10 Films That Embellished Who Actually Made Them

These movies aren’t directed by who you think they are.

tim burton nightmare before christmas
Disney

It’s an easy enough mistake to make considering the crafty marketing tactics movies employ to get us to see them. Posters and trailers all too often underemphasise a movie’s real director – especially if they’re relatively new to the industry – while overemphasising a bigger, more recognisable name to get cinemagoers in seats.

In reality, however, those bigger names often have very little to do with the movie in question. Usually, they’re merely a producer or in the even more detached role of ‘presenter’ which basically means they’re lending their name to a movie for purely promotional purposes.

It’s a tad deceitful, but an undoubtedly successful marketing method...

10. The Orphanage

Sackcloth Boy The Orphanage
Wildbunch

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Guillermo del Toro

Who Really Made It: J. A. Bayona

At first glance The Orphanage has all the hallmarks of a Guillermo del Toro movie – it’s a Spanish language film, it’s dark and gothic in tone and features a strong female protagonist. That, and the fact his name appeared in a huge font above the title on tonnes of The Orphanage’s promo posters kind of hinted that way too.

But The Orphanage was actually Barcelona-born director J.A. Bayona’s first feature length film. According to Bayona, he’d first met the Mexican auteur in the early 90s and after witnessing the young filmmaker’s passion and talent del Toro had promised to help him in his future film career should he be in a powerful enough position to do so.

That moment came after the huge success of the 2006 dark fantasy Pan’s Labyrinth and thus del Toro – now a highly bankable name – took on the roles of executive producer and presenter of The Orphanage which became a huge success itself. That’s not to say The Orphanage wasn’t already a brilliant film, but the addition of del Toro’s name no doubt helped it succeed.

Since then del Toro has also lent his name and producing talents to other first-time directors’ movies including Andy Muschietti’s Mama and Troy Nixey’s Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark, although we shouldn’t give him too much flak.

He’s giving exposure to some fantastic filmmakers and it seems he has some principles when it comes to the ‘Guillermo del Toro presents’ brand, stating “I only do it when I fully believe I was involved in the product in a way that is meaningful.”


9. District 9

found footage - district 9 - spaceship
TriStar Pictures

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Peter Jackson

Who Really Made It: Neill Blomkamp

Back in 2009 hot from the success of the Lord of the Rings trilogy and his King Kong remake, Kiwi director Peter Jackson was enough of a household name that producing and loaning his name to a movie could practically guarantee its success.

Luckily for then relatively unknown South African filmmaker Neill Blomkamp, it was his feature film debut District 9 that Jackson decided to bestow his golden touch upon. The movie went on to be a massive success, raking in rave reviews and a not too shabby $210.8 million worldwide on a $30 million budget.

But it wasn’t quite the cynical marketing ploy it may first seem. Blomkamp and Jackson first met when working together on a movie adaptation of video game Halo and Blomkamp had even gone so far as to move to Jackson’s hometown in Wellington, New Zealand.

The Halo movie was set to be Blomkamp’s directorial debut with Jackson acting as mentor but when it famously fell through, a guilt-ridden Jackson insisted the pair make an original movie on their own based on a short film Blomkamp had made a few years previously called Alive in Joburg. And lo and behold, District 9 was born.

It seems it was equally rewarding for both. Blomkamp got to work with a director he respected and made a brilliant movie in the process and Jackson – who described the process of making District 9 as “guerrilla filmmaking” – got to vicariously relive his younger days as a novice director unencumbered by big studio demands. It’s all quite sweet really.


8. Poltergeist

Poltergeist 1982
United Artists

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Tobe Hooper

Who Really Made It: Steven Spielberg

There’s no doubting that classic 80s horror Poltergeist was the brainchild of Steven Spielberg. He came up with the story, co-wrote the screenplay and produced it after all, but if Hollywood legend is to be believed his work on set extended even beyond those pretty hands-on roles.

Rumour has it that as Spielberg was contractually obliged to direct E.T. the Extraterrestrial as Poltergeist was going into production he essentially took on Tobe Hooper as a hired gun to make sure Poltergeist got made but was nevertheless very involved in the day-to-day making of the movie.

It’s practically been confirmed by many a cast and crew member that Spielberg did a lot more in the way of directing than Hooper did. Even Spielberg himself slipped up and all but admitted he was Poltergeist’s de facto director in a 1982 interview with the LA Times before the film’s release, stating:

"Tobe isn't what you'd call a take-charge sort of guy. He's just not a strong presence on a movie set. If a question was asked and an answer wasn't immediately forthcoming, I'd jump up and say what we could do. Tobe would nod agreement, and that became the process of the collaboration.”

Sounds more like a puppet master and his marionette than a collaboration, but if you insist Mr Spielberg.

The rumours of his over-involvement were so persistent that even the Directors Guild of America investigated the matter upon which Spielberg started downplaying his role and pushing Hooper as Poltergeist’s director. We all know the truth though.


7. The Nightmare Before Christmas

The Nightmare Before Christmas
Disney

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Tim Burton

Who Really Made It: Henry Selick

Commonly dubbed ‘Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas’, it’s no wonder there’s some confusion over who actually directed the creepy animated classic.

Though Burton acted as producer and came up with the story and characters behind the film (basing it on a three-page poem he’d penned in the early 80s), it was master of stop-motion Henry Selick that directed it and was majorly responsible for how the movie turned out.

In fact, Selick has claimed that Burton spent as little as ten days on set over the course of the movie’s two-year production – a far less hands-on role than one would assume. At the time, however, it made perfect marketing sense to over-emphasise Burton’s role who’d just directed several very successful films including Beetlejuice and Edward Scissorhands.

Nevertheless, the focus on Burton understandably irritated Selick who stated in an interview with The Daily Beast in 2013: “I was shoved pretty far in the background, which threw me, but it was probably a good marketing decision.”

Canny marketing move or not, the Tim Burton association has continued to dog Selick’s career as we shall soon see.


6. Coraline

Coraline movie
Focus Features

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Tim Burton

Who Really Made It: Henry Selick

Sixteen years after the release of The Nightmare Before Christmas, Henry Selick directed the dark fantasy stop-motion animation Coraline based on the novel of the same name by British writer Neil Gaiman.

Yet thanks to some rather enigmatically worded marketing that promoted the film as ‘from the director of The Nightmare Before Christmas’ many people wrongly assumed that Coraline was a Tim Burton film too when in fact he had nothing whatsoever to do with it.

It’s unknown whether playing on the common misconception that Burton directed The Nightmare Before Christmas was a deliberate attempt on behalf of Coraline’s marketing team to give it more exposure, but it certainly led to Coraline’s wrongful association with Burton regardless.

It was enough to get Neil Gaiman’s hackles up. After noticing several big-name media outlets refer to it as ‘Tim Burton’s Coraline’ he took to his blog and Twitter to remind everyone that Selick was the talent behind the film.

Not that it helped all that much, of course, since many still think of Coraline as a Tim Burton rip-off today. Poor Henry Selick.


5. Piranha II: The Spawning

Piranha Ii The Spawning 1981 Film
Columbia Pictures

Who You Probably Thought Made It: James Cameron

Who Really Made It: Ovidio G. Assonitis

Ask James Cameron what his directorial debut was and he’ll most likely say it was The Terminator. Technically, however – and only very technically – his first feature film as director was actually the 1981 horror sequel Piranha II: The Spawning.

Anyone who’s seen that movie can understand why Cameron would want to distant himself from it (hint: it’s not very good at all) but the truth is a little more complicated. The production was contractually obligated to employ a North American director and so Cameron was hired. Truthfully though, the person really pulling the strings was Piranha II’s executive producer Ovidio G. Assonitis, an Italian director of B-movie horrors.

According to Cameron, he was fired two and a half weeks into production with Assonitis taking over pretty much all aspects of production while still crediting Cameron as director. Cameron seems to have gotten over his not so glittering entry into the film industry, since calling his so-called directorial debut “the finest flying piranha movie ever made”.

Assonitis probably owes Cameron a thank you card or two for taking the fall for his fish-shaped flop though.


4. From Dusk Till Dawn

From Dusk Till Dawn Quentin Tarantino George Clooney Salma Hayek
Miramax

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Quentin Tarantino

Who Really Made It: Robert Rodriguez

Any film fan worth their salt probably knows now that From Dusk till Dawn is a Robert Rodriguez film but back when it was first released some ambiguously worded promo material suggested Quentin Tarantino played a bigger part in its making than he really did.

Granted, Tarantino did write the screenplay, executive produce and star in From Dusk till Dawn. Not to mention, with the wildly successful Pulp Fiction recently under his belt, giving prominence to Tarantino’s higher profile name was a savvy marketing move.

There were a few clues that it wasn’t a Tarantino directorial effort, however. Though its was typically violent in a Tarantino kind of way, vampires weren’t exactly in keeping with his penchant for pulp crime at the time.

A similar tactic was employed when its sequel From Dusk till Dawn 2: Texas Blood Money was released: Scott Spiegel may have been its director but that didn’t stop its marketers claiming it was a movie from Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino despite the pair only serving as executive producers.


3. Sanctum

sanctum review
Universal Pictures

Who You Probably Thought Made It: James Cameron

Who Really Made It: Alister Grierson

Thirty years after taking the hit for Piranha II: The Spawning, James Cameron was now a hugely bankable household name thanks to the likes of mega-blockbusters including Titanic and Avatar. And, as seems to be the trend in Hollywood, it was now time for Cameron to lend his name to another film he had little to do with but in a different kind of way.

The advertising for underwater survival flick Sanctum certainly stressed Cameron’s involvement as executive producer and presenter while reminding potential viewers of his past movie successes. It seemed credible as a Cameron movie too, considering his penchant and prowess for ocean-set movies like The Abyss and Titanic.

But it in reality it was little-known Aussie director Alister Grierson’s film and though it was a box office success – in part, no doubt, because of Cameron’s involvement – critics weren’t quite so impressed with it. Seems even Cameron’s golden touch couldn’t save it from a poor reception.

Not that Sanctum was quite as bad as Piranha II but it wasn’t quite the quality of film cinemagoers had come to expect from a project related to Cameron (however vaguely) by that time. Funnily enough, in the years since Grierson hasn’t done much apart from a bit of TV work and we’re still waiting on Cameron’s Avatar sequels. Read into that what you will.


2. Hero

Jet Li Hero
Miramax

Who You Probably Thought Made It: Quentin Tarantino

Who Really Made It: Zhang Yimou

From Dusk till Dawn isn’t the only time Quentin Tarantino’s involvement in a movie has been a tad inflated. A more extreme example came with the 2004 US release of Zhang Yimou’s wuxia epic Hero.

First released to massive success in its native China in 2002, Miramax were quick to snap up its American distribution rights but left it to gather dust until Tarantino – a big fan of the film who called it “an absolute masterpiece” – offered to lend his name to it as ‘presenter’.

There was a catch, however. Tarantino insisted that if the words ‘Quentin Tarantino Presents’ were to be emblazoned all over Hero’s publicity then Miramax had to keep their grubby, meddling mitts off the movie. That is, they had to release it uncut and with subtitles rather than any unnecessary and distracting English dubbing.

On the one hand, it was pretty good of Tarantino to lend his brand to Zhang’s film. If his name hadn’t been attached, the version US audiences saw may have been butchered beyond recognition or may not have seen the light of day at all.

On the flipside, it’s not like Hero wasn’t already getting praise on US soil. Prior to its 2004 US theatrical release the movie had already been nominated for Best Foreign Language Film at the Oscars and Zhang himself was by no means unnoticed by Hollywood having received two earlier Best Foreign Language nominations too.

A cynic might suggest that although Tarantino’s name no doubt raised Hero’s exposure it may have been a somewhat self-serving manoeuvre on his part. After all, it can’t hurt having your name attached to a critically acclaimed, Oscar-nominated movie can it?


1. Tombstone

Kurt Russell Tombstone
Entertainment Film

Who You Probably Thought Made It: George P. Cosmatos

Who Really Made It: Kurt Russell

It’s long been rumoured that George P. Cosmatos wasn’t really the driving force behind the 1993 western Tombstone. Maybe it was the sharp uptake in quality compared to the likes of Leviathan and Cobra that hinted something suspect was afoot, or perhaps it was his last-minute hiring after original director Kevin Jarre was fired a month into filming but either way something smelt fishy.

A year and a half after Cosmatos’ death Tombstone star Kurt Russell finally set the record straight in a 2006 interview with True West Magazine and revealed that it was really he that directed the film while Cosmatos was merely a ghost director.

For reasons unknown, Russell didn’t want to be credited as director but stated he essentially commandeered the production: “I said to George, ‘I’m going to give you a shot list every night, and that’s what’s going to be.’ I’d go to George’s room, give him the shot list for the next day, that was the deal. ‘George I don’t want any arguments. This is what it is. This is what the job is.’”

To his credit, Russell vowed not to reveal the truth until after Cosmatos died and lived up to that promise but he could of course be talking crap and it’s not like Cosmatos is here to defend himself. Nevertheless, these days it’s practically official Hollywood lore that it was Russell and not Cosmatos that directed Tombstone.


In this post: 
Tim Burton
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Helen Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.