10 Dumbest "Smart" Movies Ever Made

They think they're so smart, but they're not...

Is there anything worse than a dumb kid parading around like they're the smartest in class? Strutting around immune to criticism because of their lack of self-awareness. It's infuriating. Count that doubly when it comes to films. Those dumbo charlatans are often so infuriating that you€™ll find yourself complaining about them for years beyond release. Maybe you€™ll even write a rage-fuelled article about it... These movies - that present themselves as €˜this€™ll really make you think€™ material but then turn out to be nothing more than over-hyped cinematic simpletons - are a pet peeve of many cinemagoers, and it's mostly because they sucker you. They€™ll draw you in with smart-seeming trailers and pre-release hype, and then leave you cold and confused as the credits roll. Sometimes it€™ll be evident from the start that you€™re watching one of these dumb €˜smart€™ movies. On other occasions, though, you€™ll be convinced by a movie€™s mind-testing mettle until a disappointing third act screws it all up, failing to follow through on the film€™s intellectually stimulating promises. Obviously, they€™re still fun to rip apart in discussions at the pub, but you€™ll probably never want to watch them again. Which is sort of the opposite of what a film should aspire to.

10. Terminator: Genisys

For some unknown reason, Terminator: Genisys seems to think very highly of itself. It€™s a movie that tries to force a thought-provokingly modern rebrand (Skynet is an app now) on a beloved, classic film property. In the pre-release material, we were repeatedly told how €˜relevant€™ the film was going to be. But Genisys was dumb on several levels. Arnold Schwarzenegger€™s unstoppable killing machine was now a source of comic relief, and it stole action beats wholesale from other films (the bus flip on the bridge was pretty much a direct lift from The Dark Knight). Worst of all, Genisys even managed to dumb down its own clever, €˜relevant€™ rethink €“ the idea that Skynet is an app results in one of the stupidest scenes in the movie. The bit where, with decades to prepare for the Genisys launch, all but one of the characters time travel to the actual ruddy day before the event and flap around helplessly. The idea that an app wouldn€™t be ready until the minute before it launched is incredibly naïve, as well. Would Skynet not have finished it months ago? Surely it would be completed a little earlier than the actual day it€™s going live? Didn't they do any testing? Were there no prototypes at all?

9. The Butterfly Effect

There are a lot of fun scenes in The Butterfly Effect, and plenty of people love the film (enough for two sequels to be made, at least). Regardless of that, this is still a film that presents itself as a highly clever time travel movie, then makes a farce of its premise by breaking its own rules. The worst offending scene is when Ashton Kutcher€™s Evan travels back in time, in order to prove his abilities to his cell mate. He goes back to his preschool days, and stabs himself through the hand. Back in the present, scars appear on his hand to prove his point. Yeah, it€™s a cool idea, but the film seems to forget that it€™s own version of time travel doesn€™t work like that. Why would the scars only just turn up in the prison cell, back in the present day? If he had scarred himself as a child, he would have always had the scars, and his cellmate would already have known about them. Also, going back and stabbing himself would surely have ramifications on Evan€™s life. He would€™ve grown up as the kid who stabbed himself. His family would know, and his friends would now. Presumably he€™d be sent to therapy, and certain details of his entire life would have changed. The film never addresses this, though, because it€™s not as clever as it thinks it is.

8. The Dark Knight Rises

The Dark Knight Rises is another film that really played up its social relevance in the build up to its release. It was suggested that this was going to be a clever film, with allusions to the banking crisis. In reality, though, the movie isn€™t nearly as smart as it wants us to think. Notably, there are some huge gaps of logic in The Dark Knight Rises. Commissioner Gordon makes the dunce-level decision to send almost the entire police department in the sewers, for example. And then there€™s the scene when Bruce somehow knows the exact location of the café that Alfred mentioned that one time. Worse than that, the stock exchange scene was something of a let down, too. Rather than real social commentary, we get a generic armed robbery scene with little logical sense behind it. Surely, with 100s of witnesses and camera footage to prove that Bruce hadn€™t made the transactions, the fraud would have been proven very quickly, and Bruce€™s company kept safe. While this isn€™t exactly a plot hole €“ it€™s more of a flawed logic moment €“ it just proves that trying to be clever can sometimes make your film look dumb. By trying to make a big statement about the modern world, Christopher Nolan ended up with an irritatingly jarring scene in the middle of his movie.

7. Star Trek Into Darkness

Star Trek Into Darkness had a promotional campaign stuffed full of 9/11 imagery (notably the Enterprise crashing into a populous area). Clearly, we were meant to think of this as a politically relevant, highly intelligent addition to the Star Trek franchise. Instead, we got a film with more idiotic moments than most. We see Khan somehow beam from one planet to another (nullifying the whole point of spaceships), and later his blood is used to resurrect Captain Kirk (suggesting that anyone killed in the future of Star Trek can be saved with a simple blood transfusion). Yes, the Enterprise does crash, and some of the stylistic decisions do invoke the idea of modern day terrorism, but that isn€™t enough to justify presenting your movie as big and clever, and then actually delivering something filled with silly logic. And of course, there€™s the decision to make John Harrison secretly Khan. Behind the scenes, that was surely perceived as a smart decision that the fans would love. In reality, it was actually a fairly rubbish moment, as the score went all dramatic, and the camera pulled in, and Benedict Cumberbatch hammily sneered a name that meant absolutely nothing to any of the other characters and everything to the fans who had known it all along.

6. Looper

Ah, Looper: a movie that was almost entirely blase about its own time travel logic, sharing genetic material with Terminator Genisys by having a character simply refused to explain anything in detail because it wasn't possible. Straw diagrams were very much out of the question. It€™s all too complicated, too clever, to explain. Or so we're told. But really, Looper€™s use of time travel is a breeding ground for stupid errors and gaps in logic. The scene where Paul Dano€™s character is being dismembered, so his older self can be ambushed, for example. Surely, having fingers and limbs removed in his youth would change his entire life? Like the Butterfly Effect scene discussed earlier, such a big alteration would surely have ramifications. Call me a pedant, but the misunderstanding of causality throughout the movie makes little to no sense. If Joe sends himself back to stop the Rainmaker from existing, and then he does, surely the Rainmaker would never have killed Joe€™s wife, and Joe would never have gone back? He really should have tried out a few straw diagrams. We€™ve talked about the errors in this film in more detail here, if you want to read more about Looper€™s unique brand of dumbness.

5. Limitless

The not actually terrible Limitless hinges on the premise that Bradley Cooper's struggling writer character Eddie becomes really smart thanks to the mind-enhancing drug NZT. He quickly bashes out that book he€™d been meaning to finish, and then borrows some money from a loan shark (Andrew Howard) to set his next plan in motion €“ making loads of cash. With the cash in hand, he heads to the stock market and makes shedloads of money. Everything is looking pretty cushty for a time, before Eddie comes home to find that the loan shark looking for him. Eddie forgot to pay him back. Trouble is afoot, and the shark ends up on NZT as well, becoming a major annoyance for Eddie. But let€™s just rewind a minute €“ Eddie is supposed to be super smart. It€™s literally the very concept that defines the film - he€™s meant to be a super genius. But he forgets to pay back the scary Russian loan shark? If you€™re a pedant like me, your interest in the film begins to unravel at that point. Clearly, this stupid moment was a necessary evil as the film needed to make a villainous threat out of Howard€™s character. However, in making the super smart character look idiotically stupid, the whole movie suffers.

4. Avatar

Avatar perceives itself as having a strong ecological message. Ask pretty much anyone you meet (lest we forget that this is the biggest blockbuster of all time), and they€™ll tell you that the exploitation of fossil fuels is the defining underlying subtext of the movie. However, the way in which these themes are explored verges on idiocy. There is literally an element called €˜Unobtainium€™, for crying out loud. I€™ve seen more storytelling nuance in a colouring book. By being so on-the-nose about its eco subtext, the film treats us all like fools incapable of understanding subtlety. There€™s also the fact that Avatar is hugely derivative. When witnessing elements of Dances With Wolves and Pocahontas rehashed before our eyes, it€™s difficult to think of Avatar as an intelligent film that actually has any new or important to say. This is dumbness parading as cleverness, yet again. You also get to witness some stellar stupidity from the Na€™vi characters. After the battle with the humans is done, rather than imprisoning them or making some kind of peace treaty, they just send them back home. Back to where their weapons are kept. Where they can plot their next attack. Sure, that probably happens to enable the next film, but it doesn€™t make it any less stupid.

3. Ocean€™s Eleven

Ocean€™s Eleven is a terrifically fun movie and more so than quite a few of the films on this list, it€™s very watchable. That is, however, until one big scene at the end tries its best to ruin the movie with spectacular levels of stupidity. So, the original loot that left the vault was actually filled with fake money. While Benedict rushed to catch the decoy loot, George Clooney€™s Danny Ocean and assorted friends casually left the venue with the real money whilst disguised as a SWAT team. But when and how could they have swapped the real money with the fake decoy? It€™s not an exaggeration to say that there genuinely wasn€™t a single second when this could have happened. Only three people entered the vault €“ one by hiding in a trolley, and two by negotiating some lasers. None of them had a big bag of fake cash with them. Here, the script pretends to be clever by dangling an impossible scenario in front of the audience. But - seeing as there€™s no explanation - this isn€™t actually clever, it€™s highly dumb. It€™s an aggravating example of deus ex machina in what could otherwise have been a fantastic film.

2. The Matrix Franchise

Three films, thrice the stupidity. These films, sadly, aren€™t half as clever as they€™d like us to think they are. Looking past the fact that the series€™ metaphysical premise is hardly all that original, there are still many stupid moments in these films. The idea that the sky has been scorched to stop the machines is rather silly, for starters. Without the sun, it€™s surely not a given that Earth would continue to survive in any way. And also €“ if the machines need a power source that gives off heat, aren€™t there easier ways to do that then creating a super-complicated virtual reality to enslave all the humans? Couldn€™t you just kill all the humans and get some heat from a few billion nice placid cows instead? At the end of Matrix: Reloaded, the series also pretty much abandons its own concept by allowing Neo to have all his powers outside The Matrix, not just within the programme. This allowed for some more cool action scenes, but is a fairly dumb decision that undermines the basic fabric of the original story. We could write a whole article about the stupid things in the supposedly-smart Matrix franchise. In fact, we did.

1. Skyfall

Ironically, Skyfall's biggest dumb decision is in trying to present its villain as some sort of mega-genius. After all, there comes a point when making a character too clever simply seems stupid. This applies to Javier Bardem€™s Silva, in a big way. It turns out that he€™s predicted every tiny detail of the film€™s twisty second act well in advance. This goes all the way to rigging explosives in the exact tunnel where Bond would later chase him, and timing a tube train€™s arrival in perfect synchronisation. Yes, it€™s a cool action beat, but it€™s dumb, sloppy scripting. Despite all Silva€™s ingenious plans, his chosen method of trying to kill M is to barge into a court hearing and shoot the place up. As if, in that scenario, she wouldn€™t have been quite well guarded. Why didn€™t he just break out of his cell when she was in the same room as him, if he€™s so clever? He€™s seemingly only intelligent when the action demands it, but an idiot when it doesn't. It€™s frustrating to watch. Introducing Ben Whishaw as young, savvy Q was a pretty cool decision, admittedly. Clearly, he€™s meant to be a clever character. However, he makes the immensely stupid decision to plug Silva€™s virus-filled laptop directly into the MI6 mainframe without taking any security precautions. Moron. Are there any dumb €˜smart€™ movies that really grind your gears? Let us know in the comments€

Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.