10 Films Directors Regret Making
Directors wish they never made these movies.
It's so easy for moviegoers to take for granted just how damn difficult it is to get even the worst movie made.
No matter how bad a film might be, there's someone, somewhere who worked extremely hard on it, whether the filmmaker, cast, or below-the-line crew.
And for many directors, a gig is a gig - a film might not have the greatest script, but if it pays decently and keeps them in the life to which they're accustomed, that's not so bad, right?
Yet that hasn't stopped filmmakers periodically piping up, getting uncommonly honest, and even straight-up announcing that they regret one of their past ventures.
This is, of course, much easier to admit with a film that was critically and/or commercially unsuccessful, and so it's little surprise that most of the movies on this list underwhelmed in one way or another.
But they're certainly not all disasters - far from it, in some cases - yet to the same token, if a filmmaker spends years of their life working on a movie only for it to be rejected by critics or audiences, that's gotta sting.
And so, here are 10 movies which, for better or worse, those behind the camera regret making...
10. The Game - David Fincher
Though few are going to hold up The Game as one of David Fincher's better movies - largely due to the sheer number of stone cold masterpieces he counts among his back catalogue - by any metric it's a taut, solidly crafted thriller.
Yet Fincher, ever the famous perfectionist, has serious misgivings about the film's third act, enough that he even wishes he followed the advice of his wife/producer Ceán Chaffin and didn't direct the movie at all.
In a 2014 interview with IndieWire, Fincher said:
"In hindsight, my wife was right. We didn't figure out the third act, and it was my fault, because I thought if you could just keep your foot on the throttle it would be liberating and funny."
Though The Game's ending - where it's revealed that Nicholas' (Michael Douglas) entire harrowing ordeal was indeed a staged game - is certainly the film's most polarising aspect, there are still many fans who are very, very happy that a director as skilled as Fincher was the one to make it.
9. Fifty Shades Of Grey - Sam Taylor-Johnson
2015's big-screen adaptation of hit erotic novel Fifty Shades of Grey cycled through a bevy of name filmmakers such as Patty Jenkins, Bill Condon, Bennett Miller, Steven Soderbergh, and Joe Wright before finally landing with on-the-rise director Sam Taylor-Johnson (Nowhere Boy).
The film was ultimately panned by critics and Taylor-Johnson received a Worst Director Razzie nomination for her work, yet her filmmaking was certainly totally competent, if unsurprisingly unable to elevate an atrocious script.
Though the director was reportedly paid over $2 million for her work and initially approached to return for the two sequels, she opted to walk away due to her difficulty working with the series' author, E. L. James.
In a 2017 interview with The Sunday Times, Taylor-Johnson revealed that while she couldn't quite bring herself to say out-loud that she regretted the experience, that's basically what she feels in retrospect:
"I can never say I regret it because that would just finish me off... With the benefit of hindsight would I go through it again? Of course I wouldn't. I'd be mad... It was a struggle and there were lots of onset tête-à-têtes, with me trying to bat it into the [right] place. I like everyone - and I get really confused when they don't like me. I was so confused by E.L. James. I don't understand when I can't navigate a person, when there's no synergy."
8. The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 2 - Francis Lawrence
Another director who regrets making a movie adaptation of a hugely popular book now, though Francis Lawrence's experience with The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 2 is a little different.
For starters, Lawrence was hired to direct the entire two-part adaptation of the Hunger Games series' final book, Mockingjay, with both movies being shot back-to-back.
But even before Part 1 was released, many questioned the "necessity" of splitting a book the same length as its two predecessors in half - beyond the obvious money-grubbing reasons, of course.
And indeed, once Part 2 came out, the most common criticism of the duology was that the split was unnecessary and Mockingjay could've been easily adapted as a single film.
Lawrence kept quiet about this for years, but while recently promoting his Hunger Games prequel The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, he confirmed to People that he regretted making Part 2 rather than simply producing Mockingjay as one movie:
"I totally regret it. I totally do. I'm not sure everybody does, but I definitely do."
Ironically, perhaps the most vocal criticism of The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is that its ending is rushed, with some suggesting it - being adapted from a considerably longer novel than any of the original Hunger Games books - might've actually benefitted from a two-part split.
7. Che - Steven Soderbergh
Though few will hold up Steven Soderbergh's two-part Che project as one of the director's better movies, it's certainly a laudably ambitious, sober-minded effort topped by a terrific performance from Benicio del Toro as the titular revolutionary.
Both films proved bitterly divisive with critics, and Soderbergh has since spoken extensively about how personally draining the back-to-back production was, enough that he wishes he never actually made the movies at all. In a 2009 interview with The Guardian, he confessed:
"Everybody got scarred by [Che] a little bit... I don't know how to describe it. It took a long time to shake off. It was just such an intense four or five months that it really… You know, for a year after we finished shooting I would still wake up in the morning thinking, 'Thank God I'm not shooting that film'... Literally I'd wake up and think, 'At least I'm not doing that today.'"
The interviewer also point blank asked Soderbergh if he wished he hadn't made the film and he replied with a clear, emphatic "Yeah."
6. Transformers: The Last Knight - Michael Bay
Michael Bay doesn't really come off as a director who regrets anything he makes, and yet, he's been incredibly candid about overstaying his welcome in the Transformers franchise and continually accepting paychecks even when his creative juice for the franchise was basically used up.
In an interview with Unilad while promoting his most recent film Ambulance, Bay said:
"I made too many of them. Steven Spielberg said, 'Just stop at three.' And I said I'd stop. The studio begged me to do a fourth, and then that made a billion too. And then I said I'm gonna stop here. And they begged me again. I should have stopped. They were fun to do."
Given that Bay revealed his net worth was sitting at around $500 million in 2016, the man clearly doesn't need Transformers-sized paydays to keep himself going, and if Ambulance proved nothing else, it's that he can deliver superior results on a smaller canvas and tighter budget.
5. Dune - David Lynch
David Lynch's 1984 adaptation of Frank Herbert's sci-fi opus Dune may well be one of the most disappointing films of all time - an intermittently enthralling yet oft-leaden blockbuster which was quite obviously put through the executive mangle, enough that Lynch effectively disowned it.
A big sticking point for Lynch is that he didn't have final cut on the production, and despite knowing the risks this presented, he signed on regardless.
Though Lynch evidently doesn't like talking much about Dune - enough that he even vowed to never watch Denis Villeneuve's new adaptation - he has admitted that he shouldn't have made it:
"I started selling out on Dune. Looking back, it's no one's fault but my own. I probably shouldn't have done that picture, but I saw tons and tons of possibilities for things I loved, and this was the structure to do them in. There was so much room to create a world. But I got strong indications from [producers] Raffaella and Dino De Laurentiis of what kind of film they expected, and I knew I didn't have final cut."
Since then, Lynch has been adamant about having final cut on all of his projects, and with Dune's immediate follow-up Blue Velvet, Lynch even agreed to slash his salary in half and drastically lower the film's budget to make it happen.
4. Green Lantern - Martin Campbell
Martin Campbell is one of those reliable journeyman directors every studio wants to have on their speed dial, because if you give him a great script, he'll deliver spectacular results (GoldenEye, The Mask of Zorro, Casino Royale), and even if not, he'll do his damnedest to elevate mediocre material.
But it's tough to picture anyone salvaging 2011's risible DC superhero film Green Lantern, which from the ground-up just seemed like an egregiously ill-advised project.
A $200 million budget for a movie based on a superhero general audiences weren't terribly familiar with, and one that dared to render Ryan Reynolds' Lantern suit entirely in post production? Risky doesn't even begin to describe it.
Green Lantern went on to flop critically and commercially, its legacy cemented as something of a punchline once Reynolds' career rebounded with the Deadpool movies.
Campbell, who hadn't directed a film as CGI-reliant as this before, seemed out of his depth, and in a 2021 interview with Screenrant, admitted that he shouldn't have made it:
"The film did not work, really. That's the point, and I'm partly responsible for that. I shouldn't have done it. Because with something like Bond - I love Bond, and I watched every Bond film before I ever directed it. Superhero movies are not my cup of tea, and for that reason, I shouldn't have done it. But directors always have to carry the can for the failures. What do they say? Success has many fathers, failure has one. And that's me."
3. Gigli - Martin Brest
Gigli is one of the most infamous flops of all time - a stonking box office failure which also won six Razzie awards, including Worst Director and Worst Screenplay for filmmaker Martin Brest.
Brest, an acclaimed director with hit movies to his name like Beverly Hills Cop, Midnight Run, and Scent of a Woman - the latter even earning him two Oscar nominations - effectively had his career torpedoed by Gigli's catastrophic failure.
Brest hasn't directed anything in the 20 years since and has maintained an extremely low profile, though in a recent Variety interview finally broke his silence about Gigli.
While Brest was reluctant to even speak the movie's name aloud, preferring to call it "the G movie," he said of his experience making the film:
"Extensive disagreements between the studio and myself got to the point where post-production was shut down for eight months while we battled it out. In the end I was left with two choices: quit or be complicit in the mangling of the movie. To my eternal regret I didn't quit, so I bear responsibility for a ghastly cadaver of a movie."
Brest additionally revealed, as many suspected, that he's struggled to get subsequent scripts off the ground, and so rather than spend years fighting to get them made, he decided to quit the industry altogether.
2. Shutter Island - Martin Scorsese
There's a strong argument to be made that Martin Scorsese is the single most consistent director still working today, and even though 2010's Shutter Island ultimately ranks on the lower end of the master filmmaker's output, it's still a rich, terrifically crafted thriller in its own right.
While promoting his recent film Killers of the Flower Moon, Scorsese spoke candidly about his career, and particularly the notion that, at 81 years of age and considering the large-scale pictures he likes to make, he probably only has one or two movies left in him.
Scorsese also surprisingly implied that, with his career now winding down, he regrets making Shutter Island in place of other projects he was more passionate about.
In a brilliant interview with GQ, he said that winning a long-belated Best Director Oscar for The Departed in 2007 encouraged him to make a frothy studio picture like Shutter Island, but that he "should have gone on probably to do Silence."
Silence is of course Scorsese's most famous passion project, which languished in development for 25 years before finally being produced in 2016 to rave reviews but a dismal box office.
It just goes to show, even the director with arguably the single most enviable filmography in history has misgivings about how it's all gone down.
1. The Impostors - Stanley Tucci
We'll wrap this list up with a deep cut now - 1998 The Impostors, the second directorial effort from Stanley Tucci, which while receiving broadly positive reviews from critics was a box office flop.
In a 2021 interview on Variety's Awards Circuit Podcast, Tucci spoke irreverently about the film's failure and his own regrets with making it as not only director but also writer, producer, and star. He said:
"Every now and then, someone will come up to me and say they love the second movie I made, which was called The Imposters... They say, 'It's my favorite movie of all time.' And then I accuse them having escaped from an asylum... [If he hadn't directed it] then I think it would have been a really good movie."
Sure, the movie wasn't a hit and certainly a comedown from his acclaimed 1996 debut Big Night, but Tucci's still being pretty damn harsh on himself here. It's not like he made Gigli, right?