10 Best Picture Oscar Winners That Aged Terribly

Just try watching these with a straight face in 2017.

Forrest Gump Ice Cream
Paramount Pictures

It’s nearly Oscar time again, and you know what that means: it’s time for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to completely bungle their assessment of what the best films of last year were...

No awards ceremony has made quite as many blunders when it comes to assessing the best examples of the art that they are supposed to judge. Somehow the Oscar voters manage to repeatedly allow themselves to be tricked into voting for the hackiest, pandering, and cliché films on the ballot.

To really assess how wrong they can get it, you only need to rewatch some of their selections and see if they are timeless, or whether they feel ridiculous from a 2017 vantage point. While some flicks like Casablanca and Schindler’s List are still as relevant and fresh today, more often than they'd probably care to admit, the Academy’s choices look more ludicrous with each year that passes.

These are ten of the films that have aged the worst since they won the big prize. But they are far from the only guilty parties.

10. American Beauty (1999)

American Beauty
DreamWorks Pictures

American Beauty is in no way a bad film. It was the first film directed by Sam Mendes after a career in the theatre, and it's clear that the director put a huge amount of work into it. Similarly, writer Alan Ball put a lot of his personal experiences and views into the script over the better part of a decade, and that care is apparent on the screen.

But was American Beauty, the Lolita-esque film about a rich middle-aged man creepily grooming his teenage daughter's best friend to have sex with him, really the best film of 1999? Of course, it wasn't. It sure wasn’t the worst (that would be Wild, Wild, West), but it’s such a unique product of its time, it’s hard to imagine anyone being particularly sympathetic to Lester Burnham in 2017.

The film resonated so well with critics and Academy Award judges in 1999 because it was well crafted, and because it had legitimately funny pitch black humour in abundance – which was a novelty at the time. Most importantly, though, all the narratives and themes in the film resonated with privileged, white, middle-aged males. You'll recognise that as the exact demographic that makes up basically the entire Academy Awards voting bloc, and in 1999, the vast majority of the film criticism industry.

Due in no small part to its creepy sexism, fragile masculinity, and profoundly nostalgic views, a critical backlash has emerged in the ensuing years. Even Sam Mendes has stated that he thinks the film was ‘over-praised’ when it came out.

It still might look gorgeous, but it sure feels a whole more shallow than it once did.


9. Chicago (2002)

Chicago Catherine Zeta Jones
Miramax

What was going through the Academy's mind when they picked this one as the best picture of 2002? Admittedly, 2002 was not a stellar year for the motion picture industry, but this vacant, indulgent, and empty musical adaptation directed by Rob Marshall might even outdo Braveheart and Crash for inexplicable Academy Award decisions.

Plenty of viewers and film fans were eagerly watching the awards in anticipation that Martin Scorcese might finally win the best director nod, for Gangs of New York. Now that film certainly didn’t deserve to win (it’s easily one of his worst), but in comparison to the vacant eye candy that Catherine Zeta-Jones and Renee Zellweger fronted that year, Gangs felt like it was the Magnificent Ambersons of the early 21st century.

All that aside, though, why has it aged poorly? Well, it now feels very dated because of its own legacy. Since Chicago was so successful, the film helped kickstart a new wave of big screen musical adaptations as filmmakers became desperate to recapture the kudos and awards that the film reaped.

This has, unfortunately, lead to such filmic horrors as Gerard Butler as the Phantom of the Opera, Johnny Depp attempting to sing in Sweenye Todd, a Rock of Ages movie with Tom Cruise, a Mamma Mia movie, and possibly the worst adaptation of Rent imaginable.

Musicals are now so common, and most of the time so bad, that any freshness or originality that might have been present when Chicago debuted, has long vanished under the crippling weight of further awful broadway adaptations.

Today, Chicago feels like just another crappy musical in an overcrowded market of even crappier musicals (La La Land aside, OBVIOUSLY).


8. Braveheart (1995)

Mel Gibson Braveheart
Paramount/20th Century Fox

Mel Gibson’s historically flexible 1995 smash, Braveheart, has aged so badly that it has become a shorthand for the incompetence of Academy voters to evaluate the worth of cinematic properties. Named the Worst Best Picture by Empire magazine, Braveheart might not necessarily be the absolute worst of the best (that would be A Beautiful Mind), but it’s hardly a serious piece of filmmaking.

Today, Braveheart is essentially a fun, cheesy, enjoyable romp. In fact, it now looks like a parody of a historical epic; if characters in a film were watching a film or a sitcom, it undoubtedly would look like Braveheart.

With its incredibly contrived set pieces, and its woefully misguided love story (complete with awkward and uncomfortable sex scenes) it’s hard to imagine how a bonkers movie like Braveheart could be taken seriously in 1995, let alone today. It is so stylistically of its time that it could have had Steven Seagal or Jean-Claude Van Damme, and it probably wouldn’t lose any gravitas.

While scholars might have their problems with the treatment of the historical subjects in the film, that’s doesn’t even really matter in terms of why it has not stood the test of time. It’s dated simply because it’s classic 90s action, trying to be something far more serious.


7. Rain Man (1988)

Dustin Hoffman Cards Rain Man
United Artists

The Best Picture of 1988, Rain Man, is a bit different to the other films on this list. Rain Man is a good film that has aged poorly, due to increasing medical knowledge, and social understanding of a condition we now know is quite common.

For those unfamiliar, Dustin Hoffman plays Ray Babbitt, a man who has the condition Savant Syndrome, which is a disorder related to the autism spectrum. Essentially, Babbitt is a superpowered genius, who is seriously hampered by his condition’s negative features. He is confined to an institution until the younger brother he didn't know he had, played by Tom Cruise, shows up and they go on a Road Trip doing all kinds of neat tricks.

The film feels dated now because our understanding of spectrum disorders has expanded so massively in the past thirty years. In 1988 spectrum disorders were largely still a mystery to most people, so the film was kind of groundbreaking. It was really the first film to feature a leading character with a disorder like this.

However, most spectrum disorders aren’t like Savant syndrome, which is presented in the film as a kind of superpower. Audiences today are much more aware of spectrum disorders, and almost everyone knows that the vast majority don’t manifest themselves like this.

You only have to look at the lukewarm reaction that the producers of the film The Accountant had last year when that film used autism as a sort of superpower. The film wasn’t completely savaged, but Ben Affleck’s autistic killer led to a significant amount of eye rolling.

Rain Man is a good film, but it is a text from another medical era. The fact that it does feel like it has aged poorly is only something to celebrate.


6. The Sound Of Music (1965)

The Sound of Music
20th Century Fox

This is one of those movies that people hold incredibly dear to their hearts, as demonstrated by its cult following. That makes sense because a lot of people watch this as a kid. But if you do love this movie, then try and watch it with fresh, objective eyes. If you do, what you’ll find is that is an interminably long, tedious, and insufferably saccharine film that has not aged well.

The Sound of Music has aged poorly because it sits in an odd place chronologically. It belongs to a style of musical film that was already feeling obsolete by 1965 when it was released. In the 1960s Hollywood was in the midst of a revolution in filmmaking. Iconic films such as Bonnie and Clyde and Easy Rider tore up the filmmaking playbook in the latter half of the decade. But even by 1965, the decade had seen the likes of Psycho, Dr Strangelove, and Italian maestro Federico Fellini’s 8½.

These films would be the films that shaped the tone and style of filmmaking through to the present day. They would destroy the Hays code, and lead to an overhaul of the rating system for movies. That's why you can watch the Graduate, released only two years after The Sound of Music, and it feels sincere and fresh.

The Sound of Music, conversely, missed that sea change, and that’s why it feels so overwhelmingly ridiculous. Unlike some of the better films (and even musicals) of that era, it now only exists as a channel for soppy nostalgia, or for those looking for irony.

If your film is mainly used as a punchline, like the Sound of Music is, then it demonstrably hasn’t stood the test of time.


5. Forrest Gump (1994)

Forrest Gump Kurt Russell
Paramount Pictures

Well, the comments section is about to light up. So let’s just state things as plainly as possible. Forrest Gump is not a good movie. For a lot of reasons. But most importantly for the sake of this article, it couldn’t be any more stuck in the era in which it was made. (Fair warning: this entry discusses history and politics.)

Forrest Gump is a product of a 1990s America, where white baby boomers were on top of the world, and so was the USA. The economy was strong, the military was feared, and all those pesky minority groups seemed to have shut up for the time being. Forrest Gump is the self-congratulatory, hypocrisy justifying, baby boomer fairy tale, that America embraced like a warm hug on a cold day.

It doesn’t take a scholar to see that the main message of Forrest Gump is that order should not be challenged, and you should just do what you are told. By just following orders unquestioningly, Forrest stumbles through life until he becomes a transcendently successful person.

In contrast, the characters around him can be truly awful, particularly if they are protestors, and especially if they are female. Compared to Forrest, protestors are violent, achieve no change, live in conflict, and in the case of Jenny, are literally killed because of promiscuity. The message couldn’t be more explicit if this was porn.

After 9/11, two failed wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the Global Financial Crisis, Black Lives Matter, ISIS, and the election of Donald Trump, do you think a feel good myth about following the rules and celebrating the myth of the American Dream would resonate? Of course not.

In 2017, Forrest Gump is quite simply ludicrous.


4. Chariots Of Fire (1981)

Chariots Of Fire
20th Century Fox

Chariots of Fire is not a badly shot film, by any means. It’s well acted, and the cinematography makes it really feel like you’re watching 1924. Additionally, it deals with some pretty heavy themes in a very subtle way - which not a lot of recent Academy Award winners can say they have done.

However, it can’t be denied that the film feels like it’s about four hours long, and it’s almost overwhelmingly boring in parts. It’s pompous, and nostalgic, which is problematic. But what’s truly strange is that while the subject matter could lend itself to gripping, tense, exciting filmmaking, Chariots is most famous for slowing things down.

Additionally, Chariots is also another one of those films whose modern relevance has been somewhat undermined by its own success. Its famous score and famous racing sequence are both so entrenched in the public psyche, thanks to three decades of pop culture referencing, that the magic has well and truly worn off both these elements.

Now, that's not the fault of the filmmakers. It's just an unfortunate thing that happens when your art is so self-serious, that it becomes ripe for parody.

But the damage has been done. Thirty-five years of taking the mick out of its most famous elements have made the film feel like something of a tedious, and pompous joke that doesn't live up to the hype.


3. How Green Was My Valley? (1941)

How Green Was My Valley
20th Century Fox

If you haven’t heard of How Green Was My Valley (HGWMV), then don’t worry. It’s a movie that only really exists in our consciousness today as the answer to a particularly difficult pub quiz question. That question being ‘what film inexplicably beat out Citizen Kane for the Best Picture award in 1941’?

HGWMV was a perfectly fine John Ford film of an earlier era. But that’s part of the problem – it feels incredibly old-fashioned film in every single way. Even by 1941 standards, HGWMV was filmed in a style that was becoming tired. The acting is theatrical, the sets are theatrical, the direction is theatrical, and it is lousy with John Ford’s sentimentality.

It’s like something grandparents watch while muttering about how today’s filmmakers are all just interested in sex and violence.

Unfortunately, what makes it feel really dated though is the inescapable knowledge that Citizen Kane was made at the same time. Cinema might have still been a relatively young industry in 1941, but its evolution had been impressively efficient.

By the time HGWMV was released, audiences were already familiar with the tropes, images, and narratives on the big screen. In contrast, presented a turning point in cinema that would challenge both audiences, and filmmakers alike until the present day. The timelessness of the two films really cannot be any starker because of this.

If HGWMV wasn’t competing alongside Citizen Kane, it might not feel like so anachronistic, and terribly ancient. But it did, and because of that, it’s impossible today to see it as anything other than a generic old film, that is thoroughly undeserving of its award.


2. Crash (2004)

Crash Thandie Newton
Lionsgate

Unlike a lot of the other entries on the list, Crash has aged woefully, not so much because of massive social changes, but because it’s just a pretty bad film. It is the only other film that comes up as often as Braveheart does in discussions around what is the ‘worst best picture’, which makes sense. Because much like Braveheart, Crash feels like a parody of a film, rather than the real thing.

In the same way that Braveheart feels like a film within a film, Crash is so crushingly heavy-handed in its dealing with issues of race that you have to assume it’s taking the mick.

The narrative absurdity is one thing – but its discussions of race feel like they come from a film being produced in the late 1960s, by white people that had only just figured out that racism might be a bad thing. It’s so obvious and clunky that it feels like repeatedly getting hit in the face with a sign that says ‘racism is bad!’

Crash is emblematic of an era where Academy Awards voters were at their easiest to manipulate with over the top sentiment, and images that felt profound, but were anything other. It feels like a civics lesson from a dumber and more ignorant time, that has much less to say about the issues of race in America than it thinks it does.

When you compare it to some of the more recent films that deal with race as a complex and multifaceted issue (like Selma, and 12 Years a Slave, for example) it feels uncomfortably out of touch, and naïve.


1. Driving Miss Daisy (1989)

Driving Miss Daisy
Warner Bros.

Driving Miss Daisy suffers from many of the same problems that Crash does. However, because it’s a period piece, and because it’s from almost thirty years ago, it somehow feels like it has aged even more terribly than Crash has.

If you haven’t seen Driving Miss Daisy (and if you haven’t you really do not need to) it’s the story of a cranky old woman named Miss Daisy, played by Jessica Tandy. She is pretty racist, but her son then hires an African-American driver named Hoke (played by Morgan Freeman) to cart her around. Despite their differences, the two become friends, and through the magic of cinema, racism is solved. Again, it’s hamfisted, ridiculously naïve, and woefully misguided.

To say that this film has aged poorly is the biggest possible understatement because the film felt like an anachronism even in 1989. Part of the reason it was so glaringly dated was because earlier in the year Spike Lee had released Do the Right Thing - his blockbusting and profoundly original take on American race relations.

Much like Citizen Kane was everything that HGWMV wasn’t, Lee’s film was revolutionary compared to Miss Daisy. Do the Right Thing was bold, aggressive, challenging, exciting, and it asked chillingly relevant questions.

There is a reason why, nearly thirty years after it’s release, nobody talks about Driving Miss Daisy. And there is a reason why Do the Right Thing is still studied on university courses, and name-dropped by people like Barack Obama. Driving Miss Daisy speaks to those who believe in a romantic past that never existed, and who do not want to challenge their preconceptions of race. That’s not reality, and that doesn’t resonate in 2017.

Because of that, no Best Picture winner has aged quite as terribly as this snoozefest.


Contributor
Contributor

Contributor for WhatCulture across the board, and professional student. Sports obsessed. Movie nerd. Wrestling tragic. Historical junkie. I have only loved three things my entire life: my family, Batman, and the All Blacks.