10 Common Misconceptions About Science In Film And TV That Bug Real Scientists

Some of the most annoying misconceptions from the bizarre to the downright dangerous...

Harley Quinn Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

It’s no secret that when it comes to the portrayal of science in TV and cinema, that reality is often an afterthought.

For most people, this is not an issue. Cinema is escapism. Fantasy. Fiction to blunt the real world. So some fantasticism is fine.

That being said, for those whose lives revolve around the subject, spending their days to produce new innovations and research to better society and the lives of many others, this can become rather irksome, especially when these misconceptions become widespread beliefs due to their continued use throughout various media.

This however is not true for all movies and TV shows, 2019’s Dark Waters for instance, which depicted a more accurate account of the work scientists conduct, though with a few embellishments. These representations however are in the vast minority.

10. Mutations Mean Superpowers

The Incredible Hulk
Marvel Studios

Let’s start out with a rather obvious, but no less irritating example. How often is it that we see on our screens someone suffering a horrible and tragic accident, generally involving some kind of radiation or chemical spill, leading to alterations in their DNA that give them superpowers?

Well my friends, for those of you who may have slept through science class I regret to inform you that in the real world this would not happen. (I know, I know, a shocking revelation). But what would actually happen?

This all depends on numerous factors, for example: the intensity and type of radiation, what part of the DNA is affected, and just random luck. Whatever the case however, the outcomes are never good.

Say you were in a lab and were blasted with a burst of high energy Gamma radiation which shredded your DNA. Your two likeliest outcomes from this are either a somewhat fast and painful death as your body begins to disintegrate from the inside (we’ve all heard of radiation poisoning, right?), or a highly aggressive development of cancer in your body, followed shortly by once again, painful death.

This would happen for most chemicals and radiation that alters your body’s DNA. Each one of your DNA containing cells has many varied systems that examine for the signs of DNA damage. If any of these signs are recognised and are deemed irreparable (much like what would happen with high intensity radiation) the cell essentially initiates a self-destruct sequence known as apoptosis. If this occurs in enough cells, it will lead to a breakdown of tissues, resulting in multiple organ failure.

Moreover, if these alterations in DNA happen to affect enough of these cellular systems directly, the self-destruct sequence may never be started, and a rapidly dividing, immortal cell line can come into existence, more commonly known as cancer.

Less intense, lower energy radiation, such as UV-light, may only penetrate the top layers of the skin, and cause much less significant damage to the body’s systems. Some of the DNA may even be able to be repaired without issue. Repairs like these are not infallible regrettably and may lead to skin cancer. In order to negate this, the cells will often just commit suicide, resulting in what we call sunburn.

But if these mutations can occur so frequently, such as with UV light, and as mutations are meant to give superpowers, why has nobody come forward yet with such powers?


9. Human Genetic Engineering

gattaca Ethan Hawke
Columbia Pictures

Far too often do we see stories flaunting the idea that in the not too distant future, and generally based on technologies we have today, genetic engineering will be advanced enough to create so-called “designer babies”.

These are repeatedly described as individuals with the traits deemed perfect by modern standards: usually high intelligence, tall stature, and athletic. Once “perfected”, they then begin to replace ordinary folk in the job market, making them obsolete (think the movie GATTACA).

This grievance expressed by scientists could however fall within what you may consider “near future”, as it is entirely possible that this could become the case in a few centuries.

Unfortunately, with the current understanding of genetics and methods available, it is highly unlikely that this will arise within the lifetimes of anyone reading this, unless a miracle takes place in the upcoming decades.

A large contributor to this misconception is how people see these traits, such as height. Schools often teach that there is one gene for tallness and one for shortness. If this were true, then of course we could eventually become a race of super tall beings.

Regrettably, the reality is that there are 1000s of genes that contribute to an individual’s height, each with a very small contribution (think half a millimetre per gene or less in some cases).

Current methods (yes, including CRISPR) cannot feasibly edit genes to give a desired effect for just this one trait, never mind the many others.


8. Nuclear Annihilation

Modern Warfare Nuke
Activision

Countless stories exist in which nukes are launched across the globe leading to the total destruction of the Earth, with the few remaining survivors scavenging and killing for the last few scraps available.

Well, as hopefully you’ve figured out by now, I’m here to tell you that this is wrong (sorry to all of you with hopes and aspirations of living in a post-apocalyptic society, maybe the zombies can have your back on this one. Though the portrayal of zombies opens up another warm body of worms).

The fact is, that although nuclear bombs can cause destruction on unequivocal levels, there just is not enough nuclear payload available to destroy all of Earth.

In fact, a study was recently carried out simulating what would happen if conflicts between North Korea and the USA escalated into a global nuclear war. In this scenario, most countries actually survive relatively unscathed, largely due to lots of open and unused space in many countries. Only two nations came out of the simulations completely destroyed, the UK and North Korea. Sorry readers from either.

Yes, this would result in a change to the global economy and environment, but not a species-ending, long-scale nuclear winter and post-apocalyptic wasteland you see so frequently.


7. Car Crash Flight

Deadpool Car Flip
20th Century Fox

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, it’s a vehicle that just crashed at high speed. Or so we are led to believe by the movies.

This myth is so prevalent that even the Mythbusters tested this one (sort of).

If TV and movies are meant to be believed, then every time a bike or car is crashed, it will inevitably twist and fly up into the air as if propelled upwards by an unseen force, and frequently will be on fire.

What if I told you that there is no unseen force that leads to this unscheduled flight plan, and in the overwhelming majority of cases, unless someone attached explosives to the underside of the vehicle, it will stay largely planted to the ground.

Unless there is an overall resultant force occurring on the vehicle going upwards, it would not be possible to follow this trajectory.

As a bonus to this misconception, the gas tank is also unlikely to explode in a great ball of fire when a car or bike crashes.


6. Overestimation Of Scientists’ Abilities

Mark Watney the martian science the shit
20th Century Fox

You’d think that scientists would be overjoyed with people thinking that they’re good at everything, right? Wrong!

It turns out that scientists often want an accurate portrayal of the truth, even if that comes at the expense of their image.

TV and cinema portray scientists as either young, attractive models, or geriatric lunatics with frizzy grey/white hair, depending on the effect they are going for. However, one trait that is shared by all these scientists on screen is that they are experts in everything.

One time they may be shown to be an expert biochemist, then upon their next appearance suddenly they are also an expert in quantum physics, whereas in the next scene they are the world’s best hacker and computer scientist.

While it may be true that a scientist may have a more versatile knowledge of different aspects of various sciences, largely due to a keen interest in science which may have resulted in a greater scientific education than the general public, being an expert in all these different things just isn’t realistic.

Sure, with enough time and effort it may be feasible, but this is akin to someone learning a second language and people expecting them now to speak every language that ever existed by age 20.


5. Vats

The Joker Vat Chemicals
DC Comics

A quick one here to start the top 5.

Chemical companies, from ACE chemicals to Duff beer, are depicted as having large open vats of their, often highly dangerous product, with flimsy walkways suspended above them, just waiting for someone to fall in.

Not only is this a health and safety nightmare for the people who unfortunately meet their demise from a fateful fall, but would also result in large contamination from the air and people travelling on said aforementioned walkways.

These products can be ruined by even the smallest amount of contamination, such as hair or bacteria that could become a potential problem in the future, costing the company thousands.

It might make a good story device for the creation of the clown prince of crime, but there are innumerable safety precautions in place that would have prevented this.


4. Laser Guns

Storm Trooper
Lucasfilm

Star Wars and Star Trek have transcended both TV and film. Though not the sole reason for this misconception, they have had a large contribution at its perpetuation. I am of course talking about laser weapons.

Whenever a laser is fired from a gun in these films/ shows, a clear small beam of energy is can be seen leaving the barrel and travelling for a short time before hitting its target. Quite often this provides enough time for someone to viably dodge the laser if they have fast reflexes.

But where does the term laser come from? Laser is actually an acronym standing for Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation. Let’s focus on that first word, “light”.

The speed of light in a vacuum is 299,792,458 m/s (it is similar through air), whereas the speed of a regular projectile bullet is around 400 m/s.

You’d be hard pressed to see a bullet travelling this fast, let alone dodge it, so why does some that travels so much faster seem so much slower? Short answer is, it shouldn’t.

This is ok for the large distances of space, in which it may take several seconds for the light to travel from ship to ship, but in a small area, such as a palace throne room, this should be essentially instantaneous.

But what if you were the thing travelling at light speed? How do TV and Movies show this?


3. Travelling At Light Speed

Millenium Falcon Star Wars Rise Of Skywalker
LucasFilm

Light speed and relativity are tricky things to understand, that’s why it took a literal Einstein to help work out many of these concepts. However, scientists are a finickity bunch and won’t even give studios a pass for this.

When it comes to the many representations of light speed travel there are numerous faults, many more than can be detailed here, however most scientists, when asked, said their main issues are with time and mass.

When it comes to light speed, time starts to get a bit freaky. Imagine if you will you are on a ship travelling at light speed (299,792,458 m/s) towards a destination 5 billion light years away, ignoring the expansion of space, how long do you think it would take for your journey?

Well, that all depends on who you ask.

For you, the journey would be instantaneous. Not figuratively instantaneous. Literally. The passage of time does not exist at this speed.

However, for someone on observing you from the planet you started from, it would take 5 billion years (space-time and relativity- It’s weird). Just think about that for a second. 5 billion years ago the Earth didn’t exist. So many things will have changed in that time.

Granted the distances portrayed on screen are often much smaller distances, but even travelling 1000 light years would have a significant impact on what you found when returning home, entire civilisations could have risen and fallen in this time and coordination of entire fleets of ships would be impossible.

Those familiar with DC’s The Flash may also be aware of the problem with mass. Travelling this fast would give every one of your molecules infinite mass. Which in addition to killing you, would destroy everything in your wake, creating numerous blackholes and essentially breaking physics and spacetime.

Not only this but if Einstein’s famous equation of E=MC2 is true, then infinite mass requires infinite energy (the M and E parts respectively), meaning an infinite amount of energy is required to move something with mass to lightspeed (without using something that can shorten the length of spacetime, such as a warp drive).

Surprisingly, this is not the only misconception that involves The Flash.


2. Fast As A Flash

Cookie Monster Waiting
Disney

Despite what you may see on screen, science just doesn’t work that fast.

Time after time you’ll see scientific montages in which everything just works immediately, and the results are gathered in a short time frame. This is exemplified on CW’s The Flash in which the eponymous main character uses his super speed to analyse samples of DNA and other forensic evidence.

The sad reality is that most scientific processes take a certain amount of time to complete, often a long time. So its all well and good that Barry Allen can use his super speed to not have to use a centrifuge, but the next part of the analysis would just be waiting 4-10 hours for some processes, such as DNA amplification, to occur. These processes also have a relatively high failure rate and the whole methodology may need to be started again from the beginning and may take days or weeks to get results; this is often left out of these montages.

Additionally, most of the labs involved, such as in forensics, may be elsewhere in the country, or at least somewhere far away from the detective needing answers, further increasing the time taken.

I’d like to give a shout out to 2019’s Dark Waters film, in which a major source of drama revolved around the years it took to analyse the sheer volume of large data sets and get meaningful, verified results. This film took the real-life story and portrayed it on screen. Hopefully helping dispel the trope that science is instant.


1. Meds For Mental Illness

Health vitamins pills
Pixabay

So far, we’ve talked about 9 misconceptions that in their most part only lead to mild inconvenience or annoyance. But what if these myths caused serious detriments to health and wellbeing? That is why this entry takes the top spot.

Far too frequently do we see the cliché of someone suffering from a mental illness dropping their prescription meds into the trash. Suddenly, they are the happiest and most stable they’ve ever been, and life couldn’t get better for them.

If you are suffering from a mental illness, I cannot stress enough how much you should not follow this misconception. These pills are prescribed for a reason, and that reason is to make you better and help you live the life you deserve to be having.

You wouldn’t take the insulin from a diabetic, throw it away and tell them to go live their life. You wouldn’t tell a cancer patient to stop undergoing chemotherapy and tell them to go for a walk and things will get better. So why would you do it for someone with a mental illness?

I am not a licenced medical professional, so what I say here should not be taken as gospel, always consult your doctor first if you can.

To end, if any of you are suffering from a mental illness or any of their symptoms, just know that you are wanted, and the world is a better place having you in it. There are numerous support groups that you can find to help you through this. Even if not, every day you get through is a little victory, and that is the key to a better life. Things can get better.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Science
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Time's Person of the Year for 2006