10 Most Disappointing Comic Book Movies Of All-Time

Great expectations.

Given their potential to literally make billions of dollars at the box office - perhaps even more than any other type of movie in this modern cinematic age - it's no wonder that the studios have turned their attention to comic book adaptations. Yes, the movie-going public have become obsessed with the likes of the comic book movie over the course of the last decade. What started with experimental films like X-Men and Spider-Man has changed the face of cinema forever: now we have cinematic universes, spin-offs, and films about iconic superheroes fighting one another... What's remarkable about the state of comic book movies is that, on the whole, truly bad ones are a rarity. That's not to say that all comic book flicks have been successful on every level, but the most common "negative" reaction that fans seem to face when approaching a new comic adaptation is that of disappointment. And isn't feeling somewhat let down or disheartened by a long-awaited picture even worse than being outright shocked at how bad it is? You know where you are with a bad movie, after all; disappointing tends to mean that the lines are blurred. Join us, then, as we take a trip through the 10 most disappointing comic book movies of all-time. We've weighed up the associated levels of distress that these movies caused fans at the time of their release to bring you the definitive ranking of those adaptations that had patrons leaving the cinema feeling unsatisfied and confused. It's important to note here that none of the movies included on this list are terrible; these are the movies that had both good and bad things about them, but ultimately left fans and movie-goers alike with mixed feelings during the car ride home...

10. The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)

Given its standing as a reboot of a franchise that probably didn't need to rebooted so soon in the first place, there should have been a sense of "new and innovative" about The Amazing Spider-Man. Instead, we got yet another basic re-telling of the Peter Parker origin story, with not a whole lot to separate it from the original Sam Raimi version. Were the studio afraid to take risks? Were the writers and director out of ideas? So although The Amazing Spider-Man was a good enough film, there's no denying that it was a throughly disappointing one, too. The first half of the movie, far better than the second, establishes plot points regarding Peter Parker's parents that are never resolved or touch upon again, almost as if the idea was scrapped. You'll find out more in The Amazing Spider-Man 2, of course, but given that this picture was marketed around the idea that this was Spider-Man like we'd "never seen him before," it seemed like something of a cop-out. If you're taking the time to reboot something, it's important to ensure that you give audiences reason to spend their money again; this flick didn't.

9. Watchmen (2009)

Before Zack Snyder bit the bullet and adapted it into a motion picture in 2009, Watchmen was considered by fans to be one of those rare cultural artefacts that simply could not be translated to film. Based on the results of Snyder's attempts to successfully collate Watchmen's dense pages into a cinematic experience that worked, it seems the fans were right. Somewhat ironically, however, the failings behind Snyder's adaptation do not come as a result of his mistreating the source material; in fact, Watchmen doesn't quite work because it's too faithful. Snyder's commitment to ensuring that he did not veer too far from Alan Moore's seminal graphic novel only ensures that Watchmen feels about as flat and rigid as the pages it was printed on; there's no "life" to the movie because it has no room to breathe, to embrace the strengths of cinema. Snyder also mangles the themes slightly by failing to recognise that Watchmen is a satire; in places, he forgets the ridicule intended by the source material and shoots for "kick-ass" action movie. It might well be his best film, but it's still a disappointing one.

8. Iron Man 3 (2013)

Iron Man 3 is probably one of the most dividing comic book movies in cinema history; whereas many enjoyed its conceits as a buddy flick, complete with quipping dialogue, rapid-fire jokes, and a generally lightweight plot, others thought it blasphemous in its insincerity, bombastic action scenes and the liberties it took with a certain famous villains. Let's not beat about the bush: it was the Mandarin that caused such an uproar amongst fans and general movie-goers alike, who felt betrayed and disappointed with the way Marvel handled the character. Whether or not you felt like Iron Man 3 was a wasted opportunity or a hell of a lot of fun, the big Mandarin reveal - which exposes the villain, played by Ben Kingsley, as nothing but an actor-for-hire - left a lot of people feeling like Marvel had gone a step too far. The movie itself, fast-faced and infinitely more solid than the likes of Iron Man 2, still holds up, but it would be inaccurate to suggest that Tony Stark's third solo outing did not leave millions of people disappointed. Had they embraced Kingsley as the actual Mandarin? A potential classic, maybe?

7. Superman Returns (2006)

Bryan Singer jumped ship from the X-Men franchise to direct Superman Returns, but he might as well have stayed put - chances are we would've been gifted with a far better third X-Men movie (Brett Ratner be gone), and this bizarre mess of half reboot/half sequel might have been shelved. Almost twenty years after the last Superman film, then, Warner Bros. decided to revisit the character in a movie that would've been better off as a straightforward reboot, but instead ended up being a confusing mass of half-realised ideas and concepts. To say that Superman Returns was disappointing to fans of the world's most iconic superhero is equivalent to saying that 9/11 was a "minor tragedy." Though there are lots of redeeming features, such as the brilliant plane rescue sequence, mostly Singer fails to engage with his material, and Superman Return fails to highlight what's good about its eponymous character. It didn't help that Brandon Roth was forgettable as Clark Kent, and Kate Bosworth made no sense as Lois Lane. The biggest problem, however, is simply that there is no tension.

6. Iron Man 2 (2010)

Even Tony Stark himself, Robert Downey Jr., has admitted to being underwhelmed by the likes of Iron Man 2 - a movie which should - and could - have been one of Marvel's best films ever, given its increased budget (thanks to the success of the first Iron Man flick), the presence of both Sam Rockwell and Mickey Rourke as villains, and the fact that the writers could have literally taken the story anywhere. Unfortunately, the studio forgot to ensure that Iron Man 2 worked as a standalone film before utilising it as a tool for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Oops. Which is another way of saying: Iron Man 2 feels like it exists as a means of advertising the MCU, and not as a genuine motion picture experience that can stand up on its own two feet. So whereas there are a few stellar action sequences and good performances all round (Rockwell especially), the plot can barely be called as such; the movie flicks from scene to scene at random, failing to develop a cohesive narrative. Iron Man 2 isn't "about" anything; there's no focus. Characters come and go without reason. It's fun in places, but mostly? It's boring.

5. X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)

When Bryan Singer left the X-Men franchise after Warner Bros. offered him the chance to direct Superman Returns, 20th Century Fox were left trying to find a replacement director who would be able to replicate the success of the first two installments. After trying for Joss Whedon, among others, the job eventually fell to Matthew Vaughn, who was forced to leave during pre-production due to scheduling issues. His replacement, and the man whose name now appears beneath the "Directed By" tag? Brett Ratner, best known for his Rush Hour movies. When a studio goes with Brett Ratner, you know they must be out of options. Still, to be fair to the guy, Ratner admitted from the very beginning that he wasn't familiar with the X-Men franchise - something that feels rather apparent when you watch the film. After the excellent X-Men and X2, then, fans were handed a final chapter that felt far less polished and noticeably lacking in the heart and emotion departments. It's an entertaining film in places, but it also feels sillier and inconsequential. Safe to say the wait for The Last Stand wasn't really worth it.

4. Spider-Man 3 (2007)

The original Spider-Man, released in 2001 and directed by Sam Raimi, was something of a marvel. It was the first comic book film to truly embrace the conventions of the medium it was striving to depict on-screen to massive success; it changed cinema because it told filmmakers, "look, this is what's possible now - we can make a Spider-Man movie and it doesn't look stupid!" Raimi followed that triumph with what is still arguably the best and most accomplished superhero flick ever; the endlessly entertaining and technically brilliantly Spider-Man 2. All of which meant that the levels of hype for Spider-Man 3 reached maximum overdrive in the months before its release. Of course, with so much hype, there is a lot of pressure to deliver, and it all got too much for the third chapter in Raimi's doomed trilogy. Spider-Man 3 tried to do way too much; there were an overabundance of villains, one of which - Venom - had been forced upon Raimi by the studio against his will. What we got was a muddled, overproduced and underwritten sequel that was not entirely without merit, but certainly left fans feeling mostly unsatisfied.

3. The Dark Knight Rises (2012)

Undoubtably, The Dark Knight Rises - the follow-up to the immensely popular cinematic milestone that was The Dark Knight - is one of the most curious comic book movies ever made. On one hand, it's a technical and visual marvel, filled with great performances, admirable in its mission to be the dark, final chapter in Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy. On the other hand, it's a strange, bombastic mess - a movie that trips up on its own conceits time and time again, until the only sane reaction is that of utter bewilderment. It's like a overambitious first novel. So it's more than obvious, whether you've seen it merely one or a dozen times, that The Dark Knight Rises does not hold a candle to its far less convoluted predecessor (or, at least, its far less obviously convoluted predecessor). Packed to the brim with plot holes and an unfocused narrative, it's not surprising that so many left the theatre having glimpsed this finale clinging to feelings of disappointment. Despite its flaws, however, Rises remains an irrestisable peculiarity; discussing its merits and flaws is arguably far more interesting than actually watching the film.

2. Hulk (2003)

What a strange beast is Ang Lee's admirable but ultimately yawn-inducing take on the Hulk, who is arguably the most difficult comic book character to adapt to film. Lee, best known for films like Sense and Sensibility and Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, isn't a natural fit for the material... it's clear from the get-go that his idea of a Hulk movie isn't just things getting smashed and broken, but one rich with existential drama. This might've worked had the majority of the movie not felt so flat and tiresome, the action scenes dull and sort of bonkers. Hulk has its fair share of defenders, of course, most of whom will cite Lee's attempts to transcend the material as commendable. But just because Lee tried to make a deeper, more dramatic Hulk picture doesn't mean it was the right way to go; most of the people who ventured into cinemas to see this thing expected two hours of ripped jean shorts and explosions. Instead, they got a movie that tried desperately hard not to be like a comic book - how did comic book fans expect to be anything else other than disappointed? Praiseworthy, but a notable failure.

1. Man Of Steel (2013)

The trailers. The trailers for Man Of Steel, which seemed to promise giddy comic book fans the Batman Begins of Superman movies, were presumably the main reason as to why Zack Snyder's tone-deaf reboot failed to live up to the hype. In just a couple of minutes, the trailers packed more emotion, tension and excitement into their running time than the movie did in two and a half exhaustive hours of people punching one another through skyscrapers and Hans Zimmer's headache-inducing score. Did the wonderful teasers ensure disappointment was inevitable? Bombastic, loud and messy, Man Of Steel actually makes Superman Returns look like something of a relative triumph; here's a superhero flick that appeared so destined for greatness, given the fact that Christopher Nolan - fresh off of the back of his Dark Knight trilogy - was credited as a producer, that it feels downright illegal that it actually came out so darn generically. Not a single aspect feels fresh or innovative - its action scenes, its characters; all dull and humourless. Sure, it's pretty to look at, but just like Superman's iconic Fortress of Solitude, it leaves you feeling cold. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.