10 Biggest Mistakes The James Bond Series Ever Made
The most "cuckoo, cuckoo" decisions in 007 history.
Bond, James Bond. For more than 50 years the name has been seared into the popular consciousness, and if (I stress if) the recent rumours prove true, we may have reached that point when conversations about Bond go into overdrive: with the casting of a new actor in the role.
The purpose of this article isn't really to speculate on where the series should go from here, but if you'll indulge me for a moment: personally, I think it's definitely time for Daniel Craig to move on. Credit where it's due, he's been a revelation, and come what may he's got two of the best ever Bond movies under his belt.
But even ignoring what Craig's said in interviews (that "I'd rather slash my wrists" remark is never going away), one need only watch his performance in Spectre to see how utterly bored he is of the role. To keep on a lead actor who no longer has any interest in playing the part would, I think, be a terrible mistake.
But of course - the Bond series has made its fair share of creative mistakes. Inevitably, after 24 films, there are innumerable moments from the 007 archives which leave us wondering what the filmmakers were thinking.
Let's not forget, a level of knowing silliness has always been key to Bond's appeal. But at times, Bond has just got a bit too silly; and worse yet, some of the silliest moments were meant to be serious...
10. Dr Christmas Jones In The World Is Not Enough
Including this one does feel rather like shooting fish in a barrel at this point. But anyway you cut it, there's really no denying that Denise Richards' Dr Christmas Jones is the worst Bond girl ever. And yes, I know that's saying a lot.
1999's The World Is Not Enough was the 19th Bond movie, and Pierce Brosnan's third film in the role. The series had, by this point, managed to strike a tricky balance between edginess and absurdity, facilitated by Brosnan pitching his performance midway between Sean Connery and Roger Moore. This had worked perfectly in Goldeneye and (to a lesser extent) Tomorrow Never Dies.
Third time, in this instance, was not a charm. The World Is Not Enough is an oddly schizophrenic movie; on the one hand, it's the most grounded and character-driven Bond movie since On Her Majesty's Secret Service; on the other, it boasts some painfully goofy elements that utterly scupper any attempts at emotional realism.
The worst offender on this front: a world-class nuclear physicist dressed like Lara Croft with a demanour more becoming to a California mall than an Eastern European oil pipeline.
Kiss all sense of pathos goodbye; every time Christmas Jones is on screen, all the movie's efforts toward real drama are completely undermined. It's not just that Denise Richards was miscast, it's that the character belongs in a different movie altogether.
9. Japanese James Bond In You Only Live Twice
To fall back on the old excuse for shocking racial slurs - it was a different time. Plus, as has also been remarked time and again, the Bond franchise has never been held up as a paragon of political correctness. Even so, this was really pushing it.
1967's You Only Live Twice was the fifth Bond movie, and marked Sean Connery's temporary retirement (before his equally temporary, and perhaps misguided return on Diamonds Are Forever). It's also one of the best in most respects, thanks largely to its iconic volcano lair climax and Donald Pleasance's unforgettable turn as Blofeld.
The first four films had already established the glob-trotting element which has long been key to the franchise's global appeal. So for the fifth movie, they sent 007 to Japan, largely with the intent of capitalising on the popularity of the movies there.
However, it's one thing to dip into another culture (pardon the Bond-esque double-entendre); it's quite another to give your protagonist a temporary makeover with a view to changing his ethnicity. But that's just what they do in You Only Live Twice, with Bond adopting a Japanese identity and being married to a local girl to aid his cover story.
It's not just that putting Bond in 'yellowface' was such an awful idea; the make-up itself is terrible, with Connery looking more like a Beatle than a native of Japan. And ultimately he only wears the make-up for a few scenes anyway, so it winds up utterly superfluous. It's not enough to ruin the movie, but it is Connery's lowest moment.
8. Lazenby's Introduction In On Her Majesty's Secret Service
It's easy to see why introducing the second actor to portray James Bond was considered a big deal. It was a very bold move at the time, and established the new approach which would ensure the longevity of the series.
Of course, as we all know, it proved to count for little, as the almost completely inexperienced George Lazenby would relinquish the role after his first and only Bond performance in On Her Majesty's Secret Service. As misguided as the model-turned-actor may have been, he did a largely respectable job as the only one-and-done 007 to date; and the film itself is rightly held up to this day as one of the best of the series.
However, given Lazenby's brevity in the role, his introduction as Bond seems all the more overblown. Opening on a car chase, we get only brief glimpses of his face revealed in rapid edits, building a sense of anticipation to the new 007's reveal. Once he's finally revealed, it's a kind of visual crescendo - and, credit where it's due, Lazenby does his own thing with the role rather than simply imitating Connery.
The problem is, going in with the knowledge that On Her Majesty's Secret Service is the actor's sole outing in the role, all this dramatic build-up seems utterly misplaced. This feeling is only worsened by what has to be one of the worst fourth-wall breaking moments of the series: as Diana Rigg's Tracy dashes to her car leaving 007 high and dry, Lazenby murmurs, "this never happened to the other fellow," with a smile direct to the camera.
Yes, knowing humour has always been part of Bond, but this was a bit much. Small wonder, then, that when Roger Moore took over in Live And Let Die, he did so with no aplomb whatsoever, everyone just acting as though he always had been Bond and getting on with the story.
7. THAT Sound Effect In The Man With The Golden Gun
With Roger Moore's introduction in 1973's Live And Let Die, Bond marched boldly forth into a new decade with an all-new persona. Moore's dandyish, perpetually smirking charm was lightyears removed from Connery's more square-jawed machismo, and with this new approach came an openness to more overt comedy on all levels in the Bond movies.
It's for this reason that the Moore years have long been a divisive period among 007 devotees. Many feel that the influx of lampoonish, Carry On-esque humour took the format too far from Ian Fleming's harder-edged original creation; others argue that the films were unabashedly light-hearted and fun, a quality that the films have surely lacked in recent years.
Still, just about every Moore film has at least one comedic moment that pushed things a little too far into outright silliness. His second film, 1974's The Man With The Golden Gun, was the first to really revel in its own ridiculousness, and it's not hard to see how series aficionados of the time would have been taken aback.
The problem is, this absurdity often inadvertently sabotages what should have been truly dramatic moments. There's no better example of this than the decision to use a slide whistle effect on the corkscrew car jump. This is one of the most remarkable car stunts ever put to film, and it's a moment that should thrill the audience to their core; instead, it becomes a sight gag akin to someone slipping on a banana peel.
Other notable ill-placed comedic beats from the Moore era include the clown suit and the Tarzan impersonation in Octopussy, or Bond snowboarding to the sound of the Beach Boys in A View To A Kill. But then, by that point the films were inherently absurd thanks to the increasing age of their leading man.
On which note...
6. Keeping Roger Moore Beyond For Your Eyes Only
One of the greatest ironies of the Bond series is the fact that Roger Moore landed the role in 1973 at least partly because he looked younger than Sean Connery. In fact, Moore is three years older than his predecessor - and as his run in the role progressed, this became screamingly obvious.
It all started out well enough. Live And Let Die was a fine introduction; The Man With The Golden Gun is a bit too farcical, but still hugely enjoyable; The Spy Who Loved Me is easily one of the top 5 best Bond movies ever; and even Moonraker, while often lambasted for its jaw-dropping silliness, is still undeniably entertaining.
1981's For Your Eyes Only was Moore's fifth film (twelfth in the series overall), and marked a self-conscious return to a more down-to-earth approach in line with Fleming and the Connery movies. While it still has its painfully ridiculous moments (who can forget Margaret Thatcher's cameo), it's a considerably more introspective affair: note that it opens on an unusually sombre Moore taking flowers to his wife's grave.
For Your Eyes Only also acknowledges the hero's advancing years; Moore was now 53, and looking it. And, in what has to be a series first, Bond himself is turned off by a young woman's advances, as Lynn-Holly Johnson's young ice skater Bibi offers herself to him only for him to decline in a somewhat grandfatherly fashion.
When even Bond is creeped out by the age gap between himself and his would-be seductress, that's surely a sign that the time is right to move on. And yet the rapidly ageing Moore would remain in the role for a further two movies, 1983's Octopussy and 1985's A View To A Kill; which, not for nothing, mark possibly the lowest ebb of the entire Bond franchise.
The 80s were not especially kind to 007; which brings us to the series' next major mistake...
5. Letting John Glen Direct Every Bond Movie In The 1980s
Bond has long been something of a family business. Producer Albert R 'Cubby' Broccoli shepherded the franchise for over three decades before handing the reins to his daughter Barbara and her half-brother Michael G Wilson. As such, it's hardly surprising that other figures in the Bond machine rose through the ranks over the years.
Perhaps the most notable behind-the-scenes career progression on Bond was that of John Glen. Having started out as both editor and second unit director on On Her Majesty's Secret Service, Glen repeated these duties throughout the Moore years. Clearly he garnered a lot of trust in that time, as he ultimately made his directorial debut on 1981's For Your Eyes Only - a role he would repeat on the following four Bond films made in the 1980s.
This five film streak makes Glen the most prolific director of the series; no subsequent Bond director would helm two films back-to-back again until Sam Mendes on Skyfall and Spectre.
However, while he might have directed 007 the most, was Glen ever really the best person for the job? There's a perfunctory, workmanlike quality to his films that make the 80s Bonds blur into one another somewhat.
This became a particular problem as Glen stayed at the helm for both of Timothy Dalton's outings. This, I would argue, scuppered Dalton's chances of ever really making Bond his own from the off. Being younger, more physically adept and crucially much harder-edged than Moore, Dalton's casting marked the start of a new era, and surely called for a reshuffle in the ranks all around.
Alas, Glen remained; and whilst The Living Daylights and Licence To Kill are entirely respectable entries in the series, which pre-empt the more grounded style of the Craig years, there's no denying that they could have been so much more. A new director more attuned to a darker, grittier approach would surely have helped.
4. John Cleese As Q
Ah, that old Bond dilemma; the balance between self-conscious pastiche and outright comedy. As we touched on earlier, the Brosnan years played a tricky balancing act in this respect, and hindsight shows us that they frequently got the balance completely wrong.
The casting of John Cleese as the new Q was a particularly notable example of this. When Desmond Llewelyn originated the role in 1963's From Russia With Love (introduced not as Q but as the quartermaster Boothroyd), there was nothing comedic about the character or his function. It was only as the series progressed, and the gadgets got ever sillier, that the Q scenes came to have a comedic value.
Llewelyn remains the longest-serving Bond actor, reprising Q in every entry up until 1999's The World Is Not Enough, by which point his interactions with Brosnan were out-and-out comedy sketches. As such, one can see the logic in having an established comedic actor introduced as his replacement when Llewelyn chose to retire. (Of course, his retirement proved to be a sad and short one, as the actor was tragically killed in a car accident only three weeks after The World Is Not Enough premiered.)
When the Monty Python alumnus took over as the solo Q in Die Another Day, he had little to do other than retrace the steps of his predecessor whilst essentially just playing himself; or at least, his existing screen persona. Now, whoever they cast would have been hard-pressed not to make that invisible Aston Martin seem anything less than stupid, but still, Cleese's dynamic as Q just feels wrong.
Llewelyn was funny because he wasn't trying to be; casting a comedian playing for overt laughs just seems to miss the point.
Not that this was by any means the only issue with that particular Bond movie...
3. The First 30 Minutes In Die Another Day
Most would agree that Die Another Day is one of the most deeply flawed films in the entire 24 film 007 series. However, if you'll excuse me for deviating from the consensus, I would say its main problems are not the ones that are generally pointed out.
Yes, Die Another Day is the most mind-boggling silly Bond movie since Moonraker. Just look at that laundry list of absurdities: North Korean villain wearing the face of an English aristocrat; diamond-powered laser beams; a disappearing car; horrendous CGI surfing sequences; Madonna.
However, I don't see why any of this should be taken as a negative. Die Another Day is idiotic, but it's fun; shamelessly unrealistic entertainment worth of Moore at his most carefree. It's certainly more enjoyable than Brosnan's previous effort The World Is Not Enough; by contrast with that one, Die Another Day certainly isn't forgettable.
The film's real problem isn't how stupid it gets by the end; it's how serious it is in the beginning. Die Another Day's opening scenes seem to point toward something entirely different than the film we end up getting; indeed, something entirely different from any other Bond movie made up to that point.
We open on the unthinkable; Bond slipping up and getting caught. Then the opening titles eschew the usual suggestive female silhouettes in favour of scenes of 007 being brutally tortured by his captors. Finally we see Bond after months of imprisonment, bearded and long-haired, and dead-set on revenge.
It all seems to be building up to the darkest entry since Licence To Kill; but soon it's all swordfights, postcard humour, and Halle Berry barely contained in an orange bikini.
It's this jarring clash of sensibilities, I think, which renders Die Another Day such a dud in the eyes of so many. If they'd just been unabashedly daft from the word go, would we really have anything to complain about?
2. Not Delaying Production On Quantum Of Solace
There was a time when fans everywhere were screaming that the biggest mistake the Bond producers had ever made was casting Daniel Craig in the role. Happily, 2006's Casino Royale shut most of them up. Seemingly disregarding every performance that went before him (an entirely logical approach), the blonde-haired Chester-born actor did his own thing in a movie which took 007 back to his origins with the first official adaptation of Fleming's first Bond novel.
The rest is history; Casino Royale was a smash, Craig won over the audience, and no one wanted to waste any time getting him back on screen. Unfortunately, a rather sizeable hurdle fell in the path of follow-up movie Quantum of Solace: the Writer's Guild of America strike, which ran from November 2007 to February 2008 - i.e. just about when the 22nd Bond film was going into production.
As a result, Quantum of Solace went before cameras with a script which no one was entirely happy with, but that no writers were allowed to make amendments to. Craig has since stated that it fell on director Marc Forster and himself to rework the scenes that needed it on the spot, and as the actor himself noted, "a writer I am not."
Quantum of Solace isn't quite so bad as it's often made out to be, but there's no denying it was a major let-down after Casino Royale. The plot is bland and uninvolving (when will Bond writers learn, pipelines just aren't exciting!), and the emphasis on intense action over character and humour means it really doesn't feel like a Bond film at all.
Perhaps if they'd just put the brakes on long enough to ensure they were really ready before starting work, the film wouldn't have had such problems. That said, no writers' strikes can be held accountable for the mistakes they've made since...
1. Blofeld/Franz Oberhauser In Spectre
Any contemporary film fan with a half-decent memory can remember the whole kerfuffle that occured over 2013's Star Trek Into Darkness. The second film in JJ Abrams' reboot of the beloved sci-fi series had cast Benedict Cumberbatch in a mysterious villain role. Fans everywhere guessed he must have been playing the iconic bad guy Khan, but everyone involved in the movie denied it.
Then the movie came out, and lo and behold, Cumberbatch was playing Khan. What made it worse was that his identity had been hidden for no good reason. Within the rebooted story world, Khan had never been seen before, so the name carried no weight with anyone except existing Star Trek fans. Naturally, most of these fans felt insulted.
Still, while just about any film fan worth their salt had paid heed to this, clearly the makers of Bond hadn't, as they proceeded to do the exact same thing with the reintroduction of the classic 007 bad guy Blofeld. And, if possible, their approach was even dumber.
It was bad enough that they introduced Christoph Waltz under the needless pretence of him being someone else, only to have him reveal his true name at a point where it had no bearing on the action whatsoever. But his motivation... seriously, what were they thinking?
Yes, it transpires that the Spectre organisation was behind every adversary Bond had faced since Casino Royale, hiding in the shadows everywhere. And was it so they could covertly rule the world? No - it was so Bond's embittered step-brother could get back at him for stealing his father's affections.
I mean, really. It's bad enough that Daniel Craig looks so bored he's barely conscious thoughout Spectre. Or that they hired Monica Bellucci only to make her the most transitory, disposable Bond girl of the Craig era. Or that they cast Dave Bautista, fresh from Guardians of the Galaxy, and let him be nothing more than another anonymous thug.
No, it's this brazen, empty-headed mishandling of Bond's ultimate nemesis that really singles out Spectre as the biggest misstep the Bond movies have taken in thirty years - and really underlines the need to get some fresh blood in the mix.
Do you agree these are the worst mistakes the Bond franchise has ever made? Or do you think these weren't so bad? Can you think of worse ones? We expect you to talk in the comments section.