10 Famous Movie Plot Holes (That Are NOT Plot Holes)

Some of the biggest criticisms are completely unwarranted.

Terminator death
Fox

It has happened to us all. You're watching a movie, enjoying the action, laughing at the jokes, getting invested in the relationship between the characters and then... you notice something that doesn't add up.

A character makes a decision so illogical or the story breaks its own rules so badly, it ruins the whole experience.

Most of the time, errors like these are simple oversights. Occasionally, the director is aware of the mistake but leaves it in for the sake of pacing. We, as an audience, shouldn't let these lapses of consistency stop us from enjoying the film. We don't need to analyse every word and frame.

After all, you can find plotholes in anything if you look hard enough, right?

And that's exactly what some viewers do. Some people fixate and obsess on a part of a movie that doesn't make sense... even when it does.

Maybe these viewers didn't understand what was happening or missed a throwaway a line that would've explained everything. Here are the scenes that, despite what you may believe, make perfect sense.

10. Where Did Amanda Go? - Taken

Taken Amanda
Fox

Taken revolves around a retired field agent/Irish bad-ass called Bryan Mills who travels to France after his daughter, Kim, and her friend, Amanda, were kidnapped there and sold to sex traffickers.

In the conclusion, Bryan manages to locate Kim at a sex trafficking auction and has her returned home safely. Despite the film receiving high praise from viewers, there was one plot point that kept being brought up. What happened to Kim's friend? Obviously, getting his daughter back safe and sound would be Bryan's top priority but it seems odd that he didn't attempt to track down Amanda, knowing she would suffer a grisly fate.

This is more of an oversight than a plothole but it is brought up so often, it needs to be addressed. Eagle-eyed viewers may have noticed that Bryan DID locate Amanda. After Bryan kills the "Good Luck" guy at the safe house, he heads upstairs to find a group of drugged women and Amanda's body. Because Amanda's corpse is discoloured and she is only seen for a second, most viewers don't register it is Kim's friend and so, assume it's a total stranger.


9. How Did Cypher Enter The Matrix By Himself? - The Matrix

Cypher The Matrix
Warner Bros.

Morpheus and his crew have dedicated their lives to freeing as many minds as possible from The Matrix; a simulation that is indistinguishable from 21st century life. Morpheus explains to Neo that everyone has great difficulty adjusting when they are released from The Matrix as they realise their entire life was a lie.

One of Morpheus' crewmembers, Cypher, has grown tired of living in the real world and intends to go back to living in The Matrix. In one scene, we see him inside the Matrix, selling out his teammates to Agent Smith. This moment bothers a lot of people since it has been emphasised that a person cannot jack into The Matrix without a separate person serving as the operator

But according to the directors, Cypher isn't in The Matrix. He is in a separate program he constructed that allows him to jack in and out at will. He designed it so no one else can access it, except The Agents, so he can talk to them in private.

Although it's not made clear, the reason why Cypher acts so jumpy when Neo enters his quarters is because he's putting the final touches on this secret program before entering it.


8. Why Didn't Mr. Freeze Cure His Wife? - Batman & Robin

batman robin mr freeze
Warner Bros.

Batman & Robin is one of the most plothole-ridden films of all time. Why does Mr. Freeze smoke a cigar and wear slippers if heat can kill him? Why doesn't Batman get frozen after Mr. Freeze uses an ice ray on the entire city? How can Batman have a credit card without exposing his identity?

If you've seen this film (which many people only have out of morbid curiosity), you may have noticed an inconsistency revolving around Bruce Wayne's valet, Alfred Pennyworth. Alfred is dying from MacGregor syndrome; the same disorder that Mister Freeze's wife is suffering from. After Batman has a heart-to-heart with Freeze, the cryonic scientist agrees to give him the medicine needed to save Alfred's life.

So... why didn't he use the same remedy on his wife?

The answer is simple; Batman asks Freeze for the cure for "MacGregor Syndrome Stage 1". Because Freeze hasn't used this medicine himself, it's clear his wife's illness is in a more advanced stage, hence it not having any effect.


7. How Are There Explosions On Pandora Without Oxygen? - Avatar

Sam Worthington in Avatar
20th Century Studios

Avatar takes place in the future after humanity had depleted Earth's natural resources, forcing them to relocate to a moon called Pandora. Because humans can't breathe in the atmosphere, they have to wear oxygen masks.

When the humans declare war on the Na'vi, they destroy most of their home with missiles and bombs, causing massive explosions. But... how can there be explosions... if there's no oxygen? Considering the director, James Cameron, was fine-tuning the script for over a decade, you'd assume he would have noticed this inconsistency.

Here's the thing; he did. At no point in the film is it stated that Pandora lacks oxygen.

We, as the audience, assume it does because humans can't breathe on the surface. However, the reason why humans can't survive out in the open is because the atmosphere has a toxic amount of carbon dioxide. Cameron could've just ignored this minor plot point if he wanted to so it's admirable he found a way around it so the plot still makes sense.

And, let's be perfectly honest; did you actually think James Cameron would make a film WITHOUT explosions?


6. How Could Finn & Rey Hold Their Own Against Kylo Ren? - Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm

At the end of The Force Awakens, the First Order's commander, Kylo Ren, corners Finn outside the Starkiller base. Left with nowhere to run, the ex-Stormtrooper ignites his lightsaber and attacks Kylo head-on. As Snoke's disciple is about to kill him, Rey appears and uses Finn's lightsaber to subdue her enemy.

Because Kylo is so OPed, some viewers found it absurd that two people as inexperienced as Finn and Rey could defeat him. Finn has never held a lightsaber until a day before facing Kylo. He barely defeated a Stormtrooper with this weapon so what chance would we have against a sith? Also, Rey has NEVER held a lightsaber in her life!

The reason is simple; Kylo was heavily injured. Just before this confrontation, he was blasted by Chewbacca's bowcaster; a laser that can easily kill a regular person. Kylo's force-powers may have saved his life but he was far from full-strength during his final battle.

Also, Rey has been shown to be capable of dispatching multiple assailants by herself, adapting quickly to her surroundings, and being versatile with most forms of weaponry. When you take those circumstances into account, it doesn't seem that far-fetched she got the upper hand against Kylo.


5. Why Didn't Gandalf Use The Eagles? - The Lord Of The Rings

The Lord Of The Rings Eagles
Warner Bros. Pictures/New Line Cinema

After the hobbit, Frodo, learns he is in possession of The One Ring, Gandalf the Grey orders him to travel to Mordor and cast it in the fires of Mt. Doom, which is the only place it can be destroyed.

But why didn't Gandalf chuck the Ring into the volcano himself by flying on one of the Great Eagles? He could've completed the whole quest in a couple of days. In fact, why did he get Frodo involved in the first place?

But there's something a lot of people forget. What's the first thing Frodo does when he learns the dangers of The Ring? His first instinct is to give it to the wizard.

And what does the Gandalf do? He yells at the halfling, terrified that Sauron's dark power will corrupt him. If Gandalf had a moment of weakness while transporting the Ring to Mt. Doom, he could divert his route straight to Sauron's castle, allowing the Dark Lord to reclaim his power.

Because the Ring didn't corrupt Bilbo despite being in his possession for over 50 years, Gandalf assumes it's because of the purity of hobbits and so, believes Frodo is the perfect candidate for the quest.


4. How Did Sarah Connor Know How To Crush The Terminator? - The Terminator

sarah connor hand
Fox

In the final chase scene in The Terminator, Sarah Connor and Kyle Reese try everything they can to stop the time-travelling cyborg but to no avail. Even after blowing him up (twice), the killer robot just keeps coming. After pursuing Sarah into a factory, she lures it into a hydraulic press. As she crawls through the other side, she presses the switch the activates the machine, crushing the titular character.

There is just one tiny problem. How did she know what button to press to activate the hydraulic press? I could be wrong but I'm gonna safely assume Sarah Connor is not an expert with compressive force machinery.

If this sounds like a nitpick... it totally is.

As we've proven with the Avatar entry, James Cameron has a knack for fixing potential plotholes. Take note of when Sarah walks into the factory, as she accidentally leans into a switch, which activates the press. THAT'S how she knows how it works.

Not only can this moment be disregarded as a plothole, it's actually very clever way to foreshadow the fate of the Terminator.


3. What Happened To The Pterosaurs? - Jurassic World

jurassic world
Universal

Like every film in the franchise, the characters in Jurassic World make a series of idiotic decisions, which causes the dinos to break out of the theme park and begin chomping down on the residents. As the pterosaurs grab tourists in their talons and drop them to their death, the staff successfully shoot several of them with tranquillisers. However, a couple of these winged reptiles manage to escape from the resort.

So what happened to them? Were they ever caught? Did they kill anyone else? Why isn't this mentioned in the sequel?

How come this isn't a massive priority for the keepers who are trying to keep a lid on this crap-storm?

However, the fate of the pterosaurs is explained in one line that most viewers miss. At one point, it's mentioned that all the dinosaurs at Isla Nublar are intentionally bred with an amino deficiency so they can only survive by eating the food supplied to them by the staff.

If they manage to escape, they will be unable to receive the nutrients necessary for survival, thus solving the problem. The staff are aware they can't track the pterosaurs after they escape, but also know they'll be dead soon anyway.


2. The Time-Turner - Harry Potter & The Prisoner Of Azkaban

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
Warner Bros.

In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione and Harry use a Time-Turner to travel back in time several hours. As soon as this time machine was introduced, many viewers pointed out that Harry should've used it to stop Voldemort from killing his parents when he was a baby. (I mean, why would he choose to save Buckbeak but not his Mum and Dad!?)

You know who didn't complain about this scene? The people who read the book! Do you know why?

Because it is explained in the novel that Hermione's Time-Turner can only go back several hours and can't return the user to their original timeline. There are other Time-Turners that allow the user to go back much further, but they are off-limits to students (and nearly all of them are destroyed by the seventh book).

Even if Harry got his hands on a more powerful Time-Turner and used it to stop his parents from being killed, he would be trapped in that timeline.

As horrific as it was for Harry to lose his mother and father, he needs to accept it, since altering the timeline so drastically could end up making things worse.


1. Spinning Around The World - Superman

Superman Christopher Reeve
Warner Bros.

Superman may have been a smash hit but even avid fans can't help but laugh at the movie's climax. After Lex Luthor detonates a missile, Supes does everything in his power to stop the explosion from decimating the area. Despite his best efforts, his lover, Lois Lane, is killed by the aftershocks.

Unable to accept her death, Supes launches into the sky and begins flying at phenomenal speed. As the Man of Steel zooms around the world, we see the Earth's rotation reverse, seemingly winding back time. After time-travelling a few minutes into the past, Superman has enough time to rescue Lois. Many viewers laugh at the absurdity of this scene since reversing the Earth’s rotation wouldn’t turn back in time.

However, that's not what's happening in this scene. Superman didn't go back in time by spinning around the globe; he went back in time by travelling at the speed of light.The Earth’s rotation reversing is not caused by Superman’s superspeed; it is an effect of it.

Ironically, the director, Richard Donner only inserted a shot of the Earth's rotation reversing because he thought it would look cool... and he indirectly made nearly every viewer misintrept the movie's ending.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows