10 Characters The MCU Wishes It Could've Introduced Differently

Cameos, post-credits and bad casting? Here's a little bit of hindsight, heading into 2020.

Black Widow Avengers Interrogation
Marvel Studios

Without wishing to trigger a raft of "faaaaaanbooooooy" chants, there isn't much that Marvel has got wrong over the last few years. Yes, we've personally pulled up some plot holes and logical gaps in the narrative, but in broad strokes, everything usually averages out a success. But given the number of films and the sheer amount of time that has passed, a lot of these decisions tend to get made on the fly.

Whether it's production issues, casting problems, or just flat out changing their minds, the MCU has needed more than a few course corrects over the last decade. By and large, they've gotten away with them, but a few just haven't quite sat right when watching in hindsight. Unlike the Avengers themselves though, Marvel Studios are not blessed with a time machine and just have to live with these decisions.

But what if? What if they could have their time back and rewrite, reimagine and even recast some of their iconic heroes and villains? Who would be top of that particular list, and how exactly would they want to change them? Well, based on... uh... everything since, those answers are glaringly obvious.


10. War Machine

Iron Man Terrence Howard
Marvel

Real talk, Terrence Howard is actually really good as James Rupert "Rhodey" Rhodes in the first Iron Man movie. Given this was the MCU's first official outing and there was nothing but the weird Hulk films and Fantastic Four messes to judge it by (Maguire-era Spider-Man doesn't count because Maguire-era Spider-Man was a law unto itself) he put down one of the strongest Marvel supporting roles we'd ever seen.

Even his very cheesy War Machine tease of "next time, baby" in the film's final act got the response the studio wanted. It hinted at a wider universe of material to pull from, and let fans know that there would be plenty more of these movies in the pipeline. However Howard arrived as the movie's highest-paid actor and, following the massive pay rise Robert Downey Jr was due for the sequel, was pushed out in favour of Don Cheadle.

Marvel would have been taking a huge gamble in predicting the next 10 years of the MCU's critical and financial success but, in hindsight, they'll wish they'd cast for the long-term rather than the short. Given how Cheadle has defined the role in the subsequent movies, they'll have wished dearly they could have introduced it with him.


9. Sharon Carter

Captain America Civil War Steve Rogers Sharon Carter
Marvel Studios

This was weird.

Steve Rogers' story is that of a man who, finally finding a place in the world and the woman of his dreams, is frozen in time and awakens to discover that everything has changed. The wold he fought for is unrecognizable, and the woman he wanted to spend the rest of his life with has lived an entire life without him. Tearfully, in Civil War, he attends her funeral.

THEN NECKS ON WITH HER GRANDDAUGHTER!!! What!? Steve mate, she's been in the ground for 2 days at this point and you're copping off with her only living relative?! It was honestly as if Marvel had been really annoyed at the reaction to the Widow/Banner romance and decided to put it into context by showing them what wEiRd really looked like.

Sharon Carter is such an important part of modern-day S.H.I.E.L.D in the comics, and such a great character full stop, that relegating her to an awkward love interest in Civil War is one of Marvel's biggest creative missteps.


8. All The TV Characters

The Defenders Luke Cage Jessica Jones Matt Murdock
Netflix

Bottom line here, Marvel sold Jessica Jones, Daredevil, Luke Cage, Iron Fist and everybody else in those shows to Netflix almost entirely on the assumption they'd never have their own streaming service with which to properly use them.

Don't get me wrong, Netflix did a good job with them (both first seasons of DD and JJ are phenomenal, and Luke Cage is great in parts... we'll not talk about the rest) but these are not entirely considered part of the MCU now. They are, in a sense, but Marvel Studios doesn't pay them a second thought when planning out its own future. That's a shame too, as New York remains such a vital part of the movies it would be great to get the odd crossover.

Had Marvel known that Disney+ would be a thing by 2019, they would have held back on all of these titles and undoubtedly made some of them themselves. All the forthcoming shows on the network will connect directly to the MCU in one way or another, and it's a genuine shame that the existing Netflix efforts don't.

They might, one day, but the current agreement between Disney and Netflix means there's a cooling-off period for the characters that will last a few years. Fingers crossed they'll resurface one day.


7. Spider-Man

civil war spiderman
Marvel Studios

How Marvel finally managed to introduce Spider-Man to the MCU was, I'll just get this out of the way early, perfect. Given the problems over the licensing, the endless negotiations with Sony, and where the overall story was at the time, they absolutely nailed the introduction. Here was a young boy, new to his powers and going unnoticed, suddenly thrust into a much bigger adventure.

But this introduction is only perfect in the context of the licensing issues. Marvel would never, in a million years, have wanted Spider-Man to be a supporting character in an Avengers film before getting his own shoe-horned introduction some 8 years after the franchise started. They'd have wanted him to be front and centre from the very start being, as he is, their most bankable box office commodity. Iron Man seemed like a risk in 2008, Captain America seemed like a gamble in 2011, Thor seemed like an absurd choice that same year, if they'd had Spider-Man, they'd had led with him.

It's all worked out for the best (current status with Sony pending) and Tom Holland's role in the MCU has been one of the highlights of the entire thing, but if Marvel had a clean slate to work with when planning all of this out you can bet they'd have written his role very, very differently.


6. Black Widow

Iron Man 2 Deleted Scene Black Widow
Marvel Studios

Natasha Romanoff has been a problem for Marvel. Not a big one, not a glaring one, but a character that has caused much head-scratching in board room and script reads alike. In short, she was meant to be a background character in the first Avengers film, and then occasionally pop up throughout the MCU to add star-power to the standalone movies of more marketable heroes.

Scarlet Witch, Captain Marvel, and The Wasp were supposed to be the franchise's leading ladies (and Widow's two-dimensional writing in the early films proves) but, typically, Marvel spent too long getting around to them. All the while, Scarlett Johansson made the character feel like the warm light that all the other Avengers were just having to orbit around, she felt way, way more important than Marvel ever intended her to be.

A standalone Black Widow movie then became the only film fans seemed to actively demand, but the problem was they couldn't fit it in until after the decision to kill the character had been made. The compromise is a slightly awkward origin story for someone who's already been written out. Had Marvel known how popular she'd become, she'd likely have been afforded this privilege much, much earlier on.


5. Adam Warlock

Adam Warlock Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2
Marvel Studios

Of all the characters from Marvel's comics who haven't yet had their importance translated onto the big screen, Adam Warlock is easily in the Top... hmmm... Top 5?.. maybe Top 3? In a weird way, his moment has passed him by, as he's so integral to the Infinity Gauntlet story, but he's still crying out for a proper introduction.

Thus he was teased during the post-credits of Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, and naturally, fans speculated that we'd soon be seeing him added to the impending Infinity Wars movie. That was maybe a little fanciful given where the story already was in the MCU, but nobody at Marvel foresaw the impending disaster that was going to be Guardians 3. James Gunn has returned, but the film has now been pushed back to Phase 5.

Had Marvel known just how long the gaps would be between 2 and 3 they'd likely have introduced him elsewhere in the franchise, or simply not at all. If there was no chance of him arriving for the one story he's usually associated with, there's an argument you don't need him at all. But just having him arrive in the immediate aftermath as a supporting figure for the Guardians feels weirder still.


4. Quicksilver

Avengers Quicksilver
Marvel

This one, admittedly, isn't Marvel's fault. Whatever you might think about Age of Ultron or how it handled the Maximoff twins, Quicksilver's death has been used to fully inform Scarlet Witch's character arc going forward. She's one of the more complex and engaging heroes, and a lot of that stems from the trauma of losing her brother.

But, but but but but but, had Marvel known just how well Fox was going to nail the exact same character, they'd likely have rewritten their version.

There hasn't been too much that McAvoy X-Men universe has got right, but Evan Peters' portrayal as Quicksilver has provided it with some of the best scenes in any superhero film of the last few years. The exploding mansion, the bullet dodging, all of it has been some seminal effects work that makes full use of what's so interesting about the character.

Had Marvel known just how upstaged their version of Peter Maximoff would be, they'd either have given him Aaron Taylor-Johnson a lot more to do in the role or simply written him out entirely. The comparisons between the two don't ever come off favourably for Marvel.


3. The Mandarin

Mandarin Iron Man 3
Marvel Studios

In all honesty, I don't think Marvel really realised how much people cared when they made Iron Man 3. In the here and now we all know now that this wonderful interconnected shared universe gets scrutinised and poured over to within an inch of its life, with every single trivial detail fair game for theorising and extrapolation. But back in 2013, I think they thought they were just having some fun with some movies.

Thus when they announced that the villain for the closing chapter in Tony Stark's personal trilogy would be The Mandarin, historically his greatest ever adversary and a character who had given Marvel comics some of its greatest ever conflicts, fans were ecstatic. The Ben Kingsley showed up as... an actor... from England... called Trevor. You could hear the disappointed sighs from space.

After the inevitable (and justified) backlash over this, Marvel attempted to remedy it with an admittedly excellent One Shot sketch, but the damage had been done. Given the chance for a do-over, they'd either have rewritten Iron Man 3 entirely or kept The Mandarin on ice until they knew how to introduce him properly.


2. The Incredible Hulk

The Incredible Hulk
Universal

In short, Marvel doesn't wish they'd introduced him differently, they just wish they'd introduced him at all.

The Black Sheep of the MCU, The Incredible Hulk movie was an MCU film before there was even really and MCU. Officially, it's the start point of the whole thing, but in spirit, it's always felt like it sits apart from all the others. It really shouldn't Marvel Studios made it, William Hurt's General Ross has reappeared in other movies and there's even a post-credits scene featuring Robert Downey's Jr's Tony Stark.

But the problem is, all of this came only a few years after 2003's Hulk, which led pretty much everyone (critics and fans alike) to question why this movie needed to be made in the first place. Not realising the grand overarching plan Marvel Studios had for the MCU, this seemed like a needless cash grab and, ironically, grossed the lowest of any film in the franchise.

Had Norton continued on as Bruce Banner, it might have made a lot more sense artistically, but Mark Ruffalo replacing him in the role means that this movie still sticks out like a sore thumb.


1. Thanos

Thanos marvel
Marvel Studios

It's honestly a crying shame that the MCU's best villain (arguably even its best character full stop) was initially introduced the way he was. With some corny warning message about why you shouldn't take on Earth because, pffft, I mean, like 6 people will stop you, the camera pans across a mysterious spacial void to reveal... I weird, rubbery, Mastiff-looking purple wedge in a silly helmet. This was how we met Thanos.

Compared to the performance Josh Brolin would later put in during Infinity War, this is an almost comical representation of the Mad Titan. He looks cheap, he looks awkward, he looks like he was made on a laptop in a pub with only the big lad from the McDonald's Happy Meals for inspiration. He is not believable as a threat to a man with a bow and arrow, never mind the entire galaxy.

Why Marvel simply haven't reshot this with Brolin and added it to all future releases of the movie and its DVDs is beyond me. It could be done in a few minutes and would go light-years to making the whole Infinity Saga feel like more of a cohesive story. You can hardly blame Marvel for this in fairness but had they any idea of how important Thanos would become, they'd never have shot their load over this meagre tease.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Marvel MCU
 
First Posted On: 
Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine