10 'Creatively Different' Film Castings
WhatCulture brings you 10 more characters that have been creatively chosen compared to the source material.
Poor Tom Cruise. The man now faces his third divorce and a battle for sole custody of his daughter with Katie Holmes. He's hit a few obstacles in his recent movie career with a string of underwhelming titles - Lions of Lambs (2007), Valkyrie (2008), Knight and Day (2010) before retreating to the comforting safety in the M:I franchise. And he's 50 years old. Yep, Maverick is half a century. Ouch. Don't worry about Tommy though. You don't carve out a thirty year career as a Hollywood leading man by folding every time the going gets rough. He's already taken the helm as another iconic action hero for an upcoming December release. Jack Reacher. Can you think of a better way to soothe a savaged ego than casting yourself (5' 7") as a 6' 5", 250 pound, ex-Marine protagonist? Sign me up. And in the spirit of creative casting, WhatCulture brings you 10 more characters that have been creatively chosen compared to the source material. Note: This is not an article on miscasting. We already posted that yesterday. This is just 'different' casting.
10. Magneto (Ian McKellan)
Casting Sir Ian McKellan as the mutant terrorist Magneto was certainly not a crime against cinema. In fact, you could cast the venerable actor in just about anything and I'd stand to applaud at the end credits. But you have to admit ... there is a stark difference in the portrayal of the two characters in the two mediums. Well, except the white hair. That part is spot on. Yes, Magneto is a 90 year old Jew. So casting our favorite pensioner makes some sense. I'm just saying this: Wolverine is 130 years old and they didn't cast George Burns to play his part. The mutant gene apparently has a preserving effect that gives geriatric superheroes washboard abs and a back bigger than Arnold. But if Oompa Loompa Tom Cruise gets a 10 inch height mulligan to play Reacher, then I am certainly willing to give Sir Ian McKellan a pass on 75 pounds of shredded muscle.
9 - Kurtz (Marlon Brando)
When Mr. Kurtz is finally discovered by the protagonist of Heart of Darkness, Marlow, he is described as an apparition of sunken eyes, a ghastly 7' frame carried by his Congolese worshippers in a stretcher, too weak to even stand. When his cover is removed, every rib is visible in his terrible, emaciated condition. This was actually the exact same portrayal that Francis Ford Coppola intended to use in Apocalypse Now. The only problem was that his Colonel Kurtz, Marlon Brando, arrived on the set extremely over-weight. Poor Coppola changed the script (multiple times), the vision of the character, and hid Brando in perpetual shadows to compensate. Would a deathly frail megalomania have been more effective than a fat, effusive one? Could Marlon Brando's delivery of the movie-defining monologue been captured by anyone else? In our opinion, HELL NO. It's better to be lucky than good.
8 - Hannibal Lector (Anthony Hopkins)
The surprise of Sir Anthony Hopkin's selection is not that he fully committed himself to the role, but rather that Jonathan Demme would consider the Welshman for the part of Hannibal Lecter at all. Another middle-aged Brit had gotten the role and Brian Cox's portrayal in Manhunter (1986) was as forgettable as it was over-shadowed by an inspired Tom Noonan. Lecter was a man of wiry strength, maroon-colored eyes, and a six-fingered left hand. Hopkins was a un-imposing, mild-mannered TV movie / British film mainstay with no hint of the lurking homicidal animosity he would bring to the genius, yet sociopathic gaze of Lecter in Silence of the Lambs (1991). Yet magic struck and Hopkins destroyed the archetype for mass murderers on the silver screen in a career-defining role, earning the only Academy Award of his career and cementing his legacy as one of the great actors of a generation.
7 - James Bond (all)
The topic has already been beaten to death about Craig playing Ian Fleming's master spy, particularly his craggy, working-class (though charming) face and his hair color. The thing that I want to point out that Craig actually possesses some essential Bond qualities that none of the other portrayals attempted, which means that Sean Connery (Scottish), Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, Pierce Brosnan (Irish), and George Lazenby (Aussie) were all cast against source to some degree. Here's a description by Fleming on Bond: "Certainly good-looking€ Rather like Hoagy Carmichael in a way. That black hair falling down over the right eyebrow. Much the same bones. But there was something a bit cruel in the mouth, and the eyes were cold" And that is where the smoldering charm of Connery, the aristocratic bearing of Moore, Dalton's every-man determination, and the introspective complexity of Brosnan's performances miss ever so slightly on the original character. Bond, at his core, is a killer. He is a man capable of intense violence, as required by his profession. For all of the differences, Daniel Craig is the one Bond that fully captured the raw brutality beneath the veneer of charm and sophistication. While each man that has assumed the mantle of 007 has brought new facets to the super spy with varying levels of greatness, it can be argued that no actor has yet fully captured the vision that Ian Fleming had for his greatest creation. The true essence of Bond is probably a gestalt of 60% Connery, 20% Moore, 20% Brosnan, and 10% Craig.
6 - The Nutty Professor (Eddie Murphy)
Given the fact that the original Nutty Professor (1963) is a parody of Robert Louis Stevenson's Dr. Jekkyl and Mr. Hyde, I think its no surprise that the next iteration would taken an even further step away by casting Eddie Murphy as a hugely obese professor looking to be fit and skinny. This entry also serves as a place mark for older stories and characters to be re-told in more progressive times with a broader base of diversity, such as Jaden Smith stepping into the Karate Kid remake. Or Halle Berry turning in her worst performance ever in Catwoman (2004). Or Samuel L. Jackson filling the role of Nick Fury throughout the cinematic Marvel Universe (Ultimates, yes, I know). Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't. But just be glad that we're no longer in an age where Mickey Rooney and John Wayne can be cast as Asians. Be very glad.
5 - John Constantine (Keanu Reeves)
I'm going to take a wild guess and say that any fan base of a pre-existing character probably isn't overwhelmed with joy when Keanu is attached to the project. I take that back. The Bill & Ted fans are still euphoric. His casting as John Constantine wasn't just a diversion from the source, it was a full blown mistake. Constantine is a British, foul-mouthed, wise cracker with sharper wits than the devil. Keanu is ... well ... Keanu. No other actor has gotten more screen time and money with less emotional depth. I liked him as Neo, where he could be bewildered and obtusely stoic throughout the film and not force acrobatics from the other actors to carry the scene. His portrayal of Constantine is humorless, ham-handed, and over the top with the gravitas for his soul's destination. Not to mention that he stole Agent Smith's wardrobe, has black hair, clean cut features, and a boyish face. I can see why the Devil gave him back.4 - I Am Legend (Will Smith)
This entry could have easily fallen into the catchall for casting new ethnicities in older roles, but there is more to this character that changed against the source that is worth mentioning. Will Smith played Robert Neville, the sole survivor of a global pestilence that created a sub-race of vampires. The book was written in 1954 by Robert Matheson at a time when African Americans were fighting for basic civil liberties. The opportunity for a black protagonist was very slim without politicizing the story in a direction not intended by the author. The character's re-envisioning (after half a dozen writers over a ten year stint in development hell) re-defined thesis of the movie. The crux of the novel was the view of heroism/villainy. Neville was the sole survivor of the human race and he hunted the victorious species in killing sprees during their vulnerable daylight hours. The end of the book reveals that the "vampires" have actually evolved into a sophisticated new society and they view Neville as a primeval terror murdering them in their sleep and he dies he'll become a mythical evil in the new race's collective conscious, i.e. a Legend. Will Smith's portrayal instead focuses on the will to survive in isolation and hopelessness. Any moral complexity between the two competing species is completely abandoned in favor of a easily digestible plot in which Smith finds a cure to save a suddenly not extinct human race. Which would have been the better film? You decide.
3 - GI Joe (entire movie)
Before we talk about creative casting, I feel a need to say how extremely disappointing this movie was on all levels. I had high hopes that this movie would appeal to the people who actually played with GI Joes. You know ... those children that grew up into 30-somethings that write Internet articles. Instead, it pandered to the lowest age demographic at the expense of alienating everyone else. Whew. Now I feel better. Quickly: Brutish, brunette Channing Tatum plays the blonde-haired, All-American Duke Dennis Quaid plays General Hawk, but is dresses like Flint Marlon Wayans plays an African American Ripcord Karolina Kurkova plays Cover Girl, a vapid officer in the command center, rather than the cagey tank driver in the toy line. The Baroness was supposed to be European aristocrat, but instead became Cobra Commander's sister and former fiancee of Duke. This is starting to sound like Melrose Place. Destro's silver dome is no longer a mask, but a result of nanomites. Most disappointing, we lost the Barry White deepness of Destro's voice in the cartoon. Zartan is an over-weight Arnold Vosloo rather than a menacing saboteur and assassin. The maniacal and loquacious Cobra Commander was portrayed in the most rigid and mechanical manner by a boyishly charming Joseph Gordon-Levitt in perhaps the strangest casting of the entire movie. And Storm Shadow is played by an obviously Korean actor. You didn't think we'd notice, did you? At least, we'll always have Snake Eyes. Thank you, Ray Park.
2 - Rambo (Sylvester Stallone)
This is a bit far-fetched, because we're focusing on a potential, partial inspiration for the source material, a novel, that was later made into the most famous action hero of all time after multiple script re-writes and numerous actors passing on the part until we got the Italian Stallion. Everybody got that? Good. David Morrell wrote First Blood and named his anti-hero protagonist John Rambo. He says that the name was inspired by the Rambo apple. The conspiracy theorist in me raises a dubious eye, because of lawsuits or compensation that could arise if the name was taken from an actual person if he blatantly admitted it. The fact is that A. John Rambo did exist and was a Vietnam soldier killed in action. Of course, the biography of Stallone's Rambo ends there in comparison to the real-life soldier. For one, I doubt that the real John Rambo was actually only 5' 7" tall. Hey, at that height Stallone could play Jack Reacher!
1- Vampires (all)
Bram Stoker's Victorian horror novel, Dracula, has spawned a vampire craze that has unfortunately found its way into emo teenage angst ... and stripper glitter. Thank you, Robert Hutchinson. The truth is that in only a very few instances do any of the actors picked to portray the Transylvanian noble. Stoker intended for him to originally appear pale and aristocratic with a white pointed beard and mustache in his decrepit castle, slowly regaining his youth in London with the pursuit of Mina Harker. In the most famous incarnation of good ole Vlad, he's seen as an ageless, ominous European aristocrat by Bela Lugosi. The slicked back hair and high collared cloak have become trademarks of the character since. Another version and our personal favorite see him as a bald, bestial nosferatu (also interpreted for Kurt Barlow in Salem's Lot as a deviation from Stephen King's literary version). Perhaps the most accurate portrayals to Stoker's original vision of the Count are Christopher Lee (1969) as the older version and Gary Oldman in Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992) as the younger. What do you think? Who did we miss?