10 Film Heroes Who Really Didn't Need To Die

You should never underestimate the power of death in selling a story. But then it can also be horribly pointless...

We'll always have a soft spot for those heroes of cinema who sacrificed themselves; the ones who died for the greater good and left a huge legacy for the rest of the film. Often, it wouldn't be quite so epic if someone didn't die for the cause, would it? There are those however that meet the silliest of ends, whether they're sacrificing themselves or not. These are the moments in the film where something clicks in the director's mind, it becomes obvious that someone needs to die, but there isn't nearly enough danger in the scene. Suddenly, there's a short speech, maybe a some catchy final words if we're pushed for time, before this character makes the bold decision to leave us; rather than proclaiming shock about how our favourite character can die at this crucial stage though, we're just left wondering why they've been given such a lame end. Let's have a look through ten of the most needless deaths in cinema history. Can you think of any more? Comment below!

Honourable Mention: The Henchman Who Doesn't Move - Austin Powers

Getting run over by a steam-roller has got to be one of the worst ways to go. Luckily though, most of them travel really slowly, so there's plenty of time to move out of the way. This didn't occur to Steve, a security guard in the first Austin Powers movie. Shortly after Powers (Mike Myers) and Vanessa (Liz Hurley) commandeer a steam roller, Powers tells a couple of security guards to watch out for the vehicle coming through. One of them dives out the way dramatically, whilst the other one stands on the spot, shouting "STOP!" at the top of his lungs. Not only was the steam-roller travelling at a snail's pace, one of the security guards has already shown just how easy it is to avoid a gruesome flattening. It really is one of the most avoidable deaths from any comedy film, but it was still brave of Steve to stand up to Austin Powers, if a little stupid.

10. Jonathan Kent - Man Of Steel

Man Of Steel didn't just reboot the Superman franchise, it gave Clark Kent a childhood. A lot of the film documents Clark's struggle with his superpowers, as Jonathan Kent (Kevin Costner), Clark's adopted father, tries to give him guidance and wisdom to help him with his gifts. In arguably the film's most emotional scene, Jonathan gives his life so that his son doesn't have to reveal his superpowers to the crowd of survivors; it's a noble decision to make, but unfortunately for all involved, it isn't actually the right one. As the Kent family are proceeding along the road, they notice a tornado coming towards them. Jonathan gets out to help a young family, and tells Clark and Martha to go towards the overpass; meanwhile, nobody notices that the dog is still in the car. Forgiving them for a second for forgetting the dog, it's far too dangerous for Jonathan to go back for him. Really, they should've sent Clark - you know, the one in the family most likely to survive a tornado - but Jonathan returns for the pet, and would have made it back if he hadn't have twisted his foot. And then comes the really damning aspect of all of this. Clark looks ready to rush off and save his father, but Jonathan shakes his head, sparing the boy from revealing his abilities. Didn't Clark save a bus full of children as a child? Isn't it harder to explain a child pushing a bus out of a lake than a fully grown man running over to help his father? The worst part is that their last conversation was an argument. The last thing Clark said was "You're not my father, you just found me in a field." That's heartbreaking. Especially when this accident could so easily have been spared.

9. Neil McCauley - Heat

At some point in your life, your parents have probably told you to be the bigger man and walk away. This is a piece of advice that Neil McCauley (Robert De Niro) blatantly disregarded in Heat however, and it went on to cost him his life. Neil is the leader of a group of bank robbers; he's got away with a large sum of money, and his girlfriend, both of them alive, despite his former friend Waingro actually being an undercover police officer. The fact that Neil actually survives a police shootout, started by Waingro, is a miracle, but rather than counting himself extremely lucky, and making his break for New Zealand, Neil takes the altogether more badass option of going to kill Waingro first. Whilst it's easily the cooler option for any self-respecting anti-hero, it alerts the police to his whereabouts. Oops. Archenemy Lieutenant Vincent Hanna (Al Pacino) turns up for one final showdown, and it's not one that Neil walks away from. After coming so close to the perfect getaway, he's gunned down, and all because he couldn't walk away from LA without starting one last fight. The tragedy of Neil McCauley serves an example to anyone on the run from the police: don't attack them when they've lost you. You won't go far wrong if you stick by that lesson.

8. Man In The Coffee Shop - Meet Joe Black

Meet Joe Black was a Brad Pitt-starring romance, that got off to a shaky start when Pitt's character was involved in horrific fatal accident in the opening twenty minutes. Okay, he returns later on in the movie, but when the death actually occurs, it's a fairly shocking early twist. Susan Parrish is considering marriage. She's really not that bothered about it, but she doesn't think she'll ever find anyone better than the man she's going out with; when her father tells her, "Lightning might strike," though, he inadvertently predicts that she'll meet the man of her dreams (Pitt) in a coffee shop. The pair hit it off straight away; they leave the coffee shop, and as he looks over towards where she went, hoping to catch a glimpse of her, he doesn't realise that he's standing right in the middle of the road. He moves back slightly to avoid being hit by a car, only to be hit by one behind. As his body bounces off the car he's been hit, it hits another car in the opposite direction. There's no coming back from being hit by two cars; well, not in the real world anyway. Of course, if he'd just have been looking where he was going, none of that would've happened. We're meant to believe that he was fixated on the love of his life, but as Meet Joe Black proves, even the most lovestruck of us have to remember our green cross code at all times.

7. Robert Neville - I Am Legend

I Am Legend is the tale of one man, almost alone in the world after a virus wiped out most of the population. The human race turned into zombies shortly after this virus spread, which was originally designed to cure cancer, and so it's the job of scientist Robert Neville to find a cure for this dystopia, whilst trying to stay alive. A bleak mix of mayhem and loneliness ensues for Robert, who eventually finds a cure just as time is running out; the mutants - known as Darkseekers - are attacking his laboratory, so he tells his rescuers, Anna and Ethan, to hide in a coal chute, before detonating a hand-grenade to destroy an alpha-male Darkseeker. The only problem is that he's left in the explosion. He dies, only to become a legend when his hard work pays off. The thing about grenades though, is that they have a timer on them: if they exploded as soon as you released the pin, they wouldn't be much use. Not only does Robert not take advantage of this fact, he totally forgets that there is room for three people in the chute; it's alluded to in the film. He can quite easily hide with Anna and Ethan after killing the Darkseekers. Given how upset Robert had been earlier in the film though, losing his wife and daughter, and then even attacking Darkseekers after they infected his dog, he probably chose not to go with Anna and Ethan for a reason. It would have been a nicer ending had he been allowed to build a new life though.

6. Hedwig - Harry Potter

Harry Potter and Voldemort were locked in a bitter war, with bloody casualties on both sides, and true to the books, director David Yates didn't pull any punches when it came to killing off major characters. Throughout the films, many main characters die, from Dumbledore to Snape, and even Sirius and Lupin; they're all threats to Voldemort, and as Death Eaters take them out one by one, there's a real fear that Harry might not get out of this franchise alive. But as the deaths get more and more significant, and as Voldemort gets closer and closer to Harry, one Death Eater takes the bizarre decision to murder an owl. In the grand scheme of the wizarding war, Hedwig was the most completely needless casualty of the lot, mainly because she was an owl. It wasn't Voldemort that killed Hedwig - it was an unnamed Death Eater - but was there any tactical advantage to destroying a pet bird? Was it not a sign to everyone involved that the dark side had finally lost it, and were now firing evil enchantments at animals rather than wizards? Whilst many Potterheads will be quick to point out that the killing curse was probably meant for Hagrid, Hedwig's untimely death does pose the question of what a snowy owl was doing a battlefield. And can't owls fly away from incoming curses? It's like a magical version of the Austin Powers henchman all over again.

5. Jean Grey - X2

Jean Grey was such a huge character of the early X-Men films; as well as creating a love triangle between herself, Cyclops and Wolverine, she was one of the more powerful mutants in the series. So when Magneto, Mystique and Pyro all flee a flood in their helicopter, and the X-Men's jet won't start, it becomes apparent that Jean will be the one to save the good guys. But why does she have to die in the process? Jean leaves the jet and creates a telekinetic wall to protect the X-Men against the torrent of water. This of courses sacrifices herself, as she phones in her goodbyes to Charles Xavier telepathically, but why did she have to leave the jet to stop the water? If she controls things with her mind, surely it's doable from nearby; there's never any mention that Grey has to be a certain distance away from things. If it's taking up that much energy, don't telepathically communicate a goodbye; just get on with the job. Jean Grey had to die to set up the third X-Men film; we understand that. But like this? It seems like a suicide mission if nothing else: she was established as stronger than this. This is the moment that some people would claim the X-Men franchise slid down-hill.

6. Derek's Friends - Zoolander

Male model Derek Zoolander isn't the sharpest tool in the box ("I was bulimic." "You can read minds?"). But on the brief appearance that his model friends had in Zoolander, they're even dumber than he is. Derek's down in the dumps about losing his award to Hansel. He lives with three other models, as vacuous as he is, so the three decide to go out together, to cheer poor Zoolander up. Whilst out, they stop for petrol, and having a whale of a time listening to 'Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go' by Wham, they begin having a water fight, only it's not water but petrol. Luckily, Derek Zoolander's not actually in the midst of the action - it would've been a short film had he have been - but as soon as someone lights a cigarette, the whole petrol station goes up in flames, killing everyone instantly, and prompting Derek into a brief retirement from the modelling industry. Avoiding an explosion at a petrol station is incredibly easy: just don't get petrol anywhere other than in the car, and don't light any kind of flame while in the vicinity.

3. The Whole Group - The Mist

We've all seen disaster movies where the entire human race disappears within a matter of hours. Most of us have probably wondered too, would we actually want to survive a world where evil beasts, pandemics or zombies have killed most of the Earth? Rather like I Am Legend, The Mist gives an intriguing twist on this very simple question. Protagonist David drives across the country with four other people - including his son - trying to escape the creatures that have been released by soldiers from another dimension (we've all had bad days at the office, cut them a break). Possibly the catalyst in his doom, he returns home to find he has no home anymore, as it's been destroyed, and his wife's dead; the gang carry on further, until they spot a tentacled monster. After agreement, David shoots the other four with his last bullets, even his son, and leaves the car to face the thing alone. And this is when a tank comes out of nowhere to save the day. David realises that he's been running away from help all this time, and that there are other survivors of this catastrophe. This is all happening thirty seconds after he killed his son, and three other people trying to spare them from a monster. There's no way that this tragedy could have been avoided, but that's so needless; they were so close to getting help. Talk about kicking a man when he's down.

2. Obi Wan Kenobi - Star Wars

In the very first Star Wars film, Obi Wan Kenobi is probably the most iconic character; the film revolves around the emergence of Luke Skywalker, the titular new hope against the evil Darth Vader, and it's Obi Wan's mission to train him for battle. It's one of the most famous tales of an old master lending wisdom to a younger, so it's surprising to remember then that Obi Wan actually dies in the first film. In their mission to destroy the Death Star, Vader senses Obi Wan's presence and duels with his ex-friend one last time. After a relatively short battle though - compared to the modern standards at least - Obi Wan sacrifices himself, as a distraction for Luke, Han, Leia and Chewie to escape. The only problem is, it doesn't make much sense as a plan. If Kenobi dies so that Darth Vader won't see Luke through the window, Luke's bound to react to seeing his friend killed. If Kenobi really becomes more powerful than ever after death, why didn't he? If he's sacrificing himself to give Luke more incentive to kill Vader, he's probably got enough what with believing Vader killed his father. Luke still isn't the finished article yet; he's a Jedi in progress, and for Obi Wan to leave him at this stage is particularly damning, when there's so much he could learn from him. Granted, Obi Wan returns in spirit form, but wouldn't the rest of the trilogy have been easier with a master like him by their side? It seems like Kenobi died for Alderaan reasons if you ask me.

1. Gandalf - Lord Of The Rings

Taking the prize for the most needless death ever in a film, Gandalf the Grey really could've overcome the Balrog, had he have used some of that wizarding cleverness of his. Frodo had a magical ring capable of incredible power, so Gandalf rounded up a gang, and together, they went to destroy it. Given that he was easily the most powerful character in the series, it was lucky that the hobbits had such a presence as Gandalf to help them to Mordor; it must have been heart-wrenching for him to die halfway through the journey. What really is a kick in the teeth though, is the poor whimper with which the great wizard actually perished. The whole scene, as gripping as it is, could have been handled better by everyone. Gandalf perches himself, halfway along the bridge, intent on destroying this fiery creature and buying the hobbits some time. Gandalf's big plan though, is to break the bridge that he's standing on. Would it not make more sense to stand closer to the Hobbits, or you know, not break something you're standing on? And where's all this magic that you're supposed to have Gandalf? Are you really a wizard or an old man with a big stick? The Fellowship have a good head-start on the Balrog, but still the Hobbits stay to watch the fight, despite Gandalf doing all of this so that they can run and not look back. It's a totally avoidable death, and if he hadn't have returned as Gandalf the White, it might have tainted his whole character. It's good job dying only makes his clothes brighter. Did you enjoy this article? Share your thoughts in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.