10 Director's Cuts That Seriously Improve Movies
You can argue all you want, Redux is brilliant.
Oftentimes directors and studios are at odds with one another. Directors are typically focused on artistic integrity; seeing their vision realised through pre production, principle photography, and editing. Studios want to make money. If a film can garner acclaim and make money then all the better, but money is the objective.
There are all manor of ways this might impact a finished product. In order to reach the broadest spectrum of viewers movies often get toned down and sanitised to become more palatable. And a shorter run time is often favoured to facilitate more viewings per day at the box office, meaning more ticket sales, resulting in that extra bit of revenue.
And who can blame studios for having this approach? The film industry is a business after all. But if a director takes any sort of pride in their work, then they are unlikely to look favourably on having their name associated with an obvious money grab.
The director's cut is simply the version of a movie that resembles a vision, unconcerned with.
These aren't just movies that throw in a few deleted scenes for the sake of extending the run time. The alterations made to these movies significantly enhances the viewing experience, adding a previously unseen depth to the stories.
10. Aliens Special Edition (1991)
James Cameron's endeavour to progress the Alien franchise was a triumphant success. He paid homage to the tension-building sense of claustrophobia established in the first movie, without it being the crutch of his own story. You had horror elements and plenty of jump scares, but the central theme revolved around action.
No one would argue that the theatrical cut is anything but a masterpiece. It took the Alien franchise in a new direction, while paying the utmost respect to the first movie. Filled with bug-stomping Marines, numerous quotable lines, and a hell of a lot of action, it not only did the first movie proud, it surpassed it.
The 1991 extended version only added to its legacy. There's an extended sequences which sees the Marines deploy a number of automated gun turrets to fight off the Xenomorphs, which amounts to a few more thrills. But other scenes help flesh out several plot points and character arcs.
Ripely for example is shown discovering her daughter died during her absence - an omission from the original cut that Sigourney Weaver was furious about. We're also shown a sequence on LV 426, shedding light on how Newt (Rebecca Jorden) lost her own family. Taken together, the scenes add depth to the Ripley/Newt relationship.
9. Kingdom Of Heaven: Director’s Cut (2005)
Ridley Scott rarely makes a bad movie. And when it comes to historical dramas not many do it better.
Kingdom of Heaven follows the physical and emotional journey of Balian (Orlando Bloom), a young man who flees France for the Holy Land in search of salvation. The film wrestles with notions of ideological indoctrination, the dichotomy of seeking peace through war, and the struggle between one's own morals and the perceived word of God.
But the version originally released to the public wasn't one of Scott's best works. It felt like a period-action blockbuster attempting to tackle big ideas in an overtly unsubtle way. And there's good reason for that. Scott, who often finds himself wrestling with studios about the length of his films, was forced to cut a whole 45-minutes of content. Sadly it was all the stuff that added weight and depth to the themes being tackled.
Significant moments of character development were removed, resulting in characters coming to seemingly enlightened revelations without much explanations. Scott's Director's Cut does much to remedy these issues. Characters like Sibyllia (Eve Green) become far more nuanced, with an extended sub-plot involving her leprous son, and the morally ambiguous choices she makes while wrestling with grief.
Even Orlando Bloom's character had his backstory expanded for the better. Although it wasn't enough to remedy his wet performance it was nevertheless a vast improvement.
8. The Big Red One: The Reconstruction (2004)
World War 2 veteran turned novelist and filmmaker, Sam Fuller, first release his epic-war flick in 1980. Starring Lee Marvin and Mark Hamill, the story follows a squad of infantrymen across several major conflicts during World War 2. From the deserts of North Africa, to the beaches of Normandy, and finally to a concentration camp in Czechoslovakia, the film attempts to show how the men are changed by their experiences.
On release the film was praised for it performances and its depiction of war, but Fuller was never satisfied with the finished project. The studio essentially butchered the edit, focusing on the action rather than giving credence to how the characters were effected. Notably several characters don't get the full character arc Fuller original hoped for.
The Reconstruction was an attempt to rectify those issues, utilising an additional 47-minutes of remastered footage in a significantly altered edit. Although Fuller had passed away by the point the movie got its make over, the new cut drew heavily from Fuller's more expansive novelisation of the story.
7. Brazil (1985)
The release of Terry Gilliam's Brazil was riddled with director/studio squabbling. So much so that the director was forced to take out an ad in Variety Magazine, imploring that his version be released.
Brazil sees the world through the eyes of Sam Lowry (Jonathan Pryce), a man entrenched in a bureaucracy-riddled hell scape, where the class divide has never been more prominent, and human life is devalued.
Gilliam’s depiction of the future was bleak, and his dark comedy made it all too clear what he thought about the trajectory of a capitalistic-centred society. The films protagonist is desperate to break the monotony of his life, and sees love as his only salvation. His unorthodox way of thinking eventually brings him into conflict with the authorities, when he is imprisoned, tortured, and then breaks free to save his romantic interest, living happily ever after. This was the ending the studio fought tooth and nail for, and indeed this was the product broadcast on TV.
But an alternative version was also released at the same time, Gilliam’s version, whereby the happy ending was replaced and revealed to be a hallucination. The film ends with Sam imprisoned and insane. It's far more in keeping with the tone of the film and the overall message Gilliam was going for.
6. Blade Runner: The Final Cut (2007)
Apart from George Lucas' original Star Wars trilogy, no other movie than Blade Runner has been as infamous for its many iterations.
Three versions exist which are generally available to the public, with a total of seven actually being cut. This was the movie that established Scott as something of a hothead when it came to studio interference.
The most significant difference between the widely released theatrical cut and Scott's Director's Cut (1992) is the removal of the polarising voiceover narrations. Scott was pressured to add the crime-noir style voiceover due to the studio finding the long sequences of silence, confusing and ambiguous. Harrison Ford's monologues essentially explained the whole plot, going against that old adage of filming making "show, don't tell".
The absence of the voiceover leaves the film feeling far darker. Deckard seems more isolated, more lonely and more mysterious, adding to the bleak depiction of a dystopian future. There's also far more emphasis put on the fact that Deckard is a replicant, with the famous unicorn dream-sequence. Finally the ending finishes far more abruptly, leaving it unclear what happened to Rachel and Deckard, as opposed to the theatrical release, which shows them escaping to the countryside.
When the Final Cut dropped in the late 2000s, Scott altered little of the narrative, instead, enhancing the aesthetics. Boy, is it good.
5. The New World: Director's Cut (2006)
Terrence Malick is one of those directors who's films will either have you clamouring about how he's the greatest filmmaker alive, or leave you utterly baffled by his story telling choices. Malicks films are marked by their meandering narratives, their beautiful cinematography and their wistful voiceovers.
His fourth feature film, a poetic reimagining of the Pocahontas story, is considered one of his most polarising movies. Two versions initially came out, the original 150-minute version and the 135-minute recut.
Both versions convey the tragic, squalid, and desperate struggle of the early English settlers in America; depicting the strained relationship between the Europeans and the Native Americans, and hinting at the wider, darker implications of their meeting. This serves as the backdrop for Malick to interlace the mythical tale of a romance-doomed-to-fail between Captain John Smith (Collin Farrell) and Pocahontas (Q'orianka Kilcher).
The first cut of the movie, focuses more so on the degradation of the New World by the Europeans, and the breakdown of relationship with the natives, the second cut gives more time over to the personal experiences of Pocahontas and her own struggles with the new comers.
For anyone who digs this kind of thing, Malick's third and final cut, comes in at 172-minutes. It's simply more of the same. It's more immersive, more poetic, an even more aesthetically beautiful. But damn is it long.
4. The Lord Of The Rings: Extended Editions
The combined runtime of Peter Jackson's Extended Editions will take you just under 12 hours to get through, that's including the credits. In terms of extra content, there's not a huge amount of new plot stuff that significantly alters how these movies are interpreted.
At least not in the Fellowship or the Return of the King. We essentially just get elongated fight sequences, some extra lines of dialogue, and a few more lushes shots of New Zealand. But it all amounts to more time spent in Middle-earth - and who doesn't want that?
The Two Towers, however, enriches the character of Boromir (Sean Bean) significantly. Through flashback sequences we are shown the character's interactions with his younger brother Faramir (David Wenham). Although Boromir had one of the most impactful death scenes in the trilogy, the character was a little one dimensional. We understand his moment of weakness was born out of a desire to save his people, but we never saw the full extent of his internal struggle.
In an extended sequence in the Two Towers, however, this is explored in more depth. We see how the pressure his father puts on him directly resulted in his attempt to steal the Ring.
3. Troy: Director's Cut (2007)
What happened to this movie? The costumes and set designs were great, the cast was filled with big hitters - all of whom gave fairly decent performances - and the fight sequences were brilliantly choreographed. Add to that the incredibly rich source material, Homer's Iliad, and this should have been of the great swords-and-sandals flicks of the 21st century.
But the film didn't really know what it was - a grounded interpretation of mythological epic? or an exciting action-packed bro movie?
The real issue was Wolfgang Petersen was hamstrung by the studio execs. They wanted a summer release, and a focus on pulling in the younger audience. That meant exciting fight sequences and a plethora of shots featuring Brad Pitt's brooding intensity and glistening abs.
Characters like Hector (Eric Bana) Odysseus (Sean Bean) and Agamemnon (Brian Cox) were given just enough screen time to let you know how the fit into the story, but not enough to develop any attachment to them.
Although the Director's Cut doesn't fix all the problem, it certainly addresses many of them. Even though the extended run time comes in at well over 3-hours, it doesn't drag like the theatrical release. The extra time allows the supporting characters to come alive, rather than just serving as something for Pitt to bounce off.
2. Apocalypse Now Redux (2001)
Okay, so this entry is most definitely going to divide opinion. So let's get the obvious out of the way: YES, the pacing of Redux is drastically slowed by the inclusion of almost 50 minutes of extra footage.
To some the extra footage is almost as egregious as all the tampering George Lucas did to his original Star Wars trilogy. To others the extended scenes and the added sequences only add to the bizarre hallucinogenic experience of Francis Ford Coppola's greatest movie.
The original cut of Apocalypse Now IS perfect. There's no arguing with that. It's slick, stylised and refined. Even with its 2-hour-plus run time, at no point does it feel like its dragging, such is its ability to engage the viewer. Redux comes in at over 3-hours. And damn is it an ordeal at times.
But that's sort of the point of this movie. Captain Willard's journey up river was punctuated with bursts of horrific violence (the village massacre) and moments of depraved distraction (the second playboy bunny scene). But the arduous and crawling nature of his trip was equally as important to the story.
Too much time for introspective thought left Willard questioning the validity of his task, the moral implications of it, and his own sanity. All amounting to a deep sense of unease as he imagined the terrors of what he would find up river. With its extended sequences, Redux compounds these themes, masterfully.
1. The Abyss: Special Edition (1993)
The Abyss is one of James Cameron's most under-appreciated movies. It's more subtle in its handling of other-worldly beings. There are no time traveling robots causing havoc, alien serpents don't burst through any chest cavities, and there are no blue humanoids battling colonialism. Instead, the central conflict stems from a good old fashioned fear of communism.
Virgil "Bud" Brigman (Ed Harris) is recruited by the U.S. government to assist in a deep sea operation to recover an American submarine, downed after coming into contact with an unknown object. During the expedition the crew encounter a non-terrestrial intelligence (NTI). Pretty soon Lieutenant Hiram Coffey (Michael Biehn), jumps to the conclusion that the NTI must have something to do with the Soviets, and arms a recovered warhead.
Underwater chaos ensues and the armed warhead ends up at the bottom of a deep sea trench. Bud has to go on a suicide mission to disarm it, but he is saved by the NTIs. It's revealed that Buds was saved due to his humanity.
Cameron's extended edition follows pretty much the same narrative, but with some key differences. The central conflict is dramatically enhanced by an impending war between the United States and the Soviet Union. It's also revealed that the NTIs are intending to cause a mass tsunami to prevent the human race from utterly destroying the planet through nuclear war.