10 Critical Flops That Deserve More Praise

10. Quantum of Solace

I€™m really looking forward to Skyfall. I think everyone is. Yet the way it€™s been portrayed continues to trouble me. It€™s viewed as some sort of Bond reboot, taking the franchise out of the mire in which it€™s found itself and the blame for this situation is being laid at the door of 007€™s last outing, Quantum of Solace. But was it really that bad? No, I don€™t think it was. In fact, I think it was rather good. It just couldn€™t have been more badly timed. The problem with Quantum was that it came directly after the unfathomably awesome Casino Royale. Royale had more or less dragged the franchise out of the grave dug for it by Die Another Day, through a combination of glamour, brutality and €“most of all€“ novel plot structure. It subverted audience expectation; rather than centring on Bond stopping a megalomaniac bent on world domination, Royale was more focused on Bond€™s relationship with Vesper Lynd, herself a subversion of Bond formula insofar as she isn€™t just a sex object. Le Chiffre€™s eventual death wasn€™t even the climax of the narrative. All these were unorthodox, bold and universally appreciated moves. So when Quantum reverted back to the old villain-centric formula, one could argue it was a bit of a let-down. Yet by virtue of Quantum€™s status as a direct continuation rather than a reboot, it was hamstrung on the originality front from the get-go, having been set out as a revenge flick providing closure to the Vesper arc. Another bold twist would€™ve possibly been dismissed as arbitrary. So Quantum was always judged next to this impossible benchmark. This is a shame because what€™s on offer here is mostly very good. A slightly mediocre villain and some stiff dialogue aside (the crew had to come up with the lines on set thanks to the Writer€™s Guild strike) it rattled along at a good pace, opening with a tremendously brutal and thrilling car chase, and ending with some good character growth for 007, and was punctuated with an excellent rooftop chase in Siena and the introduction of a well-rounded Bond girl in Camille Montes. It also featured an absolutely fantastic scene; the Quantum meeting in the Austrian opera. These scenes marry the glamour and subterfuge of the Bond universe (who the hell stages a secret meeting at a performance of Tosca, if not Bond villains?) with a rousingly atmospheric gun-battle €“ silent but for the opera music €“ and culminates in a suitably badass moment when Bond drops a bodyguard off the roof, only for Dominic Greene to show his villain colours (which weren€™t shown often enough) when he has the same bodyguard executed for looking at him. What I€™m saying is this: yes, Quantum of Solace isn€™t as good as Casino Royale. But taken by itself, it€™s still worthy of praise €“ an excellent character piece featuring some great action sequences. If nothing else, it€™s certainly much better than the Die Another Day nadir, and nobody wants to go back to Bond kitesurfing. (While I was writing this article a whole analysis of Quantum of Solace came out on WhatCulture, and it€™s really good. Look at it here €“ http://whatculture.com/film/007-reasons-why-quantum-of-solace-is-a-great-bond-film.php)
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.