10 Criminally Underrated Horror Movies
These little gems get lost in the mulch and may lie dormant for decades. Don't let that happen.
There is such a ton of rubbish out there in the horror cinema realm, it can be a very hard job to separate the wheat from the chaff. I see a lot of McHorror films on specialist satellite channels - real yawn fests that are as interesting as watching a nice shade of beige dry on a wall. On the other hand, little gems get lost in the mulch and may lie dormant for decades. Tod Browning directed one of Horror's great classics - Freaks - back in the 1930s. A pioneering movie which was far ahead of its time, critics were shocked and appalled when they watched it and it wasn't for many decades that Freaks' full artistic greatness was appreciated. The films on this list are not as dramatically neglected as Freaks, but on the other hand they deserve more appreciation than they get. Some of them, I would go as far to label 'masterpieces' of the genre but ultimately everything is subjective and one man's trash is another man's treasure and vice versa. I have compiled a list of what I think are the most underrated horror films out there. Please add your own below.
10. Maximum Overdrive (1986)

9. Halloween III: Season Of The Witch (1982)

8. Ginger Snaps (2000)

7. Society (1988)

6. Black Christmas (1974)

5. Dust Devil (1992)
A middle aged man is walking along a desert road in Namibia when a female motorist called Saarke pulls over, and takes him back to her house. He breaks her neck whilst they are having sex. In the morning, he has squiggled symbols all over Saarke's house and sets it on fire. He gets into her car and drives off. In Johannesburg, Mark accuses his wife Wendy of cheating on him and she flees to Namibia. When she arrives in Namibia, Wendy comes across the Dust Devil as the police are trying to solve the case (they find an old trailer with chopped up bodies). Wendy tries to cut her wrists in a bathroom but doesn't achieve this despite Dust Devil standing outside the door with a razor. Mark comes to Namibia and one of the shamans tell him that Wendy is with a 'nagtloeper' - a shapeshifting monster who preys on the desperate, the lonely, the lost. He gives Mark a charm to kill him. Wendy notices severed fingers within the shapeshifter's possessions. She tries to run away from him but a fierce sand storm breaks out. Mark and the cops are also on Dust Devil's case. Can they defeat Dust Devil before Wendy is snuffed out? The film really benefits from its spectacular Namibian desert setting which is simultaneously blank and bereft, but also menacing and full of magic and witchcraft. The idea of a 'Nagtloeper' - a shapeshifting creature that preys on desperate, suicidal women and takes their fingers as souvenirs - is an inventive horror villain. Particularly as he is not a human being and possesses superhuman powers. But whatever you do, if you are going to watch Dust Devil, please purchase the Director's Cut of the film and not the cut version which does a serious amount of damage to the film and makes it boring and confusing. If the Director's Cut had been released instead of the butchered version, Dust Devil would have been a highly critically regarded horror film and it would have not lapsed into the semi-obscure status it has today.4. Stage Fright (1987)
A group of struggling thespians are acting in a theatre, trying to pull together a play about an owl masked killer. In a nearby mental hospital - Irving Wallace, a former actor who snapped and killed 12 people is under supposed restraints. He pretends to be docile and kills the orderly, escapes and takes refuge - guess where? In the theatre where he dons the owl mask and stalks the cast. The obnoxious director had one of the actresses to hide the key to the door so that they would all be locked in and forced to rehearse. Unfortunately this actress is the first to be killed so they are trapped with a psycho killer who hunts them down one by one in a series of well staged and very gory killings. Eventually there is only one actress left and she must get the key in some very suspenseful scenes. Highly imaginative slasher goings on by Italian Horror Wunder Kind - Michele Soavi, StageFright: Aquarius is as beautifully staged as anything Italian Horror Maestros Dario Argento and Mario Bava ever did in their careers. Michele Soavi did indeed cut his teeth under Argento's tutelage and he was a very good student. He picked up several methods of working from Argento and used them in StageFright - such as the use of colours, inventive camera work and how to craft stylish murder scenes There is a fantastic cheesy 1980s soundtrack to the film, and the movie will transport you back to the gaudy days of the eighties. The silent owl masked killer is similar to the idea of the masked killer in Hallowe'en but Irving Wallace is even more relentless and scary than Michael Myers! He acquires near supernatural status at the end of the movie, and like all good baddies he cannot be downed very easily. If you like style and suspense in your slasher movies, look no further than StageFright.
3. Alice Sweet Alice (1976)

2. Dellamorte, Dellamore (1994)
Francesco Dellamorte lives in a small Italian town called Buffalora where he works as the cemetery keeper with his mentally retarded assistant Gnaghi. Dellamorte is treated badly by the townsfolk who label him impotent, nevertheless he ekes out his depressing existence by reading out of date phonebooks and crossing out the deceased. Gnaghi likes spaghetti and television and can only utter the word 'Gna'. Dellamorte develops a problem with zombification of his corpses. After 7 days of deadness, they are resurrecting and Dellamorte has to kill them. A plea to the mayor to investigate is turned down. At a funeral, Dellamorte falls in love with an elderly rich man's young wife, as they consummate their relationship, the elderly man comes out of the grave and kills his widow. Gnaghi, meanwhile, is conducting a love affair with the mayor's daughter's head after she was killed in a motorbike crash. The young widow keeps incarnating in different guises to simultaneously frustrate and tantalise Dellamorte. One of these incarnations is terrified of sex. Dellamorte considers going so far as to chop off his genitalia but then his love interest gets raped by her employer and falls in love with him. This unhinges Dellamorte and he goes on a killing spree - including killing the young men who called him impotent. The young widow comes back as a prostitute and he kills her along with some of her co-workers. His friend Franco has tried to kill himself after killing his family. Dellamorte casually kills the hospital workers and screams that he was the murderer. A very surreal ending shows our hero choosing life, although it is a bit pointless, over death. Another Italian masterpiece from Michele Soavi. Probably the last great film of the Italian horror boom and definitely one of its most stylish and distinctive films. It manages to give an interesting slant to the zombie plot, and it excludes all of the worst excesses of Italian horror cinema - no animal entrails munching, no real life animal snuff, no beleaguered Third World natives with bowl cut hairdos and no silly Amazonian frolicking or acts of ultra sleazy violence. For a start, it has a really good actor - Rupert Everett - in the role of Dellamorte who is able to convincingly display a wide and often subtle range of acting skills. Dellamorte is a very complex character and he is really Buffalora's saving grace because if it weren't for him, the town would be overrun with flesh eating ghouls. He is unfairly ignored and ridiculed, particularly by that woman who keeps coming to life in various guises and breaking his heart. It did rubbish business at the box office but it is slowly but surely gaining a wider following. This following cannot be big enough!
1. Exorcist III (1990)
