10 Films Ruined By Being An Hour Too Long

These movies were great... until we fell asleep.

Roger Ebert once famously said that: "No good movie is too long and no bad movie is short enough", and yes, often complaining that a film is too long is seen as an easy, all-catch way for a viewer to dismiss a film that they just aren't interested in. Still, it is the job of a filmmaker to ensure that the audience remains enthralled for the duration of their picture, whether it's 75 minutes long or 200. That said, we're generally much more forgiving towards short films than long ones, as the idea for many is that a film should not expend any more of our time than is necessary. Whatever your own view, I have gathered 10 films which I feel were roughly an hour too long, and with some careful preening throughout the runtime, would be a lot more tolerable and entertaining to watch. None of these films are flat-out awful and some aren't even that bad, but each would flow better if the long takes, needless preambles and countless indulgences were cut down a little. I expect many of you will disagree with me a lot in this article, so feel free to argue with me or suggest alternatives in the comments!

10. Hulk

Ang Lee's 2003 take on the Hulk runs in at 138 minutes, which isn't exactly a snooze-inducing runtime by most standards, but remember that this film is supposed to be aimed at the kid crowd as well as everyone else. The movie looks great for the most part, and though he's seen as the "lesser" Bruce Banner, Eric Bana does a fine job nevertheless. The problem with the film is that it spends far too long fashioning an origin story, such that by the time it's finished, there's not a whole lot of time for everything else, namely "Hulk smash!" Banner takes about 45 minutes to become the Hulk, when in reality, it shouldn't have taken any more than about 20. It also drags its feet with somber emotional scenes rather than being fun and light as it should have been. Perhaps that's the cost of hiring Ang Lee, an acclaimed art-house director, to turn his hand towards blockbuster "action".

9. Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End

The two previous Pirates of the Caribbean films ran in at 143 and 151 minutes respectively, both of which were frankly already pushing it. The third film in the series, At World's End, clocks in at a meaty 168 minutes, with Jerry Bruckheimer and co. apparently believing that there's no such thing as too much of a good thing. The key problem with At World's End is that it's so obvious where the fat lies, as Jack spends far too long trapped in the purgatory of Davy Jones's locker, an excuse for some pointlessly surreal sequences that likely bored younger audience members (this ain't exactly Fantasia) along with everyone else. It is a case of allowing the filmmakers to indulge themselves too much, and had the film ran for a mere 110 minutes, then perhaps the rest of it might have been viewed a little more kindly. If nothing else, it would certainly have seemed more action packed than it was.

8. The Master

I am certain that many will object to this entry, yet as much as I admire Paul Thomas Anderson's stern drama, I can't help but think it would have been vastly superior if the glacial pace had been toyed with and snipped at a little here and there. At 144 minutes, The Master is an epic, sweeping examination of desperation and post-war defeat, but does it really need all of those snarls and stares into the middle distance, all of those visually gorgeous yet protracted shots of the landscapes? Many would have balked at an 84 minute version of this story, yet there's a lot to be said for economic filmmaking, and with a snappier pace, I think it's safe to say that PTA could have conveyed much the same sentiment while saving an hour of our lives. However, the earlier trailers for the film had plenty of footage that didn't end up in the final cut, so perhaps we should be grateful that the film was "only" 144 minutes long...

7. Funny People

There's a cinematic rule of thumb that comedies don't tend to run over 2 hours in length, yet in the case of the 146 minutes Funny People, a) Judd Apatow loves to break this rule and b) despite starring Seth Rogen and Adam Sandler, Funny People is not a comedy. The film is instead a surprisingly nuanced drama about a man struggling to cope with his own mortality, laced with some darkly comic undertones, but the problem is that it just drags on and on and on, labouring its point about appreciating life when a respectable 90-100 minutes would have been plenty of time to make the same point. The banter between Sandler and Rogen is never too tiresome, but I remember leaving the cinema thoroughly exhausted at the fact that Apatow had slow-bled this relatively simple story over such a beefy runtime. The fact that his latest film, This Is 40, runs in at 134 minutes, suggests to me that Apatow needs to hire a more judicious editor.

6. 2001: A Space Odyssey

Much like The Master, this is likely to be an unpopular choice, and the emotionally exhausting atmosphere of Stanley Kubrick's sci-fi masterpiece is for many just part and parcel of its appeal, even if 142 minutes is not an especially long runtime. It's the whole style that makes it feel long: the unbroken takes of "nothingness" are a bit of a challenge and a slog to get through without zoning out, in spite of the artistic excellence of these sequences on an aesthetic level. It's perhaps more of a pacing issue than the actual runtime itself, but at around 90 minutes, this would feel a lot more succinct, even if it might lose some of its epic appeal as a meditative sci-fi to switch on when you want to relax.

5. King Kong (2005)

King Kong is Peter Jackson once again in his wholly excessive, singular mode, and it won't be the last time he appears on this list. His remake of King Kong is clearly a passion project of the director's, but that doesn't qualify why it has to run in at 187 minutes, almost double the length of the original 1933 film. In Jackson's take, it's around an hour before the crew reach Skull Island and actually meet King Kong for the first time, by which point audiences may well have already given up on the film and started rooting against it. Build up is no bad thing, but Jackson front-loads his film with so much of it that we're already tired by the time the good stuff starts. The rest of the film is pretty great, but the opening hour could easily lose 30-40 minutes in of itself, and a few chops later on to keep the beats clipping along would easily bring it down to a tolerable 2 hours.

4. Love Exposure

Shion Sono's epic story of love is, at 237 minutes in length, a challenging sit. It's a good film, although one I never want to watch again, solely because of the draining runtime that's just shy of 4 hours. How often am I going to have 4 hours that I want to devote to a single film, a drama no less? 3 hours is itself enough of an ask for a film of this type, but it would still make Sono's film feel that much tighter and more expressive. Instead, we've got protracted montages that drone on and on, bible quotes that never seem to end, and essentially a director being indulged well past the point that is healthy. Hilariously, the first cut of the film clocked in at an insane 6 hours, yet at the request of producers Sono managed to bring it down to a "more tolerable" 4 hours. This one's strictly for Sono aficionados as it stands, and I imagine the true would be same if it were an hour shorter. Still, it'd be a much better film.

3. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

Andrew Dominik's The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford is the cinematic equivalent of being flogged into submission. Many have joked over the years that the film's runtime is the only thing longer than its title, for there is a great film hiding inside the 160 minute runtime somewhere, but the long takes, needless repetition of scenes and incessant mumbling (I had to watch parts of this film with subtitles to know what was going on) create a noxious atmosphere that will turn off all but the most dedicated cinephiles. When the titular act finally happens, the low energy of the whole film invites little more than a shrug, and a feeling of "I really wish this was 100 minutes long". A little more enthusiasm and a less laborious approach would have gone a long way in doing strong service to a worthy story, yet the film still has its fans, as evidenced by a recent theatrical revival in the US.

2. Transformers: Dark Of The Moon

The third Transformers movie, Dark of the Moon, is the longest of the bunch, clocking in at 154 minutes. To its credit, it boasts an absolutely fantastic action sequence in act three which runs for about 45 minutes, but it's just a shame that we have to sit through 90 minutes of garbage before it. Cut out all of the dumb humour, all of the relationship nonsense, keep as much John Malkovich and Frances McDormand in it as possible and get straight to the action, because nobody sees these movies for the story or characters anyway. It astounds me that a studio is so keen for Michael Bay to make such a long movie about robots beating each other up. Surely a 120 minute runtime is more desirable? Could they not then show the film more times per day and potentially rake in even more money?

1. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

Peter Jackson strikes again. This spot could theoretically apply to either of The Hobbit films released so far, but as the first one, An Unexpected Journey, is a whole 8 minutes longer than The Desolation of Smaug, we'll give it to that one. Yes, An Unexpected Journey clocks in at 169 minutes, and is also clearly the more padded and overstuffed of the two, a result of Warner allowing Jackson to indulge his every whim and fancy, turning a 310 page book into over 8 hours of films. It's clear to see where the padding is, also. The opening Shire sequence of the film is roughly 45 minutes long, about double the length it needs to be, and the majority of the Rivendell scene, in which we briefly see Galadriel, Saruman and Elrond, should be left to the Extended Edition because it doesn't add enough to the plot (hence it being so vaguely mentioned in the book). Are there any excessively long films I missed? Let me know!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.