10 Established Actors Who Completely Failed At Being Action Stars

All heart, no muscle.

John Cusak action
Paramount Vantage

Who among us didn't try to replicate the things they saw in movies when they were little? If you were into action movies, that included highly-choreographed fist fights, reckless car chases, and repelling off exploding rooftops with a firehose wrapped around your waste. Ya know, typical action hero stuff.

Now, if you were given a chance to actually play out those stunts on the big screen, wouldn't you take it? Hollywood actors are people too, it turns out, and so it's only natural many of them would be drawn to the spectacle of action films and the chance to hurl themselves off a moving train and onto a bad guy's throat.

And surely any expertly-trained thespian could make the easy transition into the "dumbest" of all genres. Right? Well...maybe not so much.

You do have to give Hollywood credit for tossing a bunch of big name actors against the action hero wall to see who sticks, though. After all, could anyone have imagined Bruce Willis transforming into John McClane following his stint on Moonlighting? Or that a 60-year-old Liam Neeson punching wolves in the face would be so engrossing?

But for every Willis and Neeson, there are just as many well-known actors who have tried and failed to make an impact on the brawny genre.

10. Ice Cube

Ice Cube Ghosts Of Mars John Carpenter
Screen Gems

Attempts: Anaconda (1997), Three Kings (1999), All About the Benjamins (2002), Torque (2004), xXx: State of the Union (2005), Ride Along (2014), Ride Along 2 (2016)

Ice Cube is not an action star, nor has he ever been an action star. Is he capable of realistically reenacting the violence he used to rap about in NWA? Sure. We can't ignore Boyz N The Hood and Dangerous Ground. But to suggest the man behind classics like "It Was A Good Day" was ever primed to follow in Sylvester Stallone's footsteps is just silly.

For starters, only one of the movies listed above is generally looked back on with fondness, and it's the least action-oriented of the bunch. Three Kings is more black comedy than war movie, though Cube acclimates himself well enough to the role. The Ride Along movies are decent buddy cop movies in the mold of the Lethal Weapon sequels, but again, the action is secondary.

His true action vehicles have ranged from purposefully ridiculous (Torque) to insultingly sloppy (All About the Benjamins) to, well...whatever the hell Anaconda is. And if you needed any proof that Cube can't hang with the action crowd, his flabby attempt at filling in for Vin Diesel in the xXx sequel should put that debate to rest.


9. Pamela Anderson

Pamela Anderson Barb Wire
Gramercy Pictures

Attempts: Barb Wire (1996)

Baywatch was one of the weirdest cultural phenomena of the 90s. A soap opera masquerading as an adventure series, it was ultimately just a series about lifeguards running toward danger in super slow motion that somehow lasted for 11 seasons. Two of the biggest reasons for that were the show's star, Pamela Anderson.

Looking to ride the wave of Anderson's cult popularity -- bolstered by the infamous Tommy Lee sex tape in 1995 -- she was cast in the R-rated Barb Wire, based on the Dark Horse comic of the same name. Anderson plays the titular role, a nightclub owner and mercenary who also strips on the side. No part of that sentence was made up just now.

But Pam Anderson was no Pam Grier, and her voluptuousness -- often confused for genuine sexuality -- only got in the way.

She took the movie too seriously to be camp, but not seriously enough to give it any kind of dramatic edge. Let's just call this what it is: An attempt to cash in on the pubescent population that would happily give their allowance to see Pamela Anderson strut around in a leather onesie that's fighting a losing battle in trying to contain her ample chest.


8. Chris Klein

Chris Klein Street Fighter Legend of Chun Li
20th Century Fox Television

Attempts: Rollerball (2002), Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun Li (2009), Game of Aces (2016)

You know your action career has no legs when its biggest high point is having starred in "the worse Street Fighter movie". Now, if the only requirement to being an action star was having the biceps of a college football running back and the hair of a Greek goddess, then Klein would be unstoppable. Unfortunately for him, there's a bit more to it.

Chris Klein does not have a way with words. Which is fine, really. Half the action icons of the 80s couldn't form a complete sentence with a gun to their heads. But you at least have to know your way around a one-liner.

A supercut of every line Klein's character, Charlie Nash, speaks in Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun Li movie was lovingly assembled by videographer Jeff Rubin. It's...a bit of a problem.

If you can't see why Klein's career as a badass action star never took off, I recommend re-watching that video, this time with the sound on. And trust me, that assemblage might actually be better than the totality of Rollerball.


7. Eric Roberts

Eric Roberts Best of the Best
Taurus Entertainment

Attempts: Best of the Best (1989), Best of the Best 2 (1993), half of all movies made ever since

Of all the deeply-aged former actions stars to be cast in an Expendables movie, Eric Roberts feels like the oddest man out. (Well, aside from Kelsey Grammer. But at least he played an X-Man.) Maybe it's because he's less a "star" than a utility player.

Despite how wildly out of his element he appeared as a martial artist in the Best of the Best movies -- flailing about like a failed Twyla Tharp apprentice going through a serious midlife crisis --casting directors just kept shoving Eric Roberts into situations where he had to convince viewers he doesn't hire guys off Craigslist to punch people for him.

Then again, these haven't been the most high-profile affairs. It's clear after scrolling through Roberts' wrist cramp-inducing IMDB page that he's never turned down a job in his life. Of the more than 500 credits to his name, about a quarter of them could be loosely considered action flicks.

And the best of those movies don't have Roberts doing much more than a brisk walk to the bar, let alone kickboxing someone's shins into oblivion.


6. Jennifer Garner

Jennifer Garner Elektra
Fox

Attempts: Daredevil (2003), Elektra (2005)

Jennifer Garner's brief foray into action films began an ended with a failed superhero mini-franchise. Which is odd, because she'd spent 5 years campily kicking ass on the hit TV series Alias, which featured Garner as an international spy and master of disguise.

But the transaction to action films hit a wall immediately when she was cast as Elektra in Daredevil, which would turn out to rival Ben Affleck's other 2003 release (Gigli) as his biggest box office debacle. Daredevil wasn't a terrible movie -- the passage of time has softened critiques that the movie was too moody and death-obsessed -- but it didn't inspire much confidence in Garner as a superheroine.

That weariness was proven correct with the release of her spin-off movie, Elektra. It wasn't all her fault. Garner was treated too much like a still comic book image, all pouty lips and awkward poses that accentuate the fact that, yes, she's a grown woman.

She was an able martial artist, at least, but it's like the personality had been sucked out of her before the directory yawned "action".


5. Taylor Lautner

Tracers Taylor Lautner
Saban Films

Attempts: Abduction (2011), Tracers (2015)

On paper, Lautner had plenty going for him in 2011. He was knee deep in the super fandom of the Twilight Series, portraying Jacob Black, that oh-so worn "werewolf with abs of gold" trope. And before that, he cornered a small section of the family adventure genre with The Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl 3-D.

Unfortunately, Abduction wasn't able to cash in on any of that popularity (nor the pedigree of director John Singleton) because it was, to put it nicely, only slightly more pleasant than a coma. Watching the young Lautner wear the mask of an action hero for 100 minutes was a surefire way to combat insomnia, but provided literally nothing else of merit to the world.

The critical dismay and box office tanking of Abduction all but ripped the plug out on Lautner's future as an action star. He was set to play the real life version of both Max Steel and Stretch Armstrong, but the studios presumably decided Lautner didn't have the range to play even action figurines.

He gave it one more shot with Tracers, which was essentially a B-movie version of Joseph Gordon-Levitt's Premium Rush, but with more parkour and less on-film acknowledgment that the premise was insane. It was...not so good.


4. Seann William Scott

Bulletproof Monk Seann William Scott
MGM

Attempts: Stark Raving Mad (2002), Bulletproof Monk (2003), The Rundown (2003), The Dukes of Hazzard (2005)

It's not impossible for the star of an immensely popular teen comedy to sneak his way into the action genre (just ask Ryan Reynolds), but it's certainly not easy. No matter how hard he tried, Seann William Scott could never run fast enough or far enough to escape the Stiffler moniker.

Like his American Pie cohort, Chris Klein, Scott was destined to be typecast. The only way around it was to branch out as quickly as possible. So he threw himself into a hodgepodge of action fare, including a heist caper, a neo-kung fu flick, and a pair of adventure tales in the mold of Indiana Jones and...well, the Dukes of Hazzard.

But the movies were all bad to mediocre, and there was still a strong stench of Stiffler hanging over every one of those performances. Scott just seems more comfortable in the role of sarcastic douchebag sidekick than as a real deal action dude.


3. John Cusack

John Cusack The Carrier
Universal Studios Home Entertainment

Attempts: The Numbers Station (2013), The Carrier/The Bag Man (2014), Drive Hard (2014), The Prince (2014), Reclaim (2014), Arrival (2017)

Somehow, some way, the guy from Say Anything temporarily became sort of an alt-action hero. There were some good if not great nuggets that secretly touted Cusack as an action guy hidden beneath a comedy veneer, including Grosse Pointe Blank and Con Air, but these were never straightforward attempts at action.

Those would come later. And they would come without charm or nuance.

Just about every one of Cusack's movies post-2010 featured the former geek-as-hunk on the poster holding a gun in only the cheesiest of poses. It actually represents the movies fairly well, as Cusack doesn't do much but wander around with a gun at his side for the duration of most of these movies.

Over the last few years, he's put out these direct-to-streaming action movies at an alarming rate, and the fatigue shows. To call any of his performances "low energy" would be an insult to hibernating bears. Cusack clearly isn't excited at the prospect of a career renaissance -- at least not in this genre -- and so there's no Liam Neeson-esque gusto to carry the awful scripts.


2. George Clooney

Batman And Robin George Clooney
Warner Bros. Pictures

Attempts: From Dusk Til' Dawn (1996), The Peacemaker (1997), Batman & Robin (1997), Out of Sight (1998), Three Kings (1999), The Perfect Storm (2000)

Can you call really George Clooney a failure in this (or any) category? After all, he's got a nice little list of action roles that only someone who didn't completely botch it in those movies could have. Right?

But yes. Heck yes you can call George a failed action star.

He's one of the greatest working actors we have, one of those low-key, multi-faceted guys who can play drama, romance, and humor all with a graceful ease. Just don't ask him to do anything super physical. That's not his style. Clooney is more of a "peripheral" action guy, where the physicality is secondary to whatever caper he's involved in.

From Dusk Til Dawn was incredible, but it certainly didn't put him on the map as an "action guy". And his more straightforward action fare hasn't aged particularly well, with The Peacemaker and Out of Sight eliciting either shrugs or quizzical looks from the average film buff. And then there's Batman & Robin, which effectively kicked the franchise in the balls and sent it to its knees for a decade.


1. Ben Affleck

Ben Affleck Batman
Warner Bros.

Attempts: Reindeer Games (2000), The Sum of All Fears (2002) Daredevil (2003), Paycheck (2003), Batman v Superman/Justice League (2016/2017), The Accountant (2016)

What made producers think the world wanted Ben Affleck as an action hero? Was it his remarkable paddle work in Dazed & Confused?

Whatever the reason, Hollywood has repeatedly tried to make that happen for Affleck, but each and every time the viewing public says "No thanks, we already have our Good Will Hunting action star" and collectively walks into whichever theater has Matt Damon stabbing people bad guys with pencils.

Affleck simply doesn't seem to have that "it" factor when it comes to the run-and-gun genre. Of all the Jack Ryans who've ever Jack Ryan-ed, his performance in The Sum of All Fears was the most underwhelming. Of all the Batmans who've ever Batman-ed, his is probably the least interesting. (At least Clooney had those Bat nipples to keep people's attention.)

There seems to be some sort of Poltergeist-ian curse hanging over the cast of Daredevil that keeps them from achieving success in these types of movies. But at least Affleck momentarily broke the hex for his Jason Bourne-aping role in the excellent-if-underrated The Accountant. It may, however, be too little too late.


Watch Next


In this post: 
John-Cusack
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.