10 Crazy Directors Who Went Completely Over The Top

zack snyder sucker punch A film director is someone who has to tap dance on a carefully constructed stage centered on their own creativity, audience expectations and commercial concerns. It's a carefully choreographed ritual as strange and nuanced as a peacock mating dance. A director who skillfully shows his feathers can ride a wave of adulation that causes him to lose control of the mesmerizing performance. He can careen out of control like a creative Hindenburg flaming quickly to the ground. Everyone is at horrified and drawn to movies that are little else than creative tragedies. Films that are at the very least products of an introverted ego maniacs that some film makers have become. Compiled below are some of the greatest examples of directors who tuned out the world and decided what was happening in depths of their Psyche had to put to film with presumably only themselves considered as an audience. So join me on a trip to marvel at directors who committed creative kamikaze missions with insane bounce off the rubber room results.

10. Darren Aronofsky - Requiem for a Dream

requiem for a dream Many times films that spiral out of control are the direct result of overnight fame and success for a film maker. Such is the case of Requiem for a Dream. In 1998 Aronofsky released a small independent film PI which garnered heavy praise from critics. The film went on to earn several awards including the Directing Award at the Sundance Film Festival. PI was a densely layered psychological thriller populated by big philosophical ideas concerned ultimately with the very creation of life itself. It was however far from perfect but was definitely a minor league home run from a promising rookie. While I like PI I feel the movie received such high praise mostly because critics become bored watching the same tired plot formulas over and over again. PI provided them with a vehicle to excite rarely used neurons and remember why film was their drug of choice. Speaking of highs imagine the effect this mountain of accolades had on Darren Aronofsky. Here he was the newly crowned king of the cinematic outsiders club and he had been given a platform to do anything he wanted for his next project. I'll tell you what happened - he lost his collective creative mind and ego. The premise of Requiem for Dream is to follow the lives of several drug addicts and their nightmare fueled lives. But honestly it doesn't really matter, the movie is really about Darren Aronofsky's self-indulgence-fueled trip in a creative overdose of his own. After the first 20 minutes or so of the film I came to realize what I was watching. It was the excitement of a child given a film camera desperate to prove what a genius he was. The camera flies around constantly, there are quick zooms, intense close-ups and enough steadicam work to break the back of the most herculean camera person. I could almost hear Aronofsky's voice, "Look what I can do!! See I'm a big boy director!" The film itself is based upon a book, but even considering this the ending is an overwrought piece of cheese. The last ten minutes of this film would make Sweeney Todd seem understated by comparison. It's a cacophony of campy gore, overstated slow motion shots, an in-your-face porn circus and fast paced editing. At the end of the film I wanted to scream "enough already boy genius we get how special you are!" Of course since this film Aronofsky has improved his control of the art form and produced such films Black Swan which is a nuanced classic. It's clear that Requiem was a teething ring for a promising director and I'm glad he was given the opportunity. It is clear however that Requiem was out of control.

9. Zack Snyder - Sucker Punch

The spotlight focused onto Zack Snyder with his serviceable remake of the zombie classic Dawn of the Dead in 2004. The film even won over die-hard fans of the George Romero horror classic. Snyder followed up his success with Dawn by adapting two well-regarded comics 300 and Watchmen. The resulting pictures emphasized his strengths and weaknesses as a film maker. Both films have fantastically choreographed action scenes, but when the action stops everything feels stilted and rehearsed. This is most glaringly apparent in Watchmen which stutter-stops its way through what feels like disconnected montages rather than a cohesive whole. Part of this is because of Snyder's slavish adherence to the comic book source material instead of properly translating it to film. Where he excels is in bold action scenes with large-scale presentations like the ones seen in Snyder's Man of Steel. He has proved himself an excellent technical director but not necessarily a proficient storyteller which created a huge gaping hole in his first self-written and directed project. Riding off of the success of Watchmen Warner Bros. basically decided to blindly accept Snyder's follow-up project from his production company Cruel and Unusual Films. The result of their faith was a cruel and unusual punishment on audiences all over the world. Sucker Punch concerns Baby Doll who is wrongly put into a mental asylum and must escape before she is lobotomized. The real surprise here is how the movie breaks the fourth wall by brutalizing the viewer into feeling they are actual lobotomy victims. Basically the entire film can be distilled into one nicely packaged analogy. Sucker Punch is every poorly crafted cut scene from every video game designed for 14-year-old boys. Snyder completely disregarded all sanity and reverted back to an attention-span-disordered child slapping everything he thought was "cool" up on the screen. Think of Jackson Pollock throwing random comic book pages onto a canvas of glue and you'll start to get an idea of what Sucker Punch is all about. Again there is nothing more dangerous than a film director being given the keys to the movie studio system without limits. What usually happens is the director with their new-found freedom will spiral out control like a creative Exxon Valdez. Given total control Zach Snyder assaults the system with hyper sexualized teenage fantasies filled with swords, mechs, dirty sex club inspired grinding and machine guns galore. Snyder was completely out of control and let his inner child run amok at everyone else's expense.

8. Happiness Of The Katakuris - Takashi Miike

TheHappinessOfTheKatakuris I know what you're thinking here, "Miike is one of the most insane directors that ever lived on planet earth! How can you possibly choose one film in which he went over the top? The man is insane!!" For those unfamiliar with Miike's work his filmography is equally prolific in output and general insanity. He belongs on this list because from viewing his films I'm not even sure he ever thinks of what a target audience might be. Some times it feels he is producing these oddities strictly for his own amusement. The reason I have chosen The Happiness of the Katakuris is just the outright creative whimsy and absurdity of it all. Miike is mostly known for violent horror tinged films with gonzo hyper stylized violence, but here he combined several competing ideas into a single film. A family comedy, zombie horror film and a Rodgers and Hammerstein style musical. The result is as charmingly deranged as a trip directly into someone's subconscious as they sleep. This is actually a complement to Miike since early film makers likened going to the movies as sharing dreams with others. The story of Happiness of The Katakuris involves a family that opens an Inn Near Mount Fuji in a remote area where no major road exist to drive there. Their first guest is a suicidal traveler who unfortunately works up his courage to commit the act. Sniffing bad publicity the family hides the body but future guests discover the deed causing more bodies to pile up until the films zany musical climax. During the entire film strange events and daft musical numbers work hard to chew up the scenery. This is a glorious example of a film maker out of control and going straight for the over the top gold medal. If you are going to see a Miike film this is one of his least violent and more creative films. In summary Miike is akin to the Hunter S Thompson of film making. His work is very stream of consciousness and seemingly audiences be damned.

7. Magnolia - Paul Thomas Anderson

magnolia

As you will notice young fledgling directors jumping head first into the ring fire to prove themselves is a reoccurring theme in this feature. Anyone in a highly competitive field is always gnashing at the bit to place themselves as worthy of respect and steal the spotlight for their own. Magnolia is a very much the work of a director strutting like a peacock trying to show his plumage all at once. Much like Quentin Tarantino, Anderson had a huge unexpected hit that accumulated a lot of respect. Boogie Nights was an epic that took place during the transformative era of the adult film industry. It was grand film with a large cast and was skillfully crafted. Boogie Nights was equally comedic, tragic and filled with operatic flourishes. So how did Anderson decide to follow-up this early success? By taking every element in Boogie Nights and amping it up to 11. Magnolia is as out of control and over the top as it can be. It's the product of an amassed ego and follow-up insecurities From the opening monologue voiced by magician Ricky Jay it's clear that Magnolia has pie in the sky Oscar award ceremony ambitions. As the film starts we are introduced to a "life the universe and everything" philosophy pretzel and the opening credit sequence hasn't even rolled yet. This is a dangerous position as a viewer because there are really only two possible outcomes 1. You are about to witness a life changing piece of cinema. 2. You are about to witness a pretentious over the top mess that tries too hard for greatness. Magnolia is definitely a number 2. The largest issue with the film is scope. This is a movie with NINE main characters and THREE interwoven dramatic tragedies . So here we have the operatic qualities of Boogie Nights taken to their bloated extremes. To Anderson's credit he does juggle all these puzzle pieces well. The issue lies in the excessive lentgh of the interweaving stories. It's almost as if he was surrounded by a crew who could not provide criticism and an editor who could not say no to Hollywood's newest whiz kid. There are many scenes that are repetitive and recycle the same themes. This is the most readily apparent with Tom Cruise's character Frank T.J Mackey. Frank has Mommy abandonment issues which he has chosen to deal with in public as a motivational speaker that hosts dating seminars for insecure men. We are treated to Frank's self hating womanizing pep rallies several times during the film. While this provides depth to the character we do not need to extended re-visits to this scenario. This is the mark of a director who is either in love with his material or believes the audience isn't smart enough to get the point without it being hammered home repeatedly . Along these same lines Magnolia allows scenes that go on for countless eternities. There is a lot of dramatic tension wasted by Anderson's inability to let go of a scene. There is a considerable lack of flow to large portions of the film because bloat is misunderstood as epic character development . The best example of this is the extended scene in which John C. Reilly whom plays a police officer visits the home of drug addict he decides to ask out on a date. Watch it for yourself it just doesn't know when to stop. Boogie Nights had a lot of great camera work , sweeping crane shots and long steady cam shots that followed multiple characters in a scene. In Magnolia it feels as if Anderson is pleading for attention with too many camera acrobatics. There are dramatic slow zooms that eat away at the films running time. In one instance I wasn't quite sure if I was going to end up in a microscopic view of William H. Macy's nose hairs in a zoom from across the bar. In another instance it would seem that Anderson was trying to out do himself by filming a single shot scene just to see if he could make it longer than the one in Boogie Nights. Makes me wonder if he handed out awards to himself after it's completion. "The award for longest steadicam single shot in one of my films goes to...ME!!" At any rate I've spent too long here on this subject and I could continue with a Magnolia sized diatribe but I'll provide a summary. Magnolia is like getting a large meal from a would be chef trying to impressive with buffet like quantities and far too many different over spiced flavors.

6. Antichrist - Lars Von Trier

fox1

Yes mister fox chaos does indeed reign in this sun-drenched delightful feel-good romp of the decade. Sarcasm aside there is something about Antichrist that makes you feel queasy. It feels forbidden like an artistically rendered expression of a mental disorder. Lars made this film after already being an established art house film maker . Even as an art house diva one needs to understand the concept of restraint especially when dealing with darker matters. Antichrist is so heavily focused on darkness that it comes across that the director is merely wallowing in depravity and despair . Lars has stated that he made this film to deal with his depression. Using art as a way of coping with one's emotions is not a new concept. There is however a difference between a painting, photograph, poem and a movie. One can look at a painting, process the content and move on quickly. Exposing someone to your emotional darkness and forcing them to wallow in it for two hours is something all together different. The film itself concerns a married couple who lose a son after he falls out of window while his parents are doing the horizontal bop in a nearby room. This causes them both to go insane and perform completely bizarre acts upon each other. Other than being morbidly dark the movie itself suffers mostly from over the top excess and a lack of subtlety. You know an art film is going horribly awry when the director just starts going gonzo insane pouring on sex and violence for shock value. Shock when done right is very effective as it is in A Clockwork Orange. In the wrong hands it can come across as unfocused artistic desperation (for example, Passion of The Christ). Such is the case here especially the last act which is filled with sexual violence. Lars seemed to be struggling with his inability to understand women in abstract brutal ways. This kind of outlandish psychological excess makes Sigmund Freud seem relevant again.Lars Von Trier used Antichrist to test the limit of his psyche. I have a suggestion for Lars. No one wants to sit in a dark room while you navel gaze at their expense. My advice to Lars is hire a therapist and down expect us to pay to be yours.

5. Gummo - Harmony Korine

korine korine gummo Gummo was the work of first time director Harmony Korine. The film is nothing more than a series of loose events that were completely improvised on the fly. Nothing actually seems considered to have actual meaning beyond shocking the audience. Korine was completely out of control and produced a pretentious incomprehensible mess of an art film that attempts to hide behind a nihilistic façade. Basically Gummo follows a group of kids in a narrative free "day in the life" style format. Tummler and Solomon the two main protagonists hunt feral cats and simply bumble into Velvet Elvis style white trash portraits. These scenarios have been dreamt up in the grind house mind of Korine or the hand-picked Ohio trailer trash that star in the film. They stumble into a man flirting with a gay dwarf, a creep peddling his down syndrome sister for prostitution, satanic rituals, skin heads boxing each other and a large assortment of other deranged dilemmas. Korine simply allowed the locals chosen for the film to get high and initiate whatever chaos they wanted to in front of the camera. Gummo was the equivalent of slumming on Youtube before there was a Youtube. There is something completely exploitative about the results of the film. It's like if Jackass attempted to have a storyline and present itself as art. Gummo is not art but the work of a director who thought himself to be an avant-garde genius and threw caution completely to the wind.

4. Meet The Feebles - Peter Jackson

meet_the_feebles3 Before everyone's favorite Kiwi produced bloated high fantasy epics staring sasquatch-footed little people he was a known B movie director. Jackson's early works existed in the dark corners of the video store far removed from the main stream. It's hard to choose which of Jackson's early works dove the furthest down the gonzo gore strewn slapstick rabbit hole, but for my money Meet The Feebles is the most bizarre film put out there by someone now considered a mainstream director. What we have here are essentially Muppets committing murder, making porn and doing drugs amongst other things. Offensive comedies can be funny but the Feebles just go far beyond the pale in an almost endless parade of depravity. The entire experience is surreal but not in a good way. Meet the Feebles feels like a self-indulgent "wouldn't it be funny if?" moment amongst friends who all found each other terribly funny one night while drinking. The next morning instead of realizing their folly decided to commit fully to their madness. The result is sporadically humorous but is mostly offensive and puerile. One can only stomach so many puppet orgasms and gory puppet deaths before waving the white flag of surrender.

3. The Fall - Tarsem

the-fall-by-tarsem1 Tarsem is an incredibly talented visual director that has an adept grasp on photographic composition. There are only a few directors living or otherwise that have such a command over their artistic vision. The one glaring problem with Tarsem as a film maker is that he seems to care little for telling a story. He only utilizes narrative as a skeletal frame-work to drape imagery on. His films are all painstakingly planned works of exquisite painterly beauty in the visual department. From the aspect of story Tarsem's films fall apart quickly and usually become nothing more than long parades of visual splendor. The Fall just happens to be the most excessively long, extravagant and self-indulgent film he has ever made. The story and structure of film is not unlike the works of Guillermo del Toro. The Fall is a fantasy film strongly grounded in reality and rich in metaphors. The Fall concerns Alexandria a little girl with a vivid imagination who is in a hospital in California in the early 1900's. There she meets Roy a movie stunt man who had an accident on the set of his most recent film. Roy feeds into Alexandria's imagination and tells her of grand adventures which in turn helps him recover from his mental and physical wounds. What sends The Fall over the edge is again excess on the part of the director. Tarsem is absolutely in love with his camera work and shot composition. He lets the camera linger for far to long in most shots and several sequences seem crammed into the film just because Tarsem liked them. While the narrative in The Fall is more focused than some of his other films the pace is languid and lacks forward momentum. The Fall simply pushes the plot far into the back ground and abuses the premise as an excuse for Tarsem to create a long parade of sumptuous visuals. Again much of the film feels like self-indulgence with a complete disregard for the audience. Which is a shame since The Fall is visually one of the most beautifully filmed pieces of cinema you could ever lay your eyes on.

2. Southland Tales - Richard Kelly

southland tales Frank the Bunny - that's what everyone remembers from Donnie Darko director Richard Kelly. Frank has become an iconic image from an iconic cult film. Darko was Kelly's first feature-length film which was a hit with the indie and Hot Topic crowd. The film over time developed quite the dedicated following that was clamoring for a follow-up. Not long after Darko's video release rumblings could be heard of Southland Tales and Kelly himself had a finished script. Then 9/11 happened and everything changed. He changed the story of the film into a science fiction musical that reached for comedic absurdities of the likes of Brazil and Dr. Strangelove. The resulting film wasn't released until 2006 and had all the signs of the sophomore slumps. Southland Tales was a bloated mess of a film that made Magnolia feel tight and focused. The plot of Southland tales involves America in the midst of World War III in which a paranoid fascist government has all of its citizens under its spying microscope. It also involves 'Fluid Karma', which is an infinite source of energy developed to combat a global fuel shortage. Much like Magnolia the film tells the story of several characters whom ultimately intersect with the main storyline. The main issue here is that there are too many ideas tossed together into one cauldron. You have porn stars, terrorists, politicians, Singing Justin Timberlake, scientists and soldiers melded together in an overwrought Sci-Fi opera. None of the actors seem to know what the hell is going on and give nothing but the most cartoonish performances the world has ever seen. The entire film feels like an inside joke Kelly is playing on the audience. This is a another pretentious self-indulgent mess of film. Like many others on this list it trys too hard to impress. Somewhere hidden deep inside of Southland Tales is a good film. If only Richard Kelly could have learned to self edit and re-write instead of believing that every idea he had was pure gold. I do feel he did learn this lesson quite brutally at the 2006 Cannes film festival where the reception was less than kind. Did I mention Justin Timberlake musical numbers?

1. Tetsuo The Ironman - Shinyu Tsukamoto

tetsuo-the-iron-man For the number one position on this list I chose a movie that just doesn't care about you or your preconceived notions of what a movie is. Shinyu Tsukamoto doesn't care if you like his completely insane plot free movie. He only wants to blow your mind apart with cinematic insanity. If any one film could be considered completely over the top it's this...thing captured on film. Tetsuo The Ironman is about as close as anyone could expect to capturing a deranged person's imagination straight to film. Basically a man turns into a gruesome cyber punk nightmare to unleash havoc and copious destruction upon the world. The film is just pure confusion from beginning to end. Many of the nightmare fueled shenanigans are filmed in high-speed stop motion which only heightens the bizarre experience. The last 20 minutes of the film is two giant hunks of metal with screaming faces fighting each other to the death. For what reason? Who knows? One scene in this film which has always stuck in mind involves Tetsuo growing an intimate drill that does very disturbing things to his wife. Tetsuo The Ironman is a pure slice of abstract dementia not likely to be out done. It is a master work of an over the top and out of control director working at the fringes of insanity. Did we miss any crazy directors who went completely over the top? Share your own picks below in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Coming directly out of the cornfields of indiana is this Über film geek to pour out thoughts from his mind directly into your internet browser.