10 Cancelled Star Wars Projects That Were Devastating

Battlefront 3 and Lucas' sequels are now one with the Force.

Star Wars 1313
LucasArts

With the franchise having a vast array of films, TV shows, books and games, the galaxy-spanning saga has no shortage of fantastic stories and impactful characters. Still, that doesn't mean that every Star Wars project gets to see the light of day.

During Lucas' tenure, there were a huge number of projects that got cut down during development, or just as the final touches were being made, much to the fans’ dismay. Unfortunately, nothing has changed, with, if anything, there being a greater number of cancelled project than before. Since Disney acquired Lucasfilm in 2012, there have been plenty of TV shows, films and games that were unceremoniously cancelled, with the kindest fate these projects could face being indefinitely delayed.

Whether it’s a continuation of a fan favourite narrative that will never see completion, or a totally new story with never-before-seen characters that fizzled away, there are countless projects that Star Wars fans were dying to see once they had caught a glimpse of them before they scrapped, likely never to be seen again. Even so, that doesn’t stop fans pondering on what could have been had these projects been released.

10. David Benioff And Dan Wiess' Trilogy

Db Weiss David Benioff Star Wars Game of Thrones
Disney/HBO

Despite not being officially cancelled, it is very unlikely David Benioff and Dan Weiss will direct their Star Wars trilogy. The pair, who wrote Game of Thrones, were set to helm their own set of films in the space opera, which were due to release in 2022, 2024 and 2026.

However, once Benioff and Weiss signed a $200 million deal with Netflix in 2019, the pair had to walk away from the project. In a statement made to Deadline, the duo said: "We love Star Wars. When George Lucas built it, he built us too. Getting to talk about Star Wars with him and the current Star Wars team was the thrill of a lifetime, and we will always be indebted to the saga that changed everything.”

Once the pair made their statement, Lucasfilm president, Kathleen Kennedy, was quick to say: "David Benioff and Dan Weiss are incredible storytellers. We hope to include them in the journey forward when they are able to step away from their busy schedule to focus on Star Wars."

Now that Disney is struggling to produce Star Wars films, with the likes of Rian Johnson's trilogy and Patty Jenkins' Rogue Squadron being indefinitely delayed, as well as the backlash to the final season of Game of Thrones, the Benioff-Weiss films will probably never be made.


9. Solo Sequels

Han Solo A Star Wars Story
Lucasfilm

One film that more and more fans are coming around on is Solo. With its likeable cast and enjoyable story, Solo: A Star Wars Story deserved to be a success. Unfortunately, that was not the case.

The film was a financial failure for Disney, bringing in $393.2 million at the box office, with a budget of nearly $275 million, once a bulk of the movie was reshot after directors Phil Lord and Christopher Miller were fired from the project. This box office flop was likely due to the film releasing only 5 months after the highly controversial Episode VIII, and a general fatigue of Star Wars setting in on cinema-goers.

Still, Solo has grown in popularity in the fandom, particularly in the aftermath of Disney's controversial sequels. The film was planned to be the start of a trilogy focusing on the scoundrel and the Wookiee before the events of A New Hope, but with the nightmarish production and disappointing box office numbers, Disney has since cancelled plans for the next entries. Hopefully, the Lando Disney+ series can pick up where Solo left off, and considering Donald Glover is set to return as the suave swindler, this is not out of the realm of possibility.


8. Star Wars: The Clone Wars Season 7&8

Star Wars The Clone Wars Boba Fett Cad Bane
Lucasfilm

Although the show later received a seventh season in 2020, the original seasons of Star Wars: The Clone Wars were cancelled after Disney took control of the franchise.

Whilst it was a shame fans never got to see the final two seasons of the series as intended, most of the arcs those seasons would have told were released in one form or another through The Clone Wars Legacy. Under this project, these arcs were either adapted into comic books or novels, or were released in their incomplete form. Dark Disciple, which focused on Asajj Ventress and Quinlan Vos attempting to assassinate Count Dooku, was reworked into a book, and published in 2015. The early animation for Crystal Crisis, which saw Obi-Wan and Anakin teaming up to thwart General Grievous from obtaining a huge Kyber crystal, was released on StarWars.com in 2014.

Luckily, three of the stories initially planned were completed and released on Disney+ for the show's final season. These final arcs, namely The Bad Batch, Ahsoka's Walkabout and The Siege of Mandalore, were nearly identical to what was originally envisaged, and wrapped up the series well. Still, it would have been nice to watch all of the stories Dave Filoni and his team were planning before The Clone Wars was cancelled in 2013.


7. The Original Episode IX

Star Wars Duel Of The Fates concept art
Lucasfilm

With The Rise of Skywalker being one of the most contentious entries into the franchise, many fans wish Disney stuck with the original plans for Episode IX. The film, titled Duel of the Fates, would have been directed by Colin Trevorrow, and would have had a completely different narrative to the Episode IX that eventually got released, which became apparent once a script for the film leaked online in 2020.

The script revealed that Duel of the Fates would have spent a lot of its runtime on Coruscant, with Finn leading a Stormtrooper rebellion on the captial planet, Rey being completely unrelated to Emperor Palpatine, and Kylo being haunted by the ghost of Luke whilst he searched for ancient Sith artefacts across the galaxy.

Though some questionable choices were made, such as Poe becoming Rey's love interest, a lot of fans were disappointed to learn what could have been for the end of the space opera. Trevorrow was fired from the project over 'creative differences', and JJ Abrams was brought on to rush through the film's development to meet the strict 2019 release date. Perhaps after a few more drafts, Duel of the Fates would have been a brilliant send-off for the Skywalker saga, rather than the underbaked finale that we got.


6. Project Ragtag

Project Ragtag
Visceral Games

Project Ragtag was the code name for the Visceral Games project that had been in development since 2013. The game was headed by Amy Hennig, the head writer and creative director for the Uncharted franchise, and was said to have been in the style of the the action-adventure series.

At E3 2016, Visceral presented a demo for the game, which received a general positive reception, though saw some criticism over its lacking gameplay. Wanting to ensure the game delivered, EA brought on a second studio to work on the project, EA Vancouver. However, as time went on, it became increasingly evident that EA wanted to replace Visceral with Vancouver, and in October 2017, Visceral Games was shut down, with Ragtag being cancelled. Vancouver were tasked to retool the assets of Ragtag into a multiplayer shooter, though this too was cancelled in 2019.

In November 2017, EA would bash singleplayer games, leaving a bad taste in players' mouths. EA CFO Blake Jorgensen said: "As we kept reviewing the game [Ragtag] it continued to look like a much more linear game [which] people don't like as much today as they did 5 years ago or 10 years ago." Even so, with the wide success of Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, this could nudge EA into focusing more on singleplayer Star Wars games, like Ragtag.


5. Star Wars: Battlefront 3

Star Wars Battlefront 3
LucasArts

Star Wars: Battlefront 3 had been in production since 2006 at Free Radical, and would have seen considerable upgrades over its predecessors, including upgraded graphics, refined gunplay, and seamless ground-to-space battles.

Regrettably, the game was cancelled in 2008, due to ballooning costs and a management shakeup at LucasArts. In an interview with Eurogamer, Free Free Radical's Studio Development Director, Steve Ellis, recounted that: "For a long time we talked of LucasArts as the best relationship we'd ever had with a publisher. Then in 2008 that disappeared, they were all either fired or left. Then there was a new guy called Darrell Rodriguez, who had been brought in to do a job and it was more to do with cost control than making any games. And the games that we were making for them were costly."

Fans of the series were excited to see footage of the game appear online, which indicated that the campaign would focus on a pair of unique Clone Troopers, named X1 and X2, during the waning days of the Clone Wars. Several more leaks found their way onto the internet as the years went by, most of which showcased the game in its alpha build. As the leaks for the game continued to pile up, fans became more upset that they would never get to play what looked to be the best Star Wars shooter.


4. Knights Of The Old Republic 3

Star Wars KOTOR
LucasArts

After the success of Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords (KOTOR 2), it seemed obvious that a third entry would be immediately green-lit, and put into production.

Unfortunately, the game never became anything other than an idea. Obsidian Entertainment, the studio behind KOTOR 2, pitched their vision for a third game to LucasArts, which would have followed Revan tracking down the Sith Lord who was behind the events of the first two games. But, with Jim Ward becoming LucasArts' president in 2004, Obsidian's ideas were rejected. Ward, deciding that LucasArts was outsourcing too many games to different studios, wanted them to shift more focus onto internal projects, and so KOTOR 3 was cancelled.

Whilst this meant the end of KOTOR, the story those games told were expanded upon in the MMORPG, Star Wars: The Old Republic, which became hugely popular amongst fans, and produced fan-favourite characters, like Darth Malgus and Satele Shan. Even so, The Old Republic, which was produced by BioWare, the studio behind the first KOTOR game, did not scratch the same itch that a KOTOR 3 likely would have. With a remake of the 2003 classic on the horizon, it is possible that the KOTOR trilogy will be completed in the future, though that is probably just wishful thinking.


3. Star Wars 1313

Star Wars 1313 Boba Concept Art
Lucasarts

Star Wars 1313 was to be the video game tie-in with Star Wars: Underworld, and would have taken place in the seedy underbelly of Coruscant. The game suffered a considerable amount of internal struggles, especially with George Lucas meddling with its story. Initially, the game would have centered around Rak Jaren, a young bounty hunter, and would have told a completely new story set on the 1,313th level of the capital planet. But, when Lucas was shown the project, he insisted the protagonist should be Boba Fett, which threw LucasArts into disarray.

With Lucas' insistence on making such a major change to the game, LucasArts had to work even harder than they were to appease their boss. During E3 in 2012, a demo for the game was showcased, which featured Rak Jaren as the protagonist, with no mention of Fett at all, indicating how late in the day George Lucas enforced this character change.

Things only got worse from there. Once Lucas sold the space opera, all Star Wars projects were thrown into a a strange purgatory, with no one knowing whether the projects they had been working on would be released. Sadly for Star Wars 1313, Disney laid off the majority of the team at LucasArts, deciding to instead license out the IP to EA, leading to the death of the game in 2013.


2. George Lucas' Sequel Trilogy

Star Wars Episode 7
Lucasfilm

It is obvious that the Star Wars sequels are incredibly contentious, though things could have been very different had George Lucas had some involvement in the films. Once Disney acquired the franchise, Lucas offered his ideas for a sequel trilogy. With the House of Mouse choosing to go its own way, many fans wish they used Lucas' story, which was outlined in 2020.

In The Star Wars Archives 1999-2005, Lucas said: "The movies are about how Leia is trying to rebuild the Republic… Luke is trying to restart the Jedi.” The Star Wars visionary also revealed that: “Darth Maul trained a girl, Darth Talon, who was in the comic books, as his apprentice. She was the new Darth Vader and most of the action was with her. So these were the two main villains of the trilogy. Maul eventually becomes the godfather of crime in the universe because, as the Empire falls, he takes over.”

Despite Lucas' trilogy being scrapped, a lot of the ideas those films contained managed to find their way into other projects. Star Wars: The Clone Wars would see Maul cheat death, and become the head of a crime syndicate, and Luke would go on to rebuild the Jedi Order, even if his efforts proved to be unsuccessful.

Whilst it's nice to see not all of Lucas' ideas were wasted, it would arguably have been better to see Disney adapt them for their trilogy, rather than making their own films, with no overarching narrative to create a cohesive story.


1. Star Wars: Underworld

Star Wars: Underworld
Lucasfilm

Announced in 2005, Star Wars: Underworld was a TV series which would have taken place between Episode III and Episode IV, and was set in the crime-infested lower levels of Coruscant.

The show was masterminded George Lucas, and was led by a huge creative team, including Doctor Who writer, Chris Chibnall and Battlestar Galactica's Ronald D. Moore. The series would have moved away from the Skywalker Saga, and would have focused on smaller stories, which would have told a larger narrative. With the likes of Daniel Logan rumoured to be dawning the Boba Fett armour for the series, the anticipation for Star Wars: Underworld continued to grow amongst the fandom.

Unfortunately, Underworld was put on the 'back-burner' over budgeting issues regarding the show's special effects. In an interview with IGN in 2010, George Lucas said that: "We can't figure out a way of doing it for less than $50 million an episode, and obviously we can't afford to do that." Lucas was also asked whether Underworld would eventually get released, to which he replied: "Yeah, I think it [special effects] will advance like everything else advances. We're working on more inexpensive ways of doing all the special effects."

Sadly, this would not be the case. Once Lucas sold the franchise in 2012, Underworld was permanently shelved, with there being no signs of restarting the project.


In this post: 
Star Wars
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Star Wars fanatic. Marvel lover. DC enjoyer.