10 Criminally Underrated Horror Movies

These little gems get lost in the mulch and may lie dormant for decades. Don't let that happen.

dellamorte-dellamore-1994-01-g There is such a ton of rubbish out there in the horror cinema realm, it can be a very hard job to separate the wheat from the chaff. I see a lot of McHorror films on specialist satellite channels - real yawn fests that are as interesting as watching a nice shade of beige dry on a wall. On the other hand, little gems get lost in the mulch and may lie dormant for decades. Tod Browning directed one of Horror's great classics - Freaks - back in the 1930s. A pioneering movie which was far ahead of its time, critics were shocked and appalled when they watched it and it wasn't for many decades that Freaks' full artistic greatness was appreciated. The films on this list are not as dramatically neglected as Freaks, but on the other hand they deserve more appreciation than they get. Some of them, I would go as far to label 'masterpieces' of the genre but ultimately everything is subjective and one man's trash is another man's treasure and vice versa. I have compiled a list of what I think are the most underrated horror films out there. Please add your own below.

10. Maximum Overdrive (1986)

A skimpy plot: a comet passes the earth and makes electrical appliances come to life. Lawnmowers go crazy as do electric knives. The bulk of the film is set in a roadside diner where our hero chef, played by Emilio Estevez, tries his best to keep everything and everyone under control in this crazy new world in which even the most innocuous gadget gets murderous. Directed by Stephen King and based on one of his stories, whenever the critics got their hands on Maximum Overdrive, they heaped so much scorn onto it, you would have thought that King has poisoned their dogs and molested their wives. King is apparently very embarrassed about the film, but I see no reason why he should be. Of course, it is a ludicrous story, but it is also hilarious and engaging. Anyone watching the movie is hardly going to be expecting Fassbinder or Tarkovsky, they know that they are in for a cheesy rollercoaster. Emilio Estevez is very well cast in the film as a man trying to impose order on the rabble. There are lots of exciting moments in the movie and it is extremely entertaining watching all the electrical appliances go bonkers. It also features a kick ass soundtrack from AC/DC which is worth the price of admission alone. The film has entire vortexes of plot holes and it is very juvenile but it is also amusing and a great guilty pleasure.

9. Halloween III: Season Of The Witch (1982)

With nary a glimpse of Michael Myers, the third instalment of the Hallowe'en franchise is supernatural in nature. In late October, Harry Grimbridge is chased by a bunch of people in business suits into petrol station wearing a mask and proclaiming "They're going to kill us!". He collapses and is put under the care of a doctor in the hospital called Dr Challis. However, someone sneaks into his room, kills Harry and then immolates themselves in the hospital car park. Dr Challis and Grimbridge's daughter Ellie do some snooping and end up in a small Californian town where an Irish man called Conal Cochran is holding up the town's economy with his mask factory - the same mask that was on Harry. Challis and Ellie are in a hotel where a lot of the residents - with a link to the factory - start dying due to the masked men in suits. They tour the factory and see Harry's car outside, it guarded by the men in suits. When they cannot get any access to the outside world back in the hotel, Ellie is kidnapped and Challis breaks into the factory to save her. Cochran appears and tells Challis that the be-suited men are androids he has been making to enforce his desire to kill children on Hallowe'en. His trademark masks contain a computer chip which will be activated on 31st October through a television broadcast. They will explode and kill the wearer, and to add insult to injury - they will unleash snakes and horrible creatures to kill people within the vicinity of the wearer. This is apparently to do with an old Gaelic festival called Samhain. Will Ellie and Challis defeat Cochran and avert this terrible catastrophe on time? So it's a serious case of Save The Children in Hallowe'en III. It sticks out in the Hallowe'en franchise like a sore thumb due to its exclusion of Michael Myers as a character. I think that a lot of people dismiss the film unfairly due to Myers' absence in it. This does the film a grave disfavour because it is actually a fairly tight little number that I would rather watch any day over Myers' boring slasher fests which all look the same to me except it is different actresses being chopped up. With a very good score and enough gore to satisfy the average horror fan, Hallowe'en III should probably have been just named Season of the Witch but I appreciate what the film makers were trying to do with the franchise - push it beyond Myers and tackle a different theme with each new instalment. Unfortunately this visionary approach to the franchise did not go down well at the box office and Myers was eventually brought back to start in the crappy Hallowe'en IV. Veteran actor Dan O'Herlihy does an amusing job with his despicable Irish baddie role and the ending to the film will stick in your mind for a while. I demand a reappraisal!

8. Ginger Snaps (2000)

Two suburban teenage sisters - Ginger and Brigitte - are devoted to each other. They have a mutual obsession with death and want to die together. There has been a series of attacks on dogs in the neighbourhood and the sisters go to kidnap a classmate's dog. On attempting to do this, they come face to face with the original dog attacker - a mysterious creature who bites Ginger. An oncoming truck seems to kill the creature and Ginger's wounds heal up, so she doesn't go to the doctor. Ginger turns into a lycanthrope. She has unprotected sex with a boy from school and kills a dog. Their classmate Trina, whose dog they kidnapped, comes around and starts a fight with Ginger. In the middle of the melee, Trina slips and whacks her head on the kitchen counter and accidentally dies. The girls put her in the freezer and Brigitte remonstrates with Ginger that she cannot go out anymore. Brigitte and her friend Sam, a drug dealer, comes up with a herbal cure for lycanthropy - monkshood. It saves Brigitte from an infected boy at school (the one Ginger carelessly shagged) who is trying to attack her. However, Ginger is still on the rampage. She has killed the guidance counsellor and Brigitte watches her sister kill the janitor. At home, the girls' mother has discovered Trina's body in the freezer. On the hunt for the girls, the mother finds Brigitte and tells her they will burn down the house to erase evidence of Trina's death. Sam is fending off Ginger's advances when they find her. Ginger turns into a full on werewolf. Sam and Brigitte are concocting a cure whenever Ginger attacks Sam and gravely wounds him. To pacify her, Brigitte drinks some of Sam's blood but Ginger is unconvinced and goes on to kill Sam. Brigitte is armed with a cure and a knife as Ginger stalks her through the house. Can she save her sister or will she be forced to defend herself? Many critics slammed the film for its heavy fisted use of lycanthropy to metaphorically depict puberty and the joys of beginning menstruation. It came out in 2000 and was ignored for a while. It is by far, the best werewolf film I have ever seen, as well as one of the finest, most emotionally involving horror films I have ever seen. And I usually find werewolf films boring - they are not on the top of my favourite horror film bad guys. However, Ginger Snaps is a lot more interesting than your average teen horror flick. The chemistry between the two actresses who play devoted sisters Brigitte and Ginger is incredible, and the special effects - particularly the effects when Ginger starts to turn into a werewolf - are very good for a low budget film. The film is highly intelligent and brings a more contemporary and believable perspective on the werewolf saga to today's audience. There is also a lot of gore and blood for horror viewers who are that way inclined. But above all, it is the tales of two sisters being torn asunder by a terrible curse. They think they have problems with the 'curse' of menstruation, but a far grimmer fate awaits them... Horror film making at its apex.

7. Society (1988)

Society starts off as a teen angst film. Bill has a great family, he is rich and popular, has a good looking girlfriend and a Jeep. Yet he feels a lot of alienation in his life - like things just aren't what they appeared to be. His friend Blanchard gives him a recording of what appears to be Bill's family engaged in a crazy orgy. He gives the recording to Dr Cleveland - his shrink. When he comes back to collect it, the recording merely plays his sister's debutante party. He tries to obtain a further copy from Blanchard but when he arrives at the meeting place a body is being whisked away in an ambulance but its identity is unknown. Bill goes to a party held by his uppercrust friend Ferguson who taunts him about the tape. Annoyed, Bill leaves with a girl called Clarissa and has energetic sex with her. The next day he returns home and goes to Blanchard's funeral but isn't convinced it is a real corpse because Blanchard got messed up pretty badly. Martin, Bill's high school rival arranges to meet with Bill in secret to tell him of something important. When Bill gets to the meeting place, he finds Martin with his throat cut. He runs off to get the police but when come back the body is gone. Back at home, Bill is initiated into the secret of his family. They are a different species to Bill and they are all upperclass people who shapeshift into a giant obscene mount of seething flesh whilst feeding on the poor. Bill is adopted and does not have this wonderful ability. They demonstrate their powers by doing a number on Blanchard and now they want to feast on Bill. Can Bill escape this depraved orgy? A supposedly 'minor' entry into the genre of body horror (much beloved of Cronenberg), Society has never really been given the praise it is due. It deftly moves from Teen angst, to dodgy shenanigans right through to the final grotesque denouement which would gross out even the staunchest horror movie fan. It is genre director Brian Yuzna's directorial debut and it is a very auspicious start to his career and remains possibly his best ever film, if truth be told. Society has always had more success in the European market rather than the American market. It is funny, disturbing and engrossing. We know that something is afoot in the film due to the uneasiness of what is going on in Bill's life and the mystery keeps building up, layer upon layer, to its repulsive climax. The rich literally eat the poor! One to snap up if you have not enjoyed its charms.

6. Black Christmas (1974)

A bunch of sorority girls are leaving their dorms for the Christmas holidays. Jess picks up a heavy breather phone call - an event that has been happening in the house a lot recently. Barb takes the phone and yells abuse at the caller, who then threatens to kill her and she puts the phone down. Claire is offended by all of this trash talk and goes to pack. She hears the cat crying and whilst trying to locate him someone grabs her, asphyxiates her in plastic and puts her dead body posed in the attic with a toy on her lap. Her father arrives the next day to meet her but she doesn't arrive at the designated time and he goes to the sorority house to ascertain her whereabouts. Meanwhile, Jess tells her boyfriend she is pregnant and wants an abortion. He finds the idea repugnant. Claire's missing is reported to the police who think she is merely holed up somewhere with her boyfriend until he comes into the station and says he can't find her either. Janice, another girl is also reported missing. A search party is set up, and the boss of the sorority house Mrs Mac finds Claire's body and is immediately killed. After finding Janice's body, Jess goes back to the sorority where there is another obscene call. She contacts the police and they put a bug on the line. She has further time to argue with boyfriend Peter about the abortion. Barb is sent to bed for being too drunk. In bed, she is killed with a unicorn ornament. There is another phonecall for Jess, quoting bits of her argument with Peter, who is now the number one suspect. A girl called Phyl goes up to bed and is killed. Jess receives another call and manages to keep the caller on the line long enough so the police can find out that the call is actually coming from a second line in the house. They tell Jess to get out of the house immediately. Of course she goes and grabs a poker, ventures upstairs, sees the carnage and the attacker assails her. She hides herself in the basement and Peter tries to get in. Jess believes he is the attacker and bludgeons him to death. She gets sedated and everyone thinks they have got the attacker. But after the hullabaloo passes, why are Claire and Mrs Mac not discovered yet? And who the heck is this descending the attic stairs as the telephone begins to ring again? A highly effective little slasher movie which would seem to have been influenced by Hallowe'en but actually predates that film by four years or so. The director - Bob Clark - definitely lives up to the promise he showed on the micro budget, very entertaining, zombie film - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things. Black Christmas effectively exploits the season of Christmas and the setting of the sorority house to come up with a disturbing scenario of college girls being killed off one by one. The constant heavy breathing phone calls are menacing and so is the fact that Claire and Mrs Mac remain undiscovered in the film. Largely neglected in the 1970s, Black Christmas featured some very good acting and good characterisations. These girls are not the usual slasher fodder. They are not big boobed blonds with no brains - they are multilayered characters who are quirky and interesting. This makes the ending so depressing. There are few horror films that can sustain the level of tension and dread in Black Christmas, although it was not popular in its day, its influence on other director's films was immense - especially John Carpenter and Hallowe'en. A horrible remake of Black Christmas was absolute rubbish, and the contrast between it and its predecessor in terms of style, scares and suspense was astounding. Another unnecessary remake.

5. Dust Devil (1992)

A middle aged man is walking along a desert road in Namibia when a female motorist called Saarke pulls over, and takes him back to her house. He breaks her neck whilst they are having sex. In the morning, he has squiggled symbols all over Saarke's house and sets it on fire. He gets into her car and drives off. In Johannesburg, Mark accuses his wife Wendy of cheating on him and she flees to Namibia. When she arrives in Namibia, Wendy comes across the Dust Devil as the police are trying to solve the case (they find an old trailer with chopped up bodies). Wendy tries to cut her wrists in a bathroom but doesn't achieve this despite Dust Devil standing outside the door with a razor. Mark comes to Namibia and one of the shamans tell him that Wendy is with a 'nagtloeper' - a shapeshifting monster who preys on the desperate, the lonely, the lost. He gives Mark a charm to kill him. Wendy notices severed fingers within the shapeshifter's possessions. She tries to run away from him but a fierce sand storm breaks out. Mark and the cops are also on Dust Devil's case. Can they defeat Dust Devil before Wendy is snuffed out? The film really benefits from its spectacular Namibian desert setting which is simultaneously blank and bereft, but also menacing and full of magic and witchcraft. The idea of a 'Nagtloeper' - a shapeshifting creature that preys on desperate, suicidal women and takes their fingers as souvenirs - is an inventive horror villain. Particularly as he is not a human being and possesses superhuman powers. But whatever you do, if you are going to watch Dust Devil, please purchase the Director's Cut of the film and not the cut version which does a serious amount of damage to the film and makes it boring and confusing. If the Director's Cut had been released instead of the butchered version, Dust Devil would have been a highly critically regarded horror film and it would have not lapsed into the semi-obscure status it has today.

4. Stage Fright (1987)

Stage Fright A group of struggling thespians are acting in a theatre, trying to pull together a play about an owl masked killer. In a nearby mental hospital - Irving Wallace, a former actor who snapped and killed 12 people is under supposed restraints. He pretends to be docile and kills the orderly, escapes and takes refuge - guess where? In the theatre where he dons the owl mask and stalks the cast. The obnoxious director had one of the actresses to hide the key to the door so that they would all be locked in and forced to rehearse. Unfortunately this actress is the first to be killed so they are trapped with a psycho killer who hunts them down one by one in a series of well staged and very gory killings. Eventually there is only one actress left and she must get the key in some very suspenseful scenes. Highly imaginative slasher goings on by Italian Horror Wunder Kind - Michele Soavi, StageFright: Aquarius is as beautifully staged as anything Italian Horror Maestros Dario Argento and Mario Bava ever did in their careers. Michele Soavi did indeed cut his teeth under Argento's tutelage and he was a very good student. He picked up several methods of working from Argento and used them in StageFright - such as the use of colours, inventive camera work and how to craft stylish murder scenes There is a fantastic cheesy 1980s soundtrack to the film, and the movie will transport you back to the gaudy days of the eighties. The silent owl masked killer is similar to the idea of the masked killer in Hallowe'en but Irving Wallace is even more relentless and scary than Michael Myers! He acquires near supernatural status at the end of the movie, and like all good baddies he cannot be downed very easily. If you like style and suspense in your slasher movies, look no further than StageFright.

3. Alice Sweet Alice (1976)

In 1960s New Jersey, Catherine takes her 9 year old daughter Karen and her 12 year old daughter Alice to see Father Tom. Karen is due to take her first Holy Communion and Father Tom gives her his mother's crucifix. Alice is jealous and puts on a creepy mask which frightens Mrs Tredoni - Father Tom's housekeeper. She further taunts and torments Karen by taking her doll and threatening her she will suffer horrible consequences if she tells anybody. On the day of her first communion, someone in a yellow plastic mac and the hideous mask strangles Karen in a back room of the church then dumps her body where it will soon be found. In a yellow plastic mac, Alice lines up to receive the communion meant for Karen. Karen's body is found and pandemonium breaks out. Dom, the girls' father arrives in town to investigate. A distraught Catherine is looked after by her sister Annie who shares mutual antipathy with Alice. Walking down the stairs, Annie is stabbed in her legs by a hooded figure with a plastic mac. She screams that it was Alice. Alice is sent to a mental hospital to be evaluated. Dom is lured to a an abandoned building and stabbed in the shoulder where the real killer is revealed and they explain their motives. Will Alice be exonerated or further implicated? Also known as Communion or Holy Terror, Alice Sweet Alice is a wonderful piece of 1970s American horror film making. It gained notoriety due to the early appearance of a cute young poppet called Brooke Shields as the tragic Karen. The religious theme of the film makes it very interesting and provides plenty of chills with crucifixes acting as very sinister implements. The film is mostly a success due to Paula Sheppard's remarkable performance as Alice. She was 19 years old when she took the part but she is very convincing as the taciturn, malicious 12 year old little girl. It is a great 'Is she or isn't she?' film, Alice has been shown to be wicked - killing a cat in the basement - but is she capable of murder? The creepy mask and yellow mac feed into the horror. Furthermore, the film has aged very well - in my opinion, it has aged better than The Exorcist (which was another religion based film) and it delivers more chills and it is much more atmospheric with its Catholic imagery. Quite difficult to track down on DVD, your horror movie viewing career is nonetheless much bereft if you pass up Alice, Sweet Alice.

2. Dellamorte, Dellamore (1994)

Dellamorte Francesco Dellamorte lives in a small Italian town called Buffalora where he works as the cemetery keeper with his mentally retarded assistant Gnaghi. Dellamorte is treated badly by the townsfolk who label him impotent, nevertheless he ekes out his depressing existence by reading out of date phonebooks and crossing out the deceased. Gnaghi likes spaghetti and television and can only utter the word 'Gna'. Dellamorte develops a problem with zombification of his corpses. After 7 days of deadness, they are resurrecting and Dellamorte has to kill them. A plea to the mayor to investigate is turned down. At a funeral, Dellamorte falls in love with an elderly rich man's young wife, as they consummate their relationship, the elderly man comes out of the grave and kills his widow. Gnaghi, meanwhile, is conducting a love affair with the mayor's daughter's head after she was killed in a motorbike crash. The young widow keeps incarnating in different guises to simultaneously frustrate and tantalise Dellamorte. One of these incarnations is terrified of sex. Dellamorte considers going so far as to chop off his genitalia but then his love interest gets raped by her employer and falls in love with him. This unhinges Dellamorte and he goes on a killing spree - including killing the young men who called him impotent. The young widow comes back as a prostitute and he kills her along with some of her co-workers. His friend Franco has tried to kill himself after killing his family. Dellamorte casually kills the hospital workers and screams that he was the murderer. A very surreal ending shows our hero choosing life, although it is a bit pointless, over death. Another Italian masterpiece from Michele Soavi. Probably the last great film of the Italian horror boom and definitely one of its most stylish and distinctive films. It manages to give an interesting slant to the zombie plot, and it excludes all of the worst excesses of Italian horror cinema - no animal entrails munching, no real life animal snuff, no beleaguered Third World natives with bowl cut hairdos and no silly Amazonian frolicking or acts of ultra sleazy violence. For a start, it has a really good actor - Rupert Everett - in the role of Dellamorte who is able to convincingly display a wide and often subtle range of acting skills. Dellamorte is a very complex character and he is really Buffalora's saving grace because if it weren't for him, the town would be overrun with flesh eating ghouls. He is unfairly ignored and ridiculed, particularly by that woman who keeps coming to life in various guises and breaking his heart. It did rubbish business at the box office but it is slowly but surely gaining a wider following. This following cannot be big enough!

1. Exorcist III (1990)

A church door opens and leaves and rubbish come flying in. We collectively poop ourselves as a large crucifix opens its eyes. Cut to Detective William Kinderman, who is investigating the hideous murder of a young boy. He then goes to the cinema with a priest friend called Father Dyer. They watch It's a Wonderful life and Kinderman gives Dyer gory details of the boy's murder. The next day they come across the decapitated body of a priest. Dyer has to go into hospital and he is found drained of all his blood and ITS A WONDERFULL LIFE is written in blood on the wall. Kinderman has concerns about the murders revolving around different finger prints and modus operandi. It reminds him of the 'Gemini' Killer who always wrote with double Ls' (e.g, carefull) and the murders all bear the genuine bonafide Gemini Killer trade marks which are only known to the police because they wanted to prevent people from making false claims about the murderer. They told the press that Gemini severed the left middle finger of his victims and carved a Gemini symbol on the back of the victim. However, Gemini was really extracting the right index finger and carved the symbol in his left palm. Kinderman heads over to the psychiatric hospital where the head of the Ward - Dr Temple - introduces him to a patient who was catatonic but came around and claimed to be the Gemini murder after the spate of recent killings. This patient resembles Kinderman's friend Father Damien Karras but he denies all knowledge of him. Next morning, Temple and a nurse are dead. The patient claims that the demon that possessed Regan in the original Exorcist was outraged at being ousted from her body and it entered Damien's body. This particular demon leaves the Gemini Killer's soul to run free at night, inhabiting the senile old patient's bodies and making them commit crimes. In a terrifying scene, Gemini gets an old lady to go to Kinderman's house and attempt to decapitate his daughter Julie with the scariest looking pair of shearers you are likely to ever see. Kinderman goes back to the hospital and a nasty exorcism, with a priest called Father Morning ensues. Can they overcome the demon? I vastly prefer Exorcist III to the original. It is much, much more scary. We shall never speak of Exorcist II again, but Exorcist III deserves more love and appreciation from the horror community for it's genuine shocks and gruesome murders. It is a truly disturbing film which is much more frightening than watching a little girl give priests the run around and puke a lot of pea green soup. The original Exorcist went for the gut, Exorcist III goes for the mind and plays a lot of cerebral games with the viewer. It has a dark sense of humour with terrifying visuals. Slasher movie fans may be bored by it, but I found it to be much more creepy than the creepiest, scariest slasher movie that I ever watched (which is Stagefright by Michele Soavi). Exorcist III benefits from some fantastic acting and characterisation which mainly consists of old men sitting around talking to each other - George C Scott as Kinderman gives an amazing performance as a world weary cop who nevertheless is compelled to get to the bottom of the case. When he has lunch with Father Dyer, the chemistry between the two actors is so potent, you can believe that they have been good friends for years. And Brad Dourif - as Father Karras/The Gemini Killer shows his acting range way beyond doing voice over for a certain homicidal doll. There is graphic horror and there is explicit horror in the movie. Films dealing with the topic of Satanism can be prone to silliness. However, Exorcist III really sells its idea very well and I declare it the most underrated horror movie of all time.

Contributor
Contributor

My first film watched was Carrie aged 2 on my dad's knee. Educated at The University of St Andrews and Trinity College Dublin. Fan of Arthouse, Exploitation, Horror, Euro Trash, Giallo, New French Extremism. Weaned at the bosom of a Russ Meyer starlet. The bleaker, artier or sleazier the better!