10 Best Westerns NOT Set In The Old West

Why aren't more Westerns set in space?

Wind River Jeremy Renner Elizabeth Olsen
Lionsgate

What is a Western? We all know the obvious ones, from Siergo Leone's Dollars Trilogy and Clint Eastwod's Unforgiven, but what actually constitutes a Western? Well, for one thing, they're usually set in the mid-to-late 19th century and focus on a number of key themes: there's a lone, nomadic gunslinger with a hidden past; a violent bad guy with whom the protagonist shares a history; a lawman or two intent on catching said bad guy (and maybe even the protagonist); and a murder or an ill-fated duel.

These are the things you picture - the films made famous in the fifties, sixties and seventies made by John Wayne, John Ford and Eastwood. But Westerns aren't bound solely to this format. Some take the themes, shake 'em up slightly, and plonk the action somewhere wholly unexpected, like a different country, an entirely different planet or, more commonly, a different era.

The films on this list are all Westerns. Many incorporate a wide range of genres and themes, but all carry the fundamentals of the Western genre, be it the characters, the plot, the setting, even the clothes. So strap in and hold on tight as we take a ride across the frontier of the very best non-Western Westerns.

Spoilers follow for each entry.

10. 7 Women

7 Women John Ford
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

When talking about Westerns, John Ford is bound to come up. He gave us Stagecoach, The Searchers and The Man who Shot Liberty Valance, but one of his most overlooked and impressive pictures is that of 1966's 7 Women. The film was the last the great director ever completed before he passed away, and in it he managed to incorporate all we know and love about the Western genre and turn it on its head.

Set in 1935, the film follows a doctor (Anne Bancroft) as she ventures to a mission in the remote rural plains of China. Hoping to help the women stationed there, who have been abandoned by the authorities, Bancroft comes face to face with prejudice, politics, violence and death, and must aid the mission as it comes under attack from a Mongolian bandit clan.

It's a Western away from America, and yet the whole thing sort of fits. Populating the proceedings with a predominately female cast in a genre which typically sees men take the lead, Ford packed into the film a wide range of social commentary - including discussions into religious intolerance - and some truly compelling performances.

It's got gunfights, it's got the outcast, and it's got the feel of a small film subtly looking at the big picture; the ways of society, the roles of women, and the changing landscape of a country still growing. And it's one hell of a footnote in an illustrious, unforgettable career.


9. Rango

Rango Movie
Paramount Pictures

The joy of Rango is that it's set (technically) in the Old West. Or, rather, a "town" inhabited by animals who are marred by bandits, a large conspiracy and dire times. Directed by Gore Verbinski and starring the never funnier Johnny Depp as the titular chameleon, Rango was released in 2011 and remains one of Hollywood's most enjoyable and unique family animations.

Rango is a pet chameleon who spends his days wishing he could be the hero of a grand story. After his owners' fail to notice he has fallen from their car, Rango comes across a drought-ridden town in desperate need for help. Claiming to be a hero after accidentally killing a hawk, he becomes the town sheriff and works to help out the locals with their water and bandit problems.

As a film, it's predictable in its overall plot, but thanks to some great voice work (Depp, Isla Fisher and Bill Nighy), unique setting and impressive animation, Rango is great. It's also got some pretty splendid shout-outs to the idea of the Western hero, and a great caricature of Clint Eastwood voiced by Timothy Olyphant.

For the family, it's crazy levels of funny and stylish. As a Western, it's a respectful and brilliantly self-aware satire.


8. The Rover

The Rover Robert Pattinson
Roadshow Films

The Rover is brilliant. For anyone still questioning Robert Pattinson's acting ability, look no further than this. As a whole, the plot of this film is very simple; a classic Western piece with some key details changed to make it more accessible to modern viewers. With this also comes two phenomenal performances - Pattinson and Guy Pearce - and some fantastic set pieces.

Set in the near future when lawlessness rules and civilisation has mostly crippled, a loner called Eric (Pearce) has his car stolen and sets out to get it back. Tagging along (though not too happy about it) is Rey (Pattinson), a wounded member of the gang who stole the vehicle. Pair this seriously dysfunctional duo with the landscape of the Australian Outback and a society with no rules, and what you've got is a film destined for greatness.

And great it is. The performances are the best part of the picture, with Pearce being convincingly broken and threatening as his journey progresses and Pattinson playing Rey with great dejection and hopelessness. But thanks to some stunning scenery, seamless direction from David Michod and a solid script marked by its originality from Michod and Joel Edgerton, The Rover is both the best that the genre has to offer and a tight and emotional psychological thriller focused on the greed and evil of man.

Yeah, it's pretty damn good.


7. Vampires

James Woods John Carpenters Vampires
Columbia Pictures

One of the most exciting and genuinely fun-to-watch vampire movies ever (if you're partial to mindless violence, ridiculous plots and a mix of good and oh-so-poor acting), John Carpenter's Vampires, released in 1998, is the Western genre twisted to its most extreme and enjoyable.

Jack Crow (James Woods) is a mercenary, leading a team to retrieve the "Black Cross of Berziers", an ancient relic which can allow vampires to walk in the sunlight. In a world where vampires rule, preventing such power falling into the their hands is an imperative. And, well, that's pretty much it. Violence ensues, deaths occur and characters are betrayed.

It's solid fun, and packs a lot of action into its hour and a half runtime, but as a modern Western it's pretty brilliant. Fusing horror and the Western tropes audience's love - gunfights, romance and badass loners - is a great idea, and gives way to some typical set pieces paired with some unfamiliar situations.

Like a couple others on this list, it doesn't sound like it should work, but in terms of pure entertainment it succeeds in spades whilst being an effective neo-Western. Also, it's John Carpenter. What's not to love there?


6. Outland

Outland Sean Connery
Warner Bros.

Sean Connery as a veteran marshal. A corrupt mining facility. A violent drug gang. A remake of a classic Old West vehicle, High Noon. All of this and more, set on Io... a moon orbiting Jupiter. What more could you want?

Described by director Peter Hyams and critics at the time of its release as a "space Western", Outland hit theatres in 1981 and managed, miraculously, to capture the essence of what made High Noon so great. There's a great deal of palatable tension, some brilliant characters (Connery is always fun, let's be fair), and a typical macho-man protagonist going against some shady happenings on an outer-space mining facility.

On top of that, there's hitmen, space travel, politics, corruption (a recurring theme on this list) and betrayal.

Taking the classic formula of the Western and literally moving it through time and space gives the film an extra level of intensity - the classic adage of "In space no one can hear you scream", only with drugs and guns and a lot less aliens. It's solid fun, if slightly leave-your-brain-at-the-door in parts, but when a film is this slick, cool and weird, that doesn't greatly matter.


5. Lone Star

Lone Star Mcconaughey
Cineplex

Before Matthew McConaughey won an Oscar and began one of cinema's best career changes, he gave a compelling and passionate performance in Lone Star, a subtle and underrated gem released in 1996.

Directed and written by John Sayles, the film is set in the nineties and follows a sheriff (Chris Cooper) as he investigates the mystery surrounding a recently uncovered skeleton. Digging into the Texan town's past, Sheriff Sam Deeds come to learn that his beloved and popular father, Buddy (McConaughey) was not as clean and straight as he led to believe.

Outside of some classic Western tropes, Lone Star is also complete with a romance and subplots about corruption, money, deception, family and the looming spectre of the past.

Cooper and McConaughey are simply terrific. Every frame is expertly crafted, the tension is heightened with every revelation that comes our way, and the entire thing watches like a Western transported to another time and place, only it's still very much intact and just as juicy and great as if it was set in the 1800s.

Oh, and Kris Kristofferson's in it, which is just cool.

A great psychological thriller, it was well received upon its release but has since slipped into obscurity. It's well worth a watch, especially considering where McConaughey is now.


4. Hell Or High Water

Hell Or High Water Ben Foster Chris Pine
Lionsgate

Hell or High Water was written by Taylor Sheridan and directed by David Mackenzie, released in late 2016. Starring a never better (except Big Lebowski) Jeff Bridges alongside Chris Pine, Ben Foster and Gil Birmingham, the film sees two brothers as they start robbing banks in order to pay their mortgage.

The plan starts off well, but soon a veteran lawman (Bridges) is hot on their trail. Described as a neo-Western heist thriller, Hell or High Water is the kind of film that sits back to look at the way the Old West has effected present day life. Many things have changed, but lawmen vs bank robbers is still very much a thing, and gunfights are by no means a thing of the past.

Aided by some staggeringly good performances - including a career best Chris Pine - and a great score courtesy of Nick Cave and Warren Ellis, it's a slow burn of a picture which nonetheless leaves you transfixed by every frame, every confrontation, and every threat of violence.

The climax, too, is the stuff the best Westerns are made of - you know what's coming, how it's all going to end, but you can't help but hold on for dear life until it's over.


3. Wind River

Wind River Elizabeth Olsen
Lionsgate

Wind River came out in 2017, and was written and directed by Taylor Sheridan (one-time star of Sons of Anarchy and mastermind of Sicario). Full of the many themes audiences associate with the Western, Wind River follows wildlife officer Cory Lambert (Jeremy Renner) and FBI Agent Jane Banner (Elizabeth Olsen) as they attempt to solve the rape and murder of a teen on a Native American reservation.

In a lot of ways, this is a film that takes a step back from the Western and allows the audience to look at how the Old West and its wars and political turmoil shaped America for years to come. Beyond that, it's a film steeped in mystery, intensity and politics, a brilliant crime-thriller with sweeping sets and stunning visuals.

As he proved with Sicario, Sheridan is at his best when creating scenes of building tension and letting them pay-off massively. For that, it seems he was born to make Westerns - tense, tight, and epic in scope despite being relegated to one or two locations. Wind River is a Western through-and-through, and deserves a lot more praise for it achieved.

Plus, you know, Hawkeye and Scarlet Witch taking a break to solve crimes and deal with corruption - who doesn't want that?


2. No Country For Old Men

Josh Brolin No Country For Old Men
Paramount Pictures

Winning Best Picture at the Academy Awards, No Country for Old Men is arguably the most well-received film on this entire list. Directed and written by the unstoppable and always-stellar Coen Brothers, No Country for Old Men follows a hunter (Josh Brolin) as he attempts to flee with some stolen cash from a psychopathic hitman (an Oscar-winning Javier Bardem).

Amongst all the chases, intense as hell gunfights and moody dialogue, there is also Tommy Lee Jones' Sheriff Ed Bell, a weathered lawman whose faith in justice and peace is massively shaken. The whole thing is a stunning meditation on film-making and themes of peace, law, and the universal idea of good vs evil.

It's a Western modernised, with characters whose roles you can all recognised, but whose presence are altered by the way of the world they find themselves in.

And who can forget Jones' final speech in the closing moments of the film? Just thinking about it gives me the chills.


1. Serenity

serenity firefly
FOX

Directed and written by Joss Whedon, Serenity is the perfect Western, full of gunslingers, tough-as-nails prositutes, gunfights and scope. Released in 2005, the film was a continuation of the cult hit show Firefly, which was wrongfully cancelled after one completely fantastic season. Serenity was an attempt to appease some angry fans, finishing up the story of Malcolm Reynolds and his crew to a more satisfactory end.

The film follows the crew of the titular ship, lead by Nathan Fillion's Mal, as they attempt to escape the Alliance - the sinister regime ruling most of the universe. Harbouring two fugitives with checkered pasts and numerous secrets, the Serenity crew are pursued through space by the Operative (Chiwetel Ejiofor), who is out to bring the fugitives down.

It's not a Western in the conventional sense, thanks to the added excitement of sci-fi, fantasy, mystery and even comedy, but it still ticks all the boxes; the settings are sweeping and colourful, Mal Reynolds is the classic lone gunman archetype who talks tough but has a heart of gold, and political themes underlying the chases and violence make this a quintessential non-Western Western, with a lot to love.

We still miss Firefly, though.


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know The Films Of The Coen Brothers?

John Goodman Big Lebowski
Gramercy Pictures

1. According To Walter Sobchak In The Big Lebowski, In What Way Is Bowling NOT Like 'Nam?

Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/