10 Best Horror Movie Scream Queens
Slashers, murderers and monsters be damned, they're the SURVIVORS...
Ever since Fay Wray screamed at the sight of King Kong way back in 1933, the horror genre's scream queen has been an iconic figure in cinema history.
From Psycho's Janet Leigh to her own daughter Halloween's Jamie Lee Curtis, the scream queen's role may have ranged from unfortunate victim to resilient final girl, but the archetype's importance in the genre has always remained.
A horror isn't a horror without a leading lady to scream up a storm, outside of a small handful of exceptions (The Thing and Session Nine come to mind, but maybe there are a future WhatCulture list's worth of genre subverting flicks which feature no women in their scary stories).
So today's list is here to honour the best of horror’s leading women, from the original damsels in distress through to the tough final girls of the slasher golden age, right up to the subversive heroines of more modern horror.
Some are esteemed actors who got their start in the genre, some stayed in the critically derided but audience-adored hallowed halls of horror throughout their careers, but each of these exceptional stars has more than earned the title of scream queen in their terrifying tenure onscreen.
10. Jamie Lee Curtis
Starting off our list, it's the leading lady who truly deserves the top spot, but who's here at number ten solely because savvy readers knew her presence was inevitable on a list like this and there's a little suspense required in these run-downs.
The greatest to ever do it, horror heroine and iconic scream queen Jamie Lee Curtis was not only born to play the role of final girl as the daughter of Psycho’s unfortunate shower-er Janet Leigh, but even starred in Ryan Murphy’s self-referential horror comedy Scream Queens in 2015.
The tremendously talented actor is more than a horror icon, but an iconic run of starring roles during the early eighties' slasher boom including Halloween, The Fog, Prom Night, Terror Train, Roadgames, and Halloween II ensured her a place in cinema history.
That's without even mentioning the likes of Halloween H20 and Virus in the late nineties (which, to be fair, not many people do), and the more recent rebooted Halloween trilogy from Pineapple Express helmer David Gordon Green.
9. Barbara Steele
The original and one of the greats, it'll take a short trip into the earlier history of horror to ground the importance of Barbara Steele's contributions, but it's worth the blast from the past.
This British actor’s storied career may have spanned many genres, but her contribution to scream queen history is undeniable thanks to her roles in many iconic exploitation films of the sixties such as (deep breath) Black Sunday, The Pit and Pendulum, The Horrible Dr Hitchcock, The Long Hair of Death, Castle of Blood, Nightmare Castle, Terror-Creatures from the Grave…
And that’s just one decade of her CV, too.
Steele's work in Black Sunday saw her play the tragic villainess of the gory gothic horror from giallo icon Mario Bava, opening up the possibilities available to leading ladies who until now had been largely confined to the role of victim number one in the countless films aping Hitchcock's dark thriller stylings. With Steele's unforgettable witch came new agency for scream queens, not to mention a terrifying face for onscreen horror history.
8. Lili Taylor
Okay so this character actor is probably better known for her many superb performances in countless critically acclaimed hits, both comedic and dramatic, throughout her last few decades onscreen.
Taylor's impressive work in everything from Robert Altman's Short Cuts to American Psycho director Mary Harron's stark biographical drama I Shot Andy Warhol have ensured her a lot of praise as a dramatic performer, whereas the lighter likes of Mystic Pizza and Tamara Drewe director Stephen Frears' superb rom com High Fidelity showed off her comedic chops.
But yes, believe it or not this critically acclaimed indie actor does more than qualify for the title of scream queen.
Between 1999's laughable Jan DeBont-directed remakeThe Haunting, 2013's terrifying The Conjuring, 2020's killer kid mystery Eli, and the Texas Chainsaw Massacre prequel Leatherface, the actor has made it her mission to ensure her later career is filled with genre efforts and is building up a pretty impressive reputation as a horror heroine (and villainess) in the process.
7. Sarah Michelle Gellar
Now, any readers born before the year 2000 most likely already know why Buffy the Vampire Slayer herself is listed on here.
But outside of her outsized contribution to television horror as the snarky, resilient heroine of the iconic cult hit, it’s worth remembering that far from resting on her laurels, Scooby Doo star Sarah Michelle Gellar cemented her place in horror history via movie stardom too.
And no, not just by playing the role of former damsel in distress turned action heroine Daphne to perfection, though props are due to her for that too.
It's Gellar's roles in classic nineties slashers I Know What You Did Last Summer and Scream 2, not to mention playing the heroine of 2004’s surprisingly solid J-horror redo The Grudge, that cement her place in screen history as an iconic scream queen. After all, her (spoilers) harrowing deaths in the first two flicks mentioned there made it clear that if Buffy herself couldn't make it out alive, no one was safe.
6. Neve Campbell
Scream series heroine Neve Campbell hasn’t actually spent as much time in the horror genre as many fans assume.
Instead, the actor's quirky career saw her parlay the newfound teen stardom she enjoyed from Last House on the Left director Wes Craven's teen horror Scream and TV series Party of Fave and use it to quickly branch out and shoot more interesting indie films like Panic, The Company, and… er, Wild Things.
But whilst the actor has enjoyed an impressively varied screen career in the decades since her first breakout role, it's the work she did as an edgier, more relatable final girl which remains her most iconic role.
Between classic nineties teen horror The Craft and her signature part as the Scream series' witty, razor-sharp heroine Sidney Prescott, she’s more than earned a place in the annals of horror history even without that rumoured starring role in the upcoming fifth instalment from the directors of last year's horror comedy sleeper hit Ready or Not.
5. Taissa Farmiga
The most recent addition to this list, the younger sister of The Conjuring star Vera Farmiga has more than earned a place here as her brief but well-stocked screen career has seen her work over time to nab the title of twenty first century scream queen.
In the decade or so she has spent onscreen, Farmiga has impressed in countless genre hits. Her work in small screen horror ranges in tone from Glee co-creator Ryan Murphy's inconsistent American Horror Story, to Get Out director Jordan Peele's recent The Twilight Zone reboot, to... Well, flopped streaming service Quibi's 50 States of Fright, but everyone makes mistakes.
Meanwhile on the big screen Farmiga has been no slouch, starring in everything from 2015's warm-hearted horror comedy slasher spoof The Final Girls, to the austere, gothic Shirley Jackson adaptation We Have Always Lived in the Castle, to The Conjuring spin-off The Nun.
Again, everyone makes mistakes RE that last one.
4. Barbara Crampton
No list like this would be complete with some stars from the eighties.
The halcyon heyday of both hack 'em up slashers and inventively gruesome horror comedies, the eighties saw a generation of scream queens fall victim to mute masked murderers and surreal special effects monstrosities depending on the sub genre of the latest flick were starring in.
From Beyond starlet Barbara Crampton was a recurring presence in more offbeat and gory sci-fi horrors such as the aforementioned Lovecraft adaptation, its predecessor Re-Animator, 1986's Chopping Mall, and the original 1989 Puppet Master.
After starting in her career in the eighties with this impressive string of cult hits, Crampton then managed the feat of creating a career which spanned not one but two generations of horror movies.
The horror heroine returned to scream up a storm in the 2010’s with 2011's You’re Next, 2013's The Lords of Salem, 2015's We Are Still Here, 2015's Tales of Halloween, 2016's Beyond the Gates, and many more.
3. Katie Cassidy
She may be a pivotal part of the Arrowverse now, but Black Canary herself Katie Cassidy cut her teeth on the likes of 2006’s When a Stranger Calls remake, the same year’s Black Christmas remake, the 2010 Nightmare on Elm Street remake (noticing a pattern here?), as well as TV’s Harper’s Island.
She may have since become better known as an action heroine, but Cassidy's early roles saw her embody every one of the classic horror archetypes.
She was the goody-two-shoes final girl's bitchy blonde best friend in Con Air helmer Simon West's crazy disappointing When A Stranger Calls re-do, the bait-and-switch fake-out final girl who turns out to get brutally offed early in the film in 2010's A Nightmare on Elm Street remake, and the resilient heroic final girl who survives the night in 2006's critically derided Black Christmas re-imagining.
It's in the third of these which stands out on her crowded CV as Cassidy's performance is one of very few highlights in the Weinstein-butchered slasher remake disowned by Final Destination mastermind Glen Morgan.
2. Adrienne Barbeau
Almost out-doing her The Fog co-star Jamie Lee Curtis, eighties horror icon Adrienne Barbeau's career boasts a string of classic horrors which few of her contemporary equivalents can hope to compete with.
The hardy heroine impressed in everything from Halloween helmer John Carpenter’s The Fog, to Night of the Living Dead director George A Romero’s anthology horror Creepshow, to A Nightmare on Elm Street creator Wes Craven’s Swamp Thing in the early eighties.
Marginally older than many of the genre's leading ladies at the time, Barbeau is best remembered for playing a more mature brand of final girl than the ingenues most viewers were expecting from the latest slasher.
And that's not to mention the actor's later career renaissance in the more underrated horror comedy likes of 1998's cartoon classic kid's horror adventure Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island and 1989's silly satire Cannibal Women in the Avocado Jungle of Death.
1. Mary Elizabeth Winstead
This is, admittedly, a potentially controversial pick for the number one spot, given that this actor was barely even alive let alone acting for the heyday of the slasher film.
But consider this...
Starting her onscreen career as she meant to go on with a minor role in 2005's The Ring Two, future Birds of Prey heroine Mary Elizabeth Winstead soon came to prominence via a string of starring roles in horror films ranging from 2006’s risible aforementioned Black Christmas remake, Pulp Fiction director Tarantino’s Grindhouse instalment Death Proof, and the third entry into the Final Destination franchise.
Now this one year stint in the genre would have earned her a place in the scream queen pantheon alone, even if she did move on to many more serious dramatic roles.
But Winstead's return to the genre via 2011’s underrated The Thing remake, a villainous role in the 2014 psychological thriller Faults, a love interest part in the aptly-titled horror comedy Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, AND another horror heroine part in 10 Cloverfield Lane?
Iconic.