in their own right.

But as is often the case with horror as a whole, many performances get overlooked. Even by horror hounds, some truly fantastic characters have been cast aside in favour of more familiar faces. This list aims to rectify that by shining a spotlight on some truly standout roles that have been cast aside.

These actors brought something truly unique to their roles, whether in little indie gems or well renowned flicks that simply gloss over their roles due to the film itself being the icon rather than the actor. You may see some familiar faces, but in a role that you’d never even heard of, and you may meet some completely new characters along the way. Regardless, these horror performances deserve a hell of a lot more attention.

10. Juan Fernández As The Collector - The Collector Series

The Collector 2009
Freestyle Releasing

The world of horror in 2009 was in a funny place. Remakes of classic horror films and subpar Westernised interpretations of predominantly East Asian cinema were dime a dozen, not to mention the wave of so-called ‘torture porn’. Naturally, audiences were getting a little fed up.

Arguably, The Collector, was part of this stagnant sludge of ‘scares’. It is a home invasion, torture-trap-filled story about a petty thief trapped in a house with a masked killer. Sounds pretty generic, but the titular villain is utterly spinechilling.

The Collector himself is an unnamed force of malice, with no motivation or reason behind his acts of violence. This is what makes him so terrifying, and the viewer isn’t even sure if he’s actually human or some kind of monstrous entity. Little details, such as his reflective cat-like eyes and silent movements make him all the more eerie. Combining the intelligence of John Kramer, the ghostly ambiguity of Michael Myers and just pure nastiness, Juan Fernández casts a truly terrifying figure.

If The Collector had been released at a different time, there’s no doubt that this killer would be a slasher icon. However, the subsequent sequels remove the mystery around him and make him feel more human – which does undermine how frightening he is.


9. Duane Jones As Ben - Night Of The Living Dead

Night Of The Living Dead Ben
Continental Distributing

How is anything to do with George A. Romero’s utter classic underrated, your writer hears you howl? Gimme a minute and I’ll tell you.

The film is undoubtedly a legend, and to an extent, so is Duane Jones’ performance as Ben. However, when the character is discussed, it is often in regards to the social commentary of both his role and casting. This overlooks the performance itself and the ability of Jones as an actor.

Jones brings a sense of calm to the chaos of the film, making the viewer feel assured whenever he is on screen. Ben is resourceful, authoritative and is always trying to ensure the survival of his companions. The audience trust him, and would want a guy like him on their team in the event of a zombie apocalypse.

Played with genuine warmth that makes Ben feel real, Jones created a new type of hero but never fully reached the legendary status of the film he starred in. Whilst the whole movie is a masterpiece in terror, the character of Ben deserves to be a face and name that people instantly recognise and love.


8. Isabelle Adjani As Anna/Helen - Possession

Possession 1981
Gaumont

Andrzej Żuławski’s bleak depiction of a crumbling marriage from 1981 is underrated as a whole. It’s deeply depressing, truly frightening and very, very weird. Doppelgangers and tentacles are arguably the least bizarre part of this whole movie.

At the centre of the film, married couple Anna and Mark are in serious need of couples counselling. Anna is distant and wants a divorce, having several affairs behind Mark’s back. But Isabelle Adjani’s performance is so much more than that. With her wild eyes and throat-shredding screams, she jerks across the screen and thrashes through the story. She is almost animalistic, snarling and spitting blood whilst maiming herself and others around her. Simply put, she is a terrifying force of nature.

Then, as if one incredible performance wasn’t enough, she also plays Anna’s doppelganger Helen. There is something about Helen that gets under the viewer’s skin, in a way that is far more subdued than Anna. Mastering the uncanny valley effect, Adjani is genuinely terrifying to watch in two vastly different ways. This demonstrates her skill, even if you’re watching through your fingers.

The ‘subway scene’ in particular highlights Adjani’s embodied performance; her body contorting and thrashing with those wide eyes boring out into the dingy surroundings. Like an Argento witch and the seething mania of Annie Wilkes combined, this horror performance deserves far more attention and will utterly terrify whoever sees it.


7. Deborah Kerr As Miss Giddens - The Innocents

The Innocents
20th Century Fox

An icon of the Golden Age of Hollywood, Deborah Kerr turned in her arguably best performance in 1961’s The Innocents. Based on The Turning of the Screw, the film follows a woman who becomes convinced that the children under her care are possessed. Or are they?

The film toys with the viewer, never fully committing to any set truth. In fact, we are watching the events unfold through Kerr’s Miss Giddens, and so we begin to question her own sanity. Countless interpretations of the film have sprung up over the years, but none of them are answered. This is due in part to Kerr’s performance.

Playing Miss Giddens with the same ambiguity at the centre of the entire film, she leaves you guessing every time a ghost is seen. Is she going mad, or are they really there? The nuances within Kerr’s performance do not provide any answers, and in fact raise more questions.

It’s a multi-layered and riveting performance that continues to intrigue to this day, and the simultaneously pitiful and suspicious Miss Giddens is part of the reasoning.


6. Kwak Do-Wan As Jong-goo - The Wailing

The Wailing
Fox

You think you know horror tropes like exorcisms, mysterious diseases, and isolated locations. Watch The Wailing, and it will show you a completely new and deeply disturbing take on them. It is much more than that, telling a complex tale of loneliness, grief, and obsession.

At the heart of the horrific happenings is Jong-Goo, a policeman and father who is desperately uncover the truth whilst protecting his family. It is another fairly well trodden trope within horror cinema, but actor Kwak Do-Wan reels the audience in with an understated performance that slowly builds as the hysteria around him does.

He acts as you or I would in this situation, demonstrating his flaws as much as his attempts at heroism. Jong-goo is just an ordinary man trying to do the right thing and help people, and Do-Wan makes his struggle so bloody believable. It’s a very clever, subtle performance that taps into wider human issues of prejudice and paranoia without ever losing sight of the deeply personal elements that make up the character as a whole.

For a supernatural horror film, the humanity brought by Kwak Do-Wan grounds it in an uncomfortably close reality.


5. Megan Fox As Emma - Till Death

Till Death Megan Fox
Screen Media Films

Megan Fox deserved so much better and has done for years. It’s therefore wonderful to see her take on roles that allow her to show off her talent and stand as an actor in her own right. We all know she absolutely killed it in Jennifer’s Body, but the more recent Till Death shows she’s still got skin in the horror game.

Playing Emma, a woman trapped in an unhappy marriage, Fox turns what could easily have been another final girl into a ferocious and complex heroine. The home invasion plot is simple enough, but Emma isn’t a cookie-cutter damsel in distress. She’s resourceful and bloody brutal when she fights back against her attackers. She’s a woman pushed to the absolute edge by various sh*tty men, and the audience cheers her on as she manages to survive all of them.

It isn’t a simple ‘good for her, what a girlboss’ film, as Fox’s performance clearly demonstrates how harrowing the experience is and the toll it takes on her. It’s a victory at the end, sure, but the viewer is just as exhausted as the protagonist at the end due to how Fox is able to make her character empathetic. If you’re after a good slasher movie with a well-realised heroine, then Megan Fox has got you in this film.


4. Bill Mosely As Chop Top Sawyer - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2

Chop Top Texas Chainsaw
Cannon Films

To call Bill Moseley an underrated horror legend is an understatement. Featuring in Repo! The Genetic Opera, Prisoners of the Ghostland, Evil Bong, Tom Savini’s Night of the Living Dead and genuinely countless others. Most well known for his role as the despicable Otis B. Driftwood in Rob Zombie’s Firefly Trilogy, there is one role that Moseley absolutely shines in.

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 is a very different film from the legendary one that preceded it nearly a decade prior. Taking a far more comical approach to the terrifying Sawyer family we met in Texas, we are shown more of their zany dynamics and members. This includes Chop Top, the brother of the Hitchhiker in the first film. Moseley plays this demented character with an infectious glee, only to switch to a terrifying menace in a heartbeat with no prior warning. You can tell he’s having an absolute blast as the character, hamming up all sorts of little quirks and cringe-inducing grossness.

Whilst TCM2 is certainly a cult classic, and Chop Top is a beloved character within those circles, Moseley’s entire career could be featured on this list. Otis Driftwood might be a terrifying villain, but Moseley as Chop Top is a true delight to watch and you are never bored once when he is on-screen. Dog will hunt, indeed.


3. Mark Duplass As Josef - Creep

Creep 2014
Blumhouse Productions

Found footage is hard to get right, but 2014’s psychological nightmare proved it can be done brilliantly. But more impressive than the success of the film’s style is the utterly chilling villain, Josef.

Mark Duplass, who co-wrote the film with director and co-star Patrick Brice, plays a man who gets in contact with a struggling videographer. Josef has an inoperable brain tumour and wants the other to record a video diary of sorts for his unborn baby as he will die before the child is born. It’s obvious from the start that Josef is a bit eccentric… but he’s harmless, right?

The film doesn’t waste a lot of time with ambiguity, as Josef’s behaviour becomes more and more bizarre and disturbing. Duplass gives a fascinating performance, combining deep discomfort and disarming charisma with a slightly eerie smile. When the sh*t hits the fan, the breadcrumbs laid by Duplass throughout the film suddenly make sense and make your blood run cold. You know what’s coming, and you know that Josef is to be feared, but this works to the film’s advantage.

Duplass lets the audience try to figure Josef out for themselves, using little titbits of information and visual cues. It’s a gripping character study despite its apparently simple premise, and some scenes (aka anything to do with Peachfuzz) will be cemented into your brain.


2. Sean Harris As Philip Connell - Possum

Sean Harris Possum 2018
BFI Film Fund/Dark Sky Films

Everything about this 2018 psychological horror film is underrated. From the bleak setting to the Freudian influences to the utterly horrific puppet from which the film gets it’s name. Perhaps most underrated of all is already underappreciated actor Sean Harris’s performance as Philip.

Philip was a children’s puppeteer who was fired for unexplained reasons and later returned to his childhood home. Only living with his uncle, Maurice, a clearly unpleasant and vile individual, Philip tries to rid himself of a puppet known as Possum but continuously fails to do so. The puppet and film as a whole reads as a metaphor for trauma, and Harris is devastatingly sad in his role. Philip is so lonely in his world that he appears almost ghostlike, his only interactions with other human beings being ones of scorn and mistrust. Harris makes him pathetic, childlike and an embodiment of the desaturated and miserable world around him without ever straying into melodrama.

Yet for all the sympathy drawn from the audience, Harris still manages to make the audience unsure about Philip. Is he the reason why there is a missing boy in his hometown, and why was he fired? There are unsettling implications peppered throughout the film that suggest why, and they are equally as believable as Philip’s visions of the puppet. That’s the real magic of Harris’ performance: displaying a fragmented psyche in a way that is so delicate it could shatter at the slightest touch, but it never does – all we see is a broken and vulnerable man.


1. Bruce Campbell As Robert Van Helsing - Sundown: The Vampire In Retreat

Bruce Campbell Van Helsing
Vestron Productions

Even in an underrated role, he’s still the king and therefore gets the number one spot.

In this horror-comedy-vampire-Western (yes, all those genres do indeed come together here), Bruce Campbell plays a descendent of Van Helsing from the Dracula tale. However he is plonked into a brewing civil war between two vampire factions residing in a sleepy desert town: one that only drinks artificial blood, and the other wanting to return to their natural state of, well, feasting and maiming.

Playing Van Helsing as a well-intentioned but misguided and hopelessly over-his-head young man with the weight of destiny on his shoulders, Campbell owns every single scene he’s in. With classic Campbell physical comedy adding to the comedic script, he brings slapstick hilarity to a film that’s already brilliantly outlandish. And this is only made more fun to watch when Van Helsing himself is turned into a vampire; the scene where he awakes to find himself a new member of the undead is absolute magic to watch.

Arguably (your writer is going to sound like a heathen here), all of Bruce Campbell’s roles are underrated in comparison to the towering impact of Ash Williams, but this role shows that he can bring a different kind of charm to an entirely new role. Unlike the brash Ash, Van Helsing is an earnest and bumbling sweetheart that reminds you of that hopelessly inept co-worker that everyone has a fondness for just because they’re so dang adorable. Look at him, he’s trying his best!

The film as a whole is campy horror at it’s best, and reminds us all that Bruce Campbell is just a bloody joy to watch in whatever he’s in.


Watch Next


Contributor

Tilly Owen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.