10 Biggest Plot-Changing Movie Phone Calls

Telephones have always been the Achilles' heel of screenwriters, here are the calls that connected.

Ghostface On Phone
Dimension Films

Given the near-congruence of their invention and development, it's somewhat surprising to see how the telephone has stymied screenwriters for the past century. The last 30 years has sent audiences groaning every time a character, otherwise stranded or damned, announces that their cell phone has no service. But even before the cell became a mainstay of modern living, scenes played out ignoring logical questions regarding human behaviour ("Why don't they call the police?" "Hit *69!").

The truly gifted screenwriter treated the phone as a novelty - a plot device on which the film's entire hook may rely. But other, more lazy writers tend to ignore the modern convenienes, particularly if they're writing a particularly silly slasher movie.

Here are the calls that mattered.

10. Lost Highway

Robert Blake in Lost Highway
October Films

Critics and even some fans were perplexed by David Lynch's Lost Highway, a head trip through the seedy, bizarre streets of Los Angeles, and they wouldn't be alone. The director himself, in a rare instance wherein he openly talked about his influences, claimed he only realized he was indirectly driven by the spectacle and circus surrounding the O.J. Simpson trial.

So it's just as well, and oddly portentous, that the earth-shattering break before jazz sax player Bill Pullman's world falls apart is from another acquitted (but arguably guilty) fading celebrity: a ghost-like Robert Blake.

Beretta appears to Pullman at a party early in the film, as our protagonist (for now) has been having dreams of his wife being murdered. Blake, pasty and creepy as all get out, informs Pullman that he is, despite appearances, not at the party, but in fact at his home.

He calls home, only to find Blake answering on the other end, all the while his ghost-like apparation eerily grinning.

Soon Pullman's wife does meet a grisly fate that he is convicted of before body switching into a teenage mechanic who works for Richard Pryor and Robert Loggia.

And this was one of Lynch's more straightforward works, in that the plot seemingly unfolds linearly, if not explicitly. We'll take


9. Phone Booth

Kiefer Sutherland Phone Booth
20th Century Fox

Larry Cohen had well established himself as a hatchet-man and innovative screenwriter - good for an original draft he dreamed up in the shower that morning or some rewrite work on a major feature. It's a shame, then, that much of his work has gone unsung, with only die-hard fans seeking out his more obscure directorial efforts. His quirky sense of humour and knack for knocking out high-concept scripts at a rapid pace led to such cult favourites as Q: The Winged Serpent and The Stuff.

The legend is that Phone Booth was first pitched by Cohen to Alfred Hitchcock in the 60s. Hitch loved the idea of keeping a character in a phone booth for an entire film, but neither could figure out a compelling reason.

It was only after the D.C. Sniper attacks that Cohen revisited the idea, and not a moment too soon. It was the dawn of a new millennium and phone booths - particularly the classic ones that have their own glass doors - were dwindling in supply. Cohen capitalized on that, putting a fast-talking, wheeling and dealing agent Colin Farrell in the gunsight of a sniper (Kiefer Sutherland) who refuses to let him hang up.

Had Cohen or director Joel Schumacher had sat on the material just a little longer, it'd practically have to be a period piece.


8. Black Christmas

Black Christmas
Warner Bros.

It's easy to irritate any horror fan - simply claim that Halloween was the first slasher flick. They'll almost certainly rail against you, canceling all the rest of the noise at the party with their shrieking accusations of ignorance - how you have been remiss in not seeking out Peeping Tom or Psycho or Black Christmas.

The latter film, directed by Bob Clark, was a Canadian sleeper hit that reached the likes of Steve Martin and John Carpenter, among other major fans. The plot was even more simple than that of Halloween; a killer is in a sorority house over Christmas break, calling the tenants to harass and, ultimately, pick them off one by one.

This was the first major film variation on the "The Calls Are Coming From In The House" urban legend, although it takes many liberties. The most successful of its dated but effective suspenseful moments occurs when the heroine (Olivia Hussey) asks the police to trace the next obscene, eerie call.

This being 1974, police tracing methods were rudimentary, and the film offers us a rare insight into the process during a scene in which the operator has to run through bookshelf-sized computers to find the corresponding line.

The film's two remakes updated the film and largely ignored the phone call aspect, much to their detriment.


7. Dial M For Murder

Dial M For Murder
Warner Bros.

When laying out a plot to murder an adulterous wife, it's best to keep things simple and have an airtight alibi. Unfortunately, tennis pro Ray Milland planned every moment leading up to his wife's (Grace Kelly) killing to the last detail. But when you get so bogged down in details, you're bound to forget a few loose ends.

On its face, Milland's plan is solid: blackmail an old friend-turned-petty criminal into committing the crime while he phones home from a party, firmly assuring he was nowhere near the scene.

In the end, all that really tripped Milland up was a watch off by three minutes and a surprisingly adept Kelly, who manages to overpower her attacker. By the time Milland comes home to cover up any remaining evidence of his involvement, it's just a matter of time before he slips up.


6. Almost Famous

PSH Almost Famous
Columbia Pictures

Becoming a journalist in film, particularly in the era of Hunter Thompson, Watergate and Vietnam, always feels like seat-of-your-pants recruitment. The uninitiated are suddenly thrown into the fire with little preparation or experienced, forced to rely on their wits. There are varying degrees of truth in that, with some journalism schools forcing students to get published before their first semester ends, but nothing comes close to what William Miller (Patrick Fugit), Cameron Crowe's onscreen surrogate for his 15-year-old self, experiences.

In the span of one tour of the fictitious Stillwater band (based in large part on The Allman Brothers), Miller loses his virginity, experiments with drugs, nearly dies in a plane crash (one of the scenes in the film that actually happened to Crowe) and falls in love. All the while, unbeknownst to youthful, idealistic eyes, he's baring firsthand witness to the death of modern rock and roll.

When Miller does come to that realization, he makes a half-assed attempt to save it, writing glowingly of his experience with the band. He sacrificed the one tenet of rock journalism: he became their friend.

It's only after hs speaks to his mentor Lester Bangs (Phillip Seymour Hoffman) that he realizes the error of his ways, that being honest and unmerciful is more fulfilling. And that, as Hoffman put it, the only true currency in this bankrupt world is what you share with someone else when you're uncool.


5. Scream

Courtney Cox, Jamie Kennedy and Neve Campbell in Scream
Dimension Films

Just when the slasher genre had run its course and seemingly died out in the early 90s, it rose again like its many-storied masked killers with the popularity of Scream. Screenwriter Kevin Williamson locked himself away in a cabin to pound out a draft of his hip, wry love letter to the genre.

Much of Scream's opening scene, which features a tortured Drew Barrymore receiving threatening phone calls before becoming the killer's second victim, pays homage to more than just When A Stranger Calls, including Dario Argento's Supiria and a Halloween reference thrown in for good measure.

Scream came about at just the right time in the history of cell phones for them to be machinations of plot rather than a hindrance. They weren't so omnipresent in teenager's lives that they would be a logistical nightmare.

By the time the sequel rolled around, Williamson took any criticisms about phone tracing and technology to heart, immediately dismissing them with a quick Called ID joke.


4. When A Stranger Calls, Back, Remake

Carol Kane fails to check the children in time in When A Stranger Calls
Columbia Pictures/Embassy Pictures

Five years after Black Christmas made the infamous babysitter calls a popular horror trope, director Fred Walton tried a more straight-forward retelling of the legend.

The first 20 minutes of When a Stranger Calls, which finds a young Carol Kane tasked with babysitting two sleeping children, follow the tale almost beat for beat, with the police revealing the location of the call too late. The film's opening moments are chillingly effective enough to have generated decades of cult fans, but few seems to recall the rest of the film.

After the caller is captured by police, the film leaps ahead seven years later, where he is in an insane asylum. He escapes, only to be hunted by a metally-scarred Kane and cop Charles Durning.

Beyond the first twenty minutes, however, the film starts to show its weaknesses, devolving into a fairly generic police manhunt film.

The film's remake course-corrected, but perhaps a little too far. Simon West's 2006 film expands the opening into a feature-length film. Given West's ham-fisted, Con Air-style, he was a bad match for a film that worked on suspense, nor did it help that it was released during a period when horror films were geared toward a PG-13 audience.

Fans of the original would serve themselves well to seek out the made-for-cable sequel, which reunites Durning and Kane and follows the same beats as its originator, with equally terrifying-to-middling results.


3. A Nightmare On Elm Street

A Nightmare on elm street
New Line

Prior to A Nightmare on Elm Street, Wes Craven's films were more politically motivated and - despite their budgetary strains - felt academic. He was, after all, a humanities professor before he picked up his first 16mm camera. For Elm Street, an original idea unlike his previous works that were inspired by Ingmar Bergman and historical nightmares like the Sawney Bean massacre, he delved into his own personal demons.

Drawing on a series of L.A. Times articles about children of the Cambodian massacre dying in their sleep, his recollection of a high school bully and a creep who once stared at him through his window as a child, Craven ushered in a new kind of slasher. He was unrepentant, borne out of the secrets your parents kept from you, and he was probably a child molester in life.

His first final girl, Nancy Thompson (Heather Langenkamp) put an end to Freddy Krueger by removing all the power he garners from her fear. But prior to that, she is relentlessly tortured, first watching her friends get picked off one-by-one, then by her own alcoholic mother and see-no-evil cop father who turn her home into a prison. Surely, there must be something that springs her into action.

And it doesn't come without a cost: in this case, the death of her boyfriend Glenn (Johnny Depp). After sucking him into his bed and hosing his room with his innards, Freddy has his first out-of-character moment. It's true that we are unclear on the limitations of Freddy's abiliies in the first film, which suggest he can break through into our reality at will.

He does so in one of the film's most effective jump scares, calling Nancy on an unhooked phone to inform her of Glenn's fate and get a little tongue while he's at it.


2. Halloween III: Season Of The Witch

Halloween III: Season of the Witch Tom Atkins
Universal Pictures

It's rare you hear a good argument in favour of genocide, and Tommy Lee Wallace's standalone sequel to John Carpenter's film easily comes up with the most ludicrous: punking the kids.

It seems Conal Cochran, CEO and founder of Silver Shamrock Novelty company, is an alleged warlock (it's never clarified) who despises what children have done to the festival of Samhain. They've turned it into a mockery. In order to get them to pay their proper respect, he has implanted his top-selling Halloween masks with pieces of Stonehenge that will activate and murder when the "giveaway" plays at 9 p.m. Santa Mira time (it's worth noting that Santa Mira, California is also the fictional location of the town in Invasion of the Body Snatchers - a film Wallace and Carpenter inexplicably try and borrow from).

It's up to Dr. Daniel Challis, a local physician with a severe drinking problem that's never addressed, to warn the public before the "giveaway" airs. Challis manages to escape Cochran's grasp and make it to a gas station, where he gets on the phone to explain the situation.

Astonishingly, networks around the country start to shut down, putting a stop to the potential murder of millions of children.

But one network refuses to stop airing the ad, and the film ends with Challis screaming a plea to shut it down. Given the current pandemic and the absurd conspiracy theories and protests surrounding orders of protection, one can only wonder what network just wouldn't pull its advertisers.


1. All The President's Men

Robert Redford in All The President's Men
Warner Bros.

Alan J. Pakula's paranoid true thriller charts Bob Woodward (Robert Redford) and Carl Bernstein (Dustin Hoffman) as they investigate a suspicious break-in and the Democatic National Committee at the Watergate hotel. Pakula wisely never enters the grounds of the White House, only the driveway where we see the Washington Post be delivered every morning to an unseen monolith. How far the reach of the conspiracy is unknown, and for the film's first hour feels like a dead-end.

Redford and Hoffman grumble around each other - clearly expressing the respect but dislike for each other the two journalists had, but every lead seems to be a dead end. That is, until Redford persists with phone calls based on an anonymous tip from Deep Throat (Mark Felt, as played by Hal Holbrook) to follow the money.

The way the scene is framed is gut-wrenching, with a still shot of Redford at a newsdesk manning the phones. But as the calls start to reveal a clear tie between money connected to the Committee to Re-Elect the President and the Watergate burglars, the camera insidiously zooms in, slowly, until Redford's head is most of the frame.

It's a nice reverse from the endless, lingering overhead shot of the Library of Congress, which found the reporters at a loss in front of stacks of notecards.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Scream
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Kenny Hedges is carbon-based. So I suppose a simple top 5 in no order will do: Halloween, Crimes and Misdemeanors, L.A. Confidential, Billy Liar, Blow Out He has his own website - thefilmreal.com - and is always looking for new writers with differing views to broaden the discussion.