10 Most Emotionally Devastating Kids' Films

10 movies which support the theory that kids' movies were designed to make you into an emotional wreck for the rest of your life.

You would think that we would want to protect our children. With all the Mary Whitehouse types running around, yelling "Think of the children!" it's easy to get the impression that adults want kids to stay in a nice, safe, emotionally static bubble. Never exposed to anything painful or uncomfortable. But you wouldn't know it by taking a look at the kind of films we watched as kids.

Seriously. Sure, people get sad when they watch Terms of Endearment or Schindler's List, but if you want to see some real tears, show them a kids' film. Almost any one film will do. All of the best stories have some deep, emotional subtext going on, and in a lot of ways, films were our first exposure to the really dark stuff. Death. Loss. Existentialism. I mean, you would think that they would save that stuff for when you're a little older, but I guess not, since Disney has made a career out of emotionally crippling the youth of the nation.

Looking back, I genuinely wonder how we made it to adulthood without lasting emotional damage from watching these films as children. But we did (well, for the most part). So let's celebrate those kids' films that we can't believe were allowed to be as horrifyingly depressing as they were...

10. Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey

It would be really easy for someone to assume that a movie that personifies a group of animals on a cross-country adventure couldn't possibly be sad. I mean, it's two dogs and a cat, voiced by a trio of delightful actors, and there's probably just going to be a ton of adorable Milo and Otis type stuff going on, right? WRONG. These pets face a deadly onslaught of external forces on the journey back to their humans, and for any kids out there who are big animal lovers, this is as close to hell as you're ever going to get. It's bad enough that Sally (the fancy cat voiced by Sally Field) goes over A FREAKING WATERFALL, but that's not even the worst thing that happens. What does that say about a film, when that's not the worst thing? Because then there's Shadow. The dependable old golden retriever voiced by Don Ameche. The faithful dog that you know isn't long for this world, but you don't even want to think about that because it's just too horrible. Well anyway, Shadow gets stuck in a mud bank, and can't fight his way out because he's so old and tired and Jesus why am I even talking about this I swore I would never think about it again? It's truly horrible. I mean, he gets out eventually, but that doesn't magically erase my emotional scars, you know?

9. The Lion King

Simba has a wonderful relationship with his father Mufasa. He is shown all the majesty of his kingdom, and is taught the lessons that will one day serve him well as the leader of the pride. So really, it kind of goes without saying that Mufasa is going to die a horrible death. This is Disney, after all. But I don't think anyone quite anticipated just how his death would psychologically affect Simba. His father isn't just killed before his eyes, in the horrific, bloody, and outrageously painful death of being crushed by a stampede. Of course not. That would be too simple. Because you see, Simba is also manipulated into believing that his beloved father's death was his fault. And at that moment, we all threw away our innocence right along with the poor traumatised lion cub. It's just so unbelievably screwed up for this death scene to go down like that. It's every kids' worst nightmare to lose one of their parents, and to have to live with the guilt of it being your fault (whether that's true or not) is so far beyond what I was emotionally able to handle at the age of seven.

8. A Little Princess

A Little Princess was one of my most treasured films from my childhood, but you wouldn't know it from looking at the kid version of me, because I barely ever made it to the end without some serious tears. It's the story of a bright, kind young girl named Sara Crewe, who is forced into indentured servitude after her father and only living relative is reported as killed in action during World War I. Her strength and courage are powerful to watch, especially as a small child with little to no experience with the emotions that are being presented in the film. There are two parts that never fail to make me cry, and if you've ever seen the movie I'm sure you know what they are. One involves the first night that Sara spends in the filthy, dinghy old attic, when she draws a circle in chalk on the floor to protect her while she sobs helplessly for her papa. I know... right? The second is at the end of the film, with all the crying and the rain and the almost falling to a painful death and the "Papa, please! You have to know me!" You know what, it's probably better if we don't even talk about it.

7. Up

To be fair, I think Up might have been more traumatising for the adults who watched it than the kids. It deals with some pretty deep emotional issues between flying balloon adventures. And I don't care how old you are, the first fifteen minutes are among the most heart-wrenching I've ever seen, let alone in a film marketed towards children. It deals with the evolution of the relationship between our main character Carl and his wife Ellie. They meet as children, and together they plan out the exciting life they're going to lead. But little by little, life gets in the way of their plans, until Ellie dies and he is left a bitter, heartbroken old man. And despite having used up all of our emotional strength and being left exhausted, that's really only where the story begins. Although the beginning is the part that will have you reaching for a tissue, the entire film deals with issues of love, loss, and grief. Maybe not what all the kiddies were expecting when they saw the commercials, with comedic talking dogs and brightly colored balloons lifting a quaint little house into the sky. But hey, they've got to learn sometime that life is a perpetual disappointment and will never turn out the way we planned, am I right?

6. All Dogs Go to Heaven

Honestly, the title of this film was enough to put me off watching it when I was a kid, because talking about dogs going to heaven implies that all dogs die someday and that was just not something I ever wanted to think about. The film is about a dog named Charlie, who is murdered by his business partner and goes to heaven. While there, he steals his life watch, which allows him to go back to Earth with one major caveat - if the watch stops ticking, he goes to hell. Immediately. Do not pass go, do not collect $200, go directly to hell. So he's back on Earth, and he's protecting/taking advantage of a little orphan girl named Anne-Marie. But as the movie progresses, he softens and has a change of heart about the way he's treated the little girl. He eventually gives up his life to save hers, re-earning him a spot up in heaven. He is allowed back down to Earth in ghost form one last time to say goodbye to Anne-Marie, and the movie goes into really sad territory pretty quickly after that. But you want to know the depressing icing on top of the already heartbreaking cake? This was Judith Barsi's (Anne-Marie) last role - the ten-year-old was murdered by her father months after finishing her work on this film. So, yeah... take a minute and try to recover from that.

5. The NeverEnding Story

If you've ever met a twenty-something with a moustache waxing poetically about Camut's The Stranger, you have The NeverEnding Story to thank. It's essentially every kid's introduction to existentialism. In a land that is slowly fading into nothingness, a young boy is tasked with its salvation. I understand why they would bring Bastian into the mix. After all, the pure heart of a child and imagination and rainbows and stuff like that would probably be enough to fight off the Nothing, but why Atreyu? He's supposed to be the strongest warrior in Fantasia, and no one raises an eyebrow at that? This kid has to pretty much travel through hell by himself? Yeah, that sounds about right. So you're watching The NeverEnding Story, and you think you've got a handle on it. Nothing too bad, no tears yet. But then Atreyu gets to the Swamps of Sadness, and even as a kid you know nothing good can come out of that. Anyway, long story short, kid you were right, because Atreyu's beloved horse Artax can't fight the crippling sadness caused by the swamps, and quickly drowns. I've often tried to think of a more apt visualisation of depression, but this movie has been out since 1984 and I haven't come up with anything yet.

4. The Land Before Time

The Land Before Time is basically the story of children separated from their parents while fighting for their survival during a mass migration. You know, not anything that children legitimately have fears about. Because no one thought that might be a little hard for the kidlets to watch. There's one particularly horrifying scene where a young triceratops is separated from her family during an earthquake. As in, she is literally on a different tectonic plate from her parents and has to watch as they drift further and further away. I know people who, after watching this scene as a kid, had nightmares about this happening to them.

But of course, no discussion of The Land Before Time would be complete without Littlefoot, and the sh*tstorm he has to wade through in this film. First his mother is killed by a T-Rex, then he gets separated from his grandparents, then he has to lead a ragtag group of whiners to the Promised Land. Surprisingly, despite the large number of sequels to this film that were made, none of them detailed Littlefoot's time in dinosaur therapy.

3. Bambi

Bambi was the beta test for the cinematic emotional blitzkrieg visited upon children to this very day. It created a vicious cycle, in which the psychological damage visited upon one generation leads to the infliction of said damage on the next. Because you know who made The Lion King? The people who grew up watching Bambi. Eventually you get to a point where you start to think, "If I had to go through it, then these little b*stards are gonna go through it too!" But in a lot of ways, Bambi was so much worse than The Lion King. The latter was made in the 90s, with fifty years of Disney history to prepare us for the way sh*t was probably going to go down. And it was based on Hamlet, so you knew it probably wasn't going to be all sunshine and rainbows. But Bambi was just so idyllic. It's about this adorable little deer who's learning how to walk and makes a bunch of new woodland friends. Even the animation style is so soft and gentle you can't imagine anything bad is going to happen in this film. And then all of a sudden, Bambi's mother is shot by a hunter, and Bambi's world falls apart. It was a sneak attack, and we still haven't recovered fully. Hell, I still don't trust hunters.

2. My Girl

My Girl was a staple of my formative years. Vada Sultenfuss is the average preteen girl trying to navigate her way through life - albeit the average girl who lives in a funeral home and has a morbid obsession with death. She's got a lot going on... she's going through all the wonderful changes that puberty brings, her widowed father is seeing a new woman, and she's trying to decide if she should stay close to her best friend Thomas (played by Macaulay Culkin) or try to make new female friends. Also, there are a lot of bees in the area, and Thomas is allergic to everything. That might become relevant later in the story. Vada drops her mood ring in the forest one day, and Thomas goes back later to try to find it for her. Sadly, when he finds the ring, he also finds a hornet's nest, and is stung. To death. Vada's experience of grief, from the moment she finds out that Thomas is dead to the memorable scene at the funeral, was one of our generation's first exposures to this kind of loss. We learned that kids like us could die, and not just sick kids that you see on TV, but average, every day kids, too. It was a sobering realisation - a little piece of our childhood died that day.

1. Old Yeller

I don't know why filmmakers like to torture children with the death of their beloved pet dog, but it definitely seems to have been a theme for the past sixty years or so. Interesting story: when I looked this film up on Wikipedia to get some of the specifics, it had it listed as a "family tragedy film." You know the film industry has a morbid fascination with terrifying children when "family tragedy" is a genre that even exists. Old Yeller is the story of a young boy and his dog, who live on a farm together and are pretty much attached at the hip. It's sort of a Lassie situation, where the dog is constantly protecting the boy and his family. But one day, the dog gets into a fight with a rabid wolf, and contracts the painful, fatal disease. The boy decides that it's his responsibility to deal with the problem, and shoots Yeller to put him out of his misery, essentially waving goodbye to his childhood. I don't know a single person who has made it out of this film as anything other than a gibbering mess of snot and tears. It has a significant place in popular culture as one of the biggest tearjerkers of all time, and even if people haven't seen it, you can bet that they know exactly what happens at the end of Old Yeller. Like this list? Any to add? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.