10 "Failures" By Famous Directors (That Are Actually Better Than You Remember)
Nobody bats 1,000. Like all artists, filmmakers can have an off day; unlike many artists, filmmakers are bound by contract to have their mistakes shown in public. Virtually every director has at least one movie on their resume that's a stumble, disappointment, even an embarrassing miscalculation. For the big names, it's an extremely dangerous precipice to walk, because they have higher expectations to fulfill. When someone like Brett Ratner makes a halfway decent film, we give him a pat on the head; if Stanley Kubrick made a less than spectacular movie, we would've crucified him. Sometimes the weight of expectations is too much to bear -- and so most of the great directors have a movie somewhere in their career that is deemed a "failure", that is spoken of with derision and even shame, a movie that becomes widely accepted as "their worst film". Sometimes, though, those films turn out to have their own merits. A few are hidden masterpieces; a few of them are perfectly acceptable pieces of work simply crushed by the weight of expectation; a few...well, OK, a few of them aren't very good, but they're not good in interesting ways, and have more going on in them than meets the eye. The point I'm trying to make is, sometimes a director's greatest "failures" are most fascinating than they're given credit for; "failures" like...
10. Kiss Me, Stupid
In 1964, writer/director Billy Wilder's career had been a virtually unbroken string of hits -- with only the occasional hiccup (The Seven Year Itch and Irma la Douce had been big hits, but don't hold up very well), Wilder had, with the help of collaborators like Raymond Chandler, I.A.L. Diamond and Charles Brackett, managed to produce a dizzying list of some of the greatest American films ever made: Five Graves to Cairo, Double Indemnity, The Lost Weekend, A Foreign Affair, Sunset Boulevard, Ace in the Hole, Stalag 17, Sabrina, Love in the Afternoon, Some Like It Hot, The Apartment, One Two Three...Wilder was riding high, and could essentially do whatever he wanted. What he wound up doing was getting himself stuck in the desert with a critical and commercial dud. Kiss Me, Stupid was an Americanization of an Italian sex farce, set in the desert town of Climax, Nevada (get the double entendre?), the story of a lousy songwriter (Ray Walston) who hires a hooker (Kim Novak) to play his wife in order to seduce a drunken, womanizing crooner (Dean Martin) into buying his songs. Even by the standards of Wilder, who'd spoofed Parisian street walkers in Irma la Douce and blown up Marilyn Monroe's skirt, this seemed a little risque, even crass; Kiss Me Stupid was plagued during its production -- Walston was a last minute replacement for original star Peter Sellers, who had a heart attack two weeks into shooting -- and would be plagued after its release by lousy reviews (Variety referred to it as a having a "basically vulgar, as well as creatively delinquent, screenplay") and condemnation by the Catholic legion of decency.
To be fair to the prudes: Kiss Me, Stupid is indeed a miscalculation of a film. Wilder was infamous for having "a mind full of razorblades", but even by his standards, this story feels awfully cynical and crass. There's virtually no one in Kiss Me Stupid who even approaches likability, and the jokes, while certainly tame by today's standards, still carry some of the icky smuttiness that characterizes modern sitcoms like Two and a Half Men; prostitute Polly the Pistol's caged parrot can only say one phrase -- "Bang! Bang!" -- and it's hard to describe just how foul it is to watch Dean Martin get hot and bothered over the idea that Kim Novak wears (his emphasis) "PA-per PAN-ties!" But perhaps there's something to be said for the fact that Wilder, at the arguable height of his career, even tried something this tasteless and off the wall; almost 60, Wilder proved that he was certainly not an "old director" by making a "sex comedy" and giving it all he had -- one has to admire the chutzpah of Wilder and co-writer I.A.L. Diamond for saying "If we're going to make this movie offensive, we're not pulling any punches!" And within Kiss Me Stupid's often limp pacing and off putting sexism, there are still gems of jokes to be found, most of them centering around the character of "Dino", played by Dean Martin as a none too thinly veiled (and remarkably scathing) self parody. "Dino" warbles Gershwin songs in Vegas while flirting with showgirls; he spends most of the film sloshing drunk; he is crass and crude and rude, and his entire motivation is to lay every woman he sees. The modern equivalent would be asking Mel Gibson to play a character named "Mal" who is a former action star turned director with a drinking problem and anti-semitic tendencies -- and asking him to play it for laughs. Kiss Me Stupid shouldn't be at the top of anybody's list of great Wilder works, but it's an interesting curiosity, a rare chance to see a great artist managing nice touches even when the work as a whole stumbles.
9. Beowulf
Robert Zemeckis had arguably been one of the most consistently accomplished American "entertainers", with titles like Back to the Future, Who Framed Roger Rabbit and Forrest Gump on his resume; he had always been interested in/obsessed with pushing technological boundaries, whether it be combining Tom Hanks with real historical figures or Bob Hoskins with a cartoon rabbit, but it was always at the service of crackerjack stories (seriously, Back to the Future is pretty much the model of a perfectly structured screenplay) and engaging characters. But then in the early 2000s, Zemeckis became -- rather inexplicably, it seemed to almost everyone -- enamored of a new technique, motion capture technology, which allowed for a kind of combination of live action and animation techniques. One could understand the fascination -- motion capture theoretically allowed photorealistic characters to do all sorts of unrealistic things, resulting in greater freedom for the director -- while lamenting the results -- motion capture resulted in dead eyed characters doing all sorts of ludicrous, physics defying things, shattering any suspension of disbelief. Zemeckis' Polar Express in 2004 was charming, and if the characters looked a little dead eyed, one figured the bugs would quickly get worked out...but this turned out not to be the case, as Zemeckis' next two pictures, Beowulf and A Christmas Carol, featured similarly plastic looking characters. Those two flopped at the box office, saving us (thank God!) the spectacle of a Zemeckis directed motion capture remake of Yellow Submarine, and Zemeckis has hopefully returned to the land of the living with 2012's Flight, a solid live action drama starring Denzel Washington. Beowulf is perhaps the most decried of Zemeckis' motion capture "trilogy"; Polar Express received a "mixed to positive" reaction from critics and audiences, and Christmas Carol seems to have been more or less ignored/forgotten, but Beowulf was pretty much hated as soon as it was released, a big, clunky swing at a fantasy epic in an era when the Lord of the Rings trilogy had shown how these kinds of movies could finally be done right. Beowulf's characters were inexplicably somehow even less convincing than the ones in Polar Express (why do Ray Winstone and Robin Wright Penn come off as less emotive than Princess Fiona in Shrek?!); the film had weird, jarring tonal shifts, shoving together ancient myth with flat out slapstick (Beowulf's fight with Grendel is staged like an Austin Powers style "convenient objects hide his junk" sequence). It's long, it's turgid, and it takes an awfully long time for anything of much interest to happen; no wonder most of the press for the film focused on whether or not Angelina Jolie's character could technically be considered "naked", since she basically wears no clothes but her dirty bits are covered. Which is unfortunate, because there are some legitimately interesting thematic and dramatic ideas in Zemeckis' Beowulf -- most of them, unfortunately, not introduced until the third act, when most of the audience is asleep. A scene where Beowulf taunts a would be assassin ("You want your name in the Song of Beowulf? You think it should end with me killed by some Frisian raider with no name?") almost feels like the beginning of another, much better movie, about an old warrior who has become a king and a hero but who has built his legend on a tower of lies, who has betrayed many of the principles he claimed to represent, who is as weak a man as he is strong a warrior. If you can actually make it through the film's interminable first hour -- with its repetitive action set pieces that Peter Jackson did much better -- you might find that there's a surprisingly nuanced and intelligent critique of the myth of the hero hidden in Beowulf, in between all the dopy 3D gimmicks and animated Angelina Jolie near-nudity.
8. 1941
Steven Spielberg had had an incredible one-two punch in the mid-'70s -- Jaws and Close Encounters of the Third Kind became two of the most successful movies ever made -- and had been declared a "wunderkind", a "genius"; Universal Pictures and Columbia Pictures were ready and willing to bankroll absolutely anything the 33 year old director decided to tackle next. What Spielberg decided to tackle next, in his own words, was "a demolition derby"; 1941, originally a remarkably un-PC script by young up and comers Robert Zemeckis and Bob Gale entitled "The Night the Japs Attacked", read like It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World set during World War 2, overflowing with slapstick gags and insane special effects sequences (a tank battle, an aerial dogfight over Hollywood Blvd., a Ferris Wheel that rolls down the Santa Monica Pier) and screwball comedy characters. Spielberg pushed the project even further, with a script that kept growing and growing and growing to accommodate whatever star Spielberg thought would be willing to do a cameo (Slim Pickens, Christopher Lee, John Belushi...) and a grueling 247 day shooting schedule that inspired crew members to make T shirts: "1941 Forever...and ever...and ever." The film was considered an absolute turkey upon release -- a bloated, overstuffed mess by a director who had clearly gotten so powerful no one could tell him no -- and while it did fine at the box office the reviews were scathing, with most critics comparing the film to (in the words of Pauline Kael) "being stuck in a pinball machine". To be fair to Kael, though, she didn't mean her statement entirely as a criticism; and to be fair to 1941, maybe it's a pinball machine that deserves a second look. Stanley Kubrick famously told Spielberg that 1941 was "good, but not funny", and he might've been onto something there; 1941 is an undisciplined mess of a movie -- Zemeckis and Gale's savagely funny little satire of American jingoism, racism and sexism has clearly been misshapen by an "everything but the kitchen sink" mentality in the shooting -- but especially when seen on video, when you can take the occasional bathroom break during the movie's lengthy running time, 1941's charms reveal themselves much more readily. In the late 1970s, Spielberg was still the young upstart showing off everything he could do with his big budgets and his wonderful toys, and 1941 might darn well be his greatest technical tour de force -- this is a movie overflowing with impressive visual effects (perhaps the greatest miniatures in movie history?), beautifully mounted camera moves (Spielberg was clearly having fun test driving the brand new Louma Crane) and complicated slapstick set pieces that would (dead serious) make Buster Keaton proud and Rube Goldberg blush.
And if you can get around the messiness of the storytelling, 1941 is full of hilarious performances and characters: Nancy Allen (the epitome of late '70s hotness) as a woman who gets sexually aroused by airplanes, Robert Stack as the unflappable General Stillwell (who turns out to have a kinship with Dumbo...), Dan Aykroyd as the straight arrow tank sergeant ("If there's one thing I can't stand, it's seeing Americans fighting Americans!"), Joseph P. Flaherty as a sleazy crooner ("...maybe next time we can get a couple negros down here, have a race riot...!"), John Belushi doing that John Belushi thing...I mean, jeezus, as Zemeckis points out, this is a movie where Christopher Lee, Toshiro Mifune and Slim Pickens are all in a scene together, and they're all speaking different languages! That's gotta count for something, right?! Seriously, Stephen King is right -- 1941 is the one Spielberg movie that deserves to earn a weird little cult following.
7. The Godfather: Part III
For many people, The Godfather Part I and II are the "great American films", depicting the rise and fall of the Corleone crime family as a none too subtle metaphor for American capitalism. They were generation spanning epics; they each won the Academy Award for best picture; and they brought together maybe the greatest cast in the history of movies -- Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, Robert DeNiro, James Caan, Robert Duvall, John Cazale, Talia Shire, Diane Keaton, Lee Strasberg, Michael V. Gazzo...Obviously, a third installment in the series -- continuing and even finishing the story of Al Pacino's doomed Mafia don Michael Corleone -- was going to have a lot to live up to. And it didn't. Spectacularly. Godfather III did just fine at the box office and earned seven Academy Award nominations, but with "Godfather" in the title the film was pretty much guaranteed to open well (Paramount Pictures was more or less relying on it to save the studio from bankruptcy), and those Oscar nominations had the faint whiff of "Well, we've gotta give it to 'em, it's The Godfather, for cryin' out loud". Godfather III got mixed reviews, both for its script and -- especially -- for the controversial decision to replace last minute drop out Winona Ryder with Coppola's own daughter Sofia in the pivotal role of Michael's daughter Mary (Time's Richard Corliss wrote that Coppola's "gosling gracelessness comes close to wrecking the movie"). The movie has become almost the post child for disappointing sequels, and mention of it is often avoided when discussing the Godfather series. There's a reason Fat Tony on the Simpsons once rasped "I haven't cried this much since I paid to see Godfather III."
Which is perhaps an unfairly harsh summation, because while it doesn't reach the heights of its predecessors (what movie could?), Godfather III has its own pleasures to offer. To be fair: this is definitely an uneven film -- the production was rushed (a year from the day the decision was made to make the film to the day it was going to be released in theaters) and it shows, with remarkable scenes and setpieces fighting for time amongst narrative ennui. Mario Puzo and Coppola were clearly kind of writing this thing as they went along; Michael Corleone's existential struggle results in a lot of very long, very talky, very stagey scenes that play like first drafts to be condensed and sharpened later. And...well, yeah, Sofia Coppola is pretty damn stiff as Mary Corleone. (Ms. Coppola has since wisely realized that her (considerable) talents lie behind the camera, not in front of it.) But mixed in with the chaff, there's a lot of fantastic stuff. On a superficial level, the helicopter attack in Atlantic City is one of the series' bloodiest and most viscerally effective sequences; and in true Godfather tradition, the final montage of assassinations is beautifully handled. More importantly, Godfather III presents an ambitious (if uneven) attempt to take the Godfather into King Lear territory, aided mightily by a great performance from Al Pacino. By the early '90s Al Pacino's general acting style had become more baroque, more extreme, more...well, "hooh-ah"-y than when he first played Michael Corleone, but Godfather Part III (along with a later underrated gangster classic, Donnie Brasco) represents a demonstration of how subtle the actor can be when he tries. Michael's voice has withered to a hoarse croak, his once smooth face become cracked and lined; there's something deeply moving about seeing this man try desperately to reconcile with his wife and put the cycle of violence behind him, and Pacino handles all the character notes so beautifully you hardly notice the clumsy writing on first viewing. His performance provides the center for an honorable and ambitious -- if flawed -- gangster epic.
6. The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen
Want to talk about a movie "destroying" a director's career? Here might be exhibit 'A'. Terry Gilliam had managed to carve out an admirable little niche for himself as an "art house" director with a cult following whose films found moderate success; his last film, Brazil, had been the subject of an enormous controversy and threatened studio interference, but it had emerged triumphant, critically acclaimed and revered. Having gone through the fire once, Gilliam plunged into an even hotter fire on Baron Munchausen, an improperly planned production where budgets and schedules were sent flying out the window. Munchausen cost a fortune, got terrible press about its scheduling woes, and had the grave misfortune to come out right after a regime change at Columbia Pictures; the studio effectively dumped the movie, forgot it ever happened, and swallowed the cost. Gilliam achieved a not entirely deserved reputation as a wasteful director, and had sort of had to struggle ever since; the fact that this man has had an entire movie made about his inability to make a movie should say it all.
None of which obscures the fact that The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is a marvelous film -- maybe Gilliam's best. To be fair, the film's first reel is a bit of a mess; one thing Gilliam has never had is a light touch, and for a first time viewer in particular the opening minutes of Munchausen play less as an invitation than an assault, with scenery chewing performances and a muddled, overlapping soundtrack and eye assaulting sets all competing for attention. But once Munchausen begins his journey with young Sally Salt (future director Sarah Polley), the film becomes a feast of arresting images, sweeping adventures (a trip to the moon, into the bowels of the Earth, into the belly of a fish the size on an Island) and marvelous characters (Robin Williams at his improvisational best as the King of the Moon; Oliver Reed, a surprising comic delight as Vulcan, here conceived as a miner with a Northern accent). If you have kids, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is the kind of movie you owe it to them to introduce them to. It's the kind of movie dreams are made of.
5. The Great Waldo Pepper
As screenwriter William Goldman recounts in his book Adventures in the Screen Trade, The Great Waldo Pepper was considered a "sure thing" upon its release in 1975. It was directed by George Roy Hill, who had made the hugely successful Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and whose The Sting had just won a best picture Oscar; it featured Robert Redford, who had starred in both those previous Hill productions and had also appeared in the monster hit The Way We Were; and screenwriter Goldman (Butch Cassidy, Marathon Man, Harper) wasn't exactly chopped liver. The director of The Sting reteams with Redford and Goldman, to tell the story of the last great age of American barnstormers? It couldn't miss. But it DID miss. Great Waldo Pepper -- a passion project of Hill's, based around his love of/fascination with aviation -- got mixed reviews, but more importantly, it tanked at the box office. Goldman (and the studio) blamed a second act plot point involving the death of a major character; audiences had been able to follow Butch and Sundance to the grave and come out of the movie grinning, but Waldo Pepper's somber third act left them utterly cold. The film was considered dead on arrival, just one of those flukes; Goldman, Redford and Hill all went on to do other successful things with their careers, and Waldo Pepper was summarily forgotten about, swept under the rug.
And that's unfortunate, because Waldo Pepper is ripe for rediscovery. The film never quite reaches the heights of either Butch Cassidy or The Sting -- Goldman's script feels a little condensed, a little rushed, and some of the tonal shifts from comedy to poignancy are jarring in their suddenness -- but it's easy to forgive the few things that don't work for all the things that do work. The Great Waldo Pepper is a deeply felt elegy to a time in American history when most people had never even seen a plane, much less ridden in one; when movie star Robert Redford lands his plane in a field and offers cheap rides to the townspeople in the movie's unforgettable opening sequence, it feels like a perfect encapsulation of a time in our history, a sense of innocence and wonder, that can never be maintained. Certainly one has to marvel at Waldo Pepper's incredible wing walking sequences; those are real actors (or at the very least real stuntmen) crawling out on the wings of those planes, and there's no CGI, no bluescreen, no way to fake it -- one false move means certain death. No movie before or since has better captured the terrifying sensation of being that high in the air, the vertiginous sense of the ground seeming to plunge farther and farther away; Waldo Pepper captures both the ecstasy and the terror of flying high, and just for that, it's an unforgettable experience.
4. Sorcerer
The box office failure of William Friedkin's Sorcerer was in many ways the beginning of the end of American cinema's second golden age, the 1970s. During that decade, masterpieces like The Godfather, Mean Streets, Taxi Driver, The Deer Hunter, Nashville and Bonnie and Clyde reinvented American cinema, through the influx of a new generation of young, upstart film school grads deeply influenced by the European cinema of the 1960s. Then in 1975 and 1977 respectively, Jaws and Star Wars set new box office records, and the era of the "American art film" with a decent budget was over. Studios didn't care that Star Wars and Jaws were damn good movies; all they cared about was that those movies made huge amounts of money. "High concept" movies were pursued with a vengeance, and artists had to go scurrying out to the margins of the American film industry. Sorcerer was released the week after Star Wars, and George Lucas' film more or less blew Friedkin's off the screen; after a week of playing to empty houses, Friedkin's picture was unceremoniously dumped, a crushing blow for a film so expensive that two studios (Universal and Paramount) had been backing it. Reviewers generally scratched their heads, wondering why Friedkin would've wasted so much time and money on an inferior remake of Henri George-Clouzot's Wages of Fear. Friedkin has done some interesting work (and some not so interesting work) in the years since, but he's never retained the status as a golden boy that he acquired from the one two punch of 1971's The French Connection and 1973's The Exorcist; Sorcerer proved the beginning of the end for Friedkin as a major Hollywood director, and the film itself has slid into semi-obscurity -- the only way you can see it on video now is on a scratchy, panned and scanned, out of print DVD.
And that's a crime, because Sorcerer, it turns out, is actually a damn good movie. The film keeps the basic plot structure of Clouzot's classic: four desperate men exiled to a South American hellhole take on a suicidal mission -- they will drive across one thousand miles of jungle terrain, carrying nitroglycerin so unstable that the slightest bump will set it off. The movie starts a bit slowly for modern audiences -- the first twenty minutes or so depicting lengthy backstories for each of its protagonists -- but that slow start pays off once the actual journey starts. Instead of a fast paced car chase, Sorcerer gets infinitely more mileage (pun intended) out of the slow, dragging, plodding pace of these trucks as they try to cross the jungle. There are setpieces, like a scene where not one but two trucks have to cross a rickety rope bridge, that look like they must have been impossible to shoot, and that fully embody that old cliche of "white knuckle suspense". We feel like these powder kegs could explode any minute. And we begin to get a sinking feeling these men won't get out of this journey alive. Friedkin himself has said Sorcerer might be his favorite of his films; whatever its flaws, it's a powerful, ambitious work by an important director. C'mon Paramount and Universal, can't you guys work out your legal issues and get a decent quality version of this released?
3. Batman Returns
Yes, Virginia, there was a time when Batman movies were made by someone other than Christopher Nolan. The popular consensus on the '90s Batman franchise seems to break down thusly: there was the good one (the one with Jack Nicholson), there were the stupid ones (the ones where he had nipples)...and then there was the weird one, that one where Catwoman gets licked back to life by alley cats and Danny DeVito spits black gunk out of his mouth. The sequel to 1989's monster hit Batman, Batman Returns opened just as Tim Burton -- probably the most unlikely blockbuster director in Hollywood history -- was becoming a brand, to the extent that Disney was able to market The Nightmare Before Christmas using his name. Batman Returns had big expectations, and a pretty big public fallout; the film opened huge but dropped fast, reviews were mixed, and a large portion of the audience was put off by the dark tone, the wild divergences from comic book continuity, and the generally macabre nature of the imagery. (Parent's groups boycotted McDonalds, who had done a tie in with the film.) Batman Returns was seen as enough of a disappointment that Warner Brothers performed the drastic measure of bringing in Joel Schumacher to "lighten up" the franchise (we all know how that worked out...), and until The Dark Knight "Bruce Wayne Retires" Rises was probably the most controversial film in the entire batcanon. Might I suggest, at the risk of blasphemy, that Batman Returns is actually much better than the more culturally revered Batman? Batman has great performances, yes, and a kick ass Danny Elfman score and those beautiful Anton Furst designs (beautiful enough that they fundamentally changed the look of Gotham City in the comics -- no, armchair comic book historians, Gotham City was not a particularly gothic place before Furst got his hands on it); but it also has a remarkably messy script, full of unnessecary characters (hello, Alexander Knox, you walking exposition machine!), undercooked plot lines, terrible plot turns (I don't care if nostalgia tells you otherwise, "You ever dance with the devil in the pale moonlight?" is an awful line and the lamest possible way for Batman to figure out Joker's identity), and a main character who never really comes into focus. (Is Batman a hero? Is he a vigilante? Is he crazy? Who cares -- let's go watch Jack Nicholson!)
Batman Returns takes even bigger leaps in logic (if your suspension of disbelief is hard to earn...then boy howdy, are you in for a rough ride...), and lets go of whatever tenuous grasp the franchise had up until now on comic book continuity, but taken on its own, as an adaptation of the character and a film unto itself, it's far more cohesive -- and satisfying -- than its predecessor. The performances are fantastic: Michelle Pfeiffer gets (no kidding) the role of a lifetime as Selina Kyle, by turns seductive, vindictive, vulnerable, crazy and charming, Danny DeVito is actually ghoulishly great as Burton's freaky sewer mutant version of The Penguin, and Christopher Walken is given the character that perhaps best showcases all of his "Christopher Walken-isms", corrupt tycoon Max Schreck ("Selina Kyle -- yer FIRED! And Bruce Wayne...why're you dressed up like Batman?!"). But perhaps more than all that, Batman Returns represents a next step in the evolution of its director. Burton, who had essentially started out directing live action cartoons, had begun in Edward Scissorhands to introduce darker, sadder currents, more tragic ones. Batman Returns arguably gets the balance absolutely right -- this is a movie where Danny DeVito comically threatens Christopher Walken with a severed appendage ("Hiya Max, remember me?! I'm Fred's hand!"), but it also has perhaps the most beautifully acted scene in Burton's filmography, the dance between Selina and Bruce at the masquerade ball, where identities and intentions begin to slip and slide messily away, revealing two broken and vulnerable people. Batman Returns might just be Burton's best film: at times comic, at times tragic, always enthralling and strange and beautiful. ...oh, and it's got Batman in it, too.
2. Stardust Memories
By the late 1970s, Woody Allen had managed to achieve a pretty damn enviable level of celebrity. He was a well known comedy star, a successful stand up, an Award winning filmmaker, he was sleeping with Diane Keaton, and he had a relationship with United Artists that basically allowed him to make whatever movie he wanted. Take the Money and Run, Bananas, Sleeper, Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex, Love and Death, Annie Hall, Manhattan...with each movie Woody got better as a writer, director and actor, gradually transitioning from just making "gag comedies" into much richer, more "adult" comedies with melancholy undertones. Even the widely criticized Interiors was seen as just a hiccup, a noble if misguided attempt to Bergman. In the eyes of his adoring fans, Woody could do no wrong. Then in Stardust Memories, he spat in their faces. The film starred Allen as a neurotic (surprise, surprise!) film director trying to transition from making silly comedies to making more serious dramas -- sound familiar? Stardust Memories was full of allusions to European filmmakers, particularly Fellini, which earned it charges of pretension. More damningly, it was also full of digs and jibes at people who liked Woody Allen's movies. Allen's fans -- or the fans of his character, "Sandy Bates" -- are depicted here as swarthy, distorted, cretinous hangers-on, obsessively pestering him everywhere he goes, insisting they have some connection with him, even attempting to kill him. Even visiting extra terrestrials tell him that "We love your movies -- especially the earlier, funnier ones!"
The critics were kinda sorta right on one score -- Stardust Memories is a rather self indulgent movie, even by Allen's standards. But then this is a guy who made a (sometimes disastrous) habit of combining his personal and professional lives, and to his credit, Allen makes Stardust Memories a very knowingly self indulgent film; it manages the simultaneous trick of being sort of pretenious, and making fun of its own pretensions. Viewed outside the context of its creation -- i.e. a time when Woody Allen was the biggest name in the film world -- it's easier to not feel the movie is some sort of personal attack (as a lot of critics did) and see it, instead, as the culmination of the first period of Allen's work. Allen's movies had been growing ever darker, even more interior, ever more personal, but there had always been the veneer of quick wit, goofy humor and Gershwin music; here that veneer is removed -- Stardust Memories reveals Allen, as writer, director and cinematic persona, at his darkest. Sandy Bates is a whiner, a complainer, and the film manages to trick of both sympathizing with him and openly criticizing him; here Allen lays out quite clearly his failures as a lover, his failures as a filmmaker, the ways in which he feels he's been pidgeonholed and the ways in which he feels he's been emotionally and intellectually trapping himself. When the audience leaves the premiere of Sandy Bates' latest film at the end of Stardust Memories, it's as if Allen is closing a chapter in a book: this is who I have been, this is who I am, and this is who I will continue to be.
1. Jackie Brown
Perhaps it's unfair to type Jackie Brown any kind of "failure", but certainly "disappointment" seems to capture the flavor of the film's reputation. It's hard to remember a time when he wasn't already an institution -- often imitated, never bettered, if rarely equaled -- but back in the early '90s Quentin Tarantino absolutely exploded onto the film scene, the opening salvo of Reservoir Dogs and the ferocious knockout punch of Pulp Fiction transforming the little video store clerk into a cinematic legend. After Pulp Fiction became the water-cooler film of the mid-'90s, expectations were going to be high for Tarantino's follow-up; a drop was probably to be expected, and the general consensus amongst critics -- and certainly among fans of Tarantino -- was that 1997's Jackie Brown...well, y'know, it was OK. It had some good performances, it had some cool scenes (remember De Niro in the parking lot?), but it was too long, it was too slow, and it lacked Tarantino's usual panache. It was no Pulp Fiction. No, Jackie Brown isn't Pulp Fiction. It's better. What makes Jackie Brown so remarkable -- what makes it, arguably, the best thing Tarantino has done to date -- is that all of Tarantino's usual bravura facility with dialogue and exploitation violence is here combined with an unexpected depth. Tarantino's characters tend toward the mythic; they have quirks but sometimes lack dimension -- does anybody really care what happens to Brad Pitt in Inglourious Basterds? Pam Grier's Jackie Brown has all the smart mouth of any other Tarantino protagonist, but she's also a black woman in her mid '40s who is looking down the barrel of prison time and losing the one job she can afford to get. Robert Forster's exhausted bail bondsman, Samuel L. Jackson's sociopathic criminal -- who is not quite as sharp as he thinks he is..., Robert De Niro's over the hill, drug addled ex-con...these are real people -- heightened, yes, but with real concerns, real worries, real pain. When these characters go off on those patented Tarantino discussions of pop culture, it plays like the bored small talk of real people trying to pass the time, not the writer/director proving how many lousy '70s TV shows he knows backwards; and when the moments of startling violence come (and they do come), they come with a force that is missing in Tarantino's later, cartoonish revenge epics, because we've come to know these people. Violence has consequences. So no, Jackie Brown isn't Pulp Fiction. It's slower, more relaxed, in certain ways more assured; not a movie that slaps you in the face, but a movie you settle into, like a comfortable chair. (Tarantino has described it as his "hang out" movie -- you come to it to spend time with its characters, and the more times you see it, the better it plays.) It's a nuanced, moving, beautifully written, beautifully performed tale of desperate people on the edges of the criminal fraternity. And to riff on Inglourious Basterds, it just might be Tarantino's masterpiece.