10 Dumbest Ever Horror Movie Protagonists
Dumb, dumber and dumbest.
Horror films are usually so full of dumb people that they’re practically a prerequisite. We’ve all sat down to watch a scary movie and found ourselves screaming at the screen when some idiot with a common sense bypass goes down into the basement when they should be running out the door or decides to split from their group after uttering the immortal words ‘I’ll be right back’ when a maniac killer is on the loose.
But the thing about horror movies is that they kind of rely on idiots to propel the plot. If they didn’t have imbeciles making bad decisions, we wouldn’t get to witness the grim and gruesome situations they find themselves in. In other words, if horror films were populated by real-life people with logical thought processes and sound judgement they’d be over before they’d even really begun.
It’s not too much of an exaggeration then to say that without dumb protagonists in horror movies, we wouldn’t actually have horror movies. They’re as essential an ingredient to the horror film as the big bad villain or the final girl.
So, some stupidity is to be expected but certain acts of sheer idiocy in horror films defy all logic no matter how hard you try to suspend your disbelief. Some horror protagonists make decisions so utterly brainless that you can’t help but wonder if they’ve got a death wish.
Here’s to those characters – the dumbest of the dumb in the horror genre – in all their idiotic glory.
10. Micah - Paranormal Activity
Defining Dumb Moment:
Not taking being terrorised by a demon seriously.
There’s a few easily abided by rules when it comes to dealing with the demonic entity that’s taken up residence in your home yet the arrogant, moronic Micah from Paranormal Activity manages to wilfully break them all.
After being warned by noted psychic Dr Fredrichs – a man well acquainted with all things demonic – not to communicate with or encourage the demon in any way, shape or form Micah continues filming the weird goings-on in he and Katie’s home. He even goes so far as to try and speak with the entity via a Ouija board. So pretty much the exact opposite of the psychic’s advice then.
Even when the demon ups the ante considerably and starts leaving its cloven hoofprints around the house and physically bites Katie, Micah doesn’t think it might be time to get the hell out of there or at least get a demonologist or Catholic priest round.
So when he inevitably and brutally dies at the hands of his own now demonically possessed girlfriend, you have to admit the idiot kind of had it coming.
9. Millburn – Prometheus
Defining Dumb Moment:
Not taking proper precaution when meeting an alien lifeform.
For a movie populated by characters who are scientists and space explorers who you’d assume were reasonably intelligent, Prometheus is surprisingly overflowing with stupidity and idiotic decisions.
But one character that stands out in his sheer and absolute asininity is Millburn. This is a man who after coming across the mostly humanoid corpse of an Engineer in the temple on LV-223 practically soils his spacesuit in fright and wants to go back to the ship. Yet moments later when he encounters an actually alien-looking alien he’s all kinds of enthralled and completely lets his guard down.
So in the world of Millburn logic, humanoid lifeforms are something to be feared but a Hammerpede that emerges from a primordial black goo and looks like a cross between a penis and a cobra suffering from a bad case of vagina dentata? He runs over and tries to pet it like an excitable child meeting a cute puppy. Some biologist.
And that is how you end up getting deep-throated to death by a phallic alien lifeform. Somebody give this man a Darwin Award.
8. Dr Louis Creed - Pet Sematary
Defining Dumb Moment:
Burying not one, not two but three members of his family at a cursed Indian
burial ground.
After his family cat gets run over, Dr Louis Creed takes some rather bad pet care advice from his neighbour Jud Crandall (who is also a bit of an idiot) and buries the kitty’s corpse at an ancient Indian burial ground with the power to resurrect the dead.
What Louis is left with, however, is an undead feline that’s a ferocious sand foul-smelling shell of its former fluffy self. But does this put Louis off doing the exactly the same thing when his toddler son also tragically gets run over? Hell no.
Off Louis trots to the tainted ground and soon enough his formerly angelic child is resurrected as an evil, undead terror tot who ends up committing matricide with a scalpel. Now left with a dead wife on his hands too, Louis – the king of bad decisions – decides to bury her at the ancient Indian burial ground too.
Unsurprisingly to anyone but Louis, she too comes back evil but at least has the common sense to kill him before he can bury any other dead people in that cursed ground.
If the definition of an idiot is someone who makes the same mistakes but expects different results, then dead Dr Louis Creed is exactly that kind of idiot.
7. Barbra Cole - Night Of The Living Dead
1359145Defining Dumb Moment:
Acting like such a hysterical bint in the zombie apocalypse that it gets
her killed.
First things first, let’s recognise that the world is being overtaken by the living dead can be a traumatising time even for the hardiest of souls. That said there are times in one’s life when you just have to pick yourself up and get on with it, zombie apocalypse or not.
Damsel in distress Barbra seems incapable of this, however, and spends most of Night of the Living Dead proving herself the dictionary definition of incompetence. Seriously, within less than five minutes of realising the dead have risen Barbra has already lost both of her shoes and crashed a car into a tree and that’s when she’s dealing with just one lone zombie dude.
Later, in a fleeting moment of good judgement, Barbra finally proves a tad useful when she tries to prevent a zombie horde from entering the house she and her fellow survivors are hiding in. Soon enough though she gets distracted by her distinctly dead-looking brother Johnny but seems too dumb to discern that he’s a zombie now.
That’s despite not having seen Johnny since he, you know, DIED at the start of the film and despite the fact he’s now hanging around with a horde of his new undead friends who help him carry Barbra away and devour her.
Come to think of it, it’s probably for the best she got gobbled up by the living dead: she’d have made for a pretty dumb zombie too.
6. Billy Peltzer – Gremlins
Defining Dumb Moment:
Disobeying every rule in the mogwai care handbook
Pretty much immediately after coming into ownership of Gizmo, Billy Peltzer is informed by his dad of the three very strict but very basic rules of mogwai upkeep – don’t expose them to bright light or sunlight, don’t let them come into contact with water and never feed them after midnight.
Beyond that mogwais are a fairly low maintenance animal but can Billy abide by those three rules? Not even for a second. He starts out by almost instantly melting poor Gizmo by exposing him to bright light several times. Strike one.
Next, he lets clumsy Corey Feldman spill some water he’d irresponsibly left lying around all over Gizmo and caused the little fella to spawn a litter of evil mogwais. Completely disregarding he’s broken yet another rule and the freakish birth he’s just witnessed, Billy then takes one of Gizmo’s offspring to his former science teacher Mr Hanson to show off his new trick, thus creating more bad mogwais. He also fails to inform Hanson of the rules – strike two.
Third time unlucky, Billy proceeds to feed those wicked little critters after midnight. Granted, the bad mogwais messed with his clock but still – it was 11:35pm when he decided to give them a snack. That’s cutting it fine regardless. Strike three.
And that is how you end up with your small, picture-perfect town overrun with murderous gremlins. You had one job, Billy. One job.
5. Paxton – Hostel
Defining Dumb Moment:
Being lured into the most horrific of tourist scams by thinking with his
penis.
Cultural ingrate Paxton hasn’t come to Europe to soak up the different culture or beautiful architecture or fine cuisine. In fact, it seems his whole purpose in doing Europe is to literally do all of Europe. That is, to have sex with as many women as he possibly can – paid for or otherwise.
It’s Paxton’s lusty libido that leads him to instantly agree to an impromptu trip to Slovakia at the suggestion of a total stranger because he’s told there’s a hostel there full of beautiful women who just so happen to love nothing more than having sex with American men. Hmm, doesn’t sound to good to be true at all.
Even if the whole thing didn’t turn out to be a trick to lure Paxton and his mates into the clutches of a tourist torture and murder business, it still sounds like a pretty suspect tourist scam. Even in the best-case scenario Paxton would’ve likely got honey trapped and his money stolen but obviously this ploy went a little further than just petty theft and ended with his friends dead and Paxton missing two fingers.
But then, that’s what thinking with your penis rather than your brain gets you.
4. Bill Murray – Zombieland
Defining Dumb Moment:
Keeping his zombie costume on around people with guns.
To give Bill Murray his due, the surprisingly realistic zombie get-up he dons in Zombieland does serve a useful purpose … at least for a while. Thanks to his costume Bill spent his time in post-apocalyptic Beverly Hills roaming amongst the dead undetected and playing golf.
But all good things must come to and end and such is the case with Bill’s once genius ruse when he comes into contact with people who aren’t the living dead and it proves so convincing that he almost gets himself bludgeoned to death with a golf club by Tennessee and Wichita.
With nary a lesson learned, Bill proceeds to get stoned (a cardinal sin in a horror movie) with his newfound friends who just narrowly avoided killing him and decides to play a prank on Columbus who isn’t yet privy to the fact that Bill Murray is just playing dress-up.
Sneaking up on someone who’s understandably quite jumpy after battling the undead across the USA and is armed with a loaded gun while pretending to be a zombie really isn’t exactly the brightest idea in the world. And it’s that kind of dumb decision-making that gets you shot through the heart.
3. Wendy Torrance - The Shining
Defining Dumb Moment:
Agreeing to move to a haunted as hell hotel with her violent, alcoholic
husband.
So, your husband’s an alcoholic with a violent temper that led to him dislocating your son’s shoulder and he suggests going to live at a remote hotel in the mountains over the cold winter months that a) frequently gets snowed in, b) was built on an ancient Indian burial ground and c) was the site of a grisly act of familicide only a few years earlier?
What could possibly go wrong with that plan? It’s not like your husband will go mad with cabin fever, cheat on you with a rotting female corpse and end up trying to off you and your kid with an axe or anything.
Oh, wait – that’s EXACTLY what happens to Wendy in The Shining and pretty much what befell the murdered Grady family during their stay at the Overlook Hotel.
What’s worse about the predicament Wendy finds herself in is that early in the film we learn via her husband crazy Jack Torrance that she’s “a confirmed ghost story and horror film addict”. If what Jack says is true, then Wendy should know how things are about to go down.
An isolated hotel, an Indian burial ground, a previous murder? Come on, Wendy – a horror aficionada should know that’s a recipe for a not-so-happy, husband chasing you round the hotel wielding an axe kind of ending.
2. Tatum Riley – Scream
Defining Dumb Moment:
Trying to escape Ghostface through a doggy door.
To be fair, as the BFF of the horror heroine Tatum was kind of doomed to die from the very start and even the subversive Scream didn’t see fit to flip that particular trope on its head. Nevertheless, how Tatum gets herself killed is pretty stupid even for somebody destined to snuff it by way of trope.
Realistically, that pet door she tries to escape through looks like it would be hard-pushed to fit your average spaniel or overweight cat through never mind a fully-grown human. Not to mention the fact that she’s in a !*$% garage presumably full of tools she could weaponise against Ghostface.
She even gets the better of Ghostface a couple of times when he falls flat on his derriere but does Tatum take advantage of this or grab any of the potential weapons at her disposal to disarm him? Does she heck.
Instead she makes herself a sitting duck by opting for the doggy door getaway and gets her head crushed for her troubles, the ever-living idiot.
1. Evelyn & Lee Abbott - A Quiet Place
Defining Dumb Moment:
Bringing a baby into a post-apocalyptic world in which silence is key to
survival.
Living in a world overtaken by alien monsters with giant ear holes and hyper-sensitive hearing who will find you and kill you if you make a sound is pretty unfortunate situation for any human given what talkative, noise-making creatures we are.
The Abbott family adapt to their new circumstances fairly well at first but then parents Evelyn and Lee make the jaw-dropping decision to bring a newborn baby into the mix. A mewling, squalling infant that will most likely mark its entry into the world with an ear-splitting cry and spend much of its time thereafter crying.
That’s not exactly the brightest idea in a world in which something as inadvertent as a cough, a sneeze or an audible fart will get you killed and especially not long after you’ve just witnessed your youngest son get gobbled up by monsters for doing what kids do naturally and making a noise.
And this is after the film opens in a pharmacy where the family are silently ransacking for medication and could’ve easily picked up some condoms or contraceptive pills. Or they could’ve, you know, abstained from sex and ridden it out (or not, as the case may be) until the whole alien monster apocalypse thing blew over because bringing another child into that mess is not only stupid but irresponsible too.
No parent of the year award for you, Evelyn and Lee.