10 Common Mistakes Comic Book Movies Make

the riddler Who doesn't like a good comic book movie? According to the latest film trends, nobody. The Avengers (or Avengers Assemble, depending on your country of choice) and The Dark Knight Rises have combined made more than two and a half billion dollars and those are only the latest films in franchises that have set the film world on fire. Comic book films are back! Rising from the travesty of Joel Schumacher and bad special effects and ready to blow your mind with its fantastical characters, settings and all-round outright fun. Excelsior! Of course we all know things aren't perfect and I'm not here to criticise a genre for not being perfect, but there are some mistakes that just keep on getting made that bring comic book films down a peg. It just so happens to be one of the trappings when making a comic book film that it will always be compared to the property it is adapting. Very few genres have this pressure and as a result, the film's characters and plot come under fire for not being 'right' when compared to what we've read. These ten problems aren't universal and there are always films that don't have them but they sure are mistakes that comic book films make more so than others. We start at the top with...

10. Getting The Wrong Leading Man

constantine fixed Some comic book movies are sold by their heroes and some are sold by their leading stars. This has been used in a variety of ways, including introducing people to Men in Black via the '90s superstar that was Will Smith and revitalising the career of Robert Downey Jr. For years, leading actors have been the gateway for many people to fall in love with their new favourite characters. Christopher Reeve as Superman. Chris Hemsworth as Thor. Keanu Reeves as John Constantine. Wait. What? Lord knows I could probably count on one hand the amount of people I know who, when given even a basic description of John Constantine, would think Keanu Reeves should play him. He isn't even that bad in the film, he just really misses out on portraying Constantine how he should be on screen. Comic book films are largely comprised of characters who have years of back-story and, perhaps more challenging for Mr. Reeves, personality. Therefore, when trying to sell the public on these fantastically people, why not get a good name attached? This problem comes low on the list as films have generally gotten it right. Christian Bale, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellon and many others have been big draws for the start of their respective comic book franchises but sometimes actors just do not fit or don't bring any appeal to the film at all. Did we really want to see Seth Rogan as the Green Hornet? Sylvester Stallone as Judge Dredd? Also, does anyone know, without the aid of Google, who Ioan Gruffudd is? If you do, congratulations, because I needed Wikipedia to tell me that he was Mister Fantastic.

9. Giving Characters Stupid Costumes

goblin fixed A lot of comic book characters have had a lot of different looks over their history. Even someone like the Joker, whose entire 'costume' is usually just make-up on his face and some raggedy clothes, has been remade many different times by the various actors who have played him. Sometimes, though, the wealth of choice or an iconic look just isn't enough and a new costumes needs to be made for a character to really shine on the big screen. Other times, we get nipples on the Batsuit and the Green Goblin looking like a Power Ranger villain. Considering Spider-Man came out a decade ago, the special effects are still great. Maybe that says something about the effects industry becoming more stable and the leaps not being as big and the early SFX, nothing can help the mockery that is the Green Goblin suit. It's just one example of costumes that even for the time they were made, have to raise some questions as to what the film-makers were thinking. The most recent offender of this has been Green Lantern who ended up looking like an invitee to a green themed masquerade ball.

8. Abandoning The Source Material

wanted fixed Adapting anything for the screen undoubtedly calls for some change. Some things need to be altered or cut altogether, but certainly what you have left after the alterations needs to be comparable to what you were supposed to be adapting to begin with. So how is it that Wanted, a comic book series about super-villains, drops the entire super-villain fraternity concept, as well as a couple of other key characters for good measure, to become a James McAvoy and Angelina Jolie action romp? I can imagine that some things just need to be changed. Wanted has a character made entirely of poo in it, which is not exactly mass appeal right there but how many changes can you make before you might as well release it under a different name? Constantine is another offender of this as, completely overlooking the altered storylines and made up abilities that John Constantine never had, Keanu Reeves was cast to play a Liverpudlian who looks like Sting. Sorry to bring that up again, but it's just so stupid.

7. Replacing Actors Rather Than Characters

rhodey fixed Perhaps this is one that studios just can't get around, or maybe it doesn't matter as much right now, but having different people play the same characters across a comic book franchise is less than ideal. Comic book films are now the interest of the general public and main characters are being brought together so now we can see Robert Downy Jr, Chris Evans and Chris Hemsworth come together in one film as well as, Mark Ruffalo? Wasn't it Ed Norton before? And what happened to Rhodey? And why is Chris Evans playing ANOTHER comic book character? Again, I can forgive it as I have a stronger grasp on the characters on show than the random passer-by on the street, but I can imagine that random person wondering why some characters rather than overs are played by different people. The main problem, which we may have had a glimpse with in the form of the Hulk, is when the main characters needs to change. What if Robert Downey Jr doesn't want to be Iron Man forever and the franchise needs to keep going? Replace him? Kill him? If you do, you've just killed marketable Intellectual Property, and you know how well the comic book industry deals with that.

6. Not Giving Characters Their Due

cyclops fixed News flash time. Comic book fans are, sometimes, picky. Therefore if you're adapting a comic book franchise and putting the characters on screen, you need to stay faithful to the versions that your core audience have become attached to. So when X-Men: The Last Stand decides to kill off Cyclops out of the blue, it isn't surprising that it will upset some people. Okay. A lot of people. The real hard part about this point is that, of course, with films you cannot always give ample time or story focus to every character that is worthy of it. While this is the case, some characters are just totally overlooked or played incorrectly. What is the only thing we remember from Storm in the entire X-Men trilogy? A crappy joke about a toad being struck by lightning. Other characters included but not given their due include Volstagg from Thor and the Katayanagi twins from Scott Pilgrim. Perhaps Volstagg is more of a personal preference as I love the charismatic, blundering figure who loves to tell stories about himself but the Twins don't even get any lines in Scott Pilgrim vs The World.

5. Assuming Comic Book Films Are Action Films

hex fixed I have to be careful here and make it clear that I don't assume that a bad comic book film was made lazily and was banking on either the property it was adapting or the fact that comic book films are popular. Green Lantern and Spider-Man 3 are examples of lacklustre comic book films that require action. Green Lantern completely missed the space-opera, Star Wars style action that made the Geoff Jones run popular, but it is an action book. Some comic book movies, on the other hand, are given the action treatment when a different, often more faithful, look would have done better. Why? Because action has featured so much in the most popular comic book films that studios likely feel that it will be a safe bet. Here's a pitch for you. A Western starring Josh Brolin as a scarred, tough as nails bounty hunter with Michael Fassbender, Michael Shannon and Will Arnet as the supporting cast. Not a half bad idea right? Apart from the fact that I'm talking about Jonah Hex and the movie was made with Megan Fox and enough explosions get rid of half of the old West. If the Jonah Hex property had the same cast and was treated like a gritty Western rather than an action film I doubt it would've been the critically panned afterthought we actually received.

4. Using Franchise Building Stingers

thanos fixed I'm all for superhero films setting up a separate universe so that they can all be linked together. It was the next, logical step for the films to take so that they more closely gave us the superhero experience on screen. I remember years ago a throwaway line in Batman Forever Dick Greyson is attempting to catch up to the travlling circus after his parents have died and Bruce Wayne attempts to dissuade him with €œIt has to be almost halfway to Metropolis by now€. This blew my mind. If Superman lived in the same world as Batman, why not just call him up and get him to help out with Two-Face and the Riddler? Keep in mind, this is before I learnt that Batman absolutely hates asking people for help. So comic book films building franchises is good. The way its being done, particularly by Marvel, is starting to become a detriment as whichever film you watch involves a stinger building you up for the next film. Keep in mind you've just sat through a two hour film devoted to one character, can't we revel in the equilibrium of a job well done before we get teased for another movie? Again using Captain America as an example, the film ends with Steve Rogers waking up in the real world alive and well but having lost the world and people he knew. It's a solemn victory that leaves us guessing where he will go on from here. But you better buckle your seats, comic book fans, because here comes the Avengers trailer so quickly cut that if you blink you might just miss Hawkeye firing at something off screen or Thor standing next to a table. It completely breaks the tension by sprinkling you with excitement for the future, making you forget about the characters you've just watched. If you saw Captain America in the cinema, did you talk to your friends about it before the Avengers Assemble trailer? In the Avengers film itself we're left with the image of Thanos sneering at the camera. The leader of the army that was just defeated and assumed villain of a film that will be out in two year's time. Now that is what I call closure.

3. Creating A World Without Consequences

explosion fixed Iron Man fires at an army of robot suits who are chasing behind him. Many of them, perhaps the ones with the machine guns, perhaps those housing the guided missiles, are hit and crash to the floor in a wild explosion. This explosion occurs, knocks over a towering glass statue of some kind and people run away in a scream of terror. Is anyone killed? Hell, is anyone hurt? Nope, because even if a super-villain send a squadron of drones after a man piloting a suit so powerful it can take out a tank, not one civilian will get caught in the cross hair. Am I asking for innocent people to be slaughtered? No, but I'm already suspending my belief to include the existence of a superhero, or a Asgardian God depending on your film of choice, so why can't the world at least react realistically to the carnage that seems to follow these people? The everyday man in the Marvel Universe should be scared out of his mind right now and who knows, maybe in the Phase Two run of films we'll see this in the aftermath of the failed Chitauri invasion. I sincerely hope we do, because it isn't just the super-villains (and that one henchman from Captain America who gets thrown into a propeller) who need a little death now and then.

2. Thinking Everyone Has Batman's Rogues Gallery

whiplash fixed It would appear now that, in the wake of the massive Avengers success, not only is the cinematic comic book universe coming together, but also that characters are turning into individual franchises. Obviously this isn't the first time this has happened, the four '80s Superman movies are all sequential and the Burton-Shumacher Batman films all come within nine years of each other and can be seen as together. Yes, even Batman and Robin. You've got to take the bad with the good, people. The problem with this is that Batman and Superman have much stronger rogues galleries than the likes of Hulk and Iron Man. Here are two examples. Batman has the Joker, Two-Face, Ra's Al Ghul, Bane, the Riddler and Catwoman who all have enough of a recognised history in the comic universe to appeal to a mass audience at the box office. Iron Man has Iron Monger (admittedly a good origin bad guy) and the Mandarin who is good for mass appeal, but then the well starts to run dry. It's the product of taking superheroes who were, largely, not A-list reads before the Avengers plan picked up speed with the Iron Man film, making them the key draws. Iron Man leads the Marvel universe and the well of super-villains is already running dry. And we all know what happens next...

1. Thinking More Villains Mean A Better Threat

venom fixed The first movie in any comic book franchise, even more so for the superhero variety, has an easy out in terms of storytelling. A character's origin offers a dramatic change for the character early in the story with great consequences whether that be in the form of them discovering their powers or putting themselves on the road to the dedication of crime fighting. A superhero's first movie outing is often entertaining but, let's face it, predictable. So once you have the likes of Robert Downy Jr surprise everyone with his best Tony Stark, how do you take things to the next level for the inevitable sequel? If you answered €œuse the character's heroic status against him and essentially ruin his world€ then you win. Instead, what we often we get is the hero facing multiple villains because we are supposed to assume that more villainous characters means more threat. This is not at all the case. Spider-Man goes through a lot more turmoil facing just Doctor Octopus than he does against The Sandman, Harry Osborne and Venom. Iron Man 2, despite having Sam Rockwell absolutely, well... rock playing Justin Hammer, proves to be a showcase for Tony Stark's talents as he defeats two people at once and proves himself smarter than his super-computer house butler by inventing a new element to cure his poorly conceived, life threatening illness. Look at almost any sequel and you'll see the villain count increase. Don't get me wrong, multiple villains can work, as long as the threat itself is focused. Captain America has the Red Skull and Arnim Zola, but Zola is clearly the subordinate who acts as a right hand man. The Dark Knight Rises is the best example as no matter how many characters show up, Bane is always the focus. He arrives, defeats Batman, rules Gotham and is then defeated. Talia Al' Ghoul is revealed, but she's just a part of the team with Bane. Catwoman takes care of herself and who didn't love seeing Jonathan Crane dishing out exiles to the corrupt Gothamites? I just wish characters were treated like this in every comic book sequel.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A Cinema and Photography graduate whose media exposure has amounted to little more than an amateur comics society podcast and a one minute radio discussion about cantaloupe melons. Reader of Vertigo, watcher of Doctor Who, lover of everything film. Tweet in his direction @Story24