10 Dumbest Movie Plot Twists Of 2014

At least none of them said it was all a dream.

Twists are awesome. Nothing is guaranteed to get people talking about a movie more than some deftly-executed narrative slight-of-hand. They are a hard thing to get right - there needs to be significant set-up and a narrative justification to suddenly reveal things are not as they seem. Do it right and you have something that improves the movie as it busts its plot apart, like the Statue of Liberty at the end of The Planet Of The Apes. Do it wrong and you invalidate the whole experience and anger the audience, like Ape Lincoln at the end of Tim Burton's The Planet Of The Apes. 2014 has delivered us some cracking rug-pull moments. Marvel shook up their entire Cinematic Universe by bringing back H.Y.D.R.A. in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, while The Lego Movie smashed its own reality with an incredible, non-blocky cameo. And that's saying nothing of Gone Girl, which so brilliantly duped everyone that it'd be a crime to reveal its secret even now. Typically, however, there's also been a lot of failed attempts to illicit a big audience gasp as well. You can't just whack a last minute reveal onto a movie in the edit and expect Fight Club comparisons, which is something these ten movies didn't quite understand. Come along and see the dumbest plot twists of the year. Obviously, spoilers for all movies included. Tread lightly.

10. The Narrator Is Sleeping Beauty - Maleficent

The Twist: The big twist Maleficient originally intended to have was that "true love" isn't necessarily going to be between a Princess and the Prince she just met. Realising that Frozen had pipped them to the punch (do the various productions at Disney not coordinate?), a second reveal was added. Turns out that Galadriel-style narrator from the intro who stuck around through the whole movie is actually a future Aurora. Why It's So Dumb: Maleficent could easily have been re-titled Narration: The Movie. There's so much padding doled out in voice-over in a movie already overly-long and heavy on exposition. Yet rather than finding a better way to get the info across, the writers decided to flimsily justify it with this lazy last minute reveal and call it a day. The story of Sleeping Beauty is not a complicated one - the original animation is 75 minutes long and half of that's Aurora singing the seventeen different versions of Once Upon A Dream - and even with the shoe-horned "re-imagining" Maleficent really doesn't have a complexity that needs to be expanded upon. And trying to tie the narrator to the story doesn't hide that fact.

9. Love Is A Force - Interstellar

The Twist: Compared to Inception or The Prestige, Interstellar was Christopher Nolan working with a generally standard narrative structure. There's no ambiguous ending, nor a movie altering reveal in the final moments. But there is still that universe-realigning discovery that love is the most powerful force in the universe, allowing Matthew McConnaughey to travel through time to his daughter's bedroom. If you've not seen the film, let's just clarify that isn't made up - that's literally what happens. Why It's So Dumb: When Dr. Brand, one of the world's best scientists, first brings up her totally un-scientific theory about love being a force, rather than a mix of chemicals brought about by man's inherent social nature, it's easy to chalk that up to longing for un-seen love interest Edmunds. That is until Cooper goes into a black hole and suddenly the audience learns it was all true. The fifth-dimensional beings that created the wormholes being future humans? Absolutely fine. Cooper sending the secrets of gravity using Morse code and a second hand? Just go with it. All of this being happening out of Cooper's love for his daughter? That's where the line is. Interstellar as a film isn't as dumb as some of its critics would like you to think, but having the entire human race saved by a father-daughter dynamic is Nolan trying too hard to deal with the criticisms of him being emotionally cold.

8. Peeta Has Been Brainwashed - The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1

The Twist: Catching Fire came with one of the most unexpected gut-punch twists of 2013, not only revealing the whole movie had been a complicated Rebel plot, but that Katniss' home state, Distinct 12, had been burnt to the ground. Mockingjay Part 1 had no hope of matching that, although it did its absolute best. After being rescued from the Capitol, it's revealed the foppish vertex of the central love triangle, Peeta, has been brainwashed by the evil Empire - once reunited, he immediately tries to crush Katniss' wind-pipe. Gotta love modern family films. Why It's So Dumb: The twist is going to work for one half of the audience and utterly fail with the other. If you're a teenager, then it's the best thing ever, like having Tyler Durden, Keyser Söze and Darth Vader delivered all in one go. If you've got anything more than a passing knowledge of film, however, it's obvious Peeta and Katniss aren't about to get it on from the moment Gale muses how easy the escape was. At no point in the history of film has that led to anything good. What makes this especially dumb is that, thanks to the finically-brilliant-yet-creative-vapid decision to split the final book in two, this mid-story divergence becomes a whopping big cliff-hanger. In print this happens, but the audience isn't left with a year to mull over how cack-handed it is - that whole "the movie's story has been a secret scheme" was the exact same twist the previous movie pulled

7. Hercules Isn€™t A Demi-God - Hercules

The Twist: It's alluded to throughout the movie, so shouldn't come as much of a shock, but at the end it's rather explicitly hinted that Hercules, a Greek legend famous for being the son of Zeus, isn't the son of Zeus. He's just a normal man with an incredible P.R. team - the twelve labours were completed by a whole gang of people so his name would strike so much fear into his enemies he wouldn't even have to fight. Why It's So Dumb: Hercules is inherently a dumb film, but thanks to being self-aware enough (and casting The Rock) it comes away as a properly fun B-Movie experience. Urgh, it actually hurts to praise a Brett Ratner picture like this. Unlike John Hurt being thrown down a chasm in a comedic, pseudo-dramatic manner, however, this twist is a different type of dumb. As an idea it's pretty smart, using human psychology as a potent alternative as brute force, but it's totally out of place in Hercules. The myth isn't ingrained in popular culture to the extent where re-imagining is legitimate (like with Batman or Superman) and somehow this conceit allows a film that is categorically not an origin story still serve as a character moulding adventure.

6. Colin Firth Is The Baddie - Before I Go To Sleep

The Twist: Nicole Kidman is an amnesiac and finds herself interacting with the same two men every day, Colin Firth and Mark Strong. Trying to unravel the mystery of her condition (hard when your memories reset every day), Kidman's Christine eventually discovers that her husband (Firth) is actually a dangerous impostor. How dare you, Darcy. Why It's So Dumb: Before I Go To Sleep suffered distinctly from an inability to commit. Unlike Memento, the high watermark against which all memory loss movies must be judged, the movie is too eager to move the narrative forward at the behest of its character. The audience is given so much more information than its hero, to the extent where it's hard to empathise with Christine (and the question of what's happening to her). In regards to the twist, the film teases things a little too much. Its focus is so tight that clearly one of the two men is a bad-un and after Strong's Dr. Nasch is suspected and cleared of manipulation, obviously it's husband Ben who's not as he seems. It certainly doesn't help that the film thinks it's being really smart by having the typically bad actor (Strong) not be the bad guy. While it's a nice observation, the Jaguar advert before the movie had already pointed that out.

5. Gustav Fiers Is The Man In The Shadows - The Amazing Spider Man 2

The Twist: Because it's so much easier to copy Marvel than try anything distinct in the super-hero genre, The Amazing Spider-Man featured a mid-credits sting that showed a de-transformed Lizard visited by a mysterious "Man in the Shadows" who took a distinct interest in Peter Parker. It took over two hours of confused setting up of further sequels, but The Amazing Spider-Man 2 finally revealed who this trilby-ed mystery man was - he's Gustav Fiers. Wait, who? Why It's So Dumb: Gustav Fiers' reveal is the equivalent of the guy under the mask at the end of a Scooby-Doo episode being a totally new character (this did happen once and it was as disappointing as you'd expect). Not only is there nothing in the Amazing world pertaining to him, but he's so obscure a comic book character that even Spidey die-hards would be left scratching their heads. Known as The Gentleman, Fiers' only previous appearances in the lore have been in text novels, with the comics wisely not including such a lazily conceived character. How is his inclusion meant to get everyone amped for The Sinister Six? It's emblematic of how Sony really don't understand what they're doing with Spider-Man, tossing in whatever elements they can in the hope the franchise can free-wheel itself to success. At least the Shadow Man mystery was somewhat solved - Uncle Ben's killer is still a free man.

4. Galvatron Is Megatron - Transformers: Age Of Extinction

The Twist: You'd be forgiven for thinking Michael Bay had gotten a little self-aware with Transformers: Age Of Extinction, which shows a massive corporation trying to replicate Transformers for financial gain, but completely missing the point of their appeal. Predictably it's just another boring narrative diversion in between the equally boring fight scenes, although he does try (and fail) to inject some fun into proceedings by providing audiences with a quote unquote twist. Turns out that the big prototype robot, Galvatron, isn't actually controlled by the company, but by Decepticon leader Megatron, giving the presumed-dead alien a new body. Why It's So Dumb: If you're familiar with the Generation 1 cartoon, in particular the re-defining The Transformers: The Movie, then this is a null-surprise - in that film Megatron is explicitly transformed into Galvatron. Although even if you've never seen any of the less-offensive takes on the character, it's still obvious. Galvatron is made using Megatron as a model, he looks like Megatron and Megatron is such a popular character (read: his merchandise sells well) that Hasbro wouldn't let him lie. The whole change of body was probably only brought about because Hugo Weaving finally realised just how bad the movies were. It seems rather perfunctory to point out a Transformers movie has poor plotting, but this is such a dire attempt at narrative intrigue it needs to be mentioned. The entire second act is built around this point, and yet there's no desire to give it any purpose.

3. Lee Killed Merrin - Horns

The Twist: Daniel Radcliffe is magically given horns when his girlfriend is murdered and he becomes the prime suspect. Obviously he didn't do it (because he's Harry Potter), so, in between flashbacks galore and some odd comedic sojourns (the film even has a horny pun), Ignatius (it's smart because it means "fiery one") sets out to find out who did. Turns out it was Lee, his childhood best friend and the lawyer actually trying to get him off the murder charges, that did it. Why It's So Dumb: As with Transformers and Before I Go To Sleep, Horns' big reveal is one made painfully obvious ahead of time thanks to a small pool of characters - Lee is the only one who could have killed her - but that's not what makes it so dumb. Horns has a genre-juggling approach from the start, straddling several different movie types, but the twist pushes things too far - Lee suddenly becomes an indestructible killer in the vein of Jason Vorhees or Michael Myers. It's fine for the mild-mannered guy to have a dark rapist underside, but that's stretching the limits of credibility, even in a movie where Daniel Radcliffe sprouts horns. Speaking of the horns, the murderer reveal manages to completely distract the movie from the actual question the audience wants answering - why does Ig get the horns in the first place? That integral plot point is lost in favour of Max Minghella shooting a gay policeman.

2. What Happens At 100% - Lucy

The Twist: Take the idea humans use 10% of their brain. Now, what would happen if they used more? Telekinesis, phone-tapping and involuntary teetotalism is the answer Lucy posits. As the film ramps to its climax, so does the eponymous heroine's brain capacity, with the final minutes seeing her hit the much lauded 100%. She becomes a massive supercomputer, leaves the confines of time and space, and then becomes ethereal (exactly like Samantha in Her), although not before giving Morgan Freeman a USB stick of "knowledge". Why It's So Dumb: Lucy's science is dumb. That should be obvious, although as this movie based on a ridiculous urban legend was made by a director who in interviews insisted he subscribed to its central idea, it probably still needs to be stated. Its twist, however, is something else. There's a level of self-imposed importance to Lucy travelling backwards in time to the dawn of man that works against the grain of a definite popcorn treat. This is supposed to be a Léon-inflected action film that serves as a proto-Black Widow movie, not a The Tree Of Life-style meditation on humanity. Unbelievably, the jumps back to creation make even less sense here than they did in Mallick's opus.

1. It€™s All... A Thing? - The Maze Runner

The Twist: Boys wake up in a strange glade at the centre of an ever-changing maze is the set-up of this young adult adaptation piggybacking on The Hunger Games' success. And naturally discovering what exactly is going on is the main narrative thrust. By the end the sub-Lord Of The Flies gang have made it out, finding a massive, abandoned operations centre, before being whisked away by a platoon of soldiers. A final scene reveals this was all part of some mysterious plan. Why It's So Dumb: If you're going to have a twist, commit to having a twist. Don't give the audience a bone of an answer before immediately yanking them into a bigger mystery. It'd be like Darth Vader revealing he didn't kill Anakin Skywalker, but then leaving the rest of the twist for another adventure. That's exactly what The Maze Runner does - instead of an answer, we just get a continuation of the mystery masquerading as a reveal. It's made abundantly clear from less than halfway through that the maze is being controlled by a group of suits early on, so finding out that it's being controlled by a group of suits at the end is a paltry reward. Episodic movie-making is here to stay, which is a shame when most franchises (i.e. anything that isn't Marvel) don't put much effort in individual entries working in a stand-alone manner. The Maze Runner teases answers due in the later movies, but still presents its ending as if it's a satisfying conclusion. It's not. What do you think are the dumbest twists of the year? Let us know in the comments below.

In this post: 
interstellar
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.