10 Creepiest Movie Mistakes Ever

These mistakes are pure, unadulterated nightmare fuel.

Die Hard Mistake
Fox

It's a simple fact that nobody's perfect and no movie is 100% free of mistakes, because the sheer number of people working on any one film ensures that there's always going to be something missed by somebody somewhere.

Most mistakes are totally harmless and, on occasion, totally hilarious. But the rarest of movie gaffes can actually lend an added, often unexpected air of unease to proceedings.

These 10 movie mistakes are all quite unsettling and offputting in their own ways, whether making a supernatural implication due to a continuity or editing error, or suggesting something totally gruesome to the most eagle-eyed of audiences.

While some of the entries on this list come from the horror and thriller genres where the mistakes don't upend the movie's intended tone, in many cases these haunting mistakes found their way into family-friendly animations and slushy, feel-good rom-coms. Oops.

Thankfully many of these mistakes at least went unseen for years or even decades before being uncovered by the Internet, but once you've set your eyes upon them there's virtually no chance you'll be able to un-see them. So, sorry in advance for that...

10. Karl's "Ghost" - Die Hard

Die Hard Bruce Willis
Fox

Despite being over three decades old, keen-eyed viewers are still discovering new things about the seasonal action masterpiece Die Hard, even previously undiscovered mistakes.

One of the film's most memorable action beats is the brutal fight between John McClane (Bruce Willis) and terrorist henchman Karl (Alexander Godunov).

The brawl ends with Karl strangled, seemingly to death, by a chain and left hanging in the rafters. However, one viewer recently noticed the presence of a distinctly un-chained "Karl" in the background of the very next shot.

The last time we saw Karl, he was hanging next to a wall opposite the stairs, yet in this shot we can see him - or possibly a mannequin intended to resemble Karl - standing at the top of the stairs, many feet from where his unconscious body should be.

Considering this mistake makes little sense even when accepting it as a continuity or editing error, cue the urban legends about Die Hard being a haunted production.


9. The Sloth Victim's "Third Arm" - Se7en

Seven Sloth
Fox

David Fincher's Se7en is a sublimely creepy movie as it is, and one that includes one of the eeriest mistakes you're ever likely to see.

When Detectives Mills (Brad Pitt) and Somerset (Morgan Freeman) discover the killer's emaciated victim intended to represent sloth, viewers who take a close look at his body might notice a "third arm" is in fact visible.

In reality, the scene is colour-graded dark enough that Fincher probably assumed audiences wouldn't be able to notice the actor's real arm hidden alongside their body, while a thinner, bonier prosthetic arm lies next to it.

But we all watch movies under slightly different conditions at home, and so if you've got the brightness turned up a little higher, it's easy to see the poor guy sporting a third upper limb.

Even when you appreciate the simple technical explanation for the mistake, that's a deeply unsettling look.


8. Judi Dench's Wedding Ring - Cats

Cats Judi Dench
Universal

There's a strong argument to be made that last year's big-screen Cats adaptation is one big creepy mistake, largely due to the wholly unconvincing attempt to transform A-list actors into anthropomorphic felines courtesy of not-so-cutting-edge visual effects.

Beyond that, the film hit screens effectively unfinished, with a "patch" even being sent to cinemas to update the wonky effects shortly after release - albeit by which point the critical scorn had basically torpedoed the movie anyway.

Though the effects were reportedly touched-up for the home video release - few have seemingly convinced themselves to watch it again and find out - Universal still let a number of VFX gaffes from the cinema version make it into the "final" cut.

Surely the most infamous and offputting mistake occurs in the film's climactic musical number, "Finale: The Ad-Dressing of Cats," where Old Deuteronomy (Judi Dench) can be seen wearing the actress' real wedding ring in numerous shots.

Evidently, the VFX team were so thoroughly overworked through post-production that they missed this widely-ridiculed mistake, which only reminds audiences that, indeed, the very human Judi Dench is scarcely visible beneath that digital cat-person abomination. Terrifiyng.


7. The Fading Twin - Dead Ringers

Dead Ringers Jeremy Irons
Fox

David Cronenberg's masterful psychological thriller Dead Ringers is already plenty disturbing as it is - and, unlike Cats, mostly intentionally so. Like Cats, however, its technical limitations also resulted in some accidental added creepiness.

During an early scene where identical twins Beverly and Elliot Mantle (Jeremy Irons) are talking, Elliot walks away from his brother on the right-hand side of the screen, and those who look closely can actually see Elliot literally fade out of existence before their very eyes.

Because the twin effect was produced through clever compositing of separate takes, and the film's 1988 release predates more complex visual effects shots, Cronenberg clearly assumed nobody would notice the two shots being blended as Elliot exits the frame.

But this being the Internet, of course they did.

Ultimately this is one of those mistakes that only amps up the film's already pervasively ominous atmosphere, coincidentally supporting its themes of dualism and questionable reality.


6. Sarabi's Insanely Long Neck - The Lion King

The Lion King Nala Simba
Disney

Who among us hasn't seen The Lion King dozens of times over the last 25+ years?

Most everyone will remember the early scene where young Simba (Jonathan Taylor Thomas) is reluctantly bathed by his mother Sarabi (Madge Sinclair), but if you pay extra close attention, you might notice a technical curiosity.

When Sarabi reaches over to pick up Simba with her mouth, her neck appears to stretch a frankly disturbing length off-screen, given that the rest of her body doesn't move at all from her original position on the rock. Simply, that's physically impossible.

Obviously this is an animated film without a strict tether to our own reality, but even so, the animated "shortcut" caused fans to come up with horrifying creations such as this:


5. Premature Bullet Holes - Pulp Fiction

Pulp Fiction Samuel L Jackson John Travolta
Miramax

Though Quentin Tarantino's towering masterwork Pulp Fiction never gets creepier than the whole Zed's basement debacle, it offers up an unsettling, head-scratching continuity error all the same.

In the iconic scene where one of Brett's (Frank Whaley) associates (Alexis Arquette) shoots his gun blindly at Jules (Samuel L. Jackson) and Vincent (John Travolta) but misses them completely, you might notice that the bullet holes are actually already in the wall a few moments before he fires the gun.

Though this is a pretty standard editing mistake, it takes on an eerier dimension due to the fact that Jules literally refers to the bullets missing them as "divine intervention" a few moments later.

It seems that God didn't curve the bullets away from Jules and Vincent, but straight up embedded them in the wall before the guy even fired them. Spooky.


4. Mr. Incredible's Tooth Clips Through His Face - The Incredibles

The Incredibles Mr Incredible
Pixar

The Incredibles may be showing its age as a piece of CG animation these days, but it's still an expertly crafted banger from Pixar, and one of their finest efforts to date.

The film is nevertheless full of shortcuts employed by director Brad Bird and his team of animators, most of which pass by without incident, though you might find yourself catching the occasional one.

Here's an animation mistake that you'll need fantastic eyesight to catch - or better yet, make sure you're watching the 4K UHD version on Disney+.

Roughly four minutes into the movie when Mr. Incredible (Craig T. Nelson) is speaking to a pair of police officers, his tooth can briefly be seen clipping through the front of his face due to an issue with the animation layers.

It's little secret that Bird and his own team of animators - who were inexperienced in 3D animation - found working on The Incredibles incredibly challenging, and that's likely why haunting gaffes like this were able to slip through the cracks.

All in all it's a slightly nauseating reminder that these CGI models can end up imploding upon themselves like a Cronenbergian monstrosity if all the ones and zeroes aren't inputted correctly.


3. The Visible Crew Member - I Spit On Your Grave

I Spit On Your Grave
The Jerry Gross Organisation

I Spit on Your Grave is one of the most disturbing films ever made, and though none of the mistakes stemming from its technically roughshod production can out-ick its brutal sexual violence, it does feature one especially sinister mistake.

During an early scene where victim Jennifer (Camille Keaton) flees from her attackers through the woods, a crew member can be seen watching proceedings from the sidelines.

Because of the thick woodland, though, they effortlessly blend into the environment to all but the most observant viewer.

It's an especially unsettling mistake in a film about sexual violence, that an unsuspecting person is seemingly watching the attack on Jennifer and doing nothing about it, adding yet another discomforting layer of voyeurism to the infamous exploitation film.


2. Imogen Poots' Non-Matching Reflection - That Awkward Moment

That Awkward Moment Imogen Poots
Focus Features

That Awkward Moment is a totally frothy rom-com which came and went in 2014 without much of a peep, and most people who saw it upon release likely have few lingering memories of it today.

It's the last place you'd expect to see something scary, and yet, this totally bizarre mistake was recently noticed by a watchful Redditor.

During a scene where Ellie (Imogen Poots) is hanging out with Jason (Zac Efron) at a coffee shop, Ellie's reflection in the shop window doesn't always match what she's actually doing in reality.

It's the sort of thing you'd expect to see in a horror movie like Hereditary, not a disposable rom-com such as this.

On a technical level, we're left to assume that something went wrong with the real reflection in the original take - a visible camera or crew member, perhaps? - and so a reflection from another take was superimposed over the top, maybe?

Granted, it took people almost seven years to notice this, so it's hard to get too mad about it, incredibly weird though it undeniably is.

Once you know it's there, you'll never watch the scene the same way again.


1. Mark Watney's Changing Handwriting - The Martian

The Martian
Fox

Ridley Scott's Best Picture-nominated sci-fi crowd-pleaser is an expertly crafted blockbuster for the most part, albeit one which isn't without a few technical quirks, shall we say.

When stranded astronaut Mark Watney (Matt Damon) leaves the Ares III site at the start of the movie's third act, in two different camera set-ups we can see that Watney has signed his name distinctly differently.

While this is clearly just a continuity error where one portion of the scene was likely re-shot later in production, in a film where a human is stranded on Mars of all places, it does raise some eyebrows.

Could Watney have been body-snatched by an actual Martian who couldn't quite imitate his behaviour - namely, his handwriting - with 100% exactitude?

Suddenly the movie's title has a whole new meaning, as the film is actually a low-key prelude to Mars' invasion of Earth, maybe?

Or as Freud famously said, sometimes a continuity error is just a continuity error.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.