10 Directors Suffering From George Lucas Syndrome
Once-great filmmakers who can no longer direct their way out of a paper bag...
It may be popular to hate on George Lucas, but there is a very good reason for that. The man came storming out of the gate with three great films, THX 1138, American Graffiti and Star Wars, the latter of which of course spawned a mammoth franchise which he dictated the course of (though he didn't direct The Empire Strikes Back or Return of the Jedi). After that, he didn't direct a single movie for another 22 years. The hype around 1999's Star Wars prequel The Phantom Menace was immense, and as everyone knows, the movie just didn't live up to the hype: filmmaking had changed a lot over those two decades, and Lucas' appropriation of new technology didn't serve an underwritten script well at all. Lucas proved with his prequel trilogy the problem with enormous success: if you make enough money, nobody is going to tell you "no" or be honest and say that a bad idea is a bad idea. Lucas was surrounded by yes men who rubber-stamped everything he wanted, largely because there was no chance in hell that The Phantom Menace and the following sequels were going to flop. He had almost too much power, and the result was that without a sounding board, the prequel trilogy was for the most part pretty poor, certainly compared to the original three movies. This list aims to investigate similar filmmakers, who started off great but couldn't replicate that success later on. No, it's not filmmakers like Michael Bay and Zack Snyder who have always been hugely divisive, but talented filmmakers who have kept getting bankrolled over the years because either their movies keep making money regardless of quality, or because their earlier success has given them a ton of lee-way with studios who believe in their brand name. Here are 10 directors suffering with the debilitating illness that is George Lucas Syndrome...
10. The Wachowskis

9. Kevin Smith

8. Peter Jackson

7. Michael Mann

6. Tim Burton
His Success: Tim Burton's career successes speak for themselves: Pee-Wee's Big Adventure, Beetlejuice, two Batman movies, Edward Scissorhands, Ed Wood, Big Fish, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Corpse Bride, Sweeney Todd, Frankenweenie and Big Eyes. Hell, even his critical busts tend to turn a profit, and in fact the only sure financial duds in his entire career are Ed Wood (which nevertheless earned him huge acclaim) and Mars Attacks!, even if Big Fish and Dark Shadows were considered commercial disappointments too. People love his style, and so even his terrible movies tend to make money. His Failures: This is obviously more an artistic than commercial failure, because though Burton occasionally comes out with something totally different like Big Eyes, he's just too complacent and eager to stick to the same gothic stylings which define the vast majority of his output. It's what fans expect and so, given how much money these sorts of films tend to make, Burton seems reluctant to move away from the same tired palette and style, while usually finding a quirky supporting part for Johnny Depp or Helena Bonham Carter (though following his recent split from Carter, perhaps that's all about to change). From the last decade, Alice in Wonderland and Dark Shadows were the straws that broke the camel's back: wildly over-budgeted movies which, though stylish (even in that totally predictable Tim Burton way), boasted very little of substance to speak of, and as such were given mixed critical notices, while a lot of Burton fans began to lose their patience with his lazy filmmaking. How He Can Save His Career: Make something totally different. Big Eyes was an encouraging step away from Burton's typical work, and it'd be great to see him experimenting with different colours in his upcoming work. With Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children, Beetlejuice 2 and a live-action Dumbo movie on his slate, though, don't get your hopes up.5. Seth MacFarlane

4. Ridley Scott
His Success: Ridley Scott is, of course, known for a number of critically and/or commercially successful films, such as Alien, Blade Runner, Black Rain, Thelma and Louise, Gladiator, Hannibal, Black Hawk Down, Matchstick Men, American Gangster, Robin Hood and Prometheus. At the top of his game, he is undoubtedly a master of his filmmaking craft. However... His Failures: Scott has admittedly had one of the most maddeningly inconsistent careers of any Hollywood filmmaker, what with the following movies failing commercially (and in some cases critically also): Legend, Someone to Watch Over Me, 1492: Conquest of Paradise, White Squall, Kingdom of Heaven, A Good Year. Since 2007's American Gangster, though, Scott has been in something of a creative funk, with all five of his films since being saddled with glaring issues. Body of Lies was a critical and commercial disappointment, Robin Hood made money but people hated it, Prometheus was also successful but Alien fans largely had huge complaints about it not living up to its promise, The Counselor was widely derided despite turning a profit, and last year's Exodus: Gods and Kings didn't turn the huge profits Fox were expecting, while reviews were scathing. Just like Michael Mann, Scott is pretty much living on his prior esteem these days. Everyone knows he can make a great movie with the right script, so audiences continue to see many of his movies out of respect for his prior work, while studios similarly keep bankrolling him even though a Ridley Scott movie is these days a total gamble for everyone involved. How He Can Save His Career: Scott's upcoming film The Martin has plenty of promise, and he's not a director like many on this list who needs to step away from big budget filmmaking. His skill as a stylist is still there, but he needs to be a little more particular with his scripts before signing up, that's all.3. M. Night Shyamalan

2. Richard Kelly

1. John Lasseter
