10 Best Sherlock Holmes Film Adaptations
More than 70 actors have played the sleuth in over 200 films.

10. Nicol Williamson

9. Christopher Plummer
While most portrayals of Sherlock Holmes see the man as a cold and distant intellectual, Christopher Plummer turns that trope on its head, resulting in one of the most emotional and human versions of the detective seen on film. Plummer played Holmes in two movies, first in Silver Blaze (1977), and then in Murder by Decree (1979). In the latter film, Holmes investigates murders by Jack the Ripper, and at one point he even breaks down and weeps after being unable to save a woman, which might be the only time that the detective has teared up on camera. Another refreshing change in Murder by Decree is the fact that Holmes companion, Dr. John H. Watson (played by James Mason), is a true friend and intellectual equal to Holmes, and not just a dim-witted sidekick. Rather than being stereotyped caricatures, both Holmes and Watson are likable, real people, which is a nice change from many other versions of the duo.
8. Ian Richardson
Before the British stage actor Ian Richardson became famous as Francis Urquhart in the original House of Cards, he played Sherlock Holmes in two TV movies from 1983: The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Sign of Four. The casts in both movies were mainly British, although there was a clear American influence as producers wanted a more international draw for the Baker Street detective. The want for an American draw resulted in Richardson having to suggest corrections to the script and dialogue on multiple occasions, which ended up hurting the overall quality of the films. Overall, Richardsons portrayal of Holmes was praised by critics and audiences, as he made the detective a pacing, enthusiastic leader. Years later, from 2000 to 2001, Richardson played Dr. Joseph Bell, who was the mentor of Arthur Conan Doyle. The short-lived TV series, Murder Rooms: Mysteries of the Real Sherlock Holmes, had Dr. Bell and Arthur Conan Doyle investigating original mysteries together.
7. Robert Stephens
Robert Stephens played the infamous consulting detective in the 1970 film The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes. The film was directed and produced by Billy Wilder, and was originally set to be a 165-minute epic with an intermission, though it was eventually whittled down to 125 minutes in length. Since the film was directed by comedy film legend Billy Wilder, The Private Life was ostensibly a comedy, and Stephens version of Holmes was seen as wildly unconventional, irreverent, and funny. Some critics believed he deserved an Oscar nod for his witty take on Holmes. Also, some have pointed to Stephens portrayal of Holmes as an important influence on the new BBC series, Sherlock.
6. Ronald Howard
Ronald Howard played the sleuth for 39 episodes in the TV series, Sherlock Holmes, from 1954 until 1955. In the show, Howard plays a young, fit, and very active Holmes, which is a sharp deviation from typical versions of the character. He is approachable and affable, and an altogether more comfortable detective who always catches the bad guy in under 30 minutes. The show was geared a bit towards kids, which meant it had more comedy and action than other Sherlocks, and less complex intrigue. With a likable lead hero and an intelligent Watson as his partner, the show became quite a hit in the mid-50s, and it still retains a 7.9 rating on IMDb. Though the series was for an English audience, it was actually filmed in France, and was in black and white.
5. Vasily Livanov
Vasily Livanov is a Russian actor whose greatest success came when he played Sherlock Holmes in the 1970s and '80s for Russian TV. Many cinematographers have called Livanov the best Sherlock Holmes ever, and all eight TV movies where he has portrayed the sleuth are highly rated and acclaimed. The daughter of Arthur Conan Doyle, Jean Conan Doyle, once commented that her father would have approved of Livanov as Holmes, and he is the only Holmes to have ever become an Honorary Member of the Order of the British Empire for his work. In 2007, a sculpture featuring Holmes and Watson as portrayed by Vasily Livanov and his co-worker Vitaly Solomin was opened alongside the Embassy of the United Kingdom in Moscow. Livanovs Holmes is known for his deep, resonant voice, his cool demeanor and eccentric behavior, and for his subtle relationship with Vitaly Solomins Dr. Watson.
4. Peter Cushing

3. Basil Rathbone
For many, Basil Rathbone and one other actor are the quintessential Sherlock Holmes. Rathbone made 14 Sherlock movies between 1939 and 1946, and was the definitive Holmes during World War II. When looking back, many of the films had a distinctively odd feel because of the time period, with Holmes and Watson chasing Nazis around the world and such. Nonetheless, Rathbone created the deerstalker and cape look, and his performance in the 1939 version of Hound of the Baskervilles was a benchmark and foundation for all actors who followed in his footsteps. Rathbones Holmes was humane, gentlemanly, and even charming. Rathbone also played Sherlock over 200 times on the radio.2. Benedict Cumberbatch
Some people might be angry that the most modern form of Sherlock Holmes is not in the #1 spot, given how good Benedict Cumberbatch plays the sleuth. Cumberbatchs masterful portrayal of Holmes has made him a household name and an international star. The show Sherlock is one of BBCs most anticipated, highly-watched and acclaimed shows of all time. The show is set in the modern age, and therefore technology often takes a front seat when solving the mysteries. One of the reason why Arthur Conan Doyles Holmes is so endearing is because of his paradoxical qualities. Benedict Cumberbatch fully encapsulates those qualities: hes cold, calculating, and socially inept. He has a highly addictive personality, plenty of black moods, is constantly bored with life and people, and is viciously intolerant. He is a tormented superhero. Even with his eccentricities, the modern-day slant of Sherlock pays lip service to the original consulting detective: nicotine patches replace the pipe, a long coat replaces the deerstalker image, and Watson blogs about his cases rather than narrating them in books. The show has created a whole new way to look at Holmes, over 100 years after his creation, as the series is full of modern, tech savvy things such as GPS, texting, and on-screen graphics.
1. Jeremy Brett
Jeremy Brett is the most oft-cited person when the question is asked, Whos the quintessential Sherlock Holmes? As such, he is the best-suited person to top this list. You just cant beat the original, and Brett was the whole package. He was an actor of immense talent, and he was the spitting image of Conan Doyles Holmes. Brett played Holmes 41 times over 10 years, from 1984 to 1994. He was bipolar, which made his sudden heightened mannerisms, manic thought, and wit truly convincing. He was the most believable Holmes, completely embodying the role. He became so obsessed with the character that he took his method acting to extreme limits, often playing the character off-screen. His dedication, in part, contributed to his untimely death in 1995, but he will always be remembered as the consummate Sherlock Holmes.