10 Disappointing Movies That Killed Our Nostalgia

Rubbish reboots and silly sequels.

Son Of The Mask
New Line Cinema

In the past decade or so, it's become an increasing trend in Hollywood to reboot existing movie franchises, or launch sequels to films that originated way back in the '80s or '90s. Nostalgia is one of the biggest sellers, and the big studio producers know it.

Whilst it's always good to see production companies branching out with new IPs in the cinema, that's not to say some of the reboots haven't been effective at times. Abrams' Star Trek was generally well received back in 2009, and Nolan's Batman movies have been among the biggest releases of the decade.

Sadly, it's often the case that movie reboots and late sequels just end up undermining their brilliant predecessors. Over-use of special effects, excessive fan service, and actors that seem a bit weary of the project have all contributed to terrible movie reboots.

This list takes a look at ten movies that totally killed our nostalgia in one way or another. From films that tried (and failed) to evoke memories of the '80s, to others that somehow butchered the greatest movie franchises of all time, each of these movies were total disappointments.


10. Dumb And Dumber To

Dumb And Dumber To
Universal Pictures

The original Dumb And Dumber was a lot more intelligent than its title let on. The harebrained comedy antics constantly gave the feeling that just about anything could happen, and the fast-paced, twisting road-trip plot was like nothing else.

Dumb And Dumber To is an attempt to capitalise on the growing nostalgic appreciation of the original film. To its credit, it manages to bring back Jim Carrey and Jeff Daniels this time, and has the Farrelly brothers in the directing chair. Sadly, the comedy is far more miss than hit when compared to the laugh-a-minute pace of the original.

There's far too many fan-servicing references, and the film's sense of humour that doesn't quite match what made Dumb And Dumber special.


9. The Expendables

The Expendables
Millennium Films/Nu Image

Unlike many films on this list, The Expendables doesn't try to ride the nostalgia of one specific film. Instead, it set out to be a general throw-back to the big, sweaty '80s action movies of old. The cast featured Sylvester Stallone, Dolph Lundgren, Mickey Rourke, Jason Statham, Jet Li, Randy Couture, and Terry Crews, whilst it was directed by Sly himself.

No matter how 'bad' the film, you're guaranteed a good time, right? Nope. Inexplicably, The Expendables opted for the fast cutting style of action sequences that many have derided in post-2000 action films, making it feel like the edit was compensating for the ageing stars' lack of finesse.

The Expendables and its sequels just aren't as fun as they should have been, totally failing to capture what made the '80s such a great decade for action movie fans.


8. Blues Brothers 2000

Blues Brothers 2000
Universal Pictures

Blue Brothers 2000 was one of the earliest examples of Hollywood realising it could make some serious money through nostalgia alone. The original Blue Brothers movie, released back in 1980, is a musical cult classic, and one of the most hilariously over-the-top, action-packed comedies ever. A reunion film that brought together the original cast 18 years later could have been good fun, if done properly.

Unfortunately, the brilliant John Belushi died in 1982, and even John Goodman wasn't able to live up to the comedy giant. The musical sequences weren't as bad as they could have been, but the comedy was half-baked, and it suffered from less-than-impressive action sequences. Blues Brothers 2000, rather than being a nostalgic throwback to the original, just made us a little sad that we'll never see the dynamic duo of Belushi and Aykroyd together ever again.


7. Scooby-Doo

Scooby Doo 2002
Warner Bros.

Ever since the first episode was broadcast way back in 1969, Scooby-Doo has been a staple of childhoods across the world. The light-hearted comedy and exciting thrills have proven to be a hit for over four decades, making it the perfect candidate for a big budget movie adaptation.

In 2002, Scooby-Doo got exactly that. With an all-star cast featuring Sarah Michelle Gellar, Rowan Atkinson, and Freddie Prinze Jr., it was looking like everyone's favourite Great Dane was getting the big-screen treatment he deserved. Ultimately, despite a decent performance as Shaggy by Matthew Lillard, Scooby-Doo was a total failure, with none of the lovable wit or charm of the original animated series.


6. Son Of The Mask

Son Of The Mask
New Line Cinema

Want to know why everyone loved The Mask? It wasn't the eye-popping special effects, or the various action sequences. Rather, it was Jim Carrey's totally insane performance, with his incredible ability to squeeze laughter out of just about any scene. With this in mind, whose idea was it to create a sequel that doesn't feature Carrey in any way, instead focusing on a CGI baby as the main source of comedy?

Son Of The Mask is terrible in the way very few films are, with almost every sequence painful to watch. Of course, if a dancing, urinating baby sounds like the pinnacle of comedy to you, then this could be your perfect movie. Son Of The Mask is one of the most pointless sequels in history, and possibly the least funny 'comedy' ever made.


5. The Karate Kid

Karate Kid 2010
Columbia Pictures

One of the most iconic movies of the '80s, The Karate Kid introduced the world to Mr. Miyagi and his timeless wisdom. The decade's movie culture was obsessed with martial arts, but The Karate Kid helped to add spirituality and wisdom beyond the usual mindless action.

With the classic underdog tale and positive message for younger audiences, you might think that a remake isn't such a terrible idea. You'd be very wrong. Jackie Chan, while a great personality in his own right, just didn't have the timeless quality of Pat Morita's Mr. Miyagi. The casting of Jaden Smith as the titular kid didn't help either, with a performance that didn't come close to Ralph Macchio.

If you really want to educate the youngsters, then "wax off" this terrible reboot and "wax on" the original classic.


4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Paramount Pictures

Before the '80s came along, few would have thought that one of the most popular media franchises ever would be based around a team of teenage anthromorphic turtles named after Renaissance artists, trained in ninjutsu by a giant rat. When Michael Bay announced that he was making a movie based on the Ninja Turtles, it's fair to say the reaction wasn't entirely positive.

The end result isn't a total disaster, but it's also not particularly entertaining. Lacking the charming wit of the animated series and with too few action sequences to get excited about, Bay's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles turned out to be more dull than anyone could have imagined.


3. Charlie And The Chocolate Factory

Charlie And The Chocolate Factory
Warner Bros.

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory wasn't really a remake of Mel Stuart's Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory. Despite that fact, and maybe unfairly to Burton, it's almost impossible not to make a mental comparison to the '70s classic. Johnny Depp's casting as Willy Wonka did seem like an inspired (if overly obvious) choice, and in an alternate universe it could have been brilliant.

Sadly, Depp just can't hold up to Gene Wilder's absolutely incredible interpretation of the part. Where Wilder was at once magically upbeat and suggestive of something darker, Depp was weird. Where Wilder seemed otherworldly as an eccentric chocolate maker, Depp was... weird. It's not the worst film on this list, but even the highly imaginative costumes and sets couldn't hold up to the unquantifiable magic of Stuart's earlier adaptation.


2. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull

Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
Paramount Pictures

Jumping the shark is an idiom frequently used to mark when a television series begins a significant decline in quality. The movie equivalent? Nuking the fridge.

The most famous scene in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull is primarily referenced in the context of a classic movie series outstaying its welcome. This is a pretty clear indicator of the reception most audiences had towards the special effects-laden film, which saw Harrison Ford brandishing his trademark whip and fedora once again. The story felt too familiar, yet at once totally alien to the rest of the series, as if it was the result of computer software being fed the previous three films.


1. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Lucasfilm

Has there ever been a more disappointing cinematic release than Star Wars Episode I? The trailer was good enough to get even the most casual fan frothing at the mouth with anticipation. The cast of Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, and Natalie Portman seemed highly promising. On top of that, it was based on one of the most critically and commercially successful trilogies ever. In all fairness, The Phantom Menace had a lot to live up to. Arguably, there was no way it could match the expectations leveled against it.

By the time it rolled out into cinemas though, even the staunchest sceptics left amazed at just how badly the film held up to the original trilogy. Criticisms were made against The Phantom Menace's dull plot, wooden dialogue, and juvenile tone that didn't quite fit with its predecessors. Most notorious though, was the character of Jar Jar Binks. Lucas was accused of including the character purely for merchandising reasons, and the unfunny, irritating Gungang managed to be the CGI rotten cherry on top of this unsatisfactory prequel parfait.

-

What films managed to kill your nostalgia for beloved franchises? Are there any we should have included here? Let us know in the comments below!


Contributor
Contributor

Tom Butler hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.